Sham Sunder v. Managing Director, Prtc, Patiala












 

 






 !

!"#$#%&
!' !()!*
+
, -(
.%/!* ''!00% 1!*$.$ -!
%2#%2
#*!" *+
!'$.
/
*%$'*
*'* #%+
 #0  !$'%/!%


 !"#$
%& '( $('
)#*%&+,$  3-! -!*
!'* !*$

0"0
''!*$
(4
)!
005!/

$!!
-!
6./2(!% 7  
)!
*!!**!/

-!
!'* !*$
*
% 7 8 3-! -!*
-!
6./2(!%
$-.0/
)!
*!'* !/
#%
-!
#2!$ 7

*!$!% &

**!$-
-%/!*+
/9" !+ *
* -.-%+
/9" !+ *
-!
''!00% 

*%:#
22*50+
/9" !+ *
*%.'(
#%20+
/9" !+ *
-!
*!$'%/!%  ;;;;;







































('
)#*% -!
"-00!%2!
#%
-!
'*!$!%
''!0
#$

-!
#('.2%!/ 6./2(!%
%/
/!"*!!

-!
<5!*
''!00 !
.*
/ !/
=+ 5-!*!)4
-!
''!0
#0!/
)4
-!
*!$'%/!% >/!!%/%
2#%$
-!
6./2(!% %/
/!"*!!
/ !/

8?
9#/!
5-#"-
-!
$.#
#0!/
)4
-!
''!00% > '0#% #
-/
)!!%
/!"*!!/+
-$
)!!%
005!/

**!$-
-%/!*+
/9" !
*
* -.-%+
/9" !

''!*#%2
%
)!-0

-!
''!00%
$.)(# $
-
-!
*#0
.* +
%
-!
)$#$ 
-!
*0
%/
/".(!% *4
!9#/!%"!+
/!"*!!/
-!
$.#
*
/!"0* #%
%/



#$$.!/

/#*!" #%

-!
*!$'%/!% >/!!%/%

*!0!$!
%!
%%.0 #%"*!(!%
#%
-#$
9.*
*(
-!
*!0!9%
/ !+
#!+
==
0%2
5# - #% !*!$
@
AB
'!*
%%.(
*(
-!
/ !

#0#%2
-!
$.#
#00
# $
*!0#$ #% -!
<5!*
''!00 !
.*
/#$(#$$!/
-!
$.#
%
-!
2*.%/
-
-!
"0#( #%
-!
$.#
5$
)**!/
)4
05

0#(#  #%
$
-!
$.#
#%
*!$'!"

-! #%"*!(!%
5!
==
5$
#0!/
#%
-!
4!*
?
!
.* -!*
$.)(# $
- $."-
*!0#!
5$

*!".**#%2
".$!

" #%
%/+
-!*!*!+
-!
<5!* ''!00 !
.*
-$
"((# !/
%
#00!20# 4
%/
'!*9!*$# 4
#%
*!9!*$#%2
-! 5!00
*!$%!/
6./2(!%
%/
/!"*!!

-!
*#0
.* 
!
0$
$.)(# $
- -!
005#%2
$.)$ % #0
C.!$ #%$

05
*
/6./#" #%
)4
-#$
.* &> D

3-! -!*
-!
#('.2%!/
6./2(!%
%/
/!"*!!
9#/!
5-#"- -!
5!00
*!$%!/
6./2(!%
%/
/!"*!!

-!
*#0
.*
-$ )!!%
*!9!*$!/+
"%
)!
$.$ #%!/7 

3-! -!*
-!
#$$.!

0#(#  #%
5.0/
"*'>.'
#%
-! '*!$!%
''!0
5-!%
''!00%
#$
$.!*#%2
*!".**#%2
(%! *4 0$$
%/
#%"*!(!%
5$
%
*!0!$!/
)4
-!
*!$'%/!%
# $!0 %/
(*!9!*+
!" #%


-!
<#(#  #%
"
'*9#/!$
-
#% "$!

"% #%..$
)*!"-

"% *" +

*!$-
'!*#/
 0#(#  #%
)!2#%$

*.%
!9!*4
((!%
/.*#%2
5-#"-
-!
)*!"- "% #%..$7






*%:#
22*50
/9" !
*
*%.'(
#%20+
/9" !

''!*#%2
%
)!-0

-!
*!$'%/!%
$.)(# $
-
#%
'.*$.%"!

-!
*/!* / !/
?,+
#/9#

-*#
*%2+
%2#%2
#*!" *+
!'$.

/
*%$'*
*'* #%+
 #0
-$
)!!%
#0!/+
5-!*!#%
#
-$
)!!% $  !/
-
-!
''!00 !
. -*# 4
-/
#('0!(!% !/
-!
*/!*
/ !/ ==
%/
%!
#%"*!(!%

-!
''!00%
5$
*!0!$!/
%/ "%$!C.!% 04
-!
$0*4

-!
''!00%
5$
*!>#E!/
%/
-!
**!*$

-!

-

$(!
-9!
0$
)!!%
'#/
9#/!
#00
F
/ !/
F==8
(.% #%2

8G>
-!
#/9#
#$
:!%
%
*!"*/ 
-9!
-!*/
-!
0!*%!/
".%$!0
*
-!
'* #!$
%/
''*#$!/ -!
''!*
): -!
#/9#
/!$
%
#%/#" !
5-! -!*
#
"% #%!/
-!
!0!(!% 
#% !*!$
*
% 
-!
/!"*!!
-$

)!
"('0#!/
5# -
-!
"% !% $
(/!
#% '*2*'-
8

-!
#/9# +
*!/
-.$&>






   

                   

      

  

   !"# !$%    & 

    

  ' 

 

     



% (     

         

       

 

     )     )*   +   "* %, 
/
%
#%/
%4
6.$ ##" #%
#%
/!"#/#%2
-!
''!0
%
(!*# $ *
-!
*!$%
-
-!
)!%!#

%!
#%"*!(!%
-/
0*!/4
)!!%
2*% !/
 -!
''!00%
54
)":
#%
==8
%/
-!
$.#
5$
#0!/
#%
?
%/
-#$
" 5$
/(# !/
#%
-!
5*# !%
$  !(!%
%/
-!
*#0
.*
/6./#" !/
-! ( !*
5# -.
% #"#%2
-!
*!(!% #%!/
"% !% #% %
9#!5

-!
"
-
-!
''!00%
-$
0*!/4
)!!%
2#9!%
-! #%"*!(!% +
%
".$!

" #%
$.*9#9!$
%/
-!
''!0
#$
/#$'$!/

#%
!*($ 
-!
9!*(!% $
(/!
#%
-!
#/9#  ./0*1 ('
)# /23 %&+,$