High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6243/2013dismissed

Baldev Singh v. Abdul Razak & ANR

2015-08-185 pages

!" #"$%&%'() ) *

+#",-%'./ 00"++ '!

1"2&3& 4#3+ 5 6 '# '!/"2 "&0'#"'!&

! 2"&"'!( 2 '

%#7/ '8#,$ !" 2 27 %'8#,$ !"

2!/" 00"++ '!&& 2 ,%'7 0328#,$ !"

22"&0'#"'! ! " 2"&"'! 00" +/ &4""' %+"#49!/" 00"++ '!: +#", -%'./02 9%'. 2"'/ '$";"'! !/"$;0"'& !%' < 2#"#49!/"

+" 2'"#!2$$%#"'!+ %;&2%43' +8 %'#/"2"%'

!"22"

"22"#! &!/"=2%43' +=,%#" < 2## !"# > %'2"&0"$!!!/"#" !/ 43

+<'"#49/%;

2%"

$!& &2"," +"#%'!/"$+ %;0"!%!%' %+"#3'#"2 -"$!%' !/"!2&1"/%$+"$!8>)) 2"!/ !!/" 00"++ '! $+ %;"#!/ !</"'/" +'.<%!//%&43

+2" $/"#$/ ' ?

3# %'

2 #' ! 43!@

; ! .%$,"/%$+"4" 2%'.

2".%&!2 !%'?*?@> <'"# '##2%,"'492"&0'#"'!

:4#3+ 5 6< &4"%'.#2%,"'%' 2 &/ '#'".+%."'!; ''"2

"&0%!"&%.' +49!/" 00"++ '!8%!&!23$6 . %'&!/%&43

+ 3"! !/"%'A32%"&&3&! %'"#8!/"43

+#%"# !!/"&0!

< & +#."# !+%$"&!8$/ ' '#%&0"2!/"& %#

+#."# !

!/"4"/"&! !/" 00"++ '!8!<43

+"&&! 2!"# %./!%'.<%!/" $/ !/"2'!/"2 #8'"4"%'.03&/"#49!/"!/"2 & 2"&3+! </%$/ '" !/"43

+"&$ ;"%' 2'! !/"23''%'.,"/%$+" ++ &3##"'&3

"2%'.%'A32%"& '#$'&"B3"'!+9#%"# !!/"&0! &! 2!"; C ;%' !%' !/" #" # 43

+ < & $'#3$!"# 49 1"!"2%' 29-32."'8,"2';"'!&0%! +8$/ ' 7 + '00"++ '!

%+"#!/"$+ %;0"!%!%'02 9%'. 2$;0"'& !%'' $$3'! #" !/ /%&43

+4"&%#"&;"'! + .'9&3

"2"#49/%; "&0'#"'!& $'!"&!"# !/" $+ %; 0"!%!%' 49 %+%'.

&"0 2 !" <2%!!"' &! !";"'!& 2%,"2?$3;?<'"2 !/" ,"/%$+" :

2"&0'#"'!#"'%"#!/"$'!"'!& !/"$+ %;0"!%!%'$;0+"!"+9 $+ %;%'.!/ ! +&"

/ #4""'+#."#49!/"$+ %; '!<%!/ 3+!"2%2;!%,"!"C!2 $!$;0"'& !%' !< &2"," +"#!/ !!/" ,"/%$+"%'B3"&!%'< &%'&32"#492"&0'#"'! "&0'#"'!: %'&32 '$"$;0 '9</%$/ +&#"'%"#!/" $$%#"'! '#$+ %;"#!/ ! %!< &!/"$+ %; '!/%;&"+ </< & ! 3+! 2%,"2 !/","/%$+"%'

'9$ &"$ ''!4"/"+#.3%+!9 2!/" ++"."# $$%#"'!$ 3&"#49

+"&$;%'.%' 2'! !/"& %#,"/%$+"&3##"'+9 '&32 '$" $;0 '9 +& #"'%"# %!& +% 4%+%!9 ! 0 9 !/" $;0"'& !%' '!/".23'#!/ ! !/" ,"/%$+" < & 4"%'. 0+%"# %' $'!2 ,"'!%' !"2;& '#$'#%!%'& !/"%'&32 '$"0+%$9 ++<%'.%&&3"&<"2" 2 ;"#49!/"2%43' +(?

D/"!/"2 !/" $$%#"'! %' B3"&!%' < & $ 3&"# 49 2"&0'#"'!</%+"#2%,%'. ! .%$?*? @> %' 2 &/ '#'".+%."'!; ''"2$ 3&%'.#" !/

+ $+ %; '! +#",-%'./8 & ++"."#E %&&3"'%&02,"#8</"!/"2$+ %; '! +#",-%'./ %&"'!%!+"#! '9$;0"'& !%' '#% &8!</ !"C!"'!

'# 2;</;E

D/"!/"22"&0'#"'!'/ #,%+ !"# '9!"2;& '# $'#%!%'& %'&32 '$"0+%$9E?

"+%"

F" 2'"# 2%43' + ' $'&%#"2%'. !/"

$!& '# $%2$3;&! '$"&$'$+3#"#!/ !4!/2"&0'#"'!%"<'"2 '# #2%,"2 !/","/%$+" &<"++ &!/"$+ %; '!: 00"++ '!<"2""B3 ++9 2"&0'&%4+" %' $ 3&%'. !/" $$%#"'! /"2" 2"8 '".+%."'$" < & 002!%'"#%'2 !% * (* 1 +3" !/"#"$" &"#43

+< & &&"&&"# &@*8

G?'!/"4 &%& ",%#"'$"'2"$2# '# &3;

@8*

G? %" * H !/"2" < & < 2#"# ! !/" 00"++ '! ..2%","#!/"2" 2;02"&"'! 00" +/ &4""'02"

"22"# F" 2'"#$3'&"+ 2!/" 00"++ '!,"/";"'!+9 2.3"&!/ !

$'!2%43!29'".+%."'$"'!/"0 2! !/" 00"++ '!%&'!02,"#'

2"$2#/"2"

2"8!/"2%43' +/ &.2&&+9"22"#%'#"02%,%'.!/" 00"++ '! * H !/"$;0"'& !%' ;3'!!%& 32!/"2&34;%!!"# !/ !!/"43

+< &$ 229%'. ; +" "!3& 002C%; !"+9>I;'!/& </%$/ +&#%"#$;0"'& !%'/ &4""' $$2#"#'!/ !$3'! !/"2 2.3;"'!/ &4""'2 %&"# / ," /" 2# +" 2'"# $3'&"+ 2 !/" 00"++ '! '# 0"23&"#!/" %+" C

8</%$/< &2".%&!"2"# !!/"4"/"&!

!/"$+ %; '!%'2". 2#!!/" ++"."# $$%#"'!&/<&!/ !!/"$+ %; '! / & /%;&"+ ;"'!%'"# !/ ! !/" $$%#"'! !6 0+ $" #3" ! /%& #"$" &"#43

+ %./!%'.<%!/ '!/"2'"& 2"&3+!!/"2" 8/%&

+&!23$6 . %'&!!/","/%$+"%'B3"&!%'2"&3+!%'.%'%!&#" !/ '## ; ."!!/","/%$+""/ & #;%!!"#%'/%&$2&&"C ;%' !%' !/ !!/" ++"."# $$%#"'!!60+ $"#3"!&$3

+" !<43

+"& 3+!$ '4" 3'#<%!/!/" %'#%'.!/ !!/"#"$" &"#43

+< & 0"2;%!!"#!!2 ,"2&"!/"2 #<%!/;3$/,"/%$3+ 2!2

%$%'&3$/ $ &3 + '#23!%'"; ''"2!%&!/"#3!9 !/"<'"2!/ ,"! 6"'

020"2$ 2" '#$ 3!%'%'&3$/ &%!3 !%'!%&!4"'!"#!/ ! 2"&0'#"'!#%#'! +"" 2;!/"&0!" $$;0 '%"#!/"

$+ %; '!!!/"0+%$"0&! ; ."< &$ 3&"#!/%&,"/%$+" & <"++/"2"%&'!/%'.'2"$2#</%$/<3+#0"2&3 #"!/%&32!! ! 6" $'!2 29,%"< '2"&0"$!!!/"B3 '!3; $;0"'& !%'8, +3" !/"

#"$" &"#43

+ ."# %,"9" 2&/ &4""' &&"&&"#49D --

3/ '8 1"!"2%' 29 -32."' &&"&&;"'! %& C /"2" %& &0"$% %$2"

"2"'$"! ; +" "!3& 43!>I;'!/&#9%'.%'!/"

3!"23&%'C &<"++ &%'!/"!"&!%;'9 D !%&8!/3&8 ",%#"'!!/ !!/", +3"/ &4""' 22%,"# ! !"2! 6%'. ++!/" $!& '#$%2$3;&! '$"&%'!$'&%#"2 !%'%'$+3#%'.!/"#" # "!3& !%&2"+", '!!'!"!/ !D 8!/"$+ %; '!#%&$+&"#!/ ! /"032$/ &"#!/"& %#43

+ 2 &3; *8

G?'" '# / +

9" 202%2!!/"#" !/43!'#$3;"'! 29",%#"'$"!!/%&"

"$!%& , %+ 4+" F" 2'"#$3'&"+ 2!/" 00"++ '!%&3' 4+"!0%'!3!

* '9%'

%2;%!92%++". +%!9%'!/"B3 '!3; $;0"'& !%' &&"&&"#49 !/"+" 2'"#2%43' +/"2"%&'",%#"'$"'2"$2#!"'/ '$"!/" $;0"'& !%'& < 2#"#/"2"4"%'.'%'

%2;%!92%++". +%!9%'!/"

%;03.'"# < 2#8</%$/< 22 '!&%'!"2 "2"'$"49!/%&32!802"&"'!

00" +%&#%&;%&&"# #$%!#&& 3.3&!)8 * '()* 2!&