Jaspal Singh And ORS v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And ORS









  


 



 
  

 !
"#
!$%&%"'
(( &)*
+%',-
'.
" -!/&














 /
/0'
%1*%
2% /'
%,3

4 .(
'.
" -!/&





   5 4
(
+
+
+
     


 


 

  





 
+
+

6
(
/* !


" 


#


 
$$%&$$'


 
( 

)
*





" 

 
 



+

*
 
,*
 

$  -$-$-
.  /0 $ )
 
 

 
 
 

 
 

" 


1

 
#
#2
 /(  


 
2
$--0
#2
"2

  *
2
3

2
" 

 
 

 
2
$- 4
"



"/ 

" 




 ,

. 
/
 $$ -$- 4

 
* 
 2


 
)!)
 
 , 5  
! 
) 
 
6,
7*



" 


#



"

 
#

"/ 

" 















"

2
  



#
 

3
 


2

 

"/ 


. 
/$ 3" 

. 
/4
  
" 
 , 
4  -$- 4
3


 
 ,
 
 

"

,
 

)!)
+
  #,
#2
 ,
" 
 3

. 

2
 *



 
#
,


 
" 



 *


  
3
 





 
 
  ,
#2
*

( 
7 0'%

$- 8
"

,


 * # 

(/ 
9
( 

"
"

.  /:
3
#,
 
#2
"2

 
  
  
 
 
  ,
" 

 
#
# 2
"
 
* 


 

 

 

 
"
"


"
 
#  
 
"

#


#
"*
 +


 +

*

 
,*
  
3
#,
  







,*
 
. 
/0

*


  
#
 ,
3


 
  
 

#
,

 
 
;*,

( 



         

!"

 
  "#!" !"


$%

        ""

!"

 
  !" !"

 $

   &      

!"

!"

 '        &       (#

!"  3
   

 

 

"




. 
/0

 *


#

 
 
 


"

" 


#
 
2
 
  ,

   
 

 ,

7







  
 

 

)!)


5  
! 
) 

 
6,
7*
"

*<
#2
 
5
= ,

2  
= ,


 
# 
 

 
*
3
 



"/ 

" 
# 

 

 

  
" 

#




,*
 

 ,


 ,


" 


#
 
2
 

 , 
   
 

 ,
"

 
 2



 
)!)


5  
! 
) 
 
6, 7*
"


*<
 
3
 

 



* 
 



" 


. 
/8
"

  
>
3 2
9;
 
7*,

7

0 -$--%

 



#

 
 

+

   ,

 
 




1,
"
#
:-?

#

 #2
 
 ,


,* 
 

"



 
+ 
 
+
"

+ 
"

 
"
$
2
)!)
 @ &  ,
 

*
$
2

 

  

1,

#2
  
)!)
A

@ 3 2
 ,
2
 

*<
#2
 
5
= ,
!




 

 / )* +
  ,
 $
   - 

.   /

!0 -  1++ 2 ++

- 2& 
 
   3 
 -   ++13 +
56 78 9
1

&

:;:



<+

=  

3

& 
+  

  /

 2& ,
 :;:

> 
+ <
 &  &   


3? 2& ' 78

 -  = @

- 9
A









 4 1 
 

 

"


 *

 

#,
 



+

 
7

 

"
  
!


 
 
"

 
*

 
"
$ 2
)!)

@ &  ,
 

 
 
"

* *

#2
 
. 


B B
*
$
2

 

  

1,

#2
  
)!)
A

@ 3 2
 ,
2
 

*<
#2
 
5
= ,

3






$
2
)!)

@ &  , ! 

  





 
 
 


 
   +
 



#
*<
#2

 
5
= ,


"

2
"



 
"
+

 
#

$
2

 
 

 

 
  
+
 
 
   


#
*<
#2
 
5
= ,

#


 
+
 



 

 2
 #

*  
3


"

 

   2

" 
+

# 
  
"

+ ,
 #*
*<
#2
 
5
= ,
3
   
"

  
#2
 
(/ 
9

  ;*,

   

( 


 
# 
  

 

,2
* 






 ,  ,  
 
 , 2

 
"  


#2
 
(/ 
9
( 
3
 

 
;*,

"


#
 
" 




. 
/

/ 4 8 3
 


 
#
" * 
 
 
 ,
 
2
$--0

$- 4
 
 
*

8







 . 

 
 


 
 


;*,


( 


      

 

 



 


,
"




" 


 
 

1

" 
2

 / (  


 


 
"
"

 
 
" 
 
#2
 /(  
#
 
"

* 

#2
 /(  
 
#
*


 


 

#
'
2


 

*
+
. 

   

 
* 

 
;*,


(/ 
9
( 

 
 *

"
" 


*

  

  ,
 
 
#

#
+

 : C
 
 
 



 
 
 * 
# 

 
 /(  
#,
 
     2

 2




#2
 
;*,
 
(/ 
9
( 
"


#
 
*"




. 
/

/ 4
3




 
 


1
"
 
  
#2

  
( 


 
1
"

#
 
*"
 
  



. 
/ 4

" 
#  
 

,2

 

"
2

)!)
 

@ &  ,
 

" 

*
 
+ 
+

   



#

"


 



#2
 
5*
D*

 
1
"



3




"2
 
 

 

 + 2
 
#2 
 
9
;*,

1
7E8%

$- %
.  / 4

9







 % )

 
 
 
 

 
  ' 5,

 , 2

 
"


" 
 
 
 
#

1


 

# 

(  
(/ 
9
( 

. 
/

/ $

 


 



 
#;
,

 
   
.2
,

 


 

!


2  
"


 
 


 "*




(/ 
9
( 


 
 
  


*
#2
 
 
 

 

)!)
+



 


*
+


 
* 

#

 
 / + 
"
 
 


# *<

#2
 
5
= ,
!

( 
 
"
 
"  

#2
, 2

  
#






 
  
 


 
 


 




 
;*, 


#2
 
 
5*
D*

 
1
"
 



 . 
/ 4


 
1

"
#  
 

,2 



"
2
)!)
 


@ &  ,
 
   
 
 
 + 2
 







" 

!


;*,


1

 


 /

);

--++ + ++3   


 -   3  

1  -  3 4   +
 1 & B    +

+ =1    :;: 
3? 2& ' / 3+ 3   

1 - +&3

-  + 
     "#!" !"

 

 

    8  
+

   
 

:









;

-    --++ 1 -  3 4   +
  

--  "! !!#D

:

2+   "#"! !!

 ++13 +
 1 -
2  -  .   /56

)*./:E:.;:F EF$ ,:$<;

$<$:;9<;

EF$ ;< F;

FE .:;.;

/:<9.

!0 -  1++ 2 ++

- 2& 
 
   3 
 -  ++13 +
56

78 9
1

& :;:

 <+

=  

3

& 
+  

  /

 2& ,
 :;:

> 
+ <
 &  &    
3? 2& '

78 9

 -  = @

-  9
A

;

--++ +&   -  1 & B :;:

    <+

+=   1

+
@3 4   +
 : 1    +
 2  1

 -  2& + 3+ 3

,  A 0 !

  

( 
 
"
 

 
,

 2 #


#2

 
9
( 
"
* 

 
 *,
 
#2
 
 
 


   
 





2
, 

 +2


,
  #2



((














+
+
 @

 

 *  6 &7

 
 #  6 &7