High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4039/2015dismissed

National Insurance Company Ltd v. Pooja And ORS

2015-11-06Mr. Justice Satpal7 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*#+,#- ./ !"&(!0('1-!(%#+2!(34"$ 22#00!("

5#-'1'

6!!($"7#-' #'2($#("'

! !

-#'#(") -!*&($#---!/$*%!"# - -##-!687!((!/$*%!"#

-"7#!22#00!(" !

"! #

('"!(" !22#!0 7!' ,##( &0#$ ,3 !"&(!0 ('1-!(%# +2!(34&+&"#$%7!00#(:&(:!;!-$$!"#$ 2!''#$ ,3 "7# 0#!-(#$ "- %%&$#(" 0!&+' -&,1(!0/ &'!- 7#-#&(! "#- -# #--#$"!'"7#<-&,1(!0<;7#-#,3%+2#('!"&(""7#"1(#

// =>?7!',##(!;!-$#$"%0!&+!("'?-#'2($#("'" (!%%1(" $#!"7 !-#($#-

-&# !%"'/!'+#("&(#$&("7#%0!&+2#"&"&(/!-#"7!"( !-#($#-'&(%#$#%#!'#$;!'"-!*#00&(:(&'!-?#07& ,3#?2!''(+"-%3%0#,#!-&(:-#:&'"-!"&(? ?8?== -+ &'!-#;!'!"!+$#-!"#'2##$("7#%--#%"'&$# "7#-!$

@7#(7#-#!%7#$(#!-#''/#07&?&'!-,3#?2!''!" 2+ %!-,#!-&(:-#:&'"-!"&(?

?@?

$-&*#(,3-#'2($#(" .A!*&'7&(!-!'7/(#:0&:#("!($B&:?B!:+!((#-%!+# -+&'!- '&$# &# ,#7&($ !-#($#- !($ '"-1%C !:!&('" 7&' +"-%3%0# !-#($#--#%#&*#$'#-&1'&(61-&#'%%&$#(";!';&"(#''#$,3(# !0&2D&(:7'( D1,7!'7D!&(& @!($7!($#-D7#C7!-/;7 ;#-#!0'"-!*#00&(:(&'!-?#07&,3#?2!'' -+1"+!-C#"/&'!- ,3"7#&-%!-7#3;#-#,#7&($!-#($#-<'+"-%3%0#(61-#$;!' "!C#("#(#-!0'2&"!0/&'!-/"7#-#!

"#-'7& "#$"D!2-!'2&"!0 !"&'!-!($"7#("58#1-%!-#'2&"!0/$#0;(/&'!- ;#*#-/7#'1%%1+,#$"7&'&(61-&#'( &("7#7'2&"!0

'"+-"#+;!'%($1%"#$ $!"#$ E

;!'-#:&'"#-#$1($#-D#%"&(' /

F/ F !" 0&%# D"!"&(&"3&'!-#2-"1($#-D#%"&(F - E ;!'

&0#$!($%7!-:#E ;!' -!+#$(= 0!&+2#"&"&(1($#-D#%"&(.. "-5#7&%0#'%"/ ==;!'2-# #--#$,3"7#%0!&+!("';7!-#;&$;/+&(-%7&0$-#( !($2!-#("' $#%#!'#$!-#($#-";!'!*#--#$"7!"$#%#!'#$ ;!'-1((&(:!'72 '#00&(:+,&0#27(#'#!-(&(: / >?2#- +("7+1(" %--#;!'%0!&+#$!'%+2#('!"&( 0!&+;!'%("#'"#$,3"7#&('1-!(%#%+2!(3!';#00 !';(#-!($$-&*#-

#($&(:*#7&%0#!%"1+ "7#!%%&$#("

;!'$#(&#$ 00;&(:&''1#';#-# -!+#$,3"7#0#!-(#$-&,1(!0)?

@7#"7#-"7#!%%&$#("&(G1#'"&(%%1--#$$1#"-!'7 !($(#:0&:#("$-&*&(:

#($&(:*#7&%0#,#!-&(:

-#:&'"-!"&((?

,3-#'2($#("/!'

!00#:#$H

@7#"7#- "7# 2#"&"&(#-' !-# #("&"0#$ " -#%*#- "7# %+2#('!"&( -+ "7# -#'2($#("'/ & '/ " ;7!"

#E"#("H

@7#"7#-"7#2-#'#("2#"&"&( "7#2#"&"&(#-'&' ("

+!&("!&(!,0#&(0!;H #0&# 4#!-(#$ -&,1(!0 ( %('&$#-!"&(

!%"' !($ %&-%1+'"!(%#' %(%01$#$ "7!" "7# !%%&$#(" &( ;7&%7 !-#($#- -#%#&*#$ !"!0&(61-&#';!'%!1'#$$1#""7#-!'7!($(#:0&:#(" $-&*&(:

#($&(:*#7&%0#,3&"'$-&*#-A!*&'7 ('1-!(%# %+2!(3;!'7#0$0&!,0#"&($#+(& 3"7#&('1-#$ :# "7#$#%#!'#$A!-#($#-;!'%(%01$#$!' 3#!-'!""7#"&+# 7&'$#!"7(%+#"!E-#"1-( -"7#!''#''+#("

3#!- ? E F;!'2-*#$,3 @F!6#'781+!-/D#(&- !E ''&'"!(" (%+# "7# $#%#!'#$ ;!' #'"!,0&'7#$ " ,# / / >? 2#- !((1+ ( "7# ,!'&' (%+#!E #"1-( ( !$$&"&( I;!'#E"#($#$";!-$' 1"1-#2-'2#%"'&(*&#; "7# 61$:+#(" (<,0#D12-#+#1-"&(

((1!0&(%+# ;!'/"71'/%!0%10!"#$!"/=/ >?#$1%"&( >"7;!'#

#%"#$ !'2#-:1&$#0&(#'0!&$$;(,3"7#(<,0#D12-#+#1-"&(

" !'"7#-#!-# &*#$#2#($!("'&("7&'

%!'#10"&20&#- F;!'!220&#$&(*&#; "7#!:# "7#$#%#!'#$ "!0%+2#('!"&(

// =>?;!'!;!-$#$!'$#"!&0#$,#0;)?

4'' $#2#($#(%3

/ / >?

4'' %('-"&1+ / / >?

4'' 0*#!($!

#%"&(J/ / >?#!%7 "+&(-%7&0$-#(!($2!-#("' / / >?

#$&%!0#E2#('#'("7#,!'&' ,&00' /F / =>?

1(#-!0%7!-:#'

/ >?

"!0

// =>?

4#!-(#$ %1('#0 - !22#00!("?&('1-!(%# %+2!(3 *#7#+#("03!-:1#'"7!""7#&+21:(#$!;!-$&'0&!,0#",#'#"!'&$# !'"7#&$#("&"3 "7#$-&*#-

#($&(:*#7&%0#&'("2-*#$ ;!'-#:&'"#-#$( ;7#-#!'/"7#!%%&$#("

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

I!$$&"&(&("7#&(%+#(!%%1(" 1"1-#2-'2#%"'&'

1(%!00#$ -# #-#(%#&'+!$#"-$#-$!"#$ F $% &'

"&"0#$ ()*+(, !+-./(+%0 12(+3 40/-.-

$.-52((+6)50/- "!-:1#"7!""7#+!""#--#:!-$&(:!$$&"&(&( &(%+# ( !%%1(" 1"1-# 2-'2#%"' &( -#'2#%" '#0

#+203#$>2-&*!"#03 #+203#$ 2#-'(' '"!($' -# #--#$ " ! 0!-:#-

#(%7 ,3 "7# (<,0# D12-#+# 1-" 7#-# -#/ !;!-$

%+2#('!"&((!%%1(" 1"1-#2-'2#%"'&'1(61'"& &#$ E!::#-!"#$ !+1(" 7!' ,##( !;!-$#$ 1($#- "7# %(*#("&(!0 7#!$'/;7&%7&'0&!,0#",#-#$1%#$ 7!*# 7#!-$ 0#!-(#$ %1('#0 - "7# !22#00!(" !($ 2#-1'#$"7#!*!&0!,0#-#%-$ "&'("&($&'21"#"7!" $!"#$

;!'-#:&'"#-#$!:!&('"!*&'7&#$-&*#-

#($&(:*#7&%0#&( -#'2#%"""7#!%%&$#("&(;7&%7"7#$#%#!'#$0'"7&'0& ##2-"

1($#-D#%"&(F E !';#00!'%7!-:#E &'( -#%-$"&'("$#(&#$"7!""7#'!&$-#'2($#("&' !%&(:%-&+&(!0 2-%##$&(:'#-#$#0!3 ";$!3'&(-#:&'"-!"&( "7#&("7# 2#%10&!- !%"' "7#%!'#&'("!%&-%1+'"!(%#"%(%01$#"7!""7# !%%&$#("&(G1#'"&($&$(""!C#20!%#!'%0!&+#$ " 7!' ,##( 7#0$ ,3 "7# (<,0# D12-#+# 1-" &( $(/10-57(/*41*/5(+6(+6)50/-# $ "7!"&(%!'#'1($#-"7&'%"/&"&'"7#"1%7'"(# 2-#2($#-!(%#

2-,!,&0&"&#'(;7&%7"7#%!'# "7#%0!&+!("'7!'",#"#'"#$ 7#-#'710$(",#&('&'"#(%#(2- ,#3($-#!'(!,0#$1,"!'

&(%-&+&(!0%!'#'7#-#&'&($##$(#*&$#(%#(-#%-$"'1::#'" "7!""7#&$#("&"3 "7#$-&*#-$#'("'"!($#'"!,0&'7#$('1-!(%# %+2!(3%!((",#!,'0*#$ &"'0&!,&0&"3&('1%7%&-%1+'"!(%#'"

7!'-&:7"03,##(7#0$,3"7#0#!-(#$-&,1(!0"7!""7#(03&--#'&'"&,0#

%(%01'&(;7&%7%!(,#$-!;(&'"7!""7#!%%&$#("&(G1#'"&("C 20!%#$1#"-!'7!($(#:0&:#("$-&*&(:

#($&(:*#7&%0#,3"7# -#'2($#("A$-&*#-

#-1'!0 "7# E

-# 0#%"' "7!" &" 7!' ,##( -#:&'"#-#$("7#,!'&' '"!"#+#(" !"7#- "7#$#%#!'#$/;7 -#*#!0#$"7!"7#-#%#&*#$"#0#27(&%+#''!:#( "7!"7&'

'(7!$+#";&"7!(!%%&$#("1+,#-!($$#'%-&2"&( "7#%!-7!'

(",##($&'%0'#$,37&+;7&%7!22#!-'(!"1-!0&("7# !%"'!($ %&-%1+'"!(%#' "7#%!'#!'7#'"!"#'"7!"7#&++#$&!"#03"C7&' '( -+#$&%!0"-#!"+#(" @!0&2D&(:77!''2#%& &%!003$#2'#$ "7!"7&''"!"#+#(";!'-#%-$#$,3"7#20&%#!" !$!7;C&/

0&%#D"!"&(&"3&'!- "#-$1#&(*#'"&:!"&(/%7!00!(>-#2-"1($#- D#%"&(F - /E ;!'2-#'#("#$!:!&('""7#$-&*#-&( G1#'"&( 7!-:# ;!' -!+#$ !:!&('" "7# '!&$ $-&*#- ;7 &' !$+&""#$03 !%&(:"-&!0#$&%!0,&00'!';#00!' '"-"#+#2-"

!-#($#-E

(-#%-$2-*#$"7!"!-#($#-$&#$$1#" !"!0 &(61-&#''1

#-#$,37&+&("7#'!&$!%%&$#("7#-#&'("7&(:( -#%-$"'1::#'"!(3"7&(:""7#%("-!-371'/"7#-#&'(&( &-+&"3 &("7# &($&(:-#"1-(#$,3"7#0#!-(#$-&,1(!0("7&'%1(" (-#'2#%"""7#G1#'"&( !;!-$ %+2#('!"&(( !%%1(" 1"1-#2-'2#%"'/&"%!((",#$#(&#$"7!""7#(<,0# D12-#+#1-"7!''2#%& &%!0037#0$&("7#%!'# (80-5'12-!!'

;#00!'.++((, (*+49*2*+:.1(/ 5(/1(#$%& "7!""7#-#'710$,#!(!$$&"&(&("7#&(%+#(!%%1("

1"1-#2-'2#%"'!'2#-"7#!:# "7#$#%#!'#$#*#(&(%!'# '#0 #+203#$>2-&*!"#03#+203#$2#-'('71:7!-# #-#(%#&'+!$#

"-$#-$!"#$ F "7#(<,0#D12-#+#1-"&(D4 = = !"&(!0('1-!(%#+2!(34"$* 1'72!!($ "7#-'"'1,+&""7!""7#+!""#-&(-#'2#%""!$$&"&(&(&(%+#( !%%1(" 1"1-#2-'2#%"' '#0 ?#+203#$2#-'('#"%'"!($'

-# #--#$"!0!-:#- #(%7/&"&'("$&'21"#$"7!"2#-!"&( "7# $#%&'&(&("7#%!'# (80-5'12-!7!'(",##('"!3#$#%&'&( &(.++((, (*+-%!'#'12-!7!',##(-#($#-#$'1,'#G1#("" "7#-# #-#(%#7#-# -#/"7#-#&'(&00#:!0&"3-&( &-+&"3&(!;!-$

%+2#('!"&(&("7&'-#'2#%" 1-"7#-+-#/%0!&+!("'!-#%0#!-03#("&"0#$""7#!+1(" !;!-$#$(!%%1(" %('-"&1+!($ 1(#-!0#E2#('#' ("&"0#+#("(!%%1(" 0*#!($!

#%"&(""7#%7&0$-#( %!(!0'(",#$#(&#$C##2&(:&(*&#;"7#61$:+#("' (<,0# D12-#+#1-" &("7#%!'# (80-5 '12-! !';#00!' '( '

FDF.!($ ' ) )

D . 7#-# &' ( :-1($ - -#$1%"&( &( "7# G1!("1+

%+2#('!"&( 4#!-(#$%1('#0 -"7#!22#00!("&'1(!,0#"2&("1"

!(3&00#:!0&"3/&( &-+&"3-2#-*#-'&"3;7&%7;!--!("'&("#- #-#(%#,3 "7&'1-" 22#!0&'/!%%-$&(:03/$&'+&''#$ *-("*,, *#+,#- ./ .6;0 -"'