Dr Rosy Arora Alias Dr Rosy Dhawan v. Union Territory, Chandigarh
IN T THE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH .!/ ,,- 2 " 3 14 "
,,
,,
0 1 1
5 !"
# $%&'(!) *)+(!
!$+)#& ! *-2 *0 ,.2
! 3 02 02 /#1 ! %320 0/ .
/ ! %25"/6 02 7
!$+)# & *
. / # 0 0/
!" " # $%& ''(
')
'
'
' *+
) + ' ,*
- " ./# 0 / 1 / * * )
2 " " /*/ " /"/# / #2
,
2 2"$%/7 2 "
"
. " $% " / / #5#"
"/#8&# //
/ / / //
/ " " "02- -/ / # - - !-
* / "
"/ " / # //"" 0" 2 9 " # " / "2 #" 2 (
'
+ '
'
:
*// "" 2 # # - !- " .
# " " " *
/" / ;
;"# " * " "# # 3 7# // - !- #"/ //+
- -// # "
//# " * < /# *
-"./ #0
' 7 7 . / " // # #
# "/" / "0
, " /1 # // * :
'
'
'
</#/ / 2 2 " / 3/! = #2 7 "
#
# " //#" / "
/ - ! - " * 22 - - > 8 #
2 " 2" / & "" /* + '
' 7*
-". /# 0 < 0 ////#-/
/ # # # " / 2 * " / /# 2 2 .
/ / /# # / . " /
/ ')
'
: $% % /#
')
'
'
* " / /#
:
'
'
/ / / &// 2 2 "
# " / 02-// # / # 0 0/
/ #// / 2/2 " 2 2 * /
3 " # # 2 / ? " #" #2 .
. " / / /
&
0'
.+ (%
-
%
% %'
!
!
$ $$ **% %3 + (
#()(
* * + ( ,% * -.% 0
/ /% %. # %' + (
! 0% .
'+ (4%*% "
"1 '
%% 2+ ( + ( 56.% 7 # $%
3 0 + (
&
0 '
.8.% ( + % /# / # 4 .
"
#/0/ / 2/#/ 2 " $ $% 3 " " # .
. "
" # @ 0 // #"
/" . 2 / / "/ / /" / /# / . 2 "" /# / 82 & 2 # "7" /#; /" 22
"
" . // 2/
02 -// # # " /0 # " /# # / " / "# #""/ " / # "" 3 / & " 7 " .
. # " # " / 7 # / / / " . # "
" / / // )% 262
'%+ ( *".% %9, 3 * !7 * .
/(:( % + (4% *% ! #( + # ,,
2 *
+
(
6 %. * 7( ( // /2" / /
# " /7 " % /# / / 7 # / " / # // /2//
# 2 /2 # * / " 2 7 2 // 2 # /# //# /#2
./ / / / /" / ///# 0 2 # 7 2 /
A ; " #
: .
%+(4% %*%
B /* " 2 2 / * "2 27 # # "
" / 3 *"/ 2 " B / * " 0 0
%6 '+ (4% *% *8 ( !
- - .+ (
;
2 *8 8 (77
$ $$ $ **% %3< , 1 /% %. # %'< , # #( )(
* <, 1=$ .%' + (
-
$>7 %% . 7(./ /
2 2 2 / ""
" / ;" "
/ " " ; / " 32 2 2 /// / "" " # . " /3 2 / / "# 2 2 2 2/ " // 2#3 2 #// / # # 2 / 2 # / 2 //
6 :
2 2 2 2/ 7 2 2 2 / 2 " " 2 /
2 "//# / // / ;
; ; / "
" ;" // " / /" / / /" / #" /# 2 " % ; " "3/ "
" B /* " 0+ ( (
*%> !%?:
:7 2 2 # / # 0 2 /# /" // 2 /#
/" 2 ## / # C
2 /% %'
% @
. A'% %' +% 4(-( + ( '
"2 2 < # #7/ /#
"/ " / "/ / // # 7 # "/ #C
&
0'
.< , 1 2 / / /; / / /
2 #7 7/ ; " "/# # /2// " // / / / . ;#
7 " ;
; /# /# ; /
" # 2 /# /2 "# 2 / / "
"# # " /3 "
"/ 9 7 / / /"
"
/" "# / /# 2 2 / / /# #2 ) %/ / #()(
* <, 1
2 B / * "
2 " * 2 # # 2 # / 7 " ; ; / # 3 3
/ / "
#* // /## 2 D " / 2 D //# " 2 / " / * )% 2 62 '%B , 1 B / * " 2 22
* " / /"/3 23 2/ ?
? 2 "/ / # / 2 2 # 2
# 2
8 # . # . / ; /# / / </# /# 2 / 2 3/ / / " ; < 2 %// / * .
/(:(% B B , 1
B /* " 2 2 /" / 2< " / /# 2 2 /E E # / "//# / # "
" 3 2/2 3 // /" "# "# % / / )% .6 + (4% *% > " , 2 B /* " " ; # 3 2 //# # / 3 ; 2 . " / 2 2 # # <# #2 "
'
2 2 /
"" ; / / 2 "* 2## 2#/ 7 /# ; / 2/2 " 2 / 7 7 72 "/
/"/2/
/ " "
2 2 #7 /#; /" 2
# 2 2 / / "# 3 " /
9 /# 2 // / " 2 // A. " / 3$% % #2# 2 " $% //# / " /" / 2 "
",1#,1 /,1
/ ///# / # / ,1 2 " & & 2/" "/ / " $% 2 / 2 / " / 0 // 02-// 2 - !
- " / " # / # " / " " * / // 2 / 0 " /# / " / "/ " .
#/ "2/ 2 / .
./" 02-/ / / 2 " / * =: & / " 0 ::
/ # 0///
02-// //# " /
0;% #3 "'( '
'
) "
/ " . / / 3" 2 2
// 2 " " 2 2 " /
/ 0
/ " / " /
2 2 ; / 2 " 0 2 # 2 " // # #/3 .
" # # " # 2 # 7
0 < 2 // "
, 2
=
2 / /" //
" // // / / // / 2
+ * " " /
"
/B&B B / # " /" 7 # " / "
(MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE
,,
Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Yes/No Whet ther reportable