High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4070/2015dismissed

United India Insurance Company Ltd v. Meera And ORS

2015-07-09Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg5 pages

!" #"$%&%' (

'%!"#'#% '&)* '$"+, '-.!# ,,"// '! 0"*&)&

""* '#!1"*& "&,'#"'!& 234. 56

71"!1"*",*!"*& .$ /"8&, ,"*&+ -9" //8"#! &""!1":)#;+"'!< -"&

9"*"

"**"#!!1"",*!"*&*'!<-"& =71"!1"*!1":)#;+"'!&1)/#9"*",*!"#%'!1"%;"&!<-"& *"&"'!2 *> ),! ?#0$ !" '# &5' / !! ?#0$ !" *!1" ,,"// '! '%!"# '#% '&)* '$" +, '- .!# 1 & $1 //"';"# !1" 8 *## !"#

, &&"#9-51*% :""0- /? !*$$%#"'!

/ %+& *%9)' /? 6)*)@&1"!* 0%#" 81%$1 ' +)'! & =?(=?( A3 /';8%!1%'!"*"&!B C &!# 8 *#"#!!1"$/ %+ '!&' '$/ %+ ,"!%!%' %/"#)'#"*5"$!%'& '# DD !1" !*>"1%$/"$!? (EE ' $$)'! #" !1 +%!6)+ *

1" $!&? &,)! *!19-!1"$/ %+ '!&? *"!1 !' ( E

+%!6)+'*?&%'$"#"$" &"#8 &+0%'; *+0%// ;" '#%!!1"&%#"

1%&0%// ;".)@1%?81%/"#*%0%';1%&+!*$-$/"9" *%';*";%&!* !%'3

3 = 5 ':""0 6)+ * 8 & /& !* 0"//%'; & ,%//%' *%#"* ' 1%&

+!*$-$/" 1"- 8"*" //8"# 9- 1)&1 ' '# 5 !, / ' '!1"* +!*$-$/"+%!6)+ *8 &#*%0%';1%&+!*$-$/" ! +#"* !"&,""# '#1%&$**"$!/"

!1 '#&%#" !1"* #9&"*0%';!*

%$*)/"&! 9)!

= ,+81"'!1"-*" $1"#'" *0%// ;".)@1%?!1"

"'#%';$ *9" *%';

*";%&!* !%'3 (3(

$ +" *+,,&%!"&%#" !0"*- &!&,""# '#%' * &1 '#'";/%;"'!+ ''"*9"%';#*%0"'9-*"&,'#"'! !"* &""%';!1"

"'#%'; $ *?+%! 6)+ */8"*"##8'!1"&,""# 1%& +!*$-$/" '#$ +"'"F!*"+"/"

!1 '#&%#" !1"* #'@ $1 ,*!%'

9)!!1"

"'#%';$ *&!*)$@ ; %'&!1%&+!*$-$/" & *"&)/!?+%! 6)+ * '#1%&,%//%'*%#"* "//#8' '#*"$"%0"#+)/!%,/" '#;*%"0)& %':)*%"&1"*"

*"?%!%& //";"#!1 ! $$%#"'!!@,/ $"#)"!&/"* &1 '# '";/%;"'!#*%0%';

"'#%';$ *9-*"&,'#"'! !"*!1" $$%#"'!?

9!1 !1" %':)*"#8"*"&1% !"# !,' &,%! /?6)*)@&1"*!* 81"*"

5 ':""06)+ *8 &;! #+%!!"# '#+%!6)+ *8 &*" "**"#!?

1 '#%; *1 '# 1" &)$$)+9"# ! 1%& %':)*%"& ' !1" 8 - ! ? 1 '#%; *1 E# !"# ( E

)'#"*5"$!%'&

(?== '# = 3 !1"8 &*";%&!"*"# !/%$"5! !%'1 '& ; %'&!*"&,'#"'! '!1"&! !"+"'! 1)&1 '6)+ *1"*"

*"?!1"$/ %+ '!&1 0"

,* -"# *$+,"'& !%'!!1"!)'" &D ? ? A3 ''!%$"?*"&,'#"'! ,," *"# '# %/"#*",/- '# #"'%"#!1" 0"*+"'!&+ #"%'!1"$/ %+,"!%!%' !%& //";"#!1 !' $$%#"'!&! !"#!1 0"9""'! @"',/ $"8%!1$ *%'G)"&!%' '# /&"

$ &"1 &9""'*";%&!"*"# ; %'&!!1" '&8"*%'; *"&,'#"'!1"$ *%' G)"&!%'8 &%'&)*"#8%!1!1"'%!"#'#% '&)* '$"+, '-.!# !!1"

= !%+" //";"# $$%#"'!* -"* *#%&+%&& / !1"$/ %+,"!%!%'1 &9""'

+ #" "&,'#"'! '&)* '$"+, '- %/"#&", * !"8*%!!"'

&! !"+"'! '# //";"#!1 ! *"&,'#"'! 8 &'!1/#%';0 /%# '# "

"$!%0"#*%0%';/%$"'$" !!1"!%+" //";"# $$%#"'!81%$1%& 9*" $1

!1"!"*+& '#$'#%!%'& !1"%'&)* '$",/%$-1"*"

*"?!1" '&8"*%';

*"&,'#"'!%&'!/% 9/"!, -!1"$+,"'& !%' +)'!1"0"1%$/"%' G)"&!%'8 &9"%';#*%0"'%'$'!* 0"'!%' >$!"'-%';!1"* 0"*+"'!&? '&8"*%'; *"&,'#"'!& ,* -"# * #%&+%&& / !1" $/ %+ ,"!%!%' *+ !1" ,/" #%';& !1" , *!%"&? //8%'; %&&)"& 8"*"

* +"#23

71"!1"*!1" $$%#"'!*"&)/!%';%'!#" !1 +%!6)+ * !@,/ $"#)"!* &1 '#'";/%;"'!#*%0%'; *"&,'#"'! ?81%/"#*%0%'; *3 (3(

%&&)" %&,*0"#!81 ! +)'! $+,"'& !%' '# *+81+!1"$/ %+ '!& *""'!%!/"#!< 71"!1"*!1"*"8 &0%/ !%' !"*+& '#$'#%!%'& !1"%'&)* '$",/%$- '#*"&,'#"'! %&'!/% 9/"! , - '-$+,"'& !%'<3 "/%"

D 1"*%9)' /? !"* &&"&&%';!1"!"&!%+'- !1"8%!'"&&"& $$",!"#!1"$/ %+,"!%!%'? & *"& %#

""/%';#%&& !%& %"#8%!1!1" 90"& %#8 *#?!1"'&)* '$" +, '-1 &#%*"$!"#!1",*"&"'! ,," /

E 1 0" 1" *# /" *'"# $)'&"/ * !1" ,,"// '!A'&)* '$"

+, '- '#1 0";'"!1*);1!1"*"$*#& !1"$ &" ( ." *'"# $)'&"/ * '%!"# '#% '&)* '$" +, '- 1 & &)9+%!!"#!1 !!1"/" *'"#*%9)' /1 &! @"'!1"%'$+" #"$" &"# & &E A3,"*+'!1 &# %/-8 ;"*%' $$*# '$"8%!1 %/-7 ;"& &

%F"#9-",)!-++%&&%'"*?6)*)@&1"!* !%&&)9+%!!"#!1 !%'!1" 9&"'$" '-!1"*"0%#"'$"?!1"+%'%+)+8 ;"&$)/#1 0"9""'! @"' %'! $$)'!81%/" &&"&&%';!1"%'$+" !1"#"$" &"# '#!&),,*!!1%& $'!"'!%'? /" *'"# $)'&"/ *!1" ,,"// '! 1 & *"/%"# ),' )!1*%!-

! "#$ %&

'(!

1"&"$'#$'!"'!%'* %&"#9-!1"$)'&"/ *!1" ,,"// '!

%&!1 !+ !!"**"; *#%'; )!)*",*&,"$!)&%&,"'#%';9"

*"/ *;"*9"'$1

'49/","F)*! &9&"*0"#%') * + % , *

+ &

" $ )"$ ! -! .

(# + / (#5?!1"/" *'"#*%9)' /1 &$++%!!"#;* 0" "***9-;%0%'; +)'!' $$)'! )!)*",*&,"$!)& !1"#"$" &"#

1 0"$ *"

)//-$'&%#"*"#!1"& %#&)9+%&&%'9)!#'! %'# '- *$"%'!1 !&)9+%&&%'

1" $$%#"'!1 #! @"',/ $"%'!1"-" *

'#!1"*%9)' / 1 &! @"'%'! $$)'!!1"# %/-8 ;"& %F"#9-",)!-++%&&%'"*

6)*)@&1"!* &&E A3,"*+'!15?!1"",)!-++%&&%'"* %F"# !1" +)'! $$*#%';! %'%+)+7 ;"&$!5?!1"'&)* '$"+, '- $ ''!1 0" '-9"'"

%! *+!1" *"& %# )!1*%!%"&%"

0 + "* $ '#) * + % , *

0 + "* $1" +)'!1 &9""' //8"#@"",%';%'0%"8!1" :)#;+"'! '49/","F)*!%' 1 12

(' "'$ "$

1"+)/!%,/%"* !!1" ;"

,,/%"#9-!1"*%9)' /%& &!*%$!/-%' $$*# '$"8%!1 )!1*%!-

% & 3"'$ "$ // "

$ 1"*%9)' /1 & 8 *#"#& ? A3' $$)'! )'"* /"F,"'&"&H & ? A3' $$)'! !* '&,*! !%'$1 *;"& '#& ? ? A3" $1'

$$)'! /&& /0" '#

"$!%' '#' $$)'! $'&*!%)+! $/ %+ '!&5? !1 ! +)'! %& /& ;%0"' %' $'&' '$" 8%!1 )!1*%!- 1 0 + "* $

!1"*,%'!1 &9""')*;"#9"

*"+"

'&"G)"'!/-?!1" ,," /%&8%!1)! '-+"*%! '#!1"& +" &! '#&#%&+%&&"#

D $,- !1%&:)#;+"'!9"&"'!!!1"!*% /)*! *&!*%$!

$+,/% '$" " $

*6 3 (-