High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/641/2017dismissed

Sunil Bhatia Th Gpa Rajiv Oberoi v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-01-19Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan20 pages

#$%#&' ()

!+, -!../0 ). 1 -!. ..

! " # !

# ! $!

%%% .. ) & " ' () () *)(+,!

-./

0 1 23 4 $! 5 0 " 0 1 ((+ 67 5 0-

' 0

& 0 1 20 ' 0 - '

(8.8 "

01 ((+ 67 5 0 0

9 0

9 0 "

2 +) ))): &

2+ ))): 0 '(); 0

+8 ))):0 '(<; 0" " 6)

=-- -- --

! "

$ % & '$ " ( ( ) *

( + ,!

" " " " ! "

& ( - ,

(

. ' "

(

/ 0

- - ,

)1).1 23333, 4 " 5 233333

" "

! 2 /

5 )333, "6 78

! 3 "

4 "

" 6

%&'( 6 ';

" $

38 "

( !

$ " "! 7 4 " 5 27333, $

! "

3 "

$ !

" !" 4

$ "

2 4

!" 6 ""

"6 ! " 78" " 2$ < ;

" 3 "

! "

$ ( ) ; $ $

" ,

" " ,

$ ( ..

$ "

$ " "

! !$ !

4 " "

" " ,

$ (

! "6

= & 0 #

' < 0

6 2< ))): 0 " " +)

()

- -

! ' "#" 0 " 0

0 &

0 # "

"# 0 "

9 " ' 0 > >' ' 0 '

)8 )( *)). 1 2 ' ? 0

)7 (( (887 > > 0

*2 )( *)).0 @

5 5 0 , = 5A/0" " (( )* *)() '

(7 $0

! ! (877, >(877!>/ 9 0 " "0!

$! 5 0 1 6 )6 (* *)() &" " 0 (.

(8.8 *<; 9 (7(877!0

= A0

" '

' '" $! " 0

" ' " 6)

'" " 93 4 1 2

)+ )+ *)(( " " )< )( *)(+ &"

03 4 ' 0 )7 (( (887

! "

)* )+ *))( )2 () *))(

' 9 -B!

40 *.

(* *))7

' &"

0 '

*2 )( *)).

9 '

0 $! "# 0 0 @

" <# ## 9# ' >0 @ @

$ & () )< (88+0

" <# #C# " " (# (( (* (88+

" ' 0 0 &

'0 "

(7(877!0 ' ! ! ' ' "

" @ < 7<; " ? 0 ()

'" D();

" "

()

0 ! ! " "

0 9 " 0

( 93 4 $!" ' $! " (< 9 "

? 0)* )* *)(+ '" "

" 9 " 0 '

' " " 0 1 ( *8 )( *)(+ ? 1 2

1 2 () () *)(+ ,!

- ./

' "

86 22 286:,

*. 6( *(2:E-

+< (6 *78:/ 9

*+ (( *)(+0 1 ( # '

)< )( *)(+ ' 0 - '

- ' ' )7 (( (887, / )< )( *)(+, "0 " / 9 "

0 ' 0 9 " 0

' () () *)(+- 0

(7 )( *)(7 "

0 '

6) 0 -

" (8 )2 *)(7

- '

' ' '

& '8

' "

33)<<4

33)<<>

" /

$ " "

3333*(.-7+

6 .

$ .

$ ,

? 6 $

$ ! $

! .

: ! $

$ .

" .

= 9 ' 3*

) 445#6 55#7 #$8 #$9:4& /; #&'#$# &<#$

4=475>4$9%9:&?9' () )2 *)(6 $!

0@ ' (.

)< (88(() () *))7 >F > ' -

9 "

" .%<:#;::#$84&#$8#$9:4&/;#&'#$#

* &<#$ 4=475>4$9%9:&?9'#$8#$9:4&

( "-3)" @ "0

- '" (< " " -

G C @

& * +@

? 0"

" 0

: 0 '

" " ?

9@0

' " " "-

G " " 0

0 -

0- "

0 ? '

: '

0 0 @

& @#;4) '

9" "

( " "

0 @ 9 "

4 " 0 '@0 ' 0> - ' '

0 0 -

' # ' " ' '"

! '

" 9 0

' -

" "

& " " " ? 9 " ' ' 9> 0 " 0

0 9 0"

9" " " 0 -

" ? " 0

& 3(

A!"#"$

%% & '" ()* +$,"& % &

)

@ ' -

' , @4/

9 "

0 G ' @ @ -

" '0

H (88< - "

9 " ?

" (); $! ' '

@ 9 " '

' -

9 >-

> 0 ' " " ' ' ' $!> "

" 0 >F > " "

@ , /-!.

1 *+2(++% &' ()* +$,"& , / 3!,.

= (*,% &' ,& #"$&%&% &A" " # 0$!

'0 "

" '>-

>" "

' ' @ @ $! >-

>- " # '

9@ @ -

' 0 '0 " 0 ' &" ' ' -

" 0

" # 0 0

' '$! ' >F > '

'>-

> @

" " " # 0$!

' >F >

" ' '

' -

' '"

@ ?=?7&?949?9?$ 2

3.%<:#;::#$84&=4&;%;:4.9#94 #&'#$##$89:4&;

)7 *)(7 & "

" 9 " 0

0 3 4 '-

- ''

" ' 9@ '0 ' 0 " $!

(* )2 *)(6"

0 0 0 &" 0

@34 !

3<32;

323! !.

" "

# " .

4 $

A $

)32))2

$ $

;

" .

4 9

323 "

$ # "

4 #

" 4 323

6 $

" .

" ;

6 $

" #

! !

! $

2B !4 323 "#

" ))2 ;

" ! 323= 9 -

0' ' 5 '

$! '-

0 " !"#"$

% @#;4, / # 0$! '

>F > & 0 " " " 0'

" 0 ?

0- '

5 0 0

? 0 '

' "

0 0 9 ' -

' ' '

IF > '

0 -?

' : "

' 0 ' " :

& .-?=?7"2 *

/48#&6#;:C#9:%&?#=; #&'#$# &<#$ 4=475>4$9 %9:&?9' #$8 #$9:4&

(2 (( *)(( >0 @#

' 0 '" - " $!

" ' '

0 "

4 " 0 0

" ' ' " ' '- '

" " ' 0 "

' -

'" @

!%$?@?5#7&5&#9?$:#$8?D#&:#$89:4&;=/?5?$C%>#&#?$) .-

) *) *))7/

" 0 '

&" F"

' "

0" 9 0

@ C(

$ " "

" ; ""

(

. !$ D$" B "

$ 4 "

! - ;

! '

! " "6 "

! !

" -

. !

$ ! $

. ! " " .

B $ % ! >

38 " $

;

! ; $ "

! $

"6 "

! ;

!! !

C !

" 0 0 ' '

& ' ' ' -

0 '

& 0 -

00 '

"0"

-0 -

9 " 1 0 "

& 0 '

0$! " 0 # '

' '

- ' ' " & - " 0 ' ? '

" " ' "

? 0 ' ' ' -

@ ' ' "

(( (887

*<; !

+ (.

(8.8

0# 0 (<; ();0

0 0 9(<; "

0 " 6)

" 0 " "

9 "

" - !' (88( 9" )7 (( (887 9 " 0-

!' (88(7 (( (887" " 9 0 0 @

' 9 ' *2 )( *))." 0 5 5 0 " " " "

(( )* *)() '

9' " )8 )( *)).'# "0

' 0

' &0 ' 03 4

)* )+ *))( )2 () *))( 9 '

00 ""

(8.8"

" 0 0 -

)7 (( (887 *2 )( *)).

9 0 '

? "-

'0 ' *2 )( *)).," 0 @

5/ )< )( *)(+ ," " 0

/ 9 0 0 " ! '*<;

6 2< ))):" 0 " " +)

(8.8 ()

' - - " "0 50(88) &

9 "#"

0 >0 @ & 0 0

@ E#'C%>#& #?$=.9#94 #&'#$#

2"?=?7"2 3 "

' "# 9 0

$ " 6 $ 6

%1 ( .> ( 4&%5& ,%$ %, ,$5&% & $

E C);3" 2 6* +$,"& 1 # 7"+

$ $

$ " $

" F $ 1

" " $ " ! ! ""$ ! !

! 4 $

$ $ "

$ !

! " " $

" "

; " $ "

! 4 $ "

" 4

$ " . "

$ " "

" !

$ " "

! $ " $

" (

$ "

" 8+") "

* + $+ %

,+ % + &

%% &

&6& &&6 9" %+ +&" 5% " & :

)%%5&" &2 6 + & % %"

& 2 6 ) " & ; 2

$ 4&" <6& ) -&" &2 6%5&+ +&" %

+ ")% 4& $+" &&& "%

+ "+ -&&+") " 6& ""5 +

+ " $ % & + + +" &= + + & " &5 ++ "

;$5&&)%&" $%2+56 &;5" + % %

& 8 $)&6 "%

&5&$ " 8 & $ &"

$ %%5& "%

$ " $ + + & " > 6& + + + + " & & )&% &&6 "% + &)

&+ =+$"$ &+"% &% %+ $ &5 "% &5 "%&& "

$ %%5 &5 "%& $ + %% ?

;$ $ $ #

$ " 6 $ !

! "

$ !

;

" $

! $ 6 !

$ !

78 " " )<<4 %&'(

= 9 "

7<;0

0" '

0' # '

()

(

( 93 4 " '

, '

(/ $! " " 0 0 0)* )* *)(+ '" "

9 " " 0

" " '

? 7<; 0 9 - ' '

9 '

" "#" " E#'C%>#&#?$,;@#;4;%5&#"

0' "

3 ' '

9" )7 (( (887

9' (7 " 0#

" ' ' 0

0 '

' 0

40 *.

(* *))7 &" 'B! ' 9 0 0 - " 0 B! 0 @ /48#&6#;:

C#9:%&?#,;@#;4, /

" '

' , '

(/ "0 $! 0 9 "0

& "

0 0-

' *.

(* *)).< )( *)(+ ! '

& "

0 0)* )* *)(+ & '" 0006( )6 *)(. 0 9 "" 0" '

" ' @

6) (8 )2 *)(7 & 0 '

./0 " .. "

. #$%#&' ()

* G # ': J G0J :1