High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4114/2015disposed of

Hanifa And ORS v. Warish And ORS

2017-12-19Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal7 pages

!"# $% "

( # $% &

)

* !"# $% &

+

!

( # $% "

)

* !"# $% &

!"# $% &

!"#$% &'(&)*% %+! *))$ %+! *))$,'-.

, " %

,

-

, '

!" ' .

/ $0 $1 1

" (&& *,

$ .

# 0 0 " %

" %'

%(&' 0" '!'

$ *"

" &$ &$

! %1& "$%1 1',#" ''0

,

-

, '

!" '

%

#(* %%

% "

(%% '# ", 0'' ! " & , 2& %%

!',

!

"#$ 3" 0'' &

""

$1! (" 1

%% 4'

1 3*(

'# 0 *$, 5" 3*(

'6 0"*,%1& "

* !

") "

1$"%('

%% "

7&'

%

"

* ' *,"%'

7 "

%1 %1& 0" "

* ' *,"!

!$"%'

3" 3*(

' "

%1& " ( )#++# 89# ' "(

9 "', %1" % ) #:89 2 &

';&

8 " ('&'

- < &

%, )-#:# 89 ) +#-89; - ( ';& )89 <% (1 ) #89

+ 4( '"%'

"

(*1 "3*(

'"

''0 * % %1((&&%"; = " '!" '

( !1 . 6*' " (&1 4( !% !& '(!

)*+,!

-.%"/ (!

!-0*%1 !

"%1*( 2# 0# >( %1& 1 ,* ''0 (

% $

' "

4( ' & ! " &

# " % ,# "

(&& 1 %1& 3" % ' *"

" 0 0# ( %"'

0 1"#"'

' !%1& 3"%'

"

'' * ' % %1((&&%"; = (%" ' &

%, %1 )##-89 ?)#+ #89 ) :89; ; -@)+## :89 =0 ((&&%A )+##89 8 " 0 &

';& B 3" %'

"

'' * ' ''0 ! %1& (

% $

' "

" '!" ( !1 (!

!-0*%1 !

" %1*( 3)! *(& 9 <% (1 ) #89 ( ';& 8'

) #89 < ) #89 / $0 " *$# ' %1& %1 ) # #-89

"

' 1( )+# #+-89) # #-89 9)#++# 89#& , *'0" " =&

(11 "

& '' 'C ;%& " & ,

-

,#*"

*,"%'

1" 3*(

'

3" '& ', ''0 "

1

#$ 1'"1 #!

!$"%'* .)9--9- "

' " ' '

! " 3*(

' % " 0"*," (

%%1&

,"

* !$ !" %$, !

&

"

1', "

D 1'"1 # $

&%$',"

$"%' 3"'(*1 1

*,%( '"

"

"$"%' >( '

*,D 1'"1 * ('F 8:

*,* ('F ) "" .

G"

& " %% # "

'

*'& ,%1& " (

%%1&

,%

!" %$, !

"1/("(*1 "

"

'

(

)('

0" % "4 4$'% (# : "H44H

(%

'$ % & (% %

$

;(9

$ % '" $"%' >( 4( ' & ! " (

% %1&

, "

(&&

!"3*(

'(&"'

!&' " ("

" ( !(',$'

!"1

%

"&'%,/ !( " (

%%1&

,'

% ''

!(& "&

& (%" %(1

1',! %% # $ !'% %

&1*(" 10 & (% 3" 0 & *, " 3*(

' 0" " *$ "

% !

& %(1 !

&

0('

* "1

' % "% /(" !( &

"

1',E " ' & (%" $ !'% %

"0 ' & (% " &1 % # "

!"', * "'

*, " 3*(

' "

" (

% %1&

, ' %$, !

"

(

$"$"%'

"

1 ,# &( ' " 0 1 ' *, &

0('

1 7$ "

(%"&' 0 *,"

&

"

"$"%' >( '

*,"1 $(* ('F

*,* ('F ) "" .

G"

&"%%( %"

,(%" &' #" &1

'$ %*

(% " !

I$ "0#

'$ % '' 0"

"&($0

1*" ''

,"%'

( #

*)('" 443" & #

$

;(9 &

1*' $ %I;

1

,

!'#" 1 " &'

(%

' $ %

%%

!', " 1 % / * %

,&'

"

"$"%' '

&"%%( %#"%

*" ,"

" '

*' & , %1& I;

1

"

!'# "

% ( *! "$"%' "

,%%( % 3"# 0" " % ;

" '!" ( % *, . H*'" (&14(/

' 1,!!& ! .**&!!

"%1*( / 01!4'

%&! !

" %1*( 2 0 56# % *, "

1(

$ % 3" $ "

! $"%'

& (% "

$ ! '% %

*' " (

% %1&

, 7 % , $% 3"$, %"

"" $ 0 "$"%'

- & (% " $ ! '% %#

$ % * "

$

&'% %/ "$0"1 # 1(%" '''!

',%

* %

!"3*(

'"

" ( !(',$'

!1

%

"% % (

% 3"* !"4("(&1( '& " 0('

$ '"

&

3*(

'#&

#

*0 % (&&',%&, ! %% # $ !'% %

&1

!$"%'*,

+: I$ $

+: # " 3*(

'

0

$ % !

9& "

%(1 *, &

#

* 3" 0 % ( &

#! "$"%'& &1>( "$"%' >( 3" & #%( '" (

% %1&

,"

', 1 !$"%'0!"'"

+ GF#$"%' >( >(&1 $0"&$ % --"J"%'%# ::K

"%%(1

%# "3*(

'"

%11 (*,"'

!"

" ( "

%11 * %" " &'%, *, '

! & (% " &18( &13"

!% *,"3*(

'!$ !%$,!""

(

% %1&

, %%( '( & (% " &18( &1 '

*'*

%%

!', "! ! # '' *,! " $"%' & 0" 1 % "

1 3"

( !(',%11 !* %""1

%

" % % (

% 9& '% %*," $#!" %$, !$ " (

% %1&

, !

" ( #

& ,1 "%'

#7& %" '"

* % 1# %

, %

1%'$

% ', $2# 8.9 52F('

6 E""& !8

,8 E""& *'

,8