Tulsa & ORS v. Parwinder Singh & ORS

   

     




 
  !" #   
  "$% %&' (
  )*  * + ))* ,!* - *   * + *  *

(  .)  * *-)  

!"#$  %  '&  !"#$ 

&"(


 ))))) *-)/0 )1 *

+ )*,,

 && $   $"   " - &&".-  " $/  &"
%   "% && $  #0 %     "$/  &"!%

 0" 1 - 2 "

-   3 % $""!/.4$ 4/ 5$&   
 7 && % .  ".-%0"0 / $% "  .83%!0%"" #%$/  $$" 2 2



7 && % .  "! 3% $  $  
 9!:!9 ()! "" .- %  "  $$" *   ;./  $% /  %

  "   <% ;./ =  % 3/" %  %

""% . %"$  %"$ "0 03 -

"> ?

%@/ 

 ""0 "% . %"$ > + ?#0 %"$ ".3  & -" ". 0+ -  3 8$" -! % / &  % " 03 - . && "  <

=  % @/  && - / &  < 2=;%" -!""/$0 "& 5&

" > ("   % $    % "$ " 0  3 - //  . ! $ % "$ "   .%" # "&"! %  ""/$ 0  @/"  .

" > (+%   % $    % "$ "
/%

/% ". "" $$/     67   !  "$/   &"  $"" % 

%/3%%"$ "0   ""

 -0 3-$  %"$ " % "  .  "   
  () & %  /$%  %  0 & .    "0  &% $  % # &" /"/"% / A 3$.-%8  B -  *&- %  $ !%03  / 0 3 
2: :& .    ""

 - 3!"/ -3".-  "$/  &"

$"

 );%

"&/".-  "$/  %  6+7 $$"3 -! % $    % "$ "  

 
 2: : /"" 
29()& %"

" -!%"$ "0 9- 

3 &"$ */<
 

         

=! 



% 33/& + ! / &  < 2= && $ . $$"3 -!

 / &  <

= && ".-%  ";./ / &  < 2= % .

 $$/ $ &/3%$ & .  627
/% /  
 ! ! ()0 "" $$/   &/ $/ B0#!%"$ """  #3.%"0"0

/ $% "&& 3 &% # %"$<          


 

=! 



  !
+ ! ()& .  $$/   &/ $/  B0# &/.@/"$ */< 

              

=!  



  !!!! /  
+ ! ()& .  $% $% "   % "$ "  $$/      &   $/   8$ % "$ "   .%" % 0"0 /  $% "! % ! %

0"0% " "
+ ! () $$/   &/ $/ !0% % /$% " %"$ " % " "
+ ! () $% $$/   &  $/ ! 
 ! ! ()  B0#!  #0   /.@/ "$   B=.  % 8/& */<          

 !  "

"

" 

   # #3  0"0 " 0  $% "!%  $/ 0 $"
 ! ! ()$$"3 -! % 3%   "$   B=.  % 8/&  */  <     !  &/ (&  $/ $"
 ! ! ()

/% .& " $$/    $$"3 -!  & 3 &% # %"$ %B=. 8/& */ 

   !%  % " "
#! () $$/         /   
 2! () 0 ""  $$/  / 5&B0#!%

  . .$ ""0
 2! ()

& 3 &% # "$ */ 

=  $$"3 -!% 3% %& " .#! %  % " "%  03$ ) "2$&34"2' ''%''%#56 $7%253 "4 0 
1 % "''%''%# 56 $7% 87 32$ 0 
1  &9%"''%''%#  () 2: : /"" 
29() ##(3$32%2':%&$'  ?  C 9 () + ? 29C

+:() %#3&$ '

(" :9 C  () 

(+% :2 2C 9:9:2 /"" 
 9:

() $"4 &9% 2 34$:4%2

2 )'' %:% #% &6

C:!+9!9 () 25

2C !

+!+9 () )''  '2$39

! ! () + ! ()%0"0 + ! () $%$% "
 ! ! () ; 
 ! ! () D$"
 ! ! ()   "$ B=.  %8/& */<     )''  '$"$% ,E

2! () 3 %2"4 ;:% '%'

2! ()

2! () $"4 9:% '"$  </=/<!

//<!

67 $$"3 -!% 3% %& " .#! 

 /   
 9!:!9 ()! %   % "  " 


!++!+9 ()

30%>:2?& /  %"

 %$  &!  "

 & ! & ! -  "-

" 6:7 "   ! % ,/ $ * & - %  ""/$  5  . - -@/ //&&$ $$"

$0%%"$ 

     /% %  % $  %  . &&"

3 %   %

 "$ " .- %  " ;./  $% / !  % "  $$"3 -!   "44>%#! " "

"   :

+! & " .- %  " ;./ !  $% / !  9# %#  % 5 " .# 0*-)1  " 3"26/
 $%&'

A%%&

3( " F( A%%& .  F(