← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6461/2017dismissed

Nirmal Singh v. Central Adm Tribunal & ORS

2017-07-31Mr. Justice Surinder Gupta,Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

 

     

 !"# $ %&'()*+!"# ,$-./

 0&(& /$1,&$2($+/$1.$/3/&

&41& 



 !"#$%&!"'(#&%% )"#*+!



 !"#$%&!&% )"#*+!

&'

5 0&/$ $6$+1%$+ /4

77777 &% )"

  /$.  ,$1  (&(%%&& (  2   /  $ 1,&$  2($+  /$1.$/  %/  8   &/  9:;  

  "

"<""!* <!"

 &  =  $&&$.  /  1  1$1  !* # !"> 8?( @A;+=/2)/&%$& &44.(4 /4$)+/$&2 $%%11

5 0&/$ $6$+$1%(&4&./4 &(2,1/$

BA*+/4$.=/&,/4&&+ %(1..$-./+=$&$441$&$1(%//$1.$/ $&4 1$C.

&4/&)&+/4=$&&/=$ -  *""+=/$&.$-./=$&$*"

/(&+/=$&6( &4 2.6(+.$-./=$&1$=.,4$)/$/4$1 /&.$1+/&(2,1$4&$ &44.(4 /&4$)2. /,$4$+2(/D(&/$&26%1

   (/  &(2,1  /$  /    )+  /$1.$/ $141  /  (6$2  $)  (&  $&  =  $&  /  &%  %1&  $& $44%$2/,4)& /-$  (6$22) $,./(& C=  $&  91&    -%      )    /$1.$/ ,4)& (@BB!:1$1*

BB!+=/%/=,$1$44%$2=

BB  $14 / (6$2 (&2)/ )+/&$1 (&$$(,$%$)$44%$2/,4)& / )+ /$1.$/+%(1.$)$,1,,$12)/-$  (6$2 , ,, &&%$/$,1,& / (6$2, =(1 $44)//$1.$/1,&$ %%1.

  /  &(%&  1$1  #

BB*  8?(  @ ;+  &&(1  2)  / ,  (6$2+/4$) /&&D(12&441(4 =//4&6(/,&$&..,4$)2)( $($ %,+4,+.$ %,% =$&(.1/$$&.

$&&.12)/ 1%./%$& /4/4,& /$=$&2$12)$= ,$$&/4/$1 $1?%& /  4    &4&    /    1$1  #

BB*  8?(  @ ;+ =/$& $%/%$, /4/$&21%12)4$&&./ 1  1$1  !* # !">  8?(  @A;

   =$&  %11  /$    =$& %(.%$(& $%$1$/2&+/ %(12% 1 $$&(4*A,/&= /6(1.,11  , -  $ .,/ - 0 121# 

& -// -1) 345$%4 36//5 %%1./$1%(& /4+/ .$ 44%$  &/(1    /$  2  1&,&&1    ,  / %,,&<1 %(.//$2%$1  /=&+&$

4 &1$=/$/4$) /&%$2&&/$/6(/ &$,%$1= /1% 9D($4$) D($=C:$1+/(&+ $% /&41&$,(&$  (1$,$./$& &/1(1%& $1  /&( 1$

=$&?&(2,1/$$$./4&4& /1$1#

BB*+%(12 $),$$,4$%$& =$&  /  1()    /  14$,    $44&  /  ,4)&  .$1. ?%&. /4 $.% 1=/&(%/4+/ &(./%$211 (./%(& //$.+//$1 .$144()/4 $$ 1$&$.=/// =$&.$1$)44()?%&4 -(%/$$ 1$/$1 2 12(=$&$11$1+/ + /&( &D(12)&.@$&1/,4(.11

/$/$1/$1%(& /4+$44$&1 /4$42C+,4(.11$1$ /=/$/16%. /%$, /42.2$12)$= ,$1&%$  $) % /&4111$1#

BB*8?( @

;+/$1$44&1$/14$,&&C4 ,/,4)&  &44.(4 /4$) 4(&$ /,4(.11%/$.12  /&/=&/$/4/$1D(&1 &44.(4 /4$) ) > !">/&14$)&%$=

BA /4,& /$/11?%&/4 &(%/& 4$)&%$  1(./41%) / .$44%$+/4=$&%$1 (4      $  $ 1$+  =/%/  =$&  1  $.  =/   "

"<"">#"<!"

&$& $%)?4$$/$&2 (&/1 /$ 1$+=/%/=(1&$& )/$/?&1$&$26(& %$

 ?%&./4, /%$, /4=$& )/./)2$12(&$  / .$44%$/$&2./) 1&,&&1, =$ ?4$$ (&/.4=$) 2$%C/)$BB* & /4$)=

BA

/  4%4    $=  (%$1   5/1  -./E&  %$& 8&(4$;

) &=%.F1+2(/ $%&$1%%(,&$%& $%/%$& /$    2  ?$,1  /  4  /  %$  1  $) 2  / ,/4&%$&/$2&% ?%& 42)/,

$. $11&=//,+/,$C. $4&$ !">=(1?1/41 ,$ )$ ,/1$ $%%($ $%$&4-%!  /1,&$2($%+ BA>

/$&& $ ,1+=1  1 =/ / 1.&112)/=/1&,&&./ .$44%$

&($)+/=4&$1&1&,&&1

8"'(#&%% 5  3&% 5 "#*+!

 "#*+!

"274) /8 1, , , 16 /9 .: /1

- '

1:

, ,  /;

'

1: