National Insurance Company Ltd v. Bindu And ORS





  
  










 




 !"#$ $$$$$  %

 ##&

    $$$$$

 # 


 !"#
 
$%&'( #
&% (#
)%*'

 '

$

(( )*#+   , $  ,

 # $-.$ &+,-,
)+./
$
&    , # /! 


  ! "#$ ( ) # # # -0$12$31-3  # /! &  '  

#   /* 4

#5& /67, & 8 4

#5&

#67* + &

#  -9$1:$31--$ 3$  ) # , & / & /

 & ( # !  & ;, ) # *#  #, ,&

/ (< #, < ,/

+!$ .$ & / ,
-=*9.*111>? * )& &)   #,)@?
  

  

47  ,

#  -9$1:$31-- 47 (

:3!

4+7 '&!

#
-1111 4+7 .1A , 4+7 ## # ) # ,

 
-1111B
.1117C
-.111

& 4+7 ->:&,4+7/+ #


-.111?
.3E17C
29E1

&

 4+7   

 !( &  

,-: 4
29E1F-3F-:7C
-=.0111 4+7 


E111 4D7  , ,+ # ,,

  
3E111 4D7  , , 
E111  
0

:$  , & #& ) #& ( #& /&) (!< 

#
-1*111>?

&$ ) + #

#
E111>?!$  ,

G?3H$## G?EI (

( #(

#&   )&&



+$&(&*  &+  # # & #

# # ( &     I/  

 )& '&D

'**'>'#' !*( *  ) I '#*  # '>   (   ) * $$ #*  ) ( (
E111>?*
.111>? #
3111>?



+ ! ,  /+

 / & ! &+  , #  +  /!  #( (  #

+ ( +#

&&

#) #)&  ( 

) #'#' !*( $ , &

/ && /&# ##,.1A

,

/

)##)/!6/  D  ,           
  

 !"#$ $ !

 #

%* 3EA ## # /  #     , &   ,

,& ( ,

&:1!

) #&,

$ E$

!*
 &+   <  /

+ , & / )&  (

#
-1*111>?*)& &

,)@?
  

            

  

  !"  !#   

$   

    

       



  %"&

   ' 

( )$ " 

 *+" ,  * #- , #. #**"* - / #0  

$)  #.    

) " "       

   * 1 2") 2""

 3

# 4 , # .     " 

 
5666      .       

#

 "    7, 

    566 56   56 5# 5#  

   

 "   

    

        

) 

"( 8,9 #    **+" ,  * # -  , # . #       "          #  "

 

( ) $ "     " 


:666   

      .          "

     *#568 

   $ :.   3    "

 $ 566

*#56 ; :<9)2

         =  *# .             $9* . . "      

  ! / >5#$9* #.  "      * *" * -  /   : ")   "       

           # "

%"  !,%" 

( )



   "          " 

  
666     .  "          " 

( " 

*+" ,  *  12")2""

3

.   



(

  "

 

#? /   "    

   )       

      

   

  

            # 8  :  "   

 ?   

)   

"))          



:

  "  

?

  

     )    7" "         

 

 :   "    

  ?#



         "

 %"   )
6#666   

  

( )   " 

! *" ,  * - , #. #*" * -  / # 0  

 $)  # /  $9 * # .   1 2") 2""

 3

# 4 , # . @ =$ 

 , 

 , ,

# ) *
 ,# & &  #/ &

#

?

D$ G?.H

#

H& * ! #

# !

,  / D

 ,&, , , !

,31-1?31--# !

31--?31-3D$ ?3# D$ ?.$ 9$  , &# )! )  !

, 

#D$ ?-*)& &/ # -=$13$31-3# & ( #&)

$


 &

,  )

$D$ ?-&  !

,   / 

,    & ,,

 & & 8  )

#  

)& G?.#)( ( !,
3111>?

 &$ &(&*  &    D

  

,   ! #  &

#  #/

, !  #&, ) !( 

,  !$ G?EI ()

# ,I'#* $ & #

 !, &/<4D$ ?97)& & !,&

#&)$ & #&#

#)) <(  

)&'&"D

'#  (  )  ) $ & ,  &  /

   # /! G?. H

#

 H& $ 
 & /

,! +#



/&   *
,&  && / & (&!

 #  

 , &   )  )&   (

 

##/

+,& /&

( , 

$ 0$
  ,   
 !

 #  6/   D   & & # & , ,

& ( (  ,:1E1*##, 3EA/ # & ) #,

$&

#) :3 !

 , (  # ##   /  #   &   

 #  , 6/   D   /+

$   ,
91*111>? 

+ & #/ ) # 

/

+, 6/  D  ,  
!

 # 2$
+ ),!/+ # * )& & 

 #

 #,)(@?
  

  

47  ,

#  -9$1:$31-- 47 (

:3!

4+7 '&!

#
-1111 4+7 3EA,4+7/ ## #,

 
-1111B
3E117C
-3E11

& 4+7 ->:&,4+7/+ #


-3E11?
.-3E7C
2.9E

& 4+7   

 !( &  

,-: 4
2.9EF-3F-:7C
-E9E111 4+7 


-E111 4D7  , ,+ # ,,

  
:1111 4D7  , , 
-E111  
12

-1$  ; ,!# /+ *&  &

 # &      ! 

#$ ) # , & /  #, # # &

) # , 

#


-=*9.*111>? 
-=*:E*111>?$ &   ,  )

! 

) #/! /, & # ,,(,&  

 

J$ ?


 !/ (

,, #( + & )# & &

, & /<

  !&  (&# ## ,$)&

, ,)@? ?

 # $-4), 7 @ E1A 47 ?

 # $34#(&

7 @ 3EA 47 ?

 # $.47 @ 3EA $+,3
/


&% (#
)%*'
I<























$%)#
  ( )    A /  

  A /