High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4191/2015dismissed

United India Insurance Company Ltd v. Ranjit Kaur And ORS

2015-07-14Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg5 pages

!" #"$%&%' (

'%!"#'#% '&)* '$"+, '-.!# ,,"// '! 0"*&)& '1%!2 )* '#!3"*& "&,'#"'!& 456. 72 83"!3"*",*!"*& .$ /"9&, ,"*&+ -:" //9"#! &""!3"1)#;+"'!< "&

:"*"

"**"#!!3"",*!"*&*'!<"& =83"!3"*!3"1)#;+"'!&3)/#:"*",*!"#%'!3"%;"&!<"& *"&"'!4 * 1"&3273 *+ >#0$ !" *!3" ,,"// '! '%!"# '#% '&)* '$" +, '- .!# 3 & $3 //"';"# !3" 9 *## !"#

, &&"#:- &, +7%';3> /" *'"# !* $$%#"'! / %+& *%:)' /> 3 '#%; *3 0%#" 93%$3 ' +)'!

& => >

?5 /';9%!3%'!"*"&!@(A&!# 9 *#"#!!3"$/ %+ '!& %' $/ %+,"!%!%' %/"#)'#"*7"$!%' BB !3" !*C"3%$/"$!> DD%'

*"&,"$! #" !3 7 * :1""!7%';3%' +!*0"3%$)/ * $$%#"'!

3" $!&> &,)! *!3:-!3"$/ %+ '!&> *"!3 !'

7 * :1""!7%';3&%'$"#"$" &"#>&' !3","!%!%'"*&9 &;%'; *+ 3 '#%; *3!.)#3% ' 93%/"#*%0%';+!*$-$/" ! +#"* !"&,""# '#

'!3"$**"$!&%#" !3"* #"9 &:"%'; //9"#:-3%&:*!3"*0! * 7%';3' '!3"*+!*$-$/" ! :)! = ,+>93"'!3"-*" $3"#'" * )*#9 * 7 3%:> '9 > )&:" *%';*";%&!* !%'5 =5D=

$ +" *+!3"%*:"3%'# !"*0"*! E%';!3"+>!3"#*%0"* !3":)& ,,/%"# :* E"& // &)##"'>%'!3"+%##/" !3"* #>9%!3)!;%0%'; '- %'#%$ !%'*&%;' />!3);3!3"*"9 &':&!*)$!%'%' *'! !3":)& "&,%!"!3" $!!3 !7 * :1""!7%';3 ,,/%"#:* E"&! 0"*!!3" $$%#"'!>3%& +!*$-$/"&!*)$E ; %'&!!3" *"& %#:)&'!3%& $$%#"'!>3"*"$"%0"# &"*%)&%'1)*%"&"9 &*"+0"#!%0%/&,%! />23 + ' '# *+ !3"*"3"9 &*"

"**"#!>3'#%; *393"*"3"#%"#' =

=>#)"

!%'1)*%"&&)&! %'"#:-3%+%'!3" $$%#"'! ( # !"# =

)'#"*7"$!%'& D=> ( '#= 5 !3"9 &*";%&!"*"# !/%$"

7! !%' !"3; *37 3%: ; %'&!*"&,'#"'! '!3"&! !"+"'! !3"

$+,/ %' '!3"*"

*">!3"$/ %+ '!&3 0",* -"# *$+,"'& !%'!!3"

!)'" & >

?5 ''!%$">*"&,'#"'! ,," *"# '# %/"#*",/- '# #"'%"#!3" 0"*+"'!&+ #"%'!3"$/ %+,"!%!%' '#&):+%!!"#!3 !'" . :37%';3 0%// ;"# *,)*%&!3"*";%&!"*"#9'"* !3"& %#:)& "&,'#"'! %/"# &", * !" 9*%!!"' &! !"+"'! '# 3 & ,/" #"#!3 !3"3 #"'; ;"#*"&,'#"'! &#*%0"* *!3"

"'#%';

:)&>'/- !"*$3"$E%'; //!3"*"F)%*"##$)+"'!& "&,'#"'!= %/"#&", * !"9*%!!"'&! !"+"'! //";%';!3 ! *"&,'#"'! 9 &'!3/#%';0 /%# '#"

"$!%0"#*%0%';/%$"'$" !!3"

!%+" //";"# $$%#"'!3"*"

*">!3" '&9"*%';*"&,'#"'!%&'!/% :/"

! , - !3" $+,"'& !%' +)'! "'-%'; !3"* 0"*+"'!&> '&9"*%'; *"&,'#"'!&,* -"# *#%&+%&& / !3"$/ %+,"!%!%' *+ !3" ,/" #%';& !3" , *!%"&> //9%'; %&&)"& 9"*"

* +"#45 83"!3"* $$%#"'!# !"#

=>*"&)/!%';%'#" !3

7 * :1""!7%';3>$$)**"#' $$)'! * &3 '# '";/%;"'!#*%0%'; 0"3%$/"5 =55D= :- *"&,'#"'! <

83"!3"*!3"$/ %+ '!& *""'!%!/"# *$+,"'& !%' * #" !3 7 * :1""!7%';3>% &>!93 !"G!"'! '# *+ 93+< 83"!3"*!3"#*%0"*

"'#%';0"3%$/"9 &'!3/#%'; 0 /%# "

"$!%0"#*%0%';/%$"'$"'!3"# !" $$%#"'!

'#!3"0"3%$/"9 &:"%';#*%0"'%'0%/ !%' !"*+& '#$'#%!%'& !3"%'&)* '$",/%$-<5= "/%"

B 3"*%:)' /> !"* &&"&&%';!3"!"&!%+'- !3"9%!'"&&"& $$",!"#!3"$/ %+,"!%!%'0%#"9 *## !"#

> & *"& %# ( ""/%'; #%&& !%& %"# 9%!3 !3" :0" & %# 9 *# # !"#

>!3"'&)* '$"+, '-3 &#%*"$!"#!3",*"&"'! ,," / D 3 0" 3" *# /" *'"# $)'&"/ * !3" ,,"// '!?'&)* '$"

+, '- '#3 0";'"!3*);3!3"*"$*#& !3"$ &"

)'&"/ *!3"'&)* '$"+, '-3 &$3 //"';"#!3"9 *# '!9;*)'#&+"'!%'"#:"/945

&! ,%'! * %&"# :- !3" /" *'"# $)'&"/ * !3" '&)* '$"

+, '-%&!3 !#"$" &"#9 &'";/%;"'!*%'!3" /!"*' !%0"%!%& $ &"

$'!*%:)!*-'";/%;"'$"!%&&):+%!!"#!3 !"0"' $$*#%';!!3"$ &"

!3" $/ %+ '! 7 * :1%! 7%';3 9 & #*%0%'; !3" +!*$-$/" '# !3" & %#

+!*$-$/"3%!:"3%'#!3")&:" *%';*";%&!* !%'5 =55D= 3 0"$ *"

)//-$'&%#"*"#!3"& %#&):+%&&%':)!#'! %'# '- *$"%'!3 !&):+%&&%'

3"$ &" !3"$/ %+ '!%&!3 !7 * :1%!7%';39 &#*%0%';!3" +!*$-$/" !+#"* !"&,""# '#*"&,'#"'! #*%0"* )&5

=55D= 3 #0"*! E"'!3":)& '#&)##"'/- ,,/%"#:* E"&%'!3" +%##/" !3"* # '# $$%#"'!3 &! E"',/ $"'!3 !;*)'#,*0" & %# &&"*!%'>!3"$/ %+ '!3 &"G +%'"#"-"9%!'"&&85 0! *7%';3> 933 &&),,*!"#!3"$ &" !3"$/ %+ '!*"; *#%';!3" $$%#"'! #):!>'&)* '$"+, '-3 &! E"'!3"&! '# '";/%;"'$" 7 * :1%!

7%';3%'!3"9*%!!"'*",/-:)!!3 !&! '#*"+ %'&', ,"*%!&"/ 3"

'&)* '$"+, '-3 &'!,*#)$"# '-"0%#"'$"%'!3%&*"; *#3" #*%0"*

"'#%';0"3%$/"3 &"0"'#"'%"#!3" $$%#"'!"3 &'!"'!"*"# %'!!3"9%!'"&&:G!#",&" :)!!3"+ ''"* $$%#"'! 7>!3"

/" *'"#*%:)' /3 &*%;3!/-#* 9%'

"*"'$" ; %'&!!3"*"&,'#"'!&7>!3"

:0"& %# *;)+"'!&*"; *#%';'";/%;"'$" 7 * :1%!7%';3*$'!*%:)!*- '";/%;"'$"%&9%!3)! '-/"; / *$" 3" &"$'# ,%'! * %&"# :- $)'&"/ * !3" ,,"// '! %& *"; *#%';F) '!)+!%&&):+%!!"#!3 !%'$+" !3"#"$" &"#3 &:""'

9*';/-! E"' &&(

?5,"*+'!3 A%'$*" &"3 &9*';/-:""'

;%0"'!%&&):+%!!"#!3 !!3"*%:)' /3 &! E"'&(

?5,"*+'!3 & +%'%+)+9 ;"&>93%$3%&'3%;3"*&%#" 3 0"$ *"

)//-$'&%#"*"#!3"& %#&):+%&&%':)!#'! %'# '- *$"%'!3 !&):+%&&%'

3"%'$+" !3"#"$" &"#3 &:""'! E"' &&(

?5,"* +'!3 ; %'&!!3"+%'%+)+9 ;"& &(

=?5,"*+'!3 ')'&E%//"# / :)*"0%&"#* !" &&"&&"#:-. :)*", *!+"'!>3 '#%; *3 &' (

=3 &:""'$'&%#"*"#93%/" &&"&&%';!3 ! +)'!>!3"#"$" &"# 9 & -" *& ;" '# &&)$3 A +)'!3 &*%;3!/-:""' ##"#%'

*"&,"$! )!)*",*&,"$!)& !3"#"$" &"#%'0%"9 )!3*%!-

3"& %# )!3*%!-3 &:""'),3"/#:-!3*"")#;"&"'$3

'6:/"!3","G)*!%'$ &"!%!/"# &#$ % !

& ' $( (

) *++," -

. /

. .

. 3" '') / %'$+" !3" #"$" &"# 3 & :""' ! E"' & &D>

?5 A3 &:""' ##"#%'*"&,"$! )!)*",*&,"$!)& A3 & :""'#"#)$!"#%'*"&,"$! ,"*&' /"G,"'&"& '#!3"+)/!%,/%"*3 &:""' *%;3!/- ,,/%"#E"",%';%'0%"9!3" ;" !3"#"$" &"# & -" *&3"

+)'!;* '!"#:-!3"*%:)' /)'#"*%+,);'"#9 *##"&'!$ // * '-%'!"* "*"'$" B '&"F)"'!/->!3" ,," /%&9%!3)! '-+"*%! '#!3"& +" &! '#&#%&+%&&"# ( $,- !3%&1)#;+"'!:"&"'!!!3"!*% /)*! *&!*%$!

$+,/% '$"

012

$!3 +