Pankaj And ORS. v. Inder Singh Kataria And ORS.

  
 

      
 

 

  !"#$ %

&'(&)&'*+!", -..!//&', 0!",1,
'*!"2'3+4&&"2&&'*+!",  - !,.'*!',  5 6 785  
5
 98

"!,!'

 5":42'*&/$!'2"*0 &!;2+ 5"<&"*!!.+!"&'$*0 &!"+! &..!//&', 5" &'&$!'2"*0 &!;2+ 5")&=+&'3&,&'* &)2'*!" &1/$*0 &!, ""!,.'*!'  5
 98$ +! &..!//&',6./&2'2, &"! &33"2!0!*  +! 2<.13'!*)1*3<!',&'**!

"!!+!1", !/;;+!"! = 2'0(2'3+!."02,2',!

2'>6&'*1'*!" "*!"  1/!  $+! 202/,12+&, !!'*2,<2,,!* 5":42'*&/$ /!&"'!* ,!'2" 1',!/ &,,2,!* = 5"<&"*!!. !+"&'$ *0 &! &..!&"2'3 " +! &..!//&', ,1 <2,+&+!2" /2!',&"!;2//2'3/!&*!02*!'

!,1 )!

 &'= !"<, &'* '*22', ;+2 + +2, 1" <&= *!!< &.."."2&!

66

5" &'&$ /!&"'!* ,!'2" 1',!/ &,,2,!* = 5")&= +&'3&,$ *0 &! &..!&"2'3 " "!,.'*!'  ,1 <2, +& +! &..!//&',6./&2'2, *2* ' /!&* !02*!' ! *!,.2! &0&2/2'3 '1<!"1,.."1'22!, 3"&'!* = +! 1" !/;  0!' +! !02*!'

! ;&, &/, /,!* = +! 1""*!",;+2 ++&,' !!'&,,&2/!*&'*+!,122, +! =!&" $;+!"!&,$ +! )1*3<!' +&, !!' .&,,!*2' 
' "! 1&/$5"2'*&/ ,1 <2, +& &// +!2'!"2< "*!", <!"3! 2' +! *!

"!! &'* 2' 02!;  ,1 + .,22' +&+!"!2,''!!* +&//!'3!+!"*!",,!.&"&!/=&'*$ +!"!"!$."02,2'+! "*!"# 1/! 6 ;1/*' &../=
 +&0! +!&"* +! /!&"'!* 1',!/ " +! .&"2!, &'* &<  +! 02!; +& +! /!&"'!* 2", ..!//&! 1" ,+1/*+&0!"!<&'*!* & (+!<&!"+!"2&/1" = &"*2'3 "!&,'& /! .."1'2=  /!&* +! !02*!' !$ +"13+ 2<.,22'  !"&2' !"<, &'* '*22',$ <1 + /!,,$ ,, 

"*2'3/=$ +! ."!,!' &..!&/ 2, &//;!*  +! )1*3<!', &'* *!

"!!  + +! 1", !/; &"! ,! &,2*!  ; +! "2&/ 1"  ,+&// ." !!* ;2+ +! ,12 ' //;2'3!"<,&'* '*22',

66 ?&@ +! "2&/ 1" ,+&// &"* +"!! !!

20! .."1'22!,  !& +  +! .&"2!,  /!&* +! !02*!'

!$2'&

"*&'

!;2+/&; ? @ +! &..!//&', ,+&// <&(! !0!"= .,,2 /! !'*!&01"  /!&* +! !02*!'

! ;2+2' +! ,2.1/&!*2<! 1'*.!"2*&'*2' &,!$+!=&2/ *,$+!"2&/1";1/* !&/2 !"=.&,, &'= "*!"$ 2' &

"*&'

! ;2+ /&;  +2, &"!<!'2'!* '*22' ;1/* &../=  +! "!,.'*!',&/, 2'

! +! "!,.'*!', +&0! !!' *"&33!* 2' 1" 1''!

!,,&"2/=$ +!"!"!$ +! &..!//&', ,+1/* ! ,&**/!*;2+"!&,'& /! ,,+! ,,&"!A1&'22!*&

, $B6$ !.&2*+!"!,.'*!',$;+2 +,+&// !&

'*22'."!

!*!'"." !!*2'31"+!"2'+!<&!" !!*/!,,,&=+&2' &,!+!&..!//&',&2/ <&(! +! .&=<!'  ,,  +! "!,.'*!',$ +!' +! ."!,!'&..!&/,+&// !*!!<!*+&0! !!'*2,<2,,!* +!"2&/1",+&//<&(!!0!"=.,,2 /!!",

'

/1*!+!." !!*2'3,2'+! 202/,12$&,!C.!*221,/=&, .,,2 /!&'*' !='*'!=!&" +! .&"2!, +"13+ +!2" 1',!/ &"! *2"!

!*  &..!&" !"!+!"2&/1"'   %

6#6

!

"*,+!1", !/;$2&'=$ !,!' & (  2,.,!*

 !"#$ %  ?5
 98@ 4   9+!+!",.!&(2'3B"!&,'!* !,B 9+!+!""!."& /!

!,B