High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/580/2014disposed of

Shatrudhan Ray And Another v. Ashok Kumar And ORS

2015-08-145 pages

!" #!

$ %&'(& ) &'

**++ ,'( &-.(/' &'

0 12*.('32 '&**++ 0' 0 32 ''* 4 ! "

' **+ & 5 + 5) & +/ *' & ,* *') 6 ' / & 7' 5) & +'

0' +/ '5( +3 7'8&' ''''&9'5( +9: ''&,* &+/ 76 7'(% &'(&' 5(; !!<;

$ /

! !; #!

6'5' 6'6' 4;= =4$$4 '2 5)'* =&-.(/' '& 6+6 /

' '(- 6 ,* 3 7& ( + >(') ((/5 &/ &* #!" ! !; #!

' % #?@<4! 7 '6' + %

&'(&'6 '* **++ ++/* ( '% ;;& 0',&++/ 6/* &( #!+-& ( &&' ,* 65(#!)' 7 2''&&77'- 6%(*'2' 0<% . ''3 7+ 3 .'

7 '

6 ;$!!<= *' / & '/ ++ (' A&++&'* ) 6&(/ & +/ 7 ' (' /* ) ' 2'( 6'( +( 6&'* &+ 62+ 2 '2 6+ '2& 62&+ ++7 6(7' '/5)&'5(

A&&'& B( '(+ 6 & ,* & ('' ! !; #!

( '&

6+6 '2 6' 4;= =4$$45)'2'

'* C

# A&&'&* '' +/* 3 7&/( '/7&/C 4 A&&'&'* 7 &+ 6&2+ 2 '2 6 + & / ++6 C

+ 1'

'5( + ' 2 +(&& B( 7'(+'&

6+6 '2 6' 4;= =4$$45)'*

( 4 7 6 & (' /* )

# '* 7( &22+ 2'2 + /* &( 3#?3@;!<=77' &+/ + 67& '&'@D*'

(/ / &7;<=*'/ & &5 )&'(/ ')2 '' 6& 7 "#!)'63&72'3/(+*+' $7**+ ' 6&6&&'7&7!)'+ (/ $!!!<='+ $!!!<= '( '+E* 7 7' 1'

( +'&**++ 7&+* 6& /5)&'5( +(5/&/(+*+' $& 5 7' 6+) **+ /* & 5 7'

( ++2 '+E* '+5+ 5 +*')&&**++ ' + ( ((' *'* & 1'

( +'&**++ '+(* & & 95+%(*'/('

$8;:%4? 1'

( + ' '* 4 F (' /* )7&+'( 6&*+- 5)&**++ (5/ &*'*'/* &+')5 7'5)&'5( 7&&*'/ ('&' / &2&'+'

( +'&*' 6 &'(6&&'' & 5 &+ 5) & 95+ %(*'/ ('

$%%&&'& (&%)8(*':&&6& 7&&'+2 &5- ( 7&+ &/(+*+' &(3&''/(+*+'5**+ &

"/+)&6&757 "=#!)' $!D( &''+)5 **+5)&'5( + ( 7&& & 95+%(*'/(' *+ &,'&-.,*& &%/+0.,)-)1.'0(,&%)2,+,2,&+(%&%/&%+0.,3

'* / ( + (('*'*3&5 &+ $%%&&')8(*':& $!D&(+ /&(+57'((' *'*7&'&5+7!)'6 - (('*'* ' ''/ 6* ) (& &5 **'25)& 95+%(*'/('

! "

# $% "

$8 :

;#$ &''3 & / & & 5 ;;<= G #44#8 /'( $!D:H

#44#8 $!D ( (('*'*:I &+5)& 95+%(*'/(' & && 8#!

4: @ % ;;3 '' ' ! &$ ( #!

$8:% 44*' ' +$!3!!!<=& ( ++2 &''3 & +/ ' + +( '

!"# $%

!"#!"% "'#

1 +2

8$!3!!!<=&:

3!!3!!!<=

'+E* #$3!!!<= +

"# " /( /* +') 7' & **++ &++ ( '/ & /( +(+ 52 **++ &++5 + '&'? $D*'

(/'/&+ 6&* ++'+J

**' / /( /* / 6 +/ &++5 &/'E5)&+'

'5( ' &'5( + '*/

'5('/ &+/ &++ (' A& & 52 / & /( 3*' **+* ()&!('' (6( 3#!

$ $/3.