High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3847/2018dismissed

Sanjay Kumar v. Lokyukta Haryana And ORS

2018-02-19Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

!"# #$%&%'() ) ) ) !'*!+,-.!/ #"%"%'#/ 0& 12!+-2"!!/+!'!!'3"4#/& #&5'3#'"& 6( 6( 6( 6(7 16 , 7 16 , 7 16 , 7 16 ,,6 ,6 ,6 ,6 /#&#'"( 6/1!8%"!/34!'93:$!"#9

/"4#5#"%"%'#/ ,,6 9 ,,6 9 ,,6 9 ,,6 9 4# 5#"%"%'#/ %& "4# /%'$%5!8 :#/'.#'" #'%/ #$'3!/+$4890%88!;#,!8%';!9#4&%8< %&"/%$" 4%=!'%&.!'+!&

&$48"#!$4#/&.!3#!$.58!%'"!;!%'&"4%. /-&-/5%';"4#;:#/'.#'" .'#+>+&#88%';"4#"/##& &$48=%"4-"5#/.%&&%'!'3!$$-'"%'; "4# .'#+ /#$#%:#3 4# &!%3 $.58!%'"9 .!3# " "4# 12!+-2"!9 =!& #'?-%/#3 %'" "4/-;4 "4# %/#$"/9 #$'3!/+ 3-$!"%' !/+!'!9 !'$42-8!9=4&->.%""#34%&/#5/"' @4#/#!

"#/9"4#.!""#/ =!&58!$#3># /#"4##;%&"/!/ /5/#8%.%'!/+#'?-%/+'"4#5/#8%.%'!/+ #'?-%/+9"4##;%&"/!/4!&5%'#3"4!"A&%'$#"4#:!8-# "4#"/##&=!&'" ;"!&&#&&#3&%"%&'"5&&%>8#"&!+=4!"=!&"4#:!8-# "4#"/##&>-" $#/"!%'8+&%'$#"4# =!&2#5"%'3!/2!'3'%'"%.!"%'=!&;%:#'!'3 !8&'5/5#/5/$#3-/# /3%&5&!8 "/##&4!&>##'!35"#3&5&&%>%8%"+ &#88%';"/##&-'3#/:!8-!"%'%'$88-&%'=%"4:%88!;#/&$!''">#/-8#3 -" %'$# #:#' "4# &!8# 5/%$# )B 4!& '" >##' 3#5&%"#3 %' "4# &$489 :" /#!&-/+ / &$48 >!'2 "4# /%'$%5!8 $!''" ># /-8#3 -"

6#/# &!+%'; "4# &!%3 !.-'" =!& &5#'" ' "4# &$48 %& '" &-

%$%#'" " 5/:#"4!"&!%3!.-'"=!&%' !$"-"%8%C#3 /"4#>#'# %" &$48!&"4#/# %&'"#:%3#'$#4=!'3%'=4!".!''#/&!%3!.-'" )B=!&&5#'" '"4#&$485/%.! !$%#%"%&5/:#3"4!""4#/%'$%5!8!'*!+,-.!/%& ;-%8"+ 3#/#8%$"%' 3-"+9 !& =#88 !& #.>#CC8#.#'" !" 8#!&" )B =4%$4=!&!88#;#3&!8#5/%$# "4#&!%3"/##&"%&!8&'"-" 58!$#" .#'"%'"4!"% !&&#&&.#'" "4#"/##&4!3>##';".!3# /."4#/#&"

#5!/".#'"9"4#'"/##&$-834!:#>##'&83'.-$44%;4#/5/%$#/#5/" ># &->.%""#3 ># /# "4# '7>8# 12!+-2"! !8'; =%"4 /#$/3 & "4!" $.5#"#'" !-"4/%"+ .!+ ># !&2#3 " "!2# !55/5/%!"# !$"%' !;!%'&" "4# /%'$%5!8D 4#/#!

"#/9 "4# .!""#/ =!& 5-" -5 ># /# "4# 12!+-2"! 4# 12!+-2"! 4!& 5!&&#3 "4# /3#/ /#$..#'3%'; $/%.%'!8 !& =#88 !& &"#/' 3#5!/".#'"!$"%'!;!%'&""4#5#"%"%'#/>+>&#/:%';"4-&( $$/3%';""4#/#&5'3#'"!88"4# %:#"/##& =#/# !-$"%'#3 !'3 "4# !-$"%' .'#+ )B4!&>##'-"%8%C#3 %8%';"4##!/"4 %'"4#&$48;/-'39!&%"=!&'#$#&&!/+%' "4#%'"#/#&" "4#&"-3#'" +/# #//%';"! 8#""#/ =/%""#' " "4# B %&"/%$"

4%=!'% !88#;#38+ &%;'#3 >+ "4# !/5!'$4 !'3 "4#/ /#&5#$"!>8# 5#/&'& /. :%88!;# %;/!'!%'$8-3%';&.# "4#$.58!%'!'"& 4# -/"4#/ &->.%"& "4!" 4# 4!& &5#'" !' !.-'" >'!

%3#8+ %' "4# %'"#/#&" "4#

&$48 =#:#/9 "4#/# %& '"4%'; %' "4# /#58+ %8#3 >+ "4# /#&5'3#'" "4!" "4# :!8-!"%' "4#"/##&4!&>##'3'#>+"4# /#&" #5!/".#'" =#/# !-$"%'#3 !& 5#/ /-8#&!'3"4#!.-'"4!&>##'3#5&%"#3%' "4#&$487&!$$-'":#'"4#"+5#!'3&%C# "/##&4!&'">##'&4='%'"4#/#58+ /. "4# !>:#9 "4# '8+ %'

#/#'$# =4%$4 $!'>#3/!='%&"4!""4#"/##&4!:#>##'&83 %'"4#.!/2#"'4%;4#/5/%$#"4!'=4%$4%& 4!&>##' &4='>+ "4# /#&5'3#'" !'3"4!" " =%"4 -" 3#5&%"%'; "4# &!.# %' "4# &$487& !$$-'" 4%&9 5/%.# !$%# %" %& ! $8#!/$-"$!&# #.>#CC8#.#'"D 1#!/'#3$-'&#8 /"4#5#"%"%'#/4!&!/;-#3"4!""4#/3#/ "4#12!+-2"!%&5!"#'"8+%88#;!8!&4#4!&>&#/:#3"4!""4#:!8-!"%' "4# "/##&4!&'">##';"3'# /."4# %&"/%$"/#&"

%$#/!'34!&/# #//#3 ""4#8#""#/ "4#/#&" #5!/".#'"9:#/'.#'" !/+!'!B!';# /#&"

%$#/9 4%=!'%3!"#3 @""4# %:%&%'!8/#&"

%$#/9

4%=!'%%'=4%$44#4!&.#'"%'#3"4!""4#"/##&%'"4#&$485/#.%&#&%& -'3#/"4#/!.!'$4!+!"9"4#!'$4!+!"!'3"4#$48!.%"%%&=/2%'; ";#"4#/!'3"4#&!.#%&'"-'3#/"4# /#&"3#5!/".#'""%&"4-&&->.%""#3 "4!""4#"/##&3'">#8';""4#/#&" #5!/".#'"9"4#/# /#9"4#/#=!&' $$!&%' /"4#5#"%"%'#/";#""4#:!8-!"%' "4#"/##& /."4#/#&"

3#5!/".#'""%&!8&!/;-#3"4!"%"%&!'!$" :#';#!'$#'"4#5!/" "4# $.58!%'!'"&!&"4#5#"%"%'#/4!&!8&.!3#!$.58!%'"!;!%'&""4#. 4!:# 4#!/3 8#!/'#3 $-'&#8 / "4# 5#"%"%'#/ !'3 !

"#/ #E!.%'%';"4#/#$/39!. "4#$'&%3#/#35%'%'"4!""4#/#%&'.#/%"%' "4#5/#&#'"5#"%"%'>#$!-&##:#'% "4#/#&"3#5!/".#'"4!&'"4%';"3 =%"4"4#"/##&!'3"4#&!.#=#/#"4#5/5#/"+ "4#&$48!&"4#+;/#= =%"4%'"4#&$485/#.%&#&!'3!8& #88%'%"&5/#.%&#&>#$!-&# &"/.#"$9 "4#:#/+ !$""4!""4#5#"%"%'#/3%3'"3#5&%""4#&!8#5/$##3& "4#"/##& %' "4# &$48 !$$-'" !'3 4!& !88#;#38+ &5#'" "4# &!.# ' &.# =#8 !/# !$"%:%"+ "4# &$489 %& &-

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

/#&!%39"4#/#%&4!/38+!'+/#!&' "4%&-/""%'"#/ #/#%'"4%&5#"%"%' /&#""%';!&%3#"4#%.5-;'#3/3#/ !'3!&&-$4"4#&!.#%&4#/#>+3%&.%&&#3 G,,6 H G,,6 H G,,6 H G,,6 H ) ) ) ) 4#"4#/&5#!2%';B/#!&'#3 #&B 4#"4#//#5/"!>8# #&B