M/S Lamba Exports Pvt. Ltd. v. M/S Dhir Global Industries Pvt. Ltd. And ORS.





   
   

 !"# !$!%&!'()  !"# %"*"+*,!-!* (.)   





!!" 

# $  %&! '(( )"$! 





& 

 " "

///   (  01

2 2
2 34
 3



%!$!* ( 

* & (!+, - . 

/0 "  # , - .



-("+ 2$(, - .



  '$, - .



-! 3&"4!, *

- .



'$

' (, - .



6& "

7$, - .

 " "

2+56&7*'!%3+% 8   :;

5;

!!"

 !!",  !!"  .&(( "0      -!!"( %!!. 3$0 , '$$0,

 (  1   " " 0!"  <   
!

!( 3$0

3$"! %!

!!", '$$0, ((5  <     ;

0" ,

  !



 ( " 1. 4$!.!"

!!"

 !!"

(!"!11 1!( $!  .!1!.

 .".,  .(!"

";

!"4$".!"

." >$ "!(  (! 1  " " !"4$".!"

(( 0!"0  "  !"     !"0 @#<A

@;0 #!&,

& )#, '$$0

."! !"

 (  
 

!

 +& "  " ;

 , , , 

 1 "" 8 (   !  (  "

) (( 0  1 ""  
  1$(( 1!"(  (  " $  5 ("

!

 , , ,  ";

$1" $"

-1  ;!"0 $ , (".

."! !"

 ?,< , ,  !

 1 "" !  0!!"

$$".

  , 0!"

!

 +&

=&$,  . !

$  , , ,   ."! !"

=& "

(   . !

( 0( "!.

A    1 ""

 1 "" !

 !( ! (!0!"  "  "

1   , ,  1 $ !

  , (( 0!"0 ..$"  4 .!"

!  (  " " 1$

 "  (;

 ,  ";!"0 ." "!" ! "!.

 $"!"0 !0!"(  "

1   , , 

) (( 0 &  $.& ."!!"

"  4 .!"

!  (  "

.". "

5$( ."!   .!"  +

) 



$"(51$((;

&  "

 !"    .  &! !0& 1 $

=&   "

5&  + .". (  !" . .( (;

!(( 0(, (1!

(!.!$

) (( 0 !" "

"  !" &! !    . ( ;

 1  ( 0!! !0& !"  

@"

!">$!;, . +"5 " 0!!"0 1 & ".!"

  . >$ !"

. !"

&! !  (!+ (;

.  &! !0& !"   $! $"" . !(;

+!"0 .  1 ""  (( 0 . !"0  1
";

5 :

. $..

. !"0 &! !0& !"   (,

" &(( $11  ! ( ( !"4$;

% 1 ""

1!"((;

 1$ 0  "( , 4$ "1!

 >$ 

) $! (5;  ;

5!((!"0 !((  ;

5!((!"0  1 !  .".

B ". , $! 1!(  !!" 

-("05!& $!, ( 1!( (!.!"

!" ! !"4$".!"

 !"!"0  ((!"0, (! "!"0, ".$ !"0  .&0!"0 $!  +!"0 +!"

(! "

$! 1 $ &!  "

!((  " ".;

$!

!(

!$0"

 <  , ((5 1 !

!" ! !"4$".!"

(!.!"

C (!"0

8 00!

0!"  ,  (("

 1  (  1
$, '$$0, ((5

   

-00!

0!"
$, !!"

 !!"

1!(

 "

!!"

." "

!!"  !"0

!$ .($     " $(;

& ( ."!"0 " "$ $"(  1 !  (  "  4 . .". ( (;

  "" &!  .

 4 .!"

!  (  " ."" ."$ !!(

" 5$( + .".

!

" 5 ."

 !  .". ."

"1.

." "

."!"$ ..  ; "  !!" ,

1   4 .!"

!  (  " 11 ,  4 .    

 " " $(;

 . !

$  A, ,  <   , 0!" $  . !

0$ ! ! !!"

1. (  "!!(!;

 (!"0 ("

  !"0 (! "

!  >$ !", ,

;

. 0!.((;

  &   "!"0  !"  !"

."

!0"



$0 ! $ !".

!(( !$  5 "

!   ( ,  !"

. !"0 &! !"    $!  ;, ! 5$(  1  5&( $ 1!(!"0 $! .""

A ((5  .!"

$"!( ((;, 4$  

& ! $ $"4$ "!.& "

$! 1!"!"0 !".""".

( 0( 1.$( !!"

 . !$0"

4$0 " " $!"( ;  (5

$ &! ." "!", &  (!

2- 7%-9&$156:

27*;68 )  7&79 )<  6%=936!=>7%+$  !;'

%7'5"  &$  9'!&  $$8 ))    7&79  ?

@$   +79'!%$*'*" 6!%&$ -'$ "*'*" 6!%8  2 )

&  &", ! ." "

 4 .!"

=! * (  " & ! "+ , 1$&  .&!.

 !"

$  !" >$ !", 5!&$

=! * (  ",  ((" 1 "" !0&, !(  !"    .$ "1 

1 $  & 

 !"!"

"  !.    " "  " ", $ .";

  " "  !. $.. 1$( .. ".

=! * (  "

." "

>$ !"

00 ."" ( 5!&$ ." " 00

 !!" (!"!11 5 (( 5 !"1 $.& 00  "

) . 0!.(    . !0&  !!"  1$.!1! . !" ! ".

"(;

.. ".

=! * (  " 

$"4 2!"( :"+ (( 1$&  . !"0 5  $ >$ "

=! * (  "

  5 "

 " " 1 "" & ! "+ 

"! $" !

 !!" (!"!11 $(;

 $"

 1$"

 " ", 1   . !

!"0 1$"

  (!  (;

!" "!"((;

 1$ ".&  "

1   $"!"0   . !

$" 

." "

5 ((  "


$, '$$0 !!"

 !!"

(!( !!

$ &! ." "!", & (.

 (!".

%'7  6!-7,9$  1 '$  &$  *7"*  "# 
*'7  *'  " 6!%$8  )  ) 2+:%!-!  "+%  $!$  

  "6*%>  *'  " 6!%$  &$  266 %" 6!%$
$:  %7& !17-7 !'8 2+:%!-!"+% $!$.A 

)

&  ! 

0"

&$0&  ( "  .

<

 $(    ( ."! !"

1!  
   +& "  $"

 !!" , 5&  ."

  

!

!! , !

 , , ,  (  

=! * (  "

)  "!"

 %&! '(( $   .  1$(( 1!"(  (  " $  5 &  1 , ! 

11 ,  ."

   !

$  , , ,  ";

$1" $"

($  ( " .($   $.

$" D E8

 

    
 

   

 

<  ""

"""#$

       

  




%    &  ' ( )*         
 



 )*             

    

          

( 

+" ,

!0&(;

& ( 1 !

.($  "!1  ! (1  !.

=&!   " 0 ." "!"

&  "&!"0 ! 5!(( $4 . .. ".

=! * (  " (

&    ."!"0 ", .. !"0

=! * (  "

-! (;, "

F& "

>$ !"

00  .$  , & "

5!&$ &   !"0 .. ".

=! * (  "

" " " 1 "" " .( !"0 !( !( ."" "1  5!&$ ! 5! "

." "

=&$, ."!"0 "   "!"0 !"!"0

 $( ( ! .( (;

5! "

".

=! * (  " !

 5 "

$"4 2!"( :"+,

"

=! * (  " !0"

"

" , "(;

& "

(".

."! !"

? $" &(( !

 &(1

"

!0&(;

& ( 5& "

.     " " &! ;, "&!"0 $ ."!"0 " 0  ", $". !"

 .$ $"."(( .!.$".  5!&$ "+G

=! * (  ", .". ."" .".($

)1  !!" (!"!11  ; " "  " ;

 "   , , ,  $1" $"

=! * (  " !   " +  

. 1 $  !!" (!"!11

!0&(;

& (  !!"  !0&  . ;

$" 0!

$$".

 ((, $ & ."" !"!  .!1!.

 ((,  . !!( ,  1$ .. 

=! * (  "

:;

 !"!"0 (! "!"

$!  ;, "+ " "  .""  . !"0  (!H $"!"0 $" (!>$!!"0  .$  

$!



. (5 .! " (!.( 1. . &"



:$!( G .

$, .($  . , " !"!

 .$ "(;

1  .. ".

=! * (  " (

" 0  ;,  .$

1  !.&0 00 1 $ ! "(;

 .$!"

 , "

1$$

  , . , !  !"0 ."!"0 " .". " !$  1

 =!( $.& (  ! 5! "

  "

* 1  ."! !"0 

&!  !"  5!((!"0"  1!"".!( !(!;

.(  ".!", & ( "!(  .!1!.

.".

=&$, &   !"0 !(( 0(!;

 !"1!!;

!$0"

!" 1  ".

&  5!& .(( 5&!(  .!!"0 !!"( 4$!!.!"

!!"

 !!"

 !"0   1  ! " !!



-((  "!"0 (!.!", !1 ";, ( "

! ..!"0(;



2&!"0   &  !"

&(( ."$  !"

 ! .

2 34
 3

  .) 

F& &   +!"0  "

/  F& &   ( /