← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5904/2014allowed

Harman Kapoor v. Kewal Singh & Other

2019-05-01Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan5 pages

       

   

  ! !!"" # $"%&''  (!   ! "#" $%&%'(

$&)*+$,++-+-./01+(% $()%+22%33+'(  )**% + ,-.+ " )%  +*+$/  /+(%/    2+&&%/  4, ()%  ($  115/%'( 3+56&$547'+3.87$79&)%($+:

$&)$(. ()%$547'+3 ;)+&4%%'+&&+53%/4, ()%+22%33+'(&%%95'<%')+'1%6%'( 162%'&+(5'+*+$/%/7'/%$"%1(5'

== ()% ($#%)513%&1(. >>:

$&)$(. ()%1( ; )%  /$50%$    1+$  4%+$5'<  $%<5&($+(5'    ? ?

:)%$%5'+ (%$$% %$$%/(+& ()%

%'/5'<0%)513%;.*'%$+'/5'&7$%$:5% %35+'1%%'%$+3'&7$+'1%62+',!565(%/; ()%

%'/5'<0%)513% )+0%4%%'+$$+,%/+&$%&2'/%'(&(@$%&2%1(50%3,5'()%+22%+3 )% +1(&'%1%&&+$, $+/-7/51+(5' ()%2$%&%'(+22%+3+$% ()+('  > .()%+22%33+'( *+& $%(7$'5'< $6)5& &1)3' )5& 6($1,13%  4%+$5'<  $%<5&($+(5'    ? ?

>@A  '  ()%   *+,.  ()% 6($1,13%*+&)5(4,()%

%'/5'<0%)513%./7%(()%562+1(.)%*+& ()$*''()%*5'/&)5%3/ ()%

%'/5'<0%)513%+'/&7&(+5'%/5'-7$5%& %*+&(+9%'("+$+&*+(5&25(+3.%)*+.()%$%+ (%$.)%*+&&)5 (%/( #5$9&25(+3.8+$'+3 $6*)%$%)%*+&&)5 (%/(.)+'/5<+$)% &7

%$%/ $+1(7$% $5<)(3%<*+&3/<%/

 '()%13+562%(5(5' 53%/.()%$547'+31+6%(()%1'137&5'

()+(  ()%  +115/%'(  *+&  $%&73(    ()%  $+&)  +'/  '%<35<%'(  /$505'<    ()%

%'/5'<  0%)513% )%  *'%$. /$50%$  +'/  ()%  5'&7$%$   ()%  

%'/5'< 0%)513%*%$%)%3/-5'(3,+'/&%0%$+33,35+43%(2+,()%162%'&+(5' )%+22%33+'(2$/71%/6%/51+34533&+67'(5'<(.>.A=AB?

5&+4535(,1%$(5 51+(%:C A;*+&2$/71%/&)*5'<()%/5&+4535(,(()% %C(%'(  DE7+()%3564 $!$,++'/ $7$/+$&)+'"5'<) /%2&%/+&F?@+'/F?

(2$0%6%/51+3($%+(6%'(/176%'(&+'/()% /5&+4535(,1%$(5 51+(%)%13+56+'(*+&>,%+$&3/+(()%(56% +115/%'( )%$547'+3+*+$/%/+&76  .

.

=B?+3'<*5()5'(%$%&(GAD2%$ +''76)%/%(+53 ()%162%'&+(5'+*+$/%/5&(+473+(%/4%3* 

  +5'+'/&7

%$5'<  .

B?

%/51+3%C2%'&%& .>.A=AB?

&25(+35H+(5'

 >.

B?

5&+4535(, >@.=> B?

$+'&2$(+(5'

 .

B?

!%+$'%/  17'&%3  $  ()%  +22%33+'(  +$<7%&  ()+(  ()%  +67'(& +*+$/%/7'/%$0+$57&2%17'5+$,+'/''?2%17'5+$,)%+/&+$%'()%3*%$ &5/% $6()%2%$7&+3 ()%+*+$/+'/()%$%3%0+'(/176%'(& 2$/71%/.()%$547'+3(95'(1'&5/%$+(5'()% +1(()+(()%+22%33+'( $%6+5'%/)&25(+35&%/ $ /+,&)%$%&73( ()%5'-7$5%&&7&(+5'%/*+& ()+()%&7

%$%//5&+4535(,(()%%C(%'(  DE7+()%3564()5'<*+& 2$/71%/(%&(+435&)()+(()%&+5//5&+4535(,E7+()%3564)+&+

%1(%/()%

7'1(5'+3+4535(, ()%+22%33+'()%$547'+31'&5/%$%/ D/5&+4535(, E7+()%3564 +&=DE7+()%*)3%4/,+'/%0%' +//%/  D 7(7$% 2$&2%1(&)%+67'(&(*+$/&2+5'+'/&7

%$5'<&.)&25(+35&+(5'+'/

@ ($+'&2$(+(5')+0%4%%'+*+$/%/ )%  "72$%6%  7$(  5'  1+&%                   

  !"

# $%%  )%3/+& 7'/%$?

      



         

 

   

           

    

 



    & "

' & #

  !    

     "    "

  "     "   

   



!

 

#





    



        " 

#





    $

# 



     

 

%   !  (

)'  & "  & #

   &      "   

 

        '   

  #      

(         

 

#!     

  



  )            "

  



 



   " 



 

    "                 

 

             "       

 

 

     " " 



 

          



             "   ! " 

  

(  

 

 !  * '05%* ()%3+*3+5//*'4,()%"72$%6%7$(5' (/ 0 #/1  0 . %223 3.()%$547'+3)+&$5<)(3, 1'&5/%$%/ D/5&+4535(,E7+()%3564+&=DE7+()%*)3%4/,1+&% 5&6+/%7( $%')+'1%6%'( ()%+67'(&+*+$/%/7'/%$0+$57&)%+/& *%0%$.*)53%+*+$/5'<()%162%'&+(5'()%$547'+3)+&'(1'&5/%$%/ ()+(()%+22%33+'($%6+5'%/)&25(+35&%/ $ /+,&+'/&7

%$%/ $+1(7$%.

)%*73/)+0%$%E75$%/+((%'/+'(/7$5'<()%2%$5/ )&25(+35&+(5'+'/ ()%$%+ (%$+3&.()%162%'&+(5'&)73/4%+*+$/%/ $()%&+6% $()%05%*4%5'<(+9%'.5(5&'(/%%6%/'%1%&&+$,(5&&7% '(51%(()%5'&7$%$+(()5&&(+<% *%0%$.5'$/%$(+*+$/-7&(+'/%E75(+43%162%'&+(5'.  .

B?5&+*+$/%/(5&13+$5 5%/()+(*)53%%')+'15'<()%+67'(.()% 5'(%$%&((4%+*+$/%/7'/%$"%1(5'A ()%1()+&4%%'(+9%'5'( 1'&5/%$+(5' )%+*+$//+(%/ 5&6/5 5%/(()%%C(%'(()+(()% +67'(+*+$/%/4,()%$547'+3(()%(7'%  .

.

=B?5&%')+'1%/4,  .

B? )%+22%+35&2+$(3,+33*%/+11$/5'<3, (5&13+$5 5%/()+(5'1+&%()%5'&7$%$5&+<<$5%0%/ ()%$/%$ 2+&&%/.5(*73/4%+(354%$(,($%050%()%+22%+34,605'<+'+22351+(5' )**% + ,- +4-*  F)%()%$&2%+95'<B$%+&'%/

%&B F)%()%$$%2$(+43%

%&B