High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4310/2015allowed

Ravinder Kaur v. Mohan Singh And ORS

2018-09-25Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu6 pages

!"!#$%&

'!# () *( ++,, .

("*" /0 #1!#20 # (" +

",#

$ /(11!(,0!30!4'

( /(

*-11 !#!4'

#/(.!,*-4'

( ",# 5#"*( 6, #7 888 9: ,,

-0 ";

#!-

3!#2 #0 6,

!# 4&45< ;7 -

/ ( !

" - !6" (!;*# -4 6(!

( >0 !#

( ( (( " ?

(!;*# -@A #

0 0

(" 6# 0" !# 6 ( 0! *- #B 9:

, ) *( = #0

(! *-

0*20!

6 #( ( !#=0! 0 - """0 *7!#20

(!;*# -;7

3!#2!#

@"6# 0-7 # (!;* 6!-7 "5<=(3 * ##* # 7 &45< ## ( !;

"!";7 ,,-7!#2 6*- ( #;7

3!#2 !# 6 (

!# 4&45< !# -*!#2 45< # *#

C, #5<# -""

*#"

-( "( *,# !"!#

<(!#

# 0!#

!"# "$% & '( ## !"# "$ % & ')*+, -*.=0 !# # !# -!# 6

E 7

(""

*7!#2!# 0 - ""4=

45<, 6# 6*- (&= ,,-!

(=(3!#2*

( # 4 -

*#"

- ( ( ",# 5#"*( 6, #7 0 " ( (( !"!# #@;- !# /!'

"0%1 2 "$ "% & (

"$% & ')*3*33=0 !# !#

!#!#2 7

("4#@;- 1*,( *(

3 !# # !# - !# 6

45< ,

##*6 0*20

!# "

! = " 0 -,!#2 0!" , " #

3!#2 # !# -!# 6

45<, ##*64#@;-

=0!- ( -7!#2 # !

!"!# !#

$ "$ % & '( &%5!

"$% & '))*.*6- 3!#

= " 7

( %% '

-* (*,

" 0 " 6 =#( --7 # !# -!# 6 ##<

(#!#26 6;

(",(!(

"45<, ##*6 !"!##@;- 1*,( *( !#)!"0 #, -@"

>1*,( A!"B&=0

"!# !#"

(= ", #& (!#2-74 6 '!

45<, ##*6

!# -!# 6

9: 6!

-74 !# !#"

= " 7

(" 6# 0" - (!#2-74 !#

(6" , ,0 !"!#

7 #@;- !# 8& 9 ( :&2 ! "'1% % 1% !%"))6*6.6*- (&=*-;

,,-!

!#"

!"!# !# 8& 9

' >"*,( A !" ,(* "*# ($<

! !

" "

#% &# %

'(#)

* +& '(#*

+# +% '(#%

+* & '(#

# % '(#+

* %& "

'(##

%# %% '(,

%* *& '()

*# *% '(%

** )& - 9B: D!3 =!"

!#"

45< # *#

C, #5<# -""

(6" ,0 B >'!!!A !"!# !# !%"

2 "';

& %91 "<

!9!&$( , <& ! "$% & ')*-3!(!2*))6=*-;

( 6,

!#45<# -""

# 45< = (" *# C, "

,0 B >'!!!A

!"!#!#

0!@" >"*,( A!"( ,(* "*# ($< *# .

/ .#%&&&0( .&&&&0( .#%&&&0(

#&1 -

3 9F: "!

=0 !" 6 (

=*-;

( 6,

!#45<# -"" !-!

- #"( !*6 !#'!

= !"!# #@;- !#

#9 0&"& 2"';

&% $ ( "; 9 2!

' ;

; 9

"$ % & ' $& !$&$ %" *.

)6 )*. !" !(!2 11& 2 % 6=*. %5 )*.

!"!#!#/ -#"*( @" >1*,( A !"( ,(* "*# ($< G&F #"

!# # 0 0!"*( !#

0! >"*,( A

(!*" 0

" *# ( =0! 0

!#!" ;

"!"D""#"( !*6 #- -, (- 4G #"( !*6H!" #!*"

(6=0! 0 # 6, "?",*"

- #"( !*6@4?,

#"( !*6@4 #?!-!

- #"( !*6@ (!20 #"( !*6 =*- !# -* #74 4 0 -,4 6( 4 2*!

4 "-

4=0! 0!" -"" 0!" 6!-7 I!

0 ( ",

",*"

4 !

=*- !# -* "

!#"=!

",*"

1,*"

- #"( !*6 !" 2 --7 !# " (!20

!#!#2 (

!#"0!, 0*";

#<=! =0! 0

--=" 6,

"*('!'!#2",*"

(-"" G 6, #74" !

74 <,

!#4

!#4 ! (!# (7 #J*2 -(

- #"( !*6 !" 2(

0!- *,#

0 4(-""G,

!4 ,(

!#4

!#4 " !

74 !" !,-!# 4 2*!

!#!#2H

!-!

- #"( !*6 !" (!20

!# !#

0 0!-#

!#2

0 0!- *"

"0 3 2#7 # 6!-7

0 2(

2#7( !" -"

!( 0!-*(!#2 !(-!

!6 0!-( '

-* ( !( -'

!#4 6, #!#"0!, !( (- !# 6!-7*#!

#"( !*6!" ", -,(!"6( -

!#2 0 #2!#2 #(6" ;*

*" #=( 0

!#"0!," / (#J*(!"!

!#"=(-<'

(0 ( 2#!K

-* 0!-@" #"( !*6

#6! -* 6,

0 0!- /"

J*(!"!

!#" ( (6!

;

!# *# ( -"" #"( !*6#

0 0!-0 6*#

" !" 6,

!# ( -"" -'

!#4 # 6, #!#"0!,

0!- / (.

0! - " !" ;

! !

-- 2!"-

,('!!#2( '!

!6"( !( 6!-!

!# "2 #*!# - !6"# =0 -"

!(6!#( 0!-4(*#6 ((!

"#(

(4 ;

-"" #"( !*6 *#

!-!

-#"( !*6

- #"( !*6 !" 0!-( # =0 -"

!( , " !# 6 ( '

0! - " *# =!20*( "0

!##

0!" *# = (4 "# - (!

7=!

0( ",

,(!# !,- "#=0! 0 6,

!# *-;

#-"" !-!

-#"( !*6 6*# 6,

;

#"( !*6 =!-- ;

;7 ,(!# !,- "

(!#2 6,

!# *# ( ?D"" #"( !*6@ !=#!#

0!>"*,( A # ,( 4 =

6 !

,,(,(!

(

"!"

(

6*# "45<

0(-"" !-!

-#"( !*6H

+ (!#2-74 !#"

"*6 "45< # #'

!# -0

=*-;

- ( F45< 9&: (!#2-74 !# -!20 ,"!

" #

!#"

!# 4&45<4 !" 0 -

!#F44>! 45<C&LF45<A -#2=!

MFN, ##*6=!

- !6,

!--

, 4- "", 4! #746

(-!

( 9%: (!#2-74

- !" --= ;7 6!7!#2 = (

&, ;7

(!;*#

>1I A *2 %&

(",

3!#25(

"# $ "5 I0

(( ,(

$ "5