Sonia v. Amandeep Mittal And ORS

 
    

!"# $ %$  !"!&"'

!"#$ %$  (

$$$$$$)) **+",

$ - - . ($  $$$$$$

)!"

",

-#  /.-($( ( (- 

 
 
  
  
 
 






  

 !" 


#### ( (- $  $

% 




&

'


 

  )* +, )+$)
 
&
 
 

 


% & 
-  



 
 

- 
$..

 




$/00 1
 
2 
% & 34





 
' 

 



 


5 6/ .67!
'
( 
8
, 69

 




 
 



 
 
 
$* $) )+$+

)





 

 

 
  
: 

 

&
 
 
% & 





  

 
 

 
 


: 

&



 ;

& (- (( (
 .  (.
  ( % 
 


 


!

 








&
 
 
% & 

 
(
 


 &



% 

 



 

 
&
(




 
&





 


*


 
 



(  
'



 
 




'


 
 
 !" 
 



<=!60* !)+$)
 
>? 
"

" 
 

-


 @


'

'
 : 

 
% 

 

   

 




"



 


 
 


 





 
(


&
  

(..0 - ( .

A3&
-


 
 

Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 12 %34(&)

!& ,+

6


(
 
 (



 

 
 
 
 
 


!

>30
  

      

      

   

         

  

  

  
  

 

 



  

 

  

         



    !"#$       

%#  !"&$       

&'    !"($      



 
31
)

      

        *              (+,      

    





 

                 


 -

 

           

        

   

         $         .  /

 

     

    

             

  
*  

 

             



          

      32
 

     

             (+,           

           (+,    

    
     

         



  

                                          

 

            
* * * * * * 42.)     

   

       &$        

     0

 1    $        !2    !(%+ %!%(

$ 

    

 3!4 %'#+

3!'#!#(

3!(#'&+

3!&&!&(

 3!#&'(+

  

    

 3!!(!((

35(''+

34 '!'(

 3(''4+

,

A3&
-


 
 

National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 12 3 4(47 6


  
 (

- 
$..
$. !

$.0

 




$/00
 
( '
!

14

 

 

  '
B
  
   C 1D4 - 

  
 '

'
  C

 '

 

& 

 '
  C 5  &
 '

  
  

 


 

 
B
 C 1E4 <



 ' 



 
'
(
 
&C
!

 B % 
 
 

 
'



!

>52. 6  conventional heads



  

   

 7/

8
*   7
%(+++   

7

!+++++    

        7  !+++++  

  

   


  

      

 

 
7/

  0   9 

 



         



             

  



   



 
:    

  

    
6          
       

 

     



  

      


   

  

  

 

  


; 

  

     

  

 

4   

       

    

        



                    

  
    

  

 * 

           

 

         

  

  

   

 

      

   7
!(+++
&++++ 7
!(+++


           

  
<       

   

 )        

     

 

 



  

  

 !+,   

)   

  



  

 

 

  = = = = = 59.3
)   

  (+,    



 



 /      &+

  


   #+, 





&+(+

* 

  

  (+'+

    !(,
        



 59.4
* 







 $       &+,

 

  

  

 &+

6  %(,

   

 &+(+

 !+,



  

 (+'+



 

 


   

   

     

 
59.5
.              

    

     #+#%0> ?

    

    59.6.

                0  > @         &%     /


59.7
 

        59.8
7   

        

 



 

     

    7  !(+++  7  &++++     7  !(+++


 

    

   !+,  

A A3&
-


 
 

-+85+   "

+*

"

& +"'

!5)+"9.:5:, ;

$ +"&+5+*:+ <&< &+5,<

1 73(

6  
  '

(+ *+;

5+
2 &) +3

 +"+9

7 ,<:2(&) +3



 
 (
'

 '
 

5 
 

 



!

B21
6  <

  C  0 8         

 

    

;

  

  
 *     

  D  D    

      



 D  

 D  D    D     D

 D
    

          

  

   

 

  

   )

 

 

 



 

%!
!
Spousal consortium 

   

         

    



      

  

    /  D
%!
%
Parental consortium     



  

D  

   

     

   

     D
%!
#
Filial consortium     

  

 

  


6 

      

         

% 


  

   



   

      

          

 
22
  



 

     

       3  /     

 



  E   



  

   

       
 3   /                 

      

 

    
       

 

  

      

 
23
 3> 

6  

    

     

  

  

  

* 

  

          

     

 

     
C  

   

     

    6 
6   

 

    
   

      

       

   

           

   



24
        

         

     

 

   D

  D   C  0 8
*  







    

  7 &++++ 

  /


 

 
'

 



 
 


 
( 

 



'

/
 

 
 



 
% 
 
% & 
(




 '

 


 


5 +++++7!

$+

"

&
(

(!

 
  
  
 (



 


 
 & 


 










 
 
&
: 
(





!  '
   

 

 '
 
% 
 

& 




&  


'


'

'

'




 
'


 ' 


>! @
(


&
  


&
(


 
 

&


 

 



 $/00

$$

"

 
 



 
  

 


>

@




 

  
 
( '
  


;


(;

 
- 


  
 
% 
A3&
-




 '  



(



  

Kajal v. Jagdish Chand & Ors. [(2020) 4 SCC 413] and Baby Sakshi Greola v. Manzoor Ahmad Simon & Anr. [2024 SCC OnLine SC 3692], (  

( 





 3



 
 
&



&
 '

7 


! 



 ;

 
( '


;


(;

 


  & & ;

$)

 '
 



 

 

 
 
   


 
 
 

 

 '



₹6+++
& '
 
 
( '


;


(;

   
 
 
 

 
- 

A

$


 

 

 
 



  

( 
 
(


  '
 
 

 (

 

   

% 
 
% &







( 
 


 



 
% 
 

: 

'






 .( $*

"
 (

 
 (



(
&
 
A3&
-


&


'
 

 
(
% 
 
)* +, )+$)

  
 '
% 
 !



  



 


 
  
 
!

Sr. No.

Heads Compensation Awarded $  
" 5 6+++7!

) <

8
*+9 5 )+++7!
1*+9

6+++4

 
( 
 
B  $7)
5 6++7!
1,+++
F
$7)4 * % 
"
5 6++7!
1,+++! 6++4   
$0 .

 
5 ,6.+++7!
1,+++F$)F$04 , G

E  5 $0$6+7!

< 
EB 5 ++++7!

/ G

  5 *0*++7!

$+   
B 5 )/ .67!

$$ !,+*!5) "

+,:!"

$7=7 =% >

 $)  &',:!" 
( 
&
 
% & $ =%= 4> $ "<+"'

+5!&", $== >27=7 =%  =%= 43 $6

-
 

 

 




&
A3& -


Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma %

4

R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nandu State Transport Corporation (2022) 5 Supreme Court Cases 107 =  
 !


' 
 

8
/9



 





 
  
 '




 
 
 
 


 

$.

% 
" 
 !
 
 

 





 
'
( 
(
 
% &



 

(
 

 
 






'
% % & 
 

 &
 





 
'



 


 


7  


 

& 
 
% & 
 


 
)* +, )+$)
% 


7  


 


 
& ;





 
% &

$,

 '
  
14



 
 


$ %$  2( (-3    


I  
 ;

'7! ;

'


J7
I  
 &


J