High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4315/2015disposed of

Naresh Tyagi v. Manoj Kumar & ORS

2018-09-24Mr. Justice Satpal5 pages

! " # !$%&'

(( )!* +,*!$! - ! "#

$ $#$## .!

!)!! '$.*"/ !$

(( !0$12!1("/ ! ! ,3/"/ !! !! !/ !04"/ !! #$## % .!

($ ( &$( !$ $ 1! & $ (! ! 6( %! *("! $! !! !!$7%! *(7*

+*!*

! &$/1!

0! !& !+* $!$$ ( ( *! 88 $!)$(9'

* +*!*

! &$!/$( **!/' $

'/$(%&:/ !'!'!;<:)<0< =!/ &! !$ '('!:1/!!$

"(!$ %&'1''($ !$$*$ &(> !$!<<(1 1 ((1'$$! &(?$$!$$@<*! ! "

'/$(%&:/ !'!'!;< :)<0< = !/ &! $'$ " !$ '('! !($$$ &(6(A

!$%&' ((1*

!+*!$('$! !

$ &>( ('1 !*!>1>( 6!" ! 8"! !! 6( 1 ! & $ ! ((1'

*1! ! &$(!%! *( <

?$$!$$9 (

" * !$ '(' !/'

' %& :/ ;<:)<0< = !/ & ! :

"1$$! !*+*! $B.

* !/"1$$!$ !( " "1$* !1$B.. ?$$!$! 1$('/(

/!/' "

B.- -( ;!%! *(! $ / !!$($$C*9 (

* !$ '(' !/' $

' %& :/ !'

!'!;<:)<0< = &! ;!%! *(

! $

(( *!

< .*

!' "D< %!E "D< ; !$!$

"D< ; * ! (& "D<

("$!' ! !

" %( "8"D< ''!/ $C** "(<+*! $ ($

(

;! *( ! $

(( * $ '! $

! &$(!%! *(> !& $ $ ;! *( ! $ ! < *! & * $ C* $ 1! & $ (! %! *(1$$(( ! *!$!$:* $$ $ !'$(&$ *'1!

* $( >!(!*( !$ ! %$! *!'!'$+*!($

1!*

! &$

(($1$$9 (

* !$ '(' !/' $

/$( &! A+,*!%$ '$

(& .?

) *( ,*!" 6(!9" > ( 6!" ! 8"

! " !*$!!! $

(( $ '*! !>!$>$$!'*!&FE. 6! & $;-$( !/ &$: !/$$

((1 !* ! !*! $( ('* 6 0&(! !*! 1$ ! (!(&( !$ (&! FE.

!/ &.?

!6$"6(!9"

6/( *!'"! "$

((*

G ! (& $( %$

((1 * !(& (* (* !*!" !E( ( "1$ !(!! 9 /"( C*! '( $'$ ;! %! *( $ !'$(&$( $ $! $' !!$$ (&*

! &$

((

!' &&!%$ !$!$ ( *$/ $

((!*!$! $ !/ !! F/ &"(! *( !$

(( * ( !/($ ! $

((!$*! $1!9 &$

((!$(/($ :$/1 $!"1*( +* $($ $!&( !'!$

((* $ (&*

! &$>1/!"$$(!%! *( $

! & * ! (& *

! &$

((:!

! !1!*

"D<$(* ! (&*

! & $ * "D< 1! * *

!' $ "D<(&"$

(($(( ( * "D< !!E "

" !( $!$" "D< !(

"D< ! ( "$!'! !(!&1!$(! %! *( %$

(("$*"( ( *!

< ; !$!$

"D< .*

!' "D< %!E "D< ; "D<

("$!' ! !

"D< 6 *

! (& "D< &'( %%)!

* (!&1!$

(($(( * !$*(*( /

(($(( (!$! H G !*$$*

!$ (' $ ((!( ?$ $ / $ *

" !

( #*+'*((

! " # ,-./ ! ?$$! 9'D!

3D ?$$!! ! (