Jagan Nath v. Hari Kishan
!"
##$$ %&' (&)" #
*&
&)*"+, &"##$$ &-)-$+&##& ....
/" ##$$" $"!'$&##$ !"'&& ! &&,01"2'&0$3 /"#$
&# $' &# #& &4
!&4$$ 5 6 3"&#"$ "& (' 7 +& -+2"!&"&'#$ 74&$ & #&48'&&!" !" &4&,!
$$!"&&!&!" &"' &44&"+ "#$
/" $'&$49!$&"" 3&$$&#"&'!""4&" "#$
/" '&"&'!"&$ #&4 8'&&!"#$
&1$ &4& &!3"
# '$# " "&'!"" /"#$
&0&"& #&"!&4$$ 5 6 +" "!&$""$ "& "':' &$$ & +
+
;+ &,
+
; & 41+ $,&"'$#"1$# ""&"#$
#&#& &4 "!&4$$" "' + & 2+2"!&" &<' "$3 < "!&4$$ = +#& &4''$08+" 9 "74&$ #$'&""'7 +& -+2"!&"
3#'&""&'!"8 ' "#&=3 '&"&$4" " #$
" &' !&' $& " "' &4 " &'&"1& =3 '&"&#$""1& 5+ "&3 4$1$4"!&' $& ""':' $$ ""& "#$
3"&&4!3 $& $$""&
" /" "9"443 '
&!&3! " 4$1 #$
+ "& &+ 3 9 8$1 $$ " "' :' 2:'$1+ <' >&$ *3& &1
5 6 ,'& 4& " 3"" 3 '$1 &!&
6 7 /" '&"&&""#$
" &4" """$<'4$& &1 ,'&
"1,?<' "!&4$$ 5 6
&# &41"<
+
;3!&4 $$30 &'$ &' &!&1/" &
<"!
+
;$430&&01"#&, =4 /<+
$"'!"+"#$
"$4""#&#&10$! <$',$1"4(3,&+0$" &4$ 3&"#2& ""#&#&1&!$$10$!"#$
8$1 /"&$2'& &##&!",,$0$"
$&"' $01"#$
&# #& &4 " !&4$$ 3&<'!" $&!&#&"!&4$$ 5 6 &# 0$$& +
;'&$4 $01" 3#01$&!""3& "#' #&#&1"< "$ "&/"&4!&$ $4"&'!"
'&$43&8 /" $" &##$/"$&@&##$$ 2'& &##&!",,$0$" $&&"
! "&$2'&"$""8'!4#01"&$ 2'&&& 2'$ &"##$$" $$1#2'$
&"##$$"$ $#1 "3&&!'4'0401 "##$$0 &"@&##$$2'& /" <' '&'43""#&,""& 3!&4$$03"#&/"!&4$$?<*+
6 #$*3& &1?<*
+>&$*3& &1?<*
A$$<'01 ,'& 4&"?<* $$ "'4",0#&'#&,01"#$
01$!
", /"##$$"$ $##$9!&,3
"8'!4
5$,&01"$&@&##$$ 2'&+3""3&&04,&&
B&'$ &"##$$"$ $'0$ :' $3$!3""##$/"'0$:' $3& <&'&
! "# !$ !% $&'
"( !$ !% $&'
) "*++ !$ !% $&'
, ,
!-.! . $$%
!$.!'. $$/
0 $$%
1 2 3 + 4 ,
,
1 4 5
6
9. : ; + $ 3
4
!$.!%. $&'
7
,
+ 4 , # <! 8
# ! 1 6 0
, => 4 >:
3 0 >>
?
,
,
!$ !% $&' ,
!$ !'
$$/
,
, , 1
5 8 "' 8 ") 7 @9*** 4 4 8 ***A% 4 :
8 )!!-
4 * 9 * 3 = , =
4 7
8 ,
+ 4 3
, 3
4 :
8 1 B 5 & $
,
3 0 -'. /!< $$)
0 C " D
!$.!%. $&'
/
,
/ 0
<
-
3 0 -' $$)D , ?
, 4
1 (
+ 4 ,
# <! 8
% 0
7 @*@ 8 4 4 =
4 7 8 4 ,
%
,
1 =
!$.!%. $&'
3
4 ?
!$.!%. $&'
,
,
$.!$. $$)
-
3 0 -' $$)
!&.!<. $$)
6 .%
(
, !$.!<. $$) ,
1 * 5 # /% 5 ,
!$.!%. $&' ,
,D
.
4 3
3
3
3
!-.!$. $$< # :
+ ( E
,
,
4 /< 3
4 B
4
F
1 ;
!$ !% $&' "
' # )' 4
,
'
4 )!" *
8 %&( , '-(
1 G 4 3
,
.
, 3
1C ?,"&#"$ $0& 1# 2'$ &"##$$"&!'""8'!4# 01"2'&&01#$!#$*3& &1+>&$ *3& &1 A$$ 5 6 & " #& " #$!/"& &+"2'&'$",&$'#" & '4B&'$" '&"&&!'""8'!4# 01"2'&0$3&&'$ 4&! ,&!
40$,B&'$" '&"&&!'"' $01 "#$
301$4="$0&""$& @&##$$2'&"3&!$1!&"3&&!'4 $01 "##$$/"!&4$$0 &0$' 4#$ <#&#&, 2"#&
"=4/< '$ &4"&'&B&'$" '&"&&!'" "'0&&01"#&#$ && '$ 2*2 =","&$&'$ &"##$$&# #& /" #& ' 3 $ & # #& &4 " !&4$$ 5 6 /"!&4$$"0#&, &3"$3/"#$
"#$!"#$" !&4$$(3,&+'##& "#$!+"#$
" #&' $#$*3& &1+>&$*3& &1 A$$<'01" '"'4&&:'&0 #$/",'!"0$01"#&&:'&0 4#& "#$!&& '$ 2*2# $$1#&,"
5 ,&1#$!"$$+$1+4 &4 "4&$ 3"""#&1#$!&$ &"$4& /"& &+ &&!'4 "$&'$" '4#$*3& &1+>&$*3& &1 A$$",0#$+"& &+'$0&$'#+ '0$ B&'$ &"##$$" '&"&'04"
! "2'&&&'$ 4&! ,&!
40$ , (3,&+ " '$ " # ' " # 3"&"&4&! ",&&!
40$," $ =","8'!4#01"2'&0$3/" 2'&0$3",##&"'4&13$$&$, 0&'!"&&01"#& B&'$ &"##$$" '&"&'04"" 8'!4#01"@&##$$2'&&&'"$& 2'&"& &&&"3&&!'4 $ #:'3"#& "3&&!'4"0 &01"2'&+"'$ &"##$$ $#'1 4&$ '04 3"" " 0 & /9! &""8'!4#01"2'&0$3&$ &+= 1&#"&!'4 " $&'$ &"##$$""8'!4 "@&##$$ 2'&$0$0"&
B&'$ &"##$$" '&"&'04"" !&4 $$ 3 &0$ 4#$ " <#& #&, 2"#&
"=4/<'$ &4 "&'&+",04 =",&"'04+!&4$$03 "&$0&"&/"<' "!&4$$#&,
5*
"=4/<+<&"3&&!'4$1 #&, " !&!
& '& " !& "$$ &!&1'43""#'&#&& &144,0$#&#&1 '$& &4$&4#$/"#&, $3$ 3"!&4$$ B&'$ &"##$$" '&"&& &&
5- "=4/<='
1" 5- $!3""&!"'!"0#&'&7 " /& & *&#&1 B&'$ &"##$$" '&"&'04"" '30&&01&& '$ 2*2/"'04 "$& '$"0&$01"$&@&##$$2'& '0+"#$
" $'$4!3&"# "#&#&1 /" " $3&44!"$4(3,&+ " &'33"&3"2'&& '#"& 0!$$','/"&$ $4"#&'3'$0 0&&'&"#&, && '$ 2*2/"'
$"#&'&3""#$
"!&4$$ "1& 5563"&&$&''6 3 $"
1& ##$$"4"$4 #$
"' B&'$ &"##$$" '&"&'04"" '30&&01$4"!&4$$ "1& 3"&'40 $
556 +"!&4$$1# &<'&!& "$&$76 " B4#&,""$4 & $!"' &# #& &4"&1& &4" < &#& &4" !&4$$ '" <+3""#$
" "#& &4& '/"#$
"#$""'
&' "4 3" " & ' "'& " 444<'"$"1& 556+"& &+"'
$01"#$
0"$001$4 A"&#:'-+'
1"" '$ &"##$$"00$0&! &"14&!
,=" '&"&0'04"40$,"0 & = 1 40$ , " 0 9 &01"2'&0$33"$&&,!"$' &!&:'2+'0"'#&," $$!!&4$$'#"#$
/"#$
"$'
,#&,"<' "!&4$$
" !&$!3"& &!&/"!&4 $$&!&'4 C'3"&#"40! " & &! " !&4 3'$ "3 " &
&!& "$3 <' $$&
+
+
;+
+
; 3 # # 3 $,& #& &$76+"' $"' &# #& &4&
&4" < &"#& &4 '" <+3" "#$
" & '$#& &4/"& &+C' 3&& &&0, C'?3"&!&"& &"3& &!'4 $01"##$$/"B&@&##$$2'& & ##&!",,$0$" $ &&!$$ # "+4"##$ $01"##$$&$1 0' '4 $! 3&&!'4"0+3'$ ,"8'!4 C'@ &4:' $3=:' 2'&&$1"2'&##&",,$0$"
$&&, ! C'>3"&!&"40$1
, ?<*6=$1# ,/"&"&4&$,$0$"
$ #&, " '#01 " #$
@'&"& 3" ?<*6 3 <"0 ,+ 08 3 9 (+ " :' 3&!"##$$ C'(+=)&:' $3C' "$&103&$"&$&#& "8'!4 /9!&" &'4 " ,,$0$" $+$"8'!4#01"2'& 0$3+= 1&& &3"" ! "
&&,01"2'& /9!&"0$ 4' +
; 3!&0#"1& 61&"$#+"& &+ "8'!4"2'&0$3&4 01 &!"#$
#1"4' +
;$!3"& "& 5D# @&"&&&0,+##$ $01"##$$ &&04
!
"
#$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0