Union Of India And Others v. Dayal Singh And Another




   
     

  !"#"$%&&


    



      !"  '%  ()'

& *
 *
'

*
*
 ()'

& *
+
,**

#$ %&&'&("&()* (+'+* ,&! -----  *
'

*
*
-&.

)/ . &!!*&/&(++0&1!0"" "(" 2 33 45  $.6  !(" 7) !"    3$1" / 7(+* 0(+8/&*'&("0(&4&(,,"( 9 7(+:6* 7);&/&*!".&(7(++;"&7,, "(7+)!(,"0,,&(1<=>,&?0 !"*...22@..33.=*;&(&7,,((A( "(7+)+1/(+)70(",(!",&)((!
 



   

3 ("  /+  ,  &  !  (0  &(  /  & "(7+),B;8(/C(/&D;(("<3>*&(1&+" &(?7"",,=>;&+0(0&7,,"(7+)

!!".&*+("/+,&! !+(/+(/&F"01, :7+ !1',"(
  



   
*;& &

:7+  !1  '  &(  5!+/+)  +"  &(  ;&  (  /+(1   ("(,"("+()*'(/&7,,(( )(!/"0&,+0,&0(+!!+/(&/*&0( ,"(7+)!7)"0,,<=>(+0;&((,;&+, &?0!"*//  E&(?&("+("/+,&!("&(? 0&0&&/(,+;&&(7+((/  ;0?(/,&!;&/&&(?7(""" 7,&'(G,+)*&(7,,"0,,"(7+)<=> ((0(3>&(70("!".//+)*("/"* &( &0&/&7,&(70("*&7,,((&+" &(?7/"&)( =     (  //""  !  &(  &  7,  ,  "0  ,, "(7+)&(7!1"7)!".&1+?*("(!& "/7)& :7+ !1',"( 



  

    
 ! 
"*&!/(& 7,,"0,,&(7,"7!17+(!&+" !/!+,+(; = /*&7,,"0,,&"(7+),13> =>&(70("(!&F"01,& :7+ !1', "(*&+("/+,&!&(7(7+&;&; 0(,&7,(&F"01,

01

23#/(4!(60(0

46 &7,,"0,,&"(7+),3>=>,(?, !".!?& +&+"!/!+,+(; @ &,&0?(/,&!&(&7,, "0,,&+"&(?+)70?,(!",&)(! &,+0,&0(+!!+/( H  ! &  +" !/!+ ,  +(; +" 7) & :7+

!1',"('?+!!(+ @,3.3+" 4 56"2 *"$781#& $"$ 
$9"

$9 2#:*"/"" 3.@*;&(+ &A;&0("+10&7,,((("17+( !",&)(;("/""*("/A+)&+,;(0("( ((("17+;0("&/+(1(*& :7+ !1 ',"(&+"("#$ 


     



      



 


                 




     


                 

         !

"  #$      

  
% 

    

  



                    

   
%                          

  
&        

   $       



  '(         )                


*

 1()7/"&(/&!/!+,+(;A(& &("&(7+"("(+"&7,*&!";"

46 (7+0(0(&+,,((;&+10&(1(++& //"*;&(/?"7)&(""/ (&&(0(0& ("+,*&!,/"?)(!!(/&&'/+(1 ,&(1+,("&("&(01&(&7,,(( &+"7/"(!",&)(  &!17+ !/(++);&*&
((,(+0(0&7,,(( ("17+1!+)//"(!& +0?0&?/( ;++(&+"!/!+,+(; 2 0"1(",(),/7)&'& ,(/("//1(/,&!/( . //"0+)*&;!"1" .. "0(!!+/(46*,()*(""!", . *
'

*
*
/   .+
,**

/ * ;

2-     E&&!(C0I("

 E&&!(7+