High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/757/2013dismissed

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Paramjit Singh Mann And ORS

2015-03-31Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg6 pages

!" #"$%&%'

!%' ('&)* '$"+, '-.%+%!"# ,,"(( '! /"*&)& * +0%!1%'23 '' '# '!3"* "&,'#"'!& 456. 17

83"!3"*",*!"*& .$ ("9&, ,"*&+ -:" ((9"#! &""!3"0)#2+"'!;

:"*"

"**"#!!3"",*!"*&*'!;

83"!3"*!3"0)#2+"'!&3)(#:"*",*!"#%'!3"%2"&!; *"&"'!413*% *%'#"*7)+ *<#/$ !" * 13*%&39 '% (9 *<#/$ !" *!3" ,,"(( '! 13*%="(<#/$ !" **"&,'#"'! 13*%, (1%'23"3 (<#/$ !" **"&,'#"'! 3%&%& ' ,," (#%*"$!"#:-!3"'&)* '$"+, '- 2 %'&! !3"9 *## !"#

, &&"#:-13*%1*"9 (<*"&%#%'2

%$"*<

!*$$%#"'!( %+&*%:)' (<1 '2*)*/%#"93%$3$( %+,"!%!%' %("# )'#"*1"$!%' >> !*="3%$("&$! %'&3*!5!3"$!#%*"$!"#:- * +0%!1%'23 ''$( %+ '!9 &, *!(- $$",!"# '# &)+ &?<>@A5 9 &2* '!"#

*%"

(-!3"$ &" !3"$( %+ '!%&!3 !'

*)'#

+$( %+ '! ('29%!33%& !3"*%"*"&,'#"'! 1 '!B31%'23 9"*"2%'2 *+

%$"*('-<1 '2*)*!!3"%*3)&"'+!*$-$("

:" *%'2*"2%&!* !%'5 =5

3" :/"& %#+!*$-$("9 & #*%/"':-!3"*"&,'#"'! '#$( %+ '!9 &!3",%((%'*%#"*( %+ '! &B"#!3"*"&,'#"'! !&(9#9'!3"&,""# +!*$-$(" '#! #*%/" !3"+!*$-$("$ *"

)((-:)!*"&,'#"'!' B",!'#*%/%'2!3"

+!*$-$("%' * &3 '#'"2(%2"'!+ ''"*)"!!3"* &3 '#'"2(%2"'! #*%/%'2 !3"+!*$-$(":-!3"*"&,'#"'! <!3"+!*$-$("&B%##"# '##)"!!3 !$( %+ '! "((#9''!3"* # '#&)&! %'"#+)(!%,("

2*%"/)&%'0)*%"&'3%&,"*&'3"+!*$-$("9 &: #(-# + 2"#%'!3" & %# $$%#"'! ( %+ '!9 &! B"'!%/%(&,%! (<1 '2*)*/"'!3" $'$"*'"##$!*&"'!!3"*)B !(%$"1! !%'%!-1 '2*)*:)!!3",(%$" '"/"*!B '- $!%' ( %+ '!9 &!3"'*" "**"#! + *&,%! (< !% ( 93"*" 3" *"+ %'"# #+%!!"# *+

( %+ '!'"/"*(#2"# '-A*"2 *#%'2 $$%#"'! &!3"/"3%$("9 & #*%/"':-3%& !3"*5*"&,'#"'! "'$"!3"$( %+,"!%!%' ''!%$"<*"&,'#"'!& ,," *"# '#*"&,'#"'! %("#3%& 9*%!!"'&! !"+"'! (("2%'2!3 !3"'"/"*#*%/"!3"/"3%$("%' * &3 '# '"2(%2"'!+ ''"*3"*"

*"<3"%&'!(% :("!, - '-$+,"'& !%'!!3" $( %+ '!+*"/"*<!3"+!*$-$("9 &%'&)*"#9%!3*"&,'#"'! '# *"&,'#"'! 9 & 3 /%'2 / (%# #*%/%'2 (%$"'$" '# *"2%&!* !%' $"*!% %$ !" "'-%'2!3"* /"*+"'!&< '&9"*%'2*"&,'#"'!,* -"# * #%&+%&& ( !3"$( %+,"!%!%' C "&,'#"'! %'3%&9*%!!"'&! !"+"'! ,(" #"#!3 !!3"

+!*$-$(" 9 & %'&)*"# 9%!3 %! ! !3" !%+" (("2"# $$%#"'! :)!

'&9"*%'2*"&,'#"'!%&'!(% :("!, - '-$+,"'& !%'!!3"$( %+ '!

(&"#%& :%(%!-$"*!% %$ !"3 &:""',*$)*"#:-!3"$( %+ '!)*!3"*<%!%& &):+%!!"#!3 !!3"$( %+ !3"# + 2"#+!*$-$(" +)'!%'2!& >C@A5 3 &:""', %#!1 '!B31%'23:-*"&,'#"'! )*!3"*%!%& (("2"# !3 !'&)$3 $$%#"'!!B,( $" & (("2"# '#9 &(#2"#:- !3"$( %+ '!"'-%'2!3"* /"*+"'!&< '&9"*%'2*"&,'#"'!,* -"# * #%&+%&& ( !3"$( %+,"!%!%' *+ !3" ,(" #%'2& !3" , *!%"&< ((9%'2 %&&)"& 9"*"

* +"#45

83"!3"*$( %+ '!2!%'0)*"#'

#)"!!3" * &3 '#'"2(%2"'!#*%/%'2 +!*$-$(":" *%'2 *"2%&!* !%'5 5=5

&#*%/"':-*"&,'#"'! ;

83"!3"*!3"$( %+ '!%&"'!%!("# *$+,"'& !%'<% &< 93 !"D!"'! '# *+93+;

83"!3"*!3"$( %+,"!%!%'%&'!+ %'! %' :("%'!3" ,*"&"'! *+;

C83"!3"*!3"$( %+ '!3 &'$ )&" $!%'! %("!3" ,*"&"'!$( %+,"!%!%'; "(%"

> 3"*%:)' (< !"* &&"&&%'2!3"!"&!%+'- !3"9%!'"&&"& $$",!"#!3"$( %+,"!%!%' '# ((9"# &)+ &?<>@)! !3"& %# +)'! & <>@A5 9"*" 2%/"' ' $$)'! +"#%$ ( !*" !+"'! '# &>

A5' $$)'! #%& :%(%!-!!3""D!"'! E9"*" ((9"#%'

!3 !*"&,"$! ""(%'2#%&& !%& %"#9%!3!3" :/"& %#9 *#<!3" ,,"(( '!5 '&)* '$"+, '-3 &#%*"$!"#!3",*"&"'! ,," (< & *"& %#

@ 3 /"3" *#(" *'"#$)'&"( *!3", *!%"& '#3 /"2'"

!3*)23!3"*"$*#& !3"$ &" ? ." *'"#$)'&"( *!3" ,,"(( '!3 &&):+%!!"#!3 ! $$%#"'! 3 &'!:""',*/"#3"*"%&'%'!3",*"&"'!$$)**"'$"

3 /"$'&%#"*"#!3"& %#&):+%&&%':)!#'! %'# '- *$"

%'!3 !&):+%&&%'

!%&'!#%&,)!"##)*%'2!3"$)*&" *2)+"'!&!3 !%'*"&,"$!

!3"& +" $$%#"'!<!3"# + 2"$( %+"#%'*"&,"$! +!*$-$("3 &:""'

((9"#1<!3" $!)+ $$%#"'!3 &:""' #+%!!"#:-!3" '&)* '$" +, '-5 ,,"(( '! :-2%/%'2!3"$+,"'& !%'%'*"&,"$! !3"+!* $-$("1<+"*" $!!3 !3 &'!:""'*"2%&!"*"#%&'! 2*)'#! #%&$ *#!3"$ &" !3"$( %+ '!

3"'"D!$'!"'!%'* %&"#:-!3"$)'&"( *!3" ,,"(( '!%& *"2 *#%'2 F) '!)+ $+,"'& !%' ! %& &):+%!!"# !3 ! +)'!

&?<>@A5%&'3%23"*&%#"

9"/"*<3 /"$'&%#"*"#!3"& %#&):+%&&%' (&:)!# '! %'# '- *$"%'!3 !&):+%&&%'

C 3"*%:)' (3 & 9 *#"# &)+ &>

A5%'*"&,"$!

E ,"*+ '"'! #%& :%(%!- 93%$3 $ ''! :" & %# ! :" ' 3%23"* &%#" '!3"*&)+ & <>@A53 &:""' $!) ((-&,"'!:-!3"$( %+ '! '#!3 ! +)'!3 &:""'*"%+:)*&"#

)'&"( *!3" ,,"(( '!3 & )*!3"*&):+%!!"#!3 !$( %+ '!

3 & %("#!,*/"!3" $!)+ * &3 '#'"2(%2"'!#*%/%'2

> 3 /"$'&%#"*"#!3"& %#&):+%&&%':)!#'! %'# '- *$"

%'!3 !&):+%&&%'

3"&! !"+"'! !3"$( %+ '!3 &:""'*%23!(- $$",!"#%'!3%& *"2 *#

@ ." *'"#$)'&"( *!3" ,,"(( '!3 & )*!3"*&):+%!!"#!3 !' $ &")'#"*1"$!%' >> !3" !*="3%$("&$!%&+ #")! &* &3 '# '"2(%2"'!#*%/%'2%&'!,*/"#!!3"+&!<%!$ ':" $ &")'#"*1"$!%'

>5 !3" !*="3%$("&$!:)!!3"& +"%&'!+ %'! %' :(" &!3" %'$+" !3"$( %+ '!9 &+*"!3 '&

A5,"*+'!3< & (("2"# '# &&)$3%'$+"9 &+*"!3 '&C

A5,"* '')+

? 3 /"$ *"

)((-$'&%#"*"#!3"& %#&):+%&&%'

3" '"2(%2"'$" *"&,'#"'! &! '#& ,*/"# 1< !3"

:/"& %# *2)+"'!%&9%!3)! '-&):&! '$"

'&"F)"'!(-<!3" ,," (%&9%!3)! '-+"*%! '#!3"& +" &! '#&#%&+%&&"#

1%'$" !3" + %' ,," ( 3 & :""' #"$%#"#< &< !3" ,*"&"'! ,,(%$ !%' 3 & :""' *"'#"*"# %'

*)$!))& '# !3" & +" (& &! '#& #%&+%&&"#

$,- !3%&0)#2+"'!:"&"'!!!3"!*% ()*! *&!*%$!

$+,(% '$"