Tarsem Singh & ORS. v. Gurdeep Singh & ANR.



 

   

         






!"

"
#$$%%
&'
('$
!"

"
#
$

     

  )

&*
+"%,

-
."

&/"
.,
-

"
$$%%
000


1""
$

%%
$$
2
/
%%.


"
3'! 4




/
 

"
$

4
56

1""
"
3'! 
"'%
/
$

"
!4

000



%
'
%
/2
"
$%


.
 
/2
"
%
'
-
3'! 





7
$$%
$ 
!
"


%

.
 

8



"

".,
$%



/ 
"
',

"
!'%

$$%
)

"
%,
" ,
.'%
/
 

/2
"
!%
$

"
'
9
",


'
%
/2
"
$%

,
"2
$2



%
"
$%


"
/ 
.

"
%
'!

*%

%,
'

"
%
:
*%

%,
/!
*"
 ;;



< ,
;;


< ,
'

-%%!
=,
"%


."",

$$2

>'

 
$''

"





/2
<' <?%%,
."",


7 7 @@7

6

"
3 /,
".!
'
$$2

/
%%
!!

-'

"
 ,
.
"'
%/%

/


"
 

"
$%






3'
.
%
% ,
!
"
 

%!
"
'
%

2


)


%
'!

*%

%
'

"
%

*%
.
%
% ,

$

"


*%

%
.
%2
/
/2
"
$%




9
.
-
"
"
'
$$2
.
.
/2
('/"
!"


"
!",
."
!!
"
 

-'

?"
A'


?"
A'
%
!!
!"

-'

3
!"


"
!"


3
!"
"
,
 
/!
"
",
'

"


B'",
('/"
!"
"
 
"

$$2
'!
"
%  

-'

?"
!"



!",
$''






!%2,
'
.


"
-'

?"
!"
"
%
,
$%


/!
"
"
"
'

"


9
.

"
?"
!"
'!
"
%  
$$%


 $

!!
$$2

$

!!
 '


,

;<

"
'2



@78

=.-,
"
2

"
!

/2
"



 <' <?%%,
.""
 %
"
!!
$$2
.
 

8

,
/2


"
"

?%%,
.""


?"
!"
$$%

.
 $,
/'
"
 
'%

/
 $% 

)%


!
$$%

.

$

"
%
'!

*%

%,

"
 
.
'
/2
"
"

"%,
.""

$

*%

%
.
"
-

"
$%


/2
).

(.

"
$

)

!
"


"
%
'!

*%

%,
'%

/
%-

'
 !
$
"',
"
'
9
 ,

.
$%,

%,
"

('/"
!"


"
!"
"
%2
"

% 


"


"
",
-

.%%


8 @7,
"
"

!"

%; 
"
'
$$2
B'",

-%
'
 :

,
%
3
!"
-
('/"
!",
.
'
'!
"
$2

"

',

 $ 
.



/.
"
$


"
/
" ,




,
.
$

('/"
!"
" % ,
'!
"
%  ,
!
"
'
$$2
 ,
$''




8

,
$
/2

?%%
9
(,
.""

" ,

"
",
"

.

!!
."
2/2


!



,
"
 
.
%%!

/
'%
 '

('/"
!"
"
'


2
'"


"
"
2
!"

'


"
 

%
',




"


'

-

,
'
"
3'! 





@:

,


-%
'

 @:,
%

('/"
!"
-
"
!"

",
-%
"
$%

% 

"-
"
"
'
%

"
"
"
!",

"
/


.%%

8 @7,

"
"
%2
"

% 

"

"',
$%

"

$.

%

 
"

%

9
 

"
 
$2

"
.%%

8 @7

6C ,

.
/-
"
%"'!"
"
 
.

$-,

>'

%.,
/'
"

"
'%
%.2
/
*



%%%
$'$
$'%%2

"
.*

"
$%

('/"
!"

-%
'
 @:

!%2,

.
/-
"
-
 ('/"
!"
"
!!
"
'
$$2,
/'
"
 
"





"
!"

"
'%
.

"
%2
"

% 

"

9
 

"
3'! 




6C)

,


-%
'

 ,
%

?"
!"
-
('/"
!",

"
/
."
$%

$'$

"-
>'
%
>'
"
'
$$2,

.
/-
"
-
"
 
"
$%



$2

"
3'! 




6C,


-%
'
 :

,
%
/2
3
!",
"
!",
.
!"

"
!"
!
('/"
!",

"
 
.



"
/


 $ 
6C ,
"
.
-

/.
"
$
'%%2,
-



,
3
!"
"
/ 
.

D
"



"
$%



"

'
/ 
.

"
 !
D
",

"
$$2
"
.

'/3


"

'
%'!
"
%

>'

"
$
'

!%2,

.
/-
"
%"'!"
3'! 




,
.
$
$

$

 ,
2
"

.
-
%
/2
('/"
!"
/ 
"
'
"

"



6C)

,

-'

?"
!"

!%2,

.
%'
"
"
3'! 




"
/ 
%

/!

('/"
!"






"



,

3
!"

"
.

$

"

',
"',
"
 
.

/!

" 

!,
3'! 



@@

6C)7
E

-%
'
 ::
 ,
%

3
!"

"
-

?"
!"

"F,
%
'$
/2
"
$%

,
-
.""
"
'
%
/2
3
!"

"
.
 ,

.
/-
"
"


6C)7

6C):,

$$%
.
$ 

"

$$%%
'


"



 
"


"
%
'
=.-,
$
 ,
3
!"

"


%
2
-

-'%%2,
"
'
.
 

.".

!%2,

.



/-
"
"
 %

"

'
.'%




"
3'! 





B'",
"
!"
.
"
.

"

$$2
%'!
"
'
%

"
"
"
,
 %2,
3
!",
+"
!"

('/"
!"



%2

% 


"
'
$$2
.
/>'"

-'

('/"
!",
$
"
",



"
!"
-%-
'$
"
.
/",
 %2,
3
!"

+"
!"
G*.,

"

3
!",
"
"
.
"
/2
"
?%
9
"

 

"
 +"
!"
.
"
/2
"
?%
9
"

!%2,
?"
!",
."
"$$

/
"
<< %.

%
'%

('/"
!",
"

!",
%



"
'
$$2

"
/!
,
$%


.

"%
%
-

"
3'
$2
,

%

$


%
'!

*%

%

"
'
.
!%2,
 

+!
!!-
!
"

,
$%


$ 

$$%

B
$$%%
'
-.
"


',
-





%2
" '
%

'
."
"
-.
.
/2
"
%
'

"
!


'$$
" 

'%%2,
"
$$%
.
 

9
"-
"
%

'%

"
$$%%

%!"

$'
"


G

'%

"
$$%%
 $%2
*


"
'/ 
"
.
-
/ 
"
'
/%.

3
 

'

 $"-


%%
."
"
"
'!

"
$''





,
'


/2
('/"
!"

"

-',
"
>'
%

"
'
$$2


"


.
-



2
$!,
"
 
"

%2
B'",
-
3'! 




@@
6C)7

6C):
E

-%
'
 ::


F,
'
%
/2
3
!"

"
!
$<<

"
$%

,
 %2,
?"
!",
.
 
."

=

"

"

'
('/"
!"
" %
.
$%







,
'


/2
('/"
!"

-'
 ?"
!"
.
%
%

"

$!
"',
"
'/ 
"
!


"
'
.'%
$


3'

G%2,
"

"
 
'%

%
%
$''




,

"
 
>'
!



'

"'!" '%


"


',
9


"

-.
"
"

$$%

-




"',
%/%

/
 

"

"

/!

" 

?%2,
"
'
$$2
.
.
/2
"
!",
"
 ('/"
!"

9

'
%
/2
('/"
!"
" %

!


-%
'
 @:,
"
*.%!
"
$''


.%%
C'
/2
"
"
"
!",


8 @7,
%2

% 

.
/>'"

"
-'

"',
"
%*
$.

%

 
"

%



/%

"
,
!%
!
.%%

8 @7,
.

$

"


-%
'
 :

 ,
%

3
!"

"

-
('/"
!"

"

 
$2
"
.
$-



6C 
%

"
.%%


8 @7,
".
"
"
!"
"
%2
/>'"

% 


-'

"

('/"
!"
"!
.
/'!"



".
"
('/"
!"
.
"
/%'
.

"
'
$$2
"
/!
,
"
 $%%2
%*
$2

%

 
"
'
%,

2



"

,
3'! 




,

"
/
."
?"
!"
$'$

"-
>'
%
>'
"
'
$$2



'


/2
('/"
!",
.


>'
+
"


2,
-
 ,


' 


 
"
('/"
!"
.
"
.

"
'
%

.
"',
%

 
"
 ,
"
>'
"
' 
! 

"
3'',

.""

"
.*

"



,
."
!",
%

,
"
.
% 
."



'







?%2,
'!
"
$2

-%
'
 :

,
%
/2
3
!"

"


"
!
('/"
!"


"
!",

 $ 
6C 
.



/.
"
$,
.""
.


$

"



6C 

)''

"

,
3
!"
$<< 

"
 
/ 
.

D
"

"
'
$$2
%'!
"
%
-%-

"
$
%

"
 !
D
"
.
.
/2
"
!",
.
!"

"
!"
3%2
!
"/2,
('/"
!",
 
"
$%



"

'

/
"
.


/-

-
/>'"
"
% ;% 


"
-'
9$'/%2,



,
.
-
>'

%
/2
('/"
!"
'!
"
%  ,
"'!"
"
-
".
"

% 



('/"
!"
.
% 
."

!",
%



"
'
%,

'


/2
"

-'
 $<<

"
 


,
.


>'

%.

6C
,
'

"

$

-'

3
!"

"
!
('/"
!"


,
.
-
/'!"

"


"
'
"








!
"
 %

"
'
%
/2
3
!"

"

-%
'
 ::
 ,

'
"

'
.
 
-
3'! 



@@

6C)7

6C):,
/'
"

%
'
"
"


.




$$%
$ 
/2
3
!"

"

#


"

.
 

"
%
'


 "

=.-,
'/>'%2,
"

'
.
 

.".
"
/!
,
"
!' 
/!
-
/2
"
%

'%

"
$$%%
"
"

3'! 
.'%
$

3'

"
$
$!,
%*
-


/
'

B%2,

/-
/2
"

$$%%
',
-

"

'
.
 

.".
."'
%/2

%
 ",


$

"
!
.'%

'



 





"
?

?-%
)'
%2,

"
3'! 



@@ ,
.


/2
"

$$%%
'

"

.
 ,
"

3'! 
/ 
H<CI

%.

.


".

'%
-
/
*
!J
 
B
 ,



,
'

C

!,
.""



,
>'
!,
'




2,
$%


-
%
"


"

"
$
'


2
"
$!
9
2
,
$%


'%
-
%
"





 
"
('/"
!"
%2
"

% 


"
'
$$2

"',
"
"

 /%
%

9
"
/

2
!",
%



"
'
$$2,
$%


%*
%'

>'
"







9
"
.*

"
$,


'
/-,

"
%'
"
"-
'%2
/

/2
/"
"
'
/%.,
"
"%2
C
2
!',
%
$%'/%

%.,

 
."
"

/!
%

"
$
$$%

>'

%.,
'"
%
2
'/%
>'

%.,



$$%
/!
-


,
!%2,
 
January 14, 2015 Rajan
( Arun Palli ) Judge