High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/775/2013dismissed

State Bank Of Patiala v. M/S Satish Kumar Contractors And ANR

2016-10-065 pages

!!"#$%&'()*"+ ,'%%&(!()- &'#% ./.

0','%,)1 ,'(,2,/%,3 (&%/4% ,22/ ,'(,2, 55%22,)'

6% !7!

8!0,'(!497:, )' ,&' !/, ),2, ,)'4% %!5)3%)'!

! ! "#

%!%)'-

4%',) ('',2/0%)( 3;&,'%<('4

97),2 72<,)(/3;&,'%/ '4%,55%22,)'

9,)!,2/3;&,'%/ %!5)3%)' ===== ! "# !" >"

'4% %,!)! :%)'()%3 () '4% ,552(&,'()!/ <4(&4 , % !755 '%3#?,(3,;('!/3%2,?*.3,?!() %"(2()@,)33,?!()(2()@'4% ,55%,2(!&)3)%3 552(&,'()!!',)33(!5!%3

55%22,)'"0','%,)1 ,'(,2,(!,@@ (%;%3'4%(:57@)%3 3% 3,'%3+/<4% %#?'4%#$%&'()! !%''()@",!(3%'4%,<, 3 3,'%3+/4,;%#%%)5, '2?,22<%3

4%',) ('',2/2%, )%30%)( 7)!%2,!!(!'%3#? 97),2

72<,)(/3;&,'%/ %5 %!%)'()@'4%,55%22,)'#,)1!7#:('!'4,''4% %<,! ,),@ %%:%)' &)!' 7&'()3:()(!' ,'(;%2&17(23()@&:5 (!()@

#,!%:%)',)3'4 %%!' (%!) 2'>>"/0%&' *"/4,)3(@, 4

%!5)3%)'<,!,55()'%3,!,)' ,&' &)!' 7&'()'4% , %:%)'()%3#2&1<%;% /,3(!57'%, !%,)3!()&%'4%,@ %%:%)' &)',()%3 '4% %!27'() 3(!57'% '4 7@4 , #(' ,'()/ #(' ,' ,&& 3()@2?<,!,55()'%34%&2,(:,)'"&)' ,&' 23@%3,!:,)?,!(;% &2,(:!/(%/ (7'!',)3()@37%),&&7)'< 13)%A ((&,!4!%&7 ('?A

(((5 (&%;, (,'(),3$7!':%)'A (;2!!),&&7)'() 7&'77!;% 4%,3 %B5%)3('7 %! ,)3A ;()'% %!'<%;% /'4% #(' ,' ,22<%32,(:! / / ,)3 +/ #7' 2,(: / <4(&4 3%,2' <('4 5 (&% ;, (,'() ,3$7!':%)'/4,!#%%) %$%&'%3#?'4% #$%&'()@7 '4,;()@,22%)<('4() '4%C%B&%5'%3:,''% D,!5% '4%5 ;(!()!2,7!%'4%,@ %%:%)'/ #7''4%&)' ,&' &723)'!',1% %!''4%&2,(:!();(%<2,7!%. '4%@%)% ,2()!' 7&'()!,)32,7!%* ,'4%'% :!,)3&)3('()!'4% ,@ %%:%)'/:7&42%!!/'4% #(' ,' !4723)'4,;%,552(%3'4% 0

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

2,<4% #(' ,' 4,3%B&%%3%34(!$7 (!3(&'() #? @(;()@ 7)37% #%)%(' ' '4% &)' ,&' #? ,&&%5'()@ '4% %B&%!!(;% :%,!7 %:%)'!@(;%)().'4,)3'4#(22!!5% '4%&2,7!%/)&%'4% %(! %B'%)!()'4%&)' ,&'/'4%&)' ,&' <723)'#%2(,#2%'&2,(:'4% '4,)%B'%)!()'(:% 3%2,?()&:52%'()'4%< 122'4%!%,&' ! 3(3)'<%(@4()'4%:()3'4% #(' ,' /:7&42%!!'4% #$%&'()@7 ' ,)3/'47!/7 @%!'4(!7 ' !%''()@",!

% &)' ,&'/ 9,)!,2/2%, )%3&7)!%2 %!5)3%)'

!7#:('!'4,''4%,<, 3'4% #(' ,' (!5% %&'/2%@,2,)3$7!'((%3

,'4% /'4%& !!"#$%&'()!4,;%,2!#%%)(2%34% #$%&'()@7 '4,! % )%7!2?!%'",!(3%2,(:''4%'7)%/./..8"/<4(&4<,!)' ,22()@<('4()'4%C%B&%5'%3:,''% !D %,!)()@4,!#%%),!!(@)%3#? '4% #$%&'()@7 '()!%''()@",!(3%'4%, %:%)'()%3&2,(:%7 '4% !7#:('!'4,''4(!7 '/:7&42%!!'4% #$%&'()@7 '/&,))' %",55 %&(,'%

& '4%%;(3%)&%,)3' %,''4%#$%&'()!,!,55%,2<4(2%!(''()@)'4%, :&4,( '4% #(' ,' /<4#%()@%B5% '/4,;()@%B,:()%3'4%%;(3%)&%) %& 3)!755 '4(!&)'%)'()/ %2(%!75)'4% ,'(3%&(3%)3(&722%3 7'#?'4%)G#2%075 %:%7 '()'()*' '++ ,-./-'0,1.,- -) 2./+3+ 140,.+#

567),&'/'4%,55%22,)'"#,)14,! )'#%%),#2%'5()'7',)?(22%@,2('?85,'%)'(22%@,2('?()'4%,<, 3;(!"," ;(!'4%&2,(:!,&&%5'%3#?'4% #(' ,' ,)3/'47!/7 @%!'4(!7 ' ,( :()@'4%()3()@!,)3,22<()@'4%& !!"#$%&'()! 4,;%4%, 3'4%2%, )%3&7)!%2 '4%5, '(%!/,55 ,(!%3'4% 5,5% #1 ,)3 '4% ;(%< '4,' '4% % (! ) &% ,)3 :% (' () '4% !7#:(!!() ('',2/ /2,7!%.'4%,@ %%:%)'(!)',&2,7!% &)' ,&',@ %%:%)'/#7',5, '@%)% ,2()!' 7&'()!''4%&)' ,&' ,)3 &)3('()! '%)3% 2,7!% * , '4% ,@ %%:%)' 5 ;(3%! '4,' '4% &)' ,&' !4,224,;%)&2,(:'4% '4,)%B'%)!()'(:% '4%3%2,?() &:52%'() '4% < 1 '4% % (! ) 3%&(!()/ 5()()/ 3( %&'() &% '((&,'%/#7'?%''4% #(' ,' &,),2<,?!()'% 5 %''4%5 ;(!()!();(%< '4% ,'(3%&(3%)3(&722%37'#?'4%)G#2%075 %:%7 '() % /-8./, '09:'*+ 2./+3+ '/(.+8 8;/'# !

4% ,552(&,'() 0 :72,/%;%)('4%%B,&'2!!<,!)') %& 3/ 4,!#%%) %&@)(!%3,)3,&&%5'%3#?'4%7 '! 2,(:<,!<('4 %@, 3''4%7'!',)3()@37%!),&&7)' '4%< 13)%/<4(&44,!)'#%%)3(!57'%32,(:<,! %7)3 '4%&,!4!%&7 ('?)'% %!'/():?;(%</4,!,2!#%%) (@4'2?,<, 3%3H >E/'47@4&2,7!% 5 ;(3%!,<, 3()@()'% %!'H*E ):?;(%</'4%5 (&%;, (,'(),3$7!':%)'<,!,22()@()2,7!% %B&%5'%3 :,''% ! ,)3/ '4% % %/ '4% #(' ,' 3(3 )' 4,;%

$7 (!3(&'()'%)'% ',(),)3' ?'4%!,:%,)3 (@4'2?!/ %$%&'%383(!&, 3%3 #? '4% #$%&'()@ 7 ' 4% #(' ,' / #%()@ ,) %B5% '/ 4,! ,2 %,3? %B,:()%3'4%&2,(:'4 %,3#, %#?',1()@()'&)!(3% ,'()'4%'% :!,)3 &)3('()!'4%,@ %%:%)',)3)''4%@%)% ,2()!' 7&'()!4%&)' ,&'(! >>,)3'4%,<, 3<,!5 )7)&%3)+,)3 (@4'2?!/>E ()'% %!')'',2,:7)' 5 % %% %)&%5% (34,!#%%),<, 3%3();(%< '4%2,<2,(33<)#?'4%)G#2%075 %:%7 '()*)./ ,+39-0,< = 010-.) 2./+3+ -'-. /0++'#

5 5 5

%@, 3()@5, '2?,&&%5',)&%#$%&'();(!",";(!2,(:/ '4%,55%,2,!<%22,!'4%& !!"#$%&'()!, % %$%&'%3,)3'4%()3()@!;(!"," ;(!2,(:!//+,)3, %754%23 >-4./ 5#

! " /'1.+8

"8.-8./ +;.'?0,<@/.'+,.) A.+@ "8.-8./ .;/-'49. A.+@