Jagdeep Singh v. Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd And ORS
!"
# $
# # % &&
'
((
) *+
) , & -
) *
) ,
& -
*,
+
) *
) *
) *+
& -
)* , & -
, ,
"
#
$
)++ ,.
)++ ,
), , *.
), , *
), , *.
), , *
/"!
* * & -
, "
% &'
(
), , & -
0 ,
% &'
*
) * 0 ,.
/"!
,
)00 , & -
0 ,
"
)+ , & -
,
"
"
!
) '
1"2 ) (!
3 4!
!
%
*+ ,- . / 0
123+)))4+!5$ 23+)))$+!5$6 0
"7123+48(+!5$6 0
"7123+4)5$+!5$6 0
"$123+)$$+!5(6 0
"(123+!!9+!5(6 0
"$123+495+!5(6 0
"4123+)$!+!5(6 , :. / 0
"+
123+)))4+!5$ 23+)))$+!5$6 0
"4+
123+48(+!5$6 0
"4+
123+4)5$+!5$6 0
"(+
123+)$$+!5(6 0
"$+
123+)$!+!5(6 ,:
% :. / 0
"! )123+)))4+!5$ 23+)))$+!5$6 0
" !123+48(+!5$6 0
123+4)5$+!5$6 0
") 7123+($+!5(6 0
"7 4;+<:
123+)$$+!5(6 0
"7 4123+!!9+!5(6 0
") 7123+495+!5(6 0
") 7123+)$!+!5(6 ,% . / 0
"7+ 123+)))4+!5$ 23+)))$+!5$6 2
")+ 123+48(+!5$6 2
")+ .123+4)5$+!5$6 2
123+($+!5(6 2
123+)$$+!5(6 0
"$123+!!9+!5( 0
"4123+495+!5(6 0
123+)$!+!5(6 ,
:". / 0
123+48(+!5$6 0
" !123+4)5$+!5$6 )
,& , . / 0 ,<'. / 0
16123+!!9+!5( 23+495+!5(6 , :
/%'. / 0
" !; 123+495+!5(6 0
" !; 123+)$!+!5(6 "
0
"4 $123+)))4+!5$6 "
0
"4123+)))$+!5$6 "
0
" !123+($+!5(6 "
0
") 8123+)$$+!5(6 "
0
")123+!!9+!5(6 === 4!
!.
!( 6 27
) *
&
&
> 0
'0! ' 0
2
. 0
+
- 00
' 0
-
'0! ' 0
) *+
&
?@
-
. '
0
)++ , &
, &
> 0
'044 ' 0
2
. 7
0
+
- 00
' 0
-
'044 ' 0
), , * &
/"!
* * &
, &
> 0
'09 ' 0
2
. 0
+
- 00
' 0
-
'09 '
), , * &
/"!
* * &
,
2
.
-
@ ++7 >
) &
A'-'0
.
00< 0
0
<:
& ' < >
0 : <'-'0
' //
0 0
- 0
$$ 0 , . 988 10 B 988 C6
>
0 00 0 > > ,
5$5!!54
0 . < "#%5)+ +!)48 > %:
< "#57+?+55$( -
/ >
0 .%:
-
0 > 4
:
/
> ' 0
-
2 / -
2"!$
5$5!!54-
000
<
!(9;)57+;7!(%% D> . " E 0 0
/ . &< / 0< < "#%5)+
+!)48 0< "#57+?+55$(
'
0 F 0
. &< - 0
-
> '
@
0 45G
/ '
/ 0
- / 0 -- < '
: ' / '< "#%5)+ +!)48-
-" < "#57+?+55$( -
-
. ! 23")))40!5$ < 23")))$0!5$ < 0 -
0 <
"#57+?+55$( /
0 0 / ' 23 "4)5$ 0 !5$ <
<' / 0< "#%5)+ +!)48# /
0 0 / ' 23")$$0!5(. 23")$!0!5( 23"($0!5(/ <
<' "
' / 0
<:
< "H3A+85++!58 23")$$0!5(23"4950!5( 23"!!90!5( < 0
+ 0 < "#57+?+55$( $
/ 0
<:
< "H3A+!54++!5( 23 "4950!5(23"48(0!5$ < 0
>
0
2 "$ 8 3 '
) & -
0 / 0 - //
3-
/ / <
< : ' / ' <
/ ' ' 0 0
<' &< ")-
*+
!
"
# $% & '""" '
( ()
'
(
'
"
" " !
!
) ' " *
'
"
+ '
) )! & / ' 0
<' 0
<
<'
0
<
*+ "
!
"
() ,
+
'
! (
' ( ( ")
- )) &
/ < /
0- - <'
0
!
< </
0<' < / / <
<
'
. 0 - < 0' /
-
@
0<'0
<' 0- < /
<'
0 "# $
%
&'
(()&& *+
" !
+ "".
! '
( ) "
/"
! ( ) " / "
/
" !
+ !
"
! (
"
"".
! !( 0
! "! )"
!
/ "
(
!
'"" +
'.(' ! 1 " !
"
0
+ ! "
1 "
(
/ "
)"
' "
( ) !)
'!"!
" !
")!
"".
!
1 "
( )"
( "
! (
!
!
. 1 "
(
! ()
'.(' + ! / "
!'"!
'
' ( "
'.(' !
1 " !
"
"
(
" ! !
"
/ "
'
+! /"
' ( "+
+ 8
'
/ "
" "
- )7 / - 0 </ .
<' -
-
/ '
<' &<
23 ")))40!5$ 23")))$0!5$
23"4)5$0 !5$- < / 0< "#%5)+ + !)48
'
- < /
<' -
0
</
0<' +
23 2# "$ 3
) 3
# 23- 33 "! 3 2# "$
2)3 ' ( *, %
7 &
<' 2'
0
A
!'
0 '
?
-<' 00
/ - / ' &
>
& &< <
'<
*+ 0
!'
3
0 "1 6I 7!'
"!10 6I77'
3(( % 9 & "
*5.555;+
!
G0 *" )
*45G , 4555@!@$J9.$5.555;+ , $ $ 0
( ,
@
++++ 0 ++++ 0 " 5 0/ 00 .55.555;+ 2
@
!4.555;+
( .*.- 9
7! &
-
# - ' 2 '
0 ?
%'
0
<
<' &< -
&
<
4.555;+
" <
00
/ - 0
. 75G 0
<
< < .
0;!<
'
,
<
0 $8 / -0- - ,
)-.
! ! / $0& 120 / 00 55><
'
&
08.555;+
00
@
0
,.
/"!
,
&
0 ,
:
0 ,
4
< 0
'16& 0 <' ' -
</ & F 0
3 0F . / 0
H3A&
H3A <
4!
+
)7'
--
/ 0
-
0
&< <
*+ 0
)7 '
3
/ 0 "1 6I )! '
"!1 6I) " # 0
&
/
*!5.555;+
!
G0 *45G )
*;)
5
, !555 @!@$J)8.75.555;+ , $ $ 0
( ,
@
++++755 0 ++++.55.555;+ 0 " 5 0/ 00 45.555;+ 2
@
!4.555;+ & 75.4.745;+ 4) , '
0
<
!5.555;+
&
0 2
045G/ <
-
<
75G" <
00 &
08.555;+ !4.555;+<
'
00
@
47 / - 0 - - <'
0
,!# ) 2 #
/ & (() & / &< /
55>
00 .45.555;+ / <
00 / 00 '. 45.555;+
0 0 / 00
<
&
00
44 E 0 0 .
; <:
00
,
/"!
* *
'
- F 0
-
<' &< 0
0
+< &' - - /
-
- - > <' Car bearing registration No.CH04-E-0067
.
-!4'
0 -> ,> ?@ / %/ ."
-
- 75.555;+
&< '
0
'
@ 0
'
!57+!54!.45.555;+00;) <
- / <
;7 , 0 8 <
'
2
/ <
K45G-
< 0
75G 0.55.555;+-
" 0 0 45.555;+ "! ) 0 0/ 00 . 0
078.555;+00 07.585;+ <
-
@
< -
0
0 08.555;+ 00
@
8.555;+00 $ "
'
< 0
<
<' )90 -
958!5$
<' ,
&<
$!
<:
00 ' ,
, , &
0
0
$$0 , . 988 <'
0 / 0 < "#57+?+55$( 0
0< "
+
>
<
$)160 988 !
( & C < ' -
0
/ - 0 - - <'
0 ,,%$
3
/
(( ) '
-
- < /
*+
3
) 1
4 56 "
76
( " 6 ( ' "
' !
1 )
'
"
"
!
! )( '
'"
" !
( )! )!
"
!
'
!)
+
!)( '
4 56 8'"
"
!
+
' ! "(
"
!
( ) )
!
! 9 ( ' )
"
4 56"
76 6
)+
"
"
"
!
' !
! '
4 56"
76 :;
)
" "
"
!
!
! '
4 56"
76 1
0 <' /'" !
'
(
" '!
"
0
+
2'
!
" !" ! ' (
! ()
"
44 "
76 9
" ) " ! '"
"
'
" '(5
"
4& !) ( ! ()
'
/')= ()
"
)=
' "!
+() )
)"
"
=()) ' ) ' ()
/' ) "
"
+
!)(
"
" ' ! ! '
"
44
+
9(' 2' 2')
!
!
+
+ ' ( '(/
"
4:+() !
!'" ! +
"' ( /' $
! ! "
! '
" ( '
!'
'
!! ()
"
+ (
! " ( "
() ' (
)
' ( '
) !
'
!) ( !
)!
1 "
' ( !
"
*>"
76
" ?5 *> % 2' !
" ! " ( )5 ! )
2' !
" < + ) "'
!'( )
5 '
()
' ' = ( '
"
"
)
1
" '(5
:
5 ) ( )
!) ( ' () !
"
" ( ) @/') ) + ' "
'
A! ) )" ) ' ()'"
' "
'(
=
"( )/')) " '(
' ()'"
' "
'(
?$ ) ( 2' 5 ( )
"
+'" 7
' " ! )!
+"
! )
" ' ()
)
"( )/')' ()'
! )
'"
' "
! )!
( ) '
!
,<! 6 +3:
B"3:
"
"+( )/')+)'
! )
5
+ ( "'(
'
"
1!
+
" +(
+ ) ' ( ) 111 1111 11111 111111 1111 11111 1111111 111111 :
'(/
'(5
+ ) " '
"
'(5
+ ) ( ) '
" )
+ '
" !+!
)?5 ' ( +
!' " ( ) ' = (
"! ) )" )+ ! " '
1 '? $ ) ) " '
'
) ! ( ) "
+ !!
) ( "
!!
!
" 6 +
'
( ""
" ""'! " '
!!
!
" 1) " '
)
111 1111 11111 111111 1111 11111 1111111 111111 & ) ) "
!
( "
+' ' )"'
'
( ( !")
"
"
)
" ) ( )
)'
" 4
" :
*>"
76
)"'
' ) ( )
!)( ' ()
'
" " /') ) ' "
'
'"
' "
'(
::
)C
!' /'!
"
0 <' ! " " '+
"
' "
'
!) ! " ( "
0 <'
)"'
6 )
)
" ! '
*> "
76
" " "
'
D'!
' ()
"
1!
" "
"
" '(!! +
"
'
'
2' ( ()
0 <'
"
"
'
"
D'!
()
0 <'
"
!
(
)
" '
! ' ( '
"
44"
76
+ "
( ! /'!
" <'
" '
<!)E %/
' +
+
! !
"
"
"
+
"'
( ()
2' +
! "
'
!)
' '
!
" :
%
)+ <'
"(4(%5
)5
% 5
/ 6$
& +
&1 7 8 2 +
7 1 !
9' :/
"'0,( D'
8
$
)
'
76()) '
"
44"
76 (' GD' <! G 9
', ') ( GD' <! G+ )
"
"
"
) (
" ()
! "'
(
" '
!'
"
'
76 ' ( '
44 "
76+"!'
'
' )
!'
" ! 9
<'
/'!
" <'!!);
#%5
/
+
( " >? G> H )+ '
"
7
6 + 3BB+
" "
G
7 6 G
! ' ( )'
!' !
()
! +
"!
('
"
9(' .
'
! ! ! !
+
9(' !)'
9
) !( 55 ' ( G/'G
! + )+ ' (
()+ " "' '/'"( "!
9 ' (
() "
"
76
44 " ! ' "
"+ ( ) /')+ '"
' "!
+ ! ) )" )+( +
' ( ! ()
'
/')= ( ()
"
)=
' "!
+ () ) "
"
= () ) ' ) ' ()
/' ) "
"
+
!)(
'(5
+
"
(
/
! ( !
"
! 9
!"
'(5
*
G
< !9(' ) "
" ' '(5
4 "
&B " ! ' 6 G 0
+
< !9('
" "
!
' '
! !
" !' !
G :* 9
6'
<!) E! '
+ :;;3 : << *>+
+
"
+
+ )
'
4 56
44 ' ( ( :& '( )+
44 "
76 GD' <! G
"
" ! ! '
44 "
76+ ' ) ' ( "! GD'<! G
!( ! ' ' ) "
)+
76( "
" " +
' ') (' GD' <! G
"
"
) (
" ()
! 0
+
! ' (
! "
'
)
"
*>"
76 ' ( (
"
+ )! ""
2' (
()
0 <' - (!
'-
< "#57+?+55$( 0 0,&
"490 8
!54
'
0 55;+ - 0
'
/ 0 -
+ / < /
<' ,&+4
,&+4 0 '
0
0 55;+ 0
0 -
+ /
!.55.555;+ & /
0
< /
<' 7(0 988
<'
,,
!
/ - <
0 0 !.55.555;+ 0 8 A' -' 0
- ' / <
-
07.!$.955;+- K$G
0 00 0
L 9 / -0</ .
-
<',& ",%;!550!54 0
@
-<
0
0 !.55.555;+ - K!G
0 00 0
L 5 / -0</ .
< <$5 97& ' -
0 -
<' &<
<
9G
! "
'
<
0
0 L ' '
< 00 9
)
%
.0 '.
00
7 % '0
<
0
4!
! 7 ((
!
# $/ !5 E
> ;
* M ;" E
< * M ;" !5