National Insurance Company v. Kirpal Kaur And ORS
! "#$
&''
% () *'
*
!"# $ %
& !"# "$
# "# $ '( ) *''++*', # $ -, . # +,*/+*'/ 0000 +
' %
$ ! . */'++*'-
1
" " !!
$ ! + 3*4*'+*')-'-" 5! ! 2 ! 6 7%(8 . !! . 9 $" # 1 " . $ $ "" ' $ #! 1 ! ! :%*;%%-;+/ 6 $$! # 8
!!
1 $ 5! !6 8". # <
( 3''*'+*')"9 *4 +/4"((/"((;)+/
. ! $
2 !6 7%(8"%.
) 2..
$ $ ',, $ " '4;; 1$ " ! $ $ '-"**"***=% 6 9$ 8 ! . $ $
$ >" !
. . ! # . = :
"9 ". ! '*"***=% 2 $ $ # - ' 6 #
%. 8 $ .
. #!
?. !
# . . .$. "<
1 $
.
! ?
1" . . 1! #
!! $ 1 .
" !
! $ !" .$ $.
<
?
1
$!! #!$ . # 1$ ?$
#
+"
$# " 1$ ! $
$ , +$ .
#
1$$ $
. ' 9
" # . 1! # 1 . #$ $
. #$$ # 2
.$ $ $ $
7$ # "
$
$ / : !
$ " 2 $ $.!
%
1. Whether deceased Jagir Singh son of Mohinder Singh died in a Motor Vehicle accident caused by respondent No.1 while driving motor cycle bearing No. PB-08-CL-5827 on 9.1.2014 in rashly and negligently?OPP 2- Whether the claimant(s) are legal representative of the deceased entitled for compensation, if so to what extent?OPP 3- Whether the claim petition is maintainable?OPP 4- Whether the claim petition is bad for mis-joinder and non-joinder of necessary party?OPP 5- Whether the respondent No.1 was not holding a valid and effective driving licence at the time of alleged accident?OPR 6- Whether vehicle in question was being driven without any driving licence and RC? OPR
7. Relief.
; $ !# 1 # "2 '6 #
%. 8 1$
!
. #! $$! # !! ". 5! !
$$ !
#
<
1 <
"
. $ ;
!
! "#$
'# $$ # #! $
6
8 < # 1 !#
$
" #!
#$$ #
4 !!
#1 $2 $. "
$ '* " ) 6 #
%. 8 . #
,
*''+', '' # $ #
%1 '+ $
' $
22
! $ ' #$$!# .
$
! #$$ # 1
# " ' . #!
.
$
#$ $
ABC$ . $
" . 1 $
! $$ # ## # $ D $ ($ "'4;4" . # $
1
1
!$$ # #
!$ E@ $
$ $$B$
$ # " '" # .. #!# $ 1 $ $ #. $"$!
$ $.B ! 1 !
%
1.! '(2 $ % $$!
$ 2
!" 1 # $ . !6
8" # $. ' $$ # #! " $ #$ $
!"
')2D 1$
.
1!# ! F '- + 6'48 $ " '4;; $ B % G+H$
% 6'48G I
1 !
$ # " # # $ $
JI ',2 ! !
. !6
8 # "'4;; $ 9 $7%'6 1< 8"<
H23$$ "5 " ' ! . $
1 ! 1 :%*;%%-;+/$$ # #$ '-'*'(')*)') ! ' # .! ! # % ABC
#
! $$ # ## #
$ D $ ($ "'4;4 '/? ". 1 #! ! ($ "'4;4 ( B
G& K2 # $
1% 6'8$ (
. #!
!!B #!. 1< $ ! $$ $ #" ! K 68
$$$ # L
9 ( ## J
618
1
!$$ # #! ##
!
# J 8 "$ #
$$B $ " MM . 1 !
K )
K2!# 1
';
MM 1
'*
!"+
4
.1
#
". #!
!!B #! 6. . % 8"
B $
$
618I '; 2
$ ( $ '4;4
. B # # $
$ !7 ! # # " $
1
1
$$ # #! #
# $
(618
1 ! # $
2
$ !
$$ 1 $
! 2
"
! "$
1
.
(618$'4;4 . 1!# .< !$B
. ! 6
8". . .#
1 #1
1< 1
. '4 ' ! . $$$!# ' 7%' 1< #
-
' ! . $ $$! # '. ! 7%+$
" .$ . . !! . ? .$. ! ?.# " # $$ 11 ! !$ E@$ $ $# # :
$ . # !$E@
? $ !
? $ B 1
1! 1 #
1 $ !2
"# 11
' .$
. #!
1 1 #! ( $ " '4;4 .
1
1
#!# 2
ABC $ 9
"
$ AB %). . $$
# . ## .
$
2# # $ 1 '.
# .
1
$
"
" .$ 1 $
AB%) +*
1 $
68
1# %%# 2 $ $
')46+8$ "
# 2
1?@1B
. ! 6
8 1$
$
.
$#
$
$ .$ 1 $ $ "
+' ' ! $
1 $
? #!
"
. # $
?.# " $ 1
12 . 1 $
!
!! #!$$$!# ' 2 $ " $ $!
#
! ++ . ! 6
8". E#.
1 #1 $
!
! !!$# 1 # D $ #
! # "
. 1.# 1.
1 1 $ = $ $ #
$
22 ! . E
$
@ $E$ 1 @ .$ #1
')46+8$ 2 1# $ ! $ . # .$ 1 $
$ 1 ' #
. $ $$!# 1$ ! $
1 2
1 ($ " '4;4$ $ #!. $1
+( 9
1#" 2
!! !# $.$ 1 $
&
$ 1
1!#! ! %
2 $ %
.B%
!# ! $ "$1
"$ . %
1 %
$ .
$# $ $
$ . $ '%. %
+) .
! +-
!" .1# .
+,
"$" $
! "#$
&/0 #1 !2 3+
7 !=
N = 7 1
N =