High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3266/2010dismissed

Sanjogita And ORS v. Dharamchand And ORS

2015-09-24Mr. Justice M.S. Sullar3 pages

!""#$%$&'"(!")*"+,-.

)! &/0$! !1"+% (("22 &!% 3"+%4% 1 + )1 &5 !1"+% "%(&5"&!% !"#$%&' ()%)(*$+&',-% 61"!1"+ "(+!"+%2# 2( ("+%) 7*" 228"5!%""!1"/450)"&!9 *"+""++"5!!1" "(+!"+%+&!9 61"!1"+!1"/450)"&!%1425*"+"(+!"5$&!1"$0"%!9

+"%"&!'

+( 21 +) -5:# !"- +!1" (("22 &!% &"+!1"+"%(&5"&!% ;;;;; )(*$+&

1"#1 22"&0"$&!1"(+"%"&! "042 +"#&5((" 2$%!!1"

/450)"&! &55"#+""!1"<8"+(("22 !"4+!-81"+"*7!1"/450)"&! &55"#+""!1"!+$ 24+!5"#+""$&0!1"%4$!!1" (("22 &!=(2 $&!$%- 1 %*""&%"!= %$5"

+( 21 +) -2" +&"5#4&%"2 ((" +$&0&*"1 2!1" (("22 &!=(2 $&!$%%4*)$!%!1 !!1"(2 $&!$% +"&&""2%"-*4!!1"8$58 &5)$&+5 401!"+% +$!1:$$&011"#2 $)$&!1"%4$!8 %-:$%= =:$% >,!1%1 +"$&!1"(+("+!7)" %4+$&0?@ & 2%) +2 % &5 %8"22 % #1 22"&0" ! !1" /450)"&! &5 5"#+"" 5 !"5 .?? %4"+"5 *7

)#1 &5- !1"+ +$!1:$ $&01 $& :4+ !8%&% " 4+!1"+

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

!1"#1 + #!"+ &5& !4+"!1"(+("+!7 % &#"%!+ 2-5&!$&!"&5!5$"+ 8$!1!1"$&5$&0%+"&5"+"5*7!1"<8"+(("22 !"4+!-81"+"*7!1"%4$! 1 %*""&5$%)$%%"5-)4#12"%%-5&!$&5 &7$22"0 2$!7 &5("+:"+%$!7$& !1"$&5$&0%%4*%! &!$ 2E4"%!$&2 8 +$%"%+5"!"+)$& !$&*7!1$% 4+! 1" ((" 2$% ##+5$&0275$%)$%%"5 ./01+2 )(*$

/34 &',-%