← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3384/2010dismissed

Avtar Singh v. Mahesh Kumar

2025-08-18Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain7 pages

   



     

   

   

  !!""

 #$#  # %$&

 #!    

 





 '

  (!

) *

!!""

  $, "*

#! ----



! "# $%

. + # $"

# ". !"

+++" #$  #/   +  !#### ,0 1 0 + #!+ !  ,0

#""

2 3

4$ "

& #$  / "# #

$    +  #! !"  #+ ++*+

 #""

"

 #+ $ ,05$ 

#""

2 3

  "$ ,"#

+# *3

6! . +  #*

6 # 

 &0   !

#

   "  5$     ,+



  .  !"

++ "

&#  !! 

 +++$,#

+ &



& 

!&7* 1 *"

&#

+ + $! 5$ # " #+ $ . !"

++  #!

#&

/,01 0+

++  # " " 



$  #$#"

+ "" & 5$ # " ,+ 3

#!

++*  !

+++$,#

# 

* 1 * +

 +  $!  .  !"

++ "

&#

 

 0 1"" ! & #!

$ $ . !

#$ ##  

  .  #$  1 #   ,0  +   # !  + * !"

++ #  &&##    .  +  ,

1 &$  + #

6+ & ++ & +9$*

 : ;! & . !"

++ #$  # &$ #/ #  ,"

/ #

&! !

# # !  + *

 #"" 1 #  5$ ,0 &  # #,"

/#

&!!

##,0 &*1   ,&#$#,0 +++ 5$ +

#"". +

# & &"

&#

+&0*1   #/

 ,"

/ #

&! !

#* & 1   ,0 ++  # #. + "# !

+

&0+#*

6  . #$ +",0 ++1 #!$ $!

"+ + +""1##$#

<  ++# " #!+!  +



2 3

= '' <  ++ # 0  1""  ! & #





2 3

= ''  >+##$? # !

*1  ++# "

"

 "+= ''  <  # &

,"= '

 <  #   $# +   +" #$ = ' 3 "+ >   !

 5$

 #""* 5 & ,

 1 ###  &"0    #  # '<   

@  #'<  #1 ##$?  *

+ # #

+$

5$ +

#""#

#!

,0 &0+  #  

@ . + + "  0 !

 #++,"

/#

&!!

,&#$#+



#""< " +1 #! ## 1""##+

++*

"@$

+$

!

#+ ++#

#!

 ,0 ++  #A5'  A5'B " 

A5'# 

, # +!"

++ ""$! & 5$ # "  "# #

# !

  .  & ) &$  $  + 

" # " #

# !

 #

&0

&+5$ +# " #$ " &$ +#

61 ,!

,0 ++. ## 1#

++ #!  0  1""  ! & # !

 . @$

 "0  +",0

 && 

"++  +#!+!  3 .   +# #

 ++ & ,0  B1  !!""

@$

" 2 ##

#+1 )$&  !

##,0

,"1*+ #,+

$"

# "

  

) #

1

 +

$   +& *1   # #$     

 



 



  

     



     

    

 









    







    



 

 

    



  





      

 

    





 !    

 





"#$!

  

  $



  

 $  

 



% 

 



    

&' (

 !  



)    

 ) 



 

    



     

 

       





  

  

        

 





     +, 

-./      

 

 





 !   





   

  



     



     0          

 !

  





 !  $   



 



  









 

  

    



 

  $   







   





 

  

1 





.#.



 

 

 



     







 





 2

8   

)  #$,&

 ,

 ! $# " +

 #"" A5'  1$" # 1

 ,"

/ #

&! !

# , $ "C  

 #"" !

!$ ,0 ++  7 #$,&

 1

#!+ &0 +  +

 !"

++ ,  &&##

 *1 " &$ +#

6 .  # ## 5 &

   #!   A #$#  #   , !$ + 4$ # &. $#* #

+ #

# &

,0 !"

++

' 

* , "*

! #$ +!" ,0

7#$,&

+$"! $# "+ +!" ,0 +  "#

  &#"+ &

,"

/#

&!!

#,0 +

& +  " "  + #

6 1  #

0 ,0 !"

++ #!

#7+$

+ #

& 1   # ##

#

#"" #$,&

#1 #! +!" . , $

,0 # #$!!

,0 !" #7#$,&

 "0*

#,"1 "0  +",0

+ !

 #+7+$

#$,&

 ,

$"

# "* !!



+#,0 #! + @$

  +# + +  ,0  @$

# ,"1    , # ,

>  

"

$#"+ !

# 

$ 

1  ," ###



 >   #$   #$  +" #/   + #!+ +

#""* ++# 4$ !"  !



  " 5$

 #""  !

0&  + 

&0D

 # $$# ## 1""## ! & #!

#""

 >  !

  #* ++    !

 5$

#"" !

0& +

&0*5 &,

 1 ###

#""E

1 ### !



#""1 ##,0+  !

# !

+

&0+#*

6> "##

#!

 

" "  

A5'1 ## 

, # 

 ,0  +   .  # &  $ #!  > # !+

*+  &#"+1

# 1 #! 

0 + # #

 . $   "

&

 !"

++ !

$  # # ,"

/ #

&! !

# 1 " " & "  ,$   & ,

* 

&

 ,"

/ #

&! !

# 1  #

0 ,0 ++  # #.& / #1 #1 "

 1 ##,5+  ##

#

#""A5' . + 

, 

1#

#

&!!

#1  

#""A5' #, 5$ *# 1  1 ##,0 

 *

&   "" +#

6+ & ++ . $   "

&#  # &0

 #

# 

#""

  ##

#* 1 *1 #",0 &

!

 # &. $#* +!" ,0 + "" +"

*

#,"1 "0#," # &

 F$ ##$+ ## 1""### * #

 , !  $

 $  + 

" # " #

 + #*8

6*

#*

6 1  !



& + 5$

 #"" 

2 3









*!"

++!

 #!

# ,+  ++ + $, #

  A5'  <  8  0#* " "   

A5'1 ## $! "" &

,+ $,#

3

 5$

#""

3

*!"

++!



  !

,+ $,#

7#!

##&#

 ++  A5'. !

#$ 1 #+"  

  1    0# +  # + $"

 &&

 ,0 + >1 +*

+#

,

#,"1

"0 +$

++ 1 0  1""  ! & # !

$ $

 G& * !

"#

##&##

  "





% #  

  <  #! /6 #= H#6? <  !

,"= H#6?