High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6107/2014dismissed

Dharampreet Kaur v. Mohinder Kaur

2015-02-198 pages

!""#$%$&'() * + ,-+""!. /+ --"00 &! 1"+%/%

*$&2"+. /+ "%-&2"&!

+.3$&40 526# !"+!*" --"00 &!

! *$% --" 0* %7""&$0"278!*" --"00 &! 4 $&%!!*" 9/24,"&!2 !"2(:;- %%"278!*"22$!$& 0$6$0/24" 3"&$+ $6$%$&5.* && <*"+"78!*"-"!$!$&$0"278*"+/&2"+3"#!$&) !*"/ +2$ & &2= +2%#!5:( $&%*+!>!*"#!?+#/%!28!*"

,$&+%&5& ,"085 % &-+""!3$&4*5< %2$%,$%%"2 "< #!%&"#"%% +8+ 29/2$# !$&!*"$&%! &! --" 0 %& ++ !"2!*"+"$&, 87"&!$#"2 *" --"00 &!$%,!*"+ &2!*" +"%-&2"&!$%4+ &2,!*"+!*",$&+*"*/%7 &2!*" --"00 &! * 22$"2&; &2%*"< %!/+&"2/!!*", !+$,&$ 0*," & (; *" #/%!28 !*" ,$&+ < % +"! $&"2 78 !*" +"%-&2"&!*" --"00 &!< %@/ 0$$"2* 6$&42$-0, + 7* A + &2%!/2$"2/-!<*"+" %!*"+"%-&2"&!< % &$00$!"+ !"<, & *" --"00 &!7"$&4!*",!*"+ &24/ +2$ &!*",$&+< %"&!$!0"2! *$%#/%!28 3*", 2"+"-" !"2+"@/"%!%!!*"+"%-&2"&!!* &2

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

- +!$"%5!*"!+$ 0#/+!+ ,"2!*"00<$&4$%%/"%'B =*"!*"+-"!$!$&"+$%"&!$!0"2!!*"#/%!28 % &-+""!3$&4*+,!*"+"%-&2"&!C =*"!*"+-+"%"&!-"!$!$&$%&!, $&! $& 70"$& !*"-+"%"&!+,C

;

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

" 4$6$&46$%$! !$&+$4*!%!!*" --"00 &!"&#"5!*"-+"%"&! --" 0 ) E" +&"2 #/&%"0 + !*" --"00 &! %/7,$!!"2 !* ! !*" --"00 &!7"$&4!*",!*"+!*",$&+* 2"6"+8+$4*!!#0 $,*$% #/%!28!< %/+!*"+%/7,$!!"2!* !!*"/!/+"!*",$&+< %2 +A$& !*"* &2%!*"+"%-&2"&! %%*"< % &$00$!"+ !"0 28!< %/+4"2 !* !!*" --"00 &!$% &"2/# !"20 28* 6$&47"!!"+"#&,$#-%$!$&5 # - #$!8 &2 #,-"!"&#8 ! " +& ! < % 0% #&!"&2"2 !* ! !*" 00"4"2 4+"","&!* 2&6 0/"$&!*""8"%0 < %!*"*/%7 &2!*" --"00 &!* 2"D-$+"2&;<*"+" %!*" 00"4"2 4+"","&! < %"D"#/!"2&(; &2 !!* !!$,"%*"< %&!$& $!%! !" ,$&2 !"+*" +$&40" +&"2#/&%"0+!*" --"00 &!5<"2&! $&2 &8,"+$!$&!*" --" 0 *"-"D/+!$& #$%&'($)$)*(&+,-$..$

/0 /(*(.0 "2$%#/%%$&4!*"$%%/"+"0 !$&4!#/%!28,$&+#*$02 * 2*"02 %/&2"+'B >

+, !*" 76" $! 00<% !* ! & +2"+ #/%!28,$&+#*$02+"&"$!*"+/&2"+!*"-+6$%$&% *" / +2$ &% &2 = +2% #!5 :( + $&2/

$&+$!8 &2/ +2$ &%*$-#!5()$%+"@/$+"2!7" , 2"78!*"/+!!+" !$&4!*"$&!"+"%! &2<"0 +" !*",$&+!7"- + ,/&!$,-+! &#"!$%&!!*" 7"!!"++$4*!!*""$!*"+- +"&!!* !</02+"@/$+" 29/2$# !$& <*$0" 2"#$2$&4 !*"$+ "&!$!0","&! ! #/%!28 *" 2"%$+" !*" #*$02 #/-0"2 <$!* !*" 6 $0 7$0$!8 #&2/#$6" &2 --+-+$ !" "&6$+&,"&!+-+-"+/-7+$&4$&4!4"!*"+<$!*!*"

7$0$!8 &2," &%!*"#&#"+&"2- +"&!!! A" # +"!*"#*$02 +"%,"!*"+"0"6 &! #!+%!* ! * 6"! 7"! A"& $&! ##/&! 78!*" /+!<*$0" 2"#$2$&4!*"$%%/"#/%!28 ,$&+=* !,/%! 7" ",-* %$F"2 $% !* ! <*$0" 00 !*"+ #!+% +" /&2/7!"208 +"0"6 &!5 $! $% !*" 2"%$+"5 $&!"+"%! &2 <"0 +"!*",$&+<*$#*$%!*"#+/#$ 0 &2/0!$, !" #&%$2"+ !$& !* ! ,/%! 4/$2" !*" 2"!"+,$& !$& +"@/$+"2!7", 2"78!*"/+!?

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

=; +& $03$&4** 2&08%! !"2!* !!*",$&+< %!*"&08#*$02 !*" --"00 &! &2*$%#/%!287"* &2"26"+!*"+6"&!*" % &23%-+6"2&+"#+278!*" --"00 &!<*$#*+"0 !"2!!*"8" +%

1 )!:<"+"&!%/$#$"&!+/-7+$&4$&4!*"#*$02&*"+#+%%B "D ,$& !$&5!*" --"00 &!%! "2!* !%*"* 2&!-"&"2 &8!/$!$& #"&!+"7/!! A"%!/$!$& !*"+*,"3*"* 2&$,,6 70"-+-"+!8$& !*"6$00 4"+ &8<*"+""0%"0!*/4*5!*" --"00 &!* 2#* 00"&4"2!*" 00"4"2 4+"","&!2 !"2(;7/!!*"+"%-&2"&!* 2-+6"2!*" % ,"780" 2$&4%/$#$"&! &2+"0$ 70""6$2"&#"2,$!!"2085!*"#*$02 < %# 00"278!*"!+$ 0/24"$&*$%#* ,7"+&;!A&< 7/! *$%<$%*<*"!*"+*"< &!"2!4<$!**$%,!*"+5!*"#*$02<** 2 !! $&"2!*" 4"G;8" +%+"-0$"2$&!*"&"4 !$6"*"#*$02< % * --8$&!*"#,- &8!*"+"%-&2"&! &2* 27""&2$&4<"00$&!*" %#*0"< %/&2!7"<"002+"%%"25<"007"* 6"2 &2$&!"00$4"&! %<"00 /+!*"+5&#$+#/,%! &#"%<"+", 2"/!!2$%-0 #"!

*"#*$02 +,!*"#/%!28!*"+"%-&2"&!"%-"#$ 0085<*"&!*",$&+$%$&*"+ #/%!285! A$&4"2/# !$& &2!*"+"$%&-+ &8#+/"0!+" !,"&!! *$,78!*"+"%-&2"&!&!*" #!% &2#$+#/,%! &#"%!*"# %"5!*" !+$ 0#/+!+$4*!08*"02!* !!*"#/%!28!*",$&+<$!*!*"+"%-&2"&! < %$&!*"$&!"+"%!!*",$&+<"6"+56$%$! $&+$4*!%<"+"4$6"&! !*",!*"+B --"00 &!*"+"0"6 &!$&2$&4%+"#+2"278!*"!+$ 0#/+! +" 2!*/%'B >( &!*"-+"%"&!# %"50" +&"2#/&%"0+ -"!$!$&"+ * % ",-* %$F"2 , $&08 & !*" #! !* !

*$&2"+ . /+ +"%-&2"&! * % & -+-"+!8 $& *"+ & ," &2!* !&08-+-"+!8/&2"+!*"##/- !$& *"+*/%7 &2$%- &#* 8 !$/!5!*"+"$%&!"6"& & $! "6$2"&#" ! %*< !* ! -"!$!$&"+ " +&% %/$#$"&!"D#"-!%"0B%"+6$&4%! !","&!-"!$!$&"+

"!$!$&"+ * % "D ,$&"2 !< <$!&"%%"% +, *"+

0# 0$!85 <* 0% * 6" %! !"2 +"4 +2$&4 !*" ,$&+ 7"$&4 &08#*$02 -"!$!$&"+ &2 !* ! *$% #/%!28 %*/027"* &2"26"+!*"+ "!$!$&"+%! !"2!* !

%*"$%* 6$&4 %55GB --+D$, !"08<*$#*%*"

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

+8+$4*!# &&!7"4$6"& /-78 & 4+"","&!57/! !!*"% ,"!$,"5$!* % 0% 7""&%"!!0"2780 <!* ! #*$02# &&!7"/-+!"2 +, *," *$% /-7+$&4$&4 !*" ,$&+ $% 02 "&/4*!+, &$&!"00$4"&!-+""+"&#"5!*"/+! , 8#&%$2"+!* !-+""+"&#" 6$&4+"4 +2!!*" #,-0"D$!$"%!*"%$!/ !$&$&<*$#*!*$%/+!* % 7""& # 00"2 /-& ! 7 0 &#" !*" ",!

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

A"#/%!28 %* &-+""! 3$&4* &2"+ !*"%" #$+#/,%! &#"%5 , !*" #&%$2"+"26$"<!* !$&!"+"%!!*"#*$02<$007"7"%! %"+6"2$*"+", $&%<$!*!*"+"%-&2"&!57/!<$!* %/$#$"&! ##"%%!!*"-"!$!$&"+!6$%$!!*",$&+ ! +"@/"&!$&!"+6 0%7/!% %&!!2$%!/+7 &22$%+/-! *$%&+, 0%!/2$"% &2!*"+ #!$6$!$"%?

E" +&"2#/&%"0+!*" --"00 &!* %&!7""& 70"! 2$%-"0 !*" $&2$&4% +"#+2"2 78 !*" !+$ 0 #/+! <*$#* +" 7 %"2 & --+"#$ !$&"6$2"&#"-+2/#"2&+"#+2="2&!$&2 &8+" %& !2$"+<$!*!*"$&2$&4%+"#+2"278!*"!+$ 0#/+! &6$"<!*" 76" &2!*"$&2$&4%+"#+2"278!*"!+$ 0

2 #/+!5&4+/&2$%, 2"/!+* &2$&46"+!*"#/%!28!*",$&+ !!*" --"00 &! ##+2$&4085!*" --" 07"$&42"6$2 &8,"+$!$% *"+"782$%,$%%"2 *"+"$% 2"0 8:2 8%$&$0$&4!*" --" 0 (B* %7""&$0"2+#&2& !$&:2 8%H2"0 8$& $0$&4!*" --" 03$&#"!*" --" 0* %7""&2$%,$%%"2&,"+$!%5& /+!*"+ +2"+% +" +"@/$+"2 ! 7" - %%"2 $& !*" --0$# !$& + #&2& !$&2"0 8$&$0$&4!*" --" 0 &2!*"% ,"$%2$%-%"2 % %/#* /

0 3# +4'5$'% 6! 1 / 0 47% 3#