High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/940/2013allowed

Roma Chhabra @ Roma Rani & ORS v. Ram Kumar & ORS

2016-11-18Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj9 pages

!!"" $#%#

&% #

!"#$%&'() $'&)$*&+(

# ' ( ) ("

* +, - !!"" # ( . ) /* +, -#! 0 ',-.-*,/0% # !!" 1 ," # #2 / , ,!#

1( ,,

" # %"*%/ 4" - #5 %"67- - 2#&% !" 4" - #5 67 + ,",,

08 98 :899

%,2 //

;<=;;>?>94" - #5 --

/+ ,"67 : # "1 ##% +"+ # !!" # #2 , -,!#

-, #- ,# /#2 !!

- #2-+

1 0 %" ""3 ,!#

- @*9A*888B; ," #*3 ,3#,!%

#-""3#';

7 -

2# &% !"

7 / -

- ,,

0?1#

7 ,- <:88! +7 %" ! ,1 - ," #

, - <:88B; ! <:88C9:7D @8<88!% 4+7 9B0 - 4 +7 +

3 !#"C!## @8<88;9=>887D 00=88 4+ 7 % ! ,1 - !!"1 %"

-9@ 00=88E9@7D @8<888 4+

7 F##-,#

% @888 4+

7 !#

3 #!

# 98888 1

< F ,%#" - !!"" # # /% 3##!2! 3#,1 /%# ## %"#

2 ,#<:88B;! *3 , #"3#

, - "* 3 , ,"%

1 1 #-3

###*," #+!+ +,

- )"" #! 2!# %#%""1 /%" ,,% 2# , -3/#-"!#!"1 1 3##- %" / " # 3"" # ,% 1 +

, /

- +1"" #

,%"

# "1 2#=888B;! #-% /%

," # "#

, -

3 #-% #* G% ,!#

-"##-,#

3 -*"##-"+ --,

, /%

,- , -

"# :@888B; 3 #-%"C!##

@ F ,%#"-#! 0;#%,!1# /% %" # / "1 #### , - 2!

+ 3 ! , C !+ / "+

* # #%,*

##,!-, % -,!#

##,

/ -

3 -% ##- "/,-!C% ,# -

!"#

$$*##%,*,!#

##,,""3 =

# "1* 2 ! , - * 3 ,3#,

# - &%*

"1- ,,

- ,

/ #!-

* 3#,,# - ,!" 2 -"# # /

/ +,

H "!! /# H;9*3 -- ##

%# 3# % / # 2*,%"

*/ -33#+ ,-08*888B;! 3#"#2!

/"!*"1* &%* 3 !1 /@>88B;! ##"1 &%!! # H;: ##

3#32 /#"!3

3#/

@>88B;! ##"1 H;0".

&%#"##

#!- 2#&% !"*3 &%3#32 /# "! %# / H;@/#) /##

3# /:@*888B;! - #%# ##

H;= %" # "# #

3# !%,# / / - #! - H;9 # "# !", ,

1 1 /

/ #%# ## #,

? &!

+ 3 "" + -, #*

# !+

3# % / #! %"

1 - 3

### /

, - % # -, !+ 3#% /#!*##%,* ,%"

2 # %#2 ""

"1 3/ #* #, - 1

,% 1+

,* ##### #=888B;! > ! -/ --% #" ,%#"- #! 0#/%

/- !C% -, % !

# A H " 2 / -, "/ , % !

# ##%-/ -

, 3 # -% % !#!,

-- /3

+ 3 2 ,#- & ' !

"# $

6" ,-!C% #+ #-""3#'; I ! "#$ # # # % & &'

(' "#'

' "

%### % #%

) !#* '

"#" # %# ## % # !! ) !# # ! + # # $% ,#" # $ # ' #$# " %% ' ! ' %# -

. 98 ,# - ( ) ( )* +

, !"#

- % /# , - J" !C % # #+ !99 9:#-""3#'; I

/ (' '.

0#'%1 ' %% # # %### & .

0#'%1 %%"# # % %## ) !# # # # #!'%## +#2 #$ !3 # # % %## ) !# # # $ # " # '# "

+ '

# %'

! '

'%#% # ## # ' #'

%! )

" +#

# # !!'% .

3 & .

0#'%1 #"#

# # "$ .

# # "

4$!! #

# # % ) !# # ! #'%' $

" &'# 5' " %$

.+ # $ #" / #6$$ 3#'(7

18/((

! !'% .

8 # # # %# &'#

5' " #" # "

K 99

-,3# "/,-J"!C%

,#- !

#8: 8? :89< .% /

9@ 8@ :89@ ,# / 0 & 1

!,# ( ( !

# --2 % /# ,- J"!C% ""3 -% ,#-#"-;!"1 !##-""3 #+

# ,#-( ) !

# 9: ,,!

- -% % !#!, # + #/# ,,# !! %

# - #%,,## -% !/## "

- 3 , # " ,%#-+ -+1% +"+ 1+,

+ -* 2!

+ 3 #

1*,!,

1 , *1 !#

# "

-* # #!, .%#

- / -

*3 , J -"

1 J 3 ,3"" + / 2 # ,- " #

-,23"

, /,/#+ ,# -"

% /"# 3 , %

,# C!##- "B"%,/#B/ -!## !-## *3

,#G%

" ,# , 3/#- "1 3/# + "# 3

## %!3 % # ! ,%#- / ,# ,# -"

+ / ! ,#-/,1

"1 + "# ,# -"

! # - + ,

+"# -, ##

% -,!#

#G% .%# #"2!

1 + 3* 3 ! ,#- # ,

#-"

2"1 ,#-%

9 90 #,# 3#%# -," 9*- - ," : !# # ,!,

1 # %# * - # !-#+ %# %

#- - "1*3 ,"#.%#

-1 / -

3 # # "1 , "2#- /#"" - "1-- #"

22,,% #*F ,,

*!1 -", ,

1 3 ""#* - - #," ,""/ / / , * ,*

," "

,-- "1 , )+ ,# 1 "#,1 +"% # # # #+ ,# 1 %#;3 - #!, 3 ,- / -

-@8L

3 # -% % !#!, # # .%#

* # #%,* ," # ""3 @8L

3 #-% # 9< " 9 # 3 - - "## - ,#

%* %" ""3 ,!#

- @888B;* 3 , , 9", + 3- #+

#-!C% ( ) % !

# " :* / , * # "#

,!#

-9", 3 #"##-"+ --,

, /%

, % - ,!#

""3 3 # -%" C!## #"#, -98*888B; :@*888B; 9@ + 3 - +* % - ,!#

3 , ," #

* ##### #-""3#';

7 /- 0?1#

7 ,- =888!

7 @8L - 4

3 # -% % !#!, =888M08887D A888! +7 9B0 - 4

# !#" C!##- 4A888;08887D =888!

4+7 % - ! ,1 - !!"1 %"

-9@ 4=888E9:E9@7D 98>8888!% 4+ 7 F##-,#

%-3 - 988888 4+

7 F## - "+ --,

- , 988888 4+

%"C!## :@888 908@888 9= ##G%"-1

#,%## +* #!!"#

# # ,,!

3 %" #

,!#

""3 ," #- - 2#&% !"

# , - @*9A*888B; 90*8@*888B; , % ,!#

3 "",1 # ? @L!%- -- - ," !

"" , %" "

#! 0;#%, !1 #%- --

/+ ,"3 "" !#

, % -,!#

2,,% -," 9!1 #

%/ - 9? #-," ;!!"" :*3 # *3 ""

N 2 # - !#

"" !

# .

1 #* 3+* ," 2 1 2

,% #/

//- #G%

- !#

- % #"" #2 /-# - %" / !1 - % !#

#- -

/ .

1 +

# ##% #+ ," - %,##1 ## ,%# %

#* 2 %#%""1 / + - %" / !1 +-

/-.

1 " 9;

* %" /%

- ," #""

# #- !#

2* "1*G% "1* "-1"1%"# #*#!,+ , C!##- %/ %! 234-

'&)$*&+( .2 %&*$ : #%!,# ;#, : % " ;#,