← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/6124/2014allowed

Raj Wati And ORS v. Suresh Kumar And ORS

2018-10-16Mr. Justice B.S. Walia9 pages



        

  



 !  "#$  & ''

 ) &*  

  "

'         +&

 &,-(.%/0

&  && '  &"12%34/0

&& ' 5 666  

   

& & & 3   ''( / 3 ((,  (7 87&

(9 (  *4#

((#*

   

& & & 3   ''( / 3 ((,  (7 587(

(9 (  *4#

((#*

  (3  (  &

,& 47 ( &  &

(3;&4*(/<3*9& =9%&% 

&&

&& > ;&4*(?

2(%,&/%*4   5/3 &0 % *(&

@

-:2:-  ;% ;&4*(47 .9 

9



@A 7 &/ 47 9

  (4*& & 

 %     @ '

&3 %/

&473'9 * 5& 

,&%'

&( 47''(793*( '( > ? 4  47 ,&9  *3   @/ ,& ( 

*3/ *   ( 

/ ,&  

 @/8/ (9, %

B @C'

&*3 &3



 *  (3'

((

*(& (D  5 & ( &  % & *& ( *43 %(( 9  ,&

.

,& 0D % *

 0  ,  3  B 

%   

,& % '

&(

/,%  3 %4

3 B5& 

 -

(7/  3*  % 4

 ,& ,& * '&'

;%&(7/ ,& * 0 (%   F*

 E (7/  

 47  ;&4*(   3* '74(  (, &

 +  &/ ( & ( & & '  5 



%  ;&4*( % &9% (7 

( (3 '

  &

'&



&4 9  %(( 9 %094

 3   &

 4  

 47 ;&4*( , #*   ''&'&

 G / %, &/ %   '*

,& * '&'

(,& ''&'&

* 0 (% B ,&

-:3:- ( *3 % 4 @/ ,&(

@/ ,& * @

%0  *43 ( & ( & '&  ;% ;&4*( ,&7 '&

4 9 

( (3'

 &4 %( ;%    %(( 9  F*  &    ( ;%

& /  *

3 B5& 

,&%'

&( %09(

4 % %&

 

&3 '&9&'%5

  -&( ) &3 0  (% ;&'&  &'&    8-/  (( &7

"

0 &

 ( *&

3'7E 0 &*+&7-

%  &/  ""0(8/& '&*

* H5;%*9%3 *

4 3 ,& &((09  ( *(

 4 * 

 ;&(.%&/ 9 &( '&

   ''(7

& *

 G09



*4 F*

  % *& / ,  &  0 , % ,%

 , 3&& / *

,& &((09   

/%*(4  

%&   5& ,%  *34 &   3(7 &    5/ 

*& % 

% ,%  *34 &   3(7 3 &   /  

% @ % ,% *34  3(73 &

:

-:4:- -

  % /

 , 3'(7  

,

 9  @7 &/

&9(7/@C

4(% 

   4 .

   

 ,%( 3'* 9 * '&'



&3 '&9&'%0

+&7-

%?

*'&"

0 &

+&7-

%? *'& & '&*

* 0 

 ,

3'(7  &   :

(&7/  C

4(%  %*(4

,&& ,%

,4 (, 9 7 &   @C,%

,4

,

 9  @7 &C,%

,4

,



9 @ 7 &%*(4 & 9&  

&7

%  3'*  ;%

4(%    3   3* : 3' ! ;%  ,  @/ ,& ( 

*3/ * (

G, &/'

&'&9&'% 0

+&7-

%? *'&/   / @/   @/  &

0 (7   4  

( *3/ * (

"

0

&

 G?4( -*'& *& +&7-

%? *'&& '&*

* 0 "

4( 9*&   0 ( % / 3 (7/ (

/( *3 * %*(  @/ /    @/  &

0 (7 ;%

-:5:- & 3* %*(4

 &

C

&7 %&

7 &I 8 

 &9

&  47  * ( %  +&7 -

%?  *'&/ G?4(  -*'&  *&    *4 F*

93J *&

E 0*"3 ( %*%&* "3/  0( ''

( 8@!   !/ 

  ! -

&/!/%% ( % K *3K *

&3,%

3'  L'*( *3L/ L'& *3L/  L ((

*3LI,&  &

  

 (  (( *3 +&9&'% !  

93J *&

E ? *'&& '&*

* !  * 2 % %*& +&7-

%*'& ( , 0&*% * &,%       

 %   E  & *3 ( 9('&(

/K *3K *

&3 ,% 3'  L'*( *3L/ L'&

*3L/  L (( *3L ;%  &9% *3 ,*(  (* 3'7/ & / % ('/ & / 9*

/ (

  

 

/ ,% %   (  %

3(7 $ % &

  '* /   ,*(  (* :*( & (  ,

 '*  -'*( *3  9 &((7

   &9%  '

9  & ( %'    %*4

-:6:- ,

,% %((, *&009'* & ( K 3'7/

7/ '

& /

/

& &7 #*9(& ( H+& *3I 9&

%(*' '& 3 % '& / & ( K'& (/'&

/

/

7/ '( / 9*

  &9K (( *3   &9% '&  

( % 

%( 

( 9 %  %( * 9& % .  97  '&   3(7 

 ;% 9&

97 &'&  ( & %(*&9 & (

3  %(&  &  0(* & & (0 / 

/

3'%' &&(  3(7* & *3 '

('&3&

9 %99&34* * ,& % 

*(& ( %' &#*&

,&(0 %0  &

9D %  0(*   %(L *3 &



3 0(* ,& 

%  %(   #*&



&  '

&3  '&  4

* &( *3 %  %( ;% 3* ,& '&  &( (0 /

/ &  3'%'

%(;%  &) % 

4

(( 9( 3 '&09& (

0

3& & 3( /

-:7:- * (3   ,%   '&  % ( & 3&

%(/&*3&& &*9%

&/ '& &  (  *3 *  %    (( & *3+& (& *3,& %(& ,% ( &'& 3 &0 % 

* 



,G9%*& %0 ,&  % G, &/ , (& 7, %&

'& '(  ,% *( 4   (   (( & *3 ;%  3*  4  

*3 ,(( 4  90 &  47  '& '(  ,&9

 * & LE   & *3L  ( ,  +&7 -

% *'&   '&

/ ,

3  ''&'&

,& & 

/ 3* " / &( ((& *3  

&9(7/ ''

,, 

  (  *3 B   ,%(    5  

 &  (   '& *3 B  %/ @/ 

* @/ 

(

 & 9&'73 

/G?4( -*'& *&  -*4 -9% &0-%73-9%  &/! "/- 8@/ 4 .9&* 

%09 .

'(

88/

&



'74( &3C 8C-

/ %

-:8:-

.'(

@/

& /

'74( 

&3 @C 8C'

&*3 

 & *3 

/  '74( ''

 (3 ,&.* * &      !

" # $%& ''!''!"()&*!  +($%

# $%& ''!''!"()&*+'  $   @  @  * +&'

 ( @ @C  @ 5 ; 

 @ @ M @N@@

 *( '( &''(   5&  @ @N5/ 5& @@ ! @N5 @ @  *

 ,& &(

  *(  7 5:: N@/ / 5 @:: N/5/

 E O

@/  @/ ! * &(O:'

@/  @/ 8 E & *3 @/  //   %

 

@C'

&*3 8C'

&*3 ; @/8/   /!/  5 

&9(7/  9    @/8/ ,&  47  ;&4*(/  (3  &  % ( ,&   /!/ (9, %

B8,  

(9 (3'

((

'73 /( 3* (& 7 'G, &/4

& '73  &  3* / ,,

, %(& %((4 ' ,&( *3  

( 3 / ,*(4 ,&    '&'& & %&

&3  47

-:9:- ;&4*(;% *&

3'7%((3.

'73

& 3.9  *

  : (4( 7 ,& *  '&'

/ 

&

 ,

   G?4(  -*'&  *&   +&7 -

%? *'&  

&9(7/''

(((, ,&

!5 3



40    ,-,./.,0 &# %..%*& $%

&'

.9&   <  $%

&& '& 4(  <