Anil Kumar Soni v. Union Of India And Others
!"#! " $ % !&#& " '( )* +,-./0
1 /
% !&#&2 " '( )* )3+14/5 ( *61!
1 /
% !&#&7 " '( )*
!,!05 +/1/
1 /
)
86) ! 00%0 86) ! 066 ! "#
$% &&!
$'( )*+,-,( (.$/
0%09 )! 7&& % " $ % !&#& " '
) " ((,1 ! $2$ )) 3 4
"3 ) )3/:/ ;15+
1 ((./(.$5 " $ 6 7$
6
& 7 ) 1 3 4 ((./(.$5 )3 /:/ ;15+
1 " $ 6 7$
0 8 6
& 3
"8
3 )00 3 % 4/ ) * + ,-,( (.$/,-,% (.$/',-,2 (.$/
9* " ((, ) : 8;
!1 )
+ 4 & :
!1 )
+ 3<4
!1)
+ ) * + ,-,( (.$/ "
!1)
+ .(.=(..5(
<-/
*9 )* + ,-,% (.$/ !1 )
+ $5.((.$$(
<-/
*)*+,-,2 (.$/ !1)
+ %$.%(..5(
<-/
*!
/ 2 % !&#& " '
9 > "3;
)?9& : & :
9 ) > !
9& :
!1 )
+ .(.=(..5 (
<-/
* 1"3)
& 3
1 3
! $$(1! $$= )
$5,( 1 "
9 3 1 "
1
3 9
6 .$.=(.$/9 "
$..%(.$/(
<-/
=*1
1
9 3 1
(-.%(.$/
3
1
% !&#&2 " '
9
6
9 (../(..5 91<7""
3 9 & : > 1
!1 )
+ $5.((.$$
<-/
9)
)
+ ! 6 ($.-(.$( 9 ;
4 )
)
+ ! 6 $=.5(.$(9
3$%.5(.$( 6 % 94 3 ! "@ (.$( "
@(.$/9
)
)
>
+ (%.%(.$/(
<-/
7* %..%(.$/ % !&#&7 " ' 9
!
1 9 (..=(.., 6 A< A )
9& : 1
!1 )
+ %$.%(..5
<-/
9
3 (-.,(.$.
<-/
;
6 61
94 3 A .(.-(.$.
<-/
2 4 ;
1
6 1
>9"
4 3 A.2.%(.$(
<-/
= 4 3
3
6 :
4 ;
61 1
1 4 9
+ .-.((.$/(
<-/
7* 6 (%.((.$/ )0 = )
/3 6 1
1 4 "
;
3 "34 ) <+61!
1 14/ " #(2& *6 2##( * /:/ ;15+
1 4/ " $ 6 7$ 0
3 " 1 7 9 )
3 3
" 1 " >)
4 / 045> ? @!61! .. /-. (.$% (5, ?>9% !!,/4 ?/ !,!>9!
++/ /+<(..5 (=/ ?>9=5 0@0+/ 61! ../!-!9!<!0!!9-/>5-/(.$, %=. ?>9 $%% ) >4-/ 5/)++!61!9 1 4/ 0 / 1 4/$5-%:
!) ,.% ! "# 6
3 3 ) )*+,-,( (.$/ 1
" 4 1 "
+ 1
8:)*+,-,% (.$/ 31 "
" 3 B@"&B) 4 & : :)*+,-,2 (.$/
)
)
4 1 " "4 0 & 9 3 "4
"3 1 1 3
" 1:
1
1 1
8 6 1 " 8
9 ;
6 ;
1 "3 B )
;
34 "
1
4 1
"34 39 4 "
;
" 1 4 B@"!
) 0 - AB 4 1/ 5!
)+: !
61!(../ ($/ ?>9%(21 ""
;
" " "3
1
1 ((, ) : ' "3 1 )*+$.--5 (.$2 )3/:/ ;15+
1 /& ((./(.$5 " $
6 7$
0 8
<-/
&
1 " "
6 4 "1
! " #$%$ &
'
(
$ ( !
!) *
(+ ,-$.
/0 +#%,1-2%% 3 $
4
! 5 6$ !
!) * '(&4'
) 7' * '(
-4 +*,8 $92
:
4$
$ ' ( *8 $"#;%:*<2::;;% '( * =
1 *
>
&4? (
@
4
( A '( 4
#=
*1 ;22$
' 4 9::$ B 4
+ , ' 3(
'(
!) *
+ , '
$ B +,
4 *1
(
' ':
$ '
($8 ' C
4' 4
$ B
!
"#$
+ ,) 7' * >4 = !
*
4
(
(
4( ' '$ B@ '
4 4 '
'D 4 ' ' 4 '3 4
*1 ;224 4
! $
4
9
;" $@
'
43 ! ' ( ( 4 : 4
9
;"
'D '( ' ('
'
$ $ )4 *
A
>& * + , $$;
;$#$;
'
!
>& $*E 8 $ 99;
%3
!
$
!
( $;$% *E 8 $ 99;
% 5
!
!
"#"
$ %"
% !
#"
$
& !
'' ! " #
$%&'!
( # ) *+ ,
- .-# + " +)&*",/0 1
21 # $ + 3
4+
(&
)
!
56
7 1 # +)&*",/ 1
0 $ $
1 " "8&/91 2 *%&' !
( # , .-# + "
9
$ # $ +)&*",/0 1
2 $
1
+)& $ - 1 .-# + "
-
-
# $
#
$
'( # $
1 6 :
$
1 "
1%&'!
( # ) +
01
;
" 1
-
## - ') ! <$
1
# +
1 "
#=(
#
+
01 "
;
+
1 "
#=(
'
# ## $
1
$1
$*# -
$
1
$
1%&'!
( #
- > 1 $
-
-#
*, $1
-
1#
- #
-# ' %&'
!
( #
$
1 .-# + "
1:
6
"5? #4&@ )
-
-# 1 !!
!
# (+
',(- '. A - #1 1 5>
+-5
*, #
*, 1 +
0 1
09 0
-
1
1+"
/
1 " 6
7 #
-
(
1 1 1
-
11
4 11
$ $
11
1 $ - 1
( 7# 1
# #
+ ##1
+-5
*, (
(
1
+- +
##
1
(
11
1
1
1
1 1
+- +
0! #
1
- 11
4 $1+-5
*, (
1
1
- 11
1 1 +-+
*,#- # $1
+-+
*,1
+
01 ;
'/ !
1 # 1
+
0 #
-#
1&
-
-
-
#
?
#
#- #
-#
$ $
1 797 0!
6 :
<$
1 "
- #1
!
# +
1 & - %
#+ # !
(
0*1 B&%+!
.,@ +
1&%+!
0 990 #
1 1 $
-
1 0 $ 8 #
# $ > 1
#
1 #
19
## $ 250 1 $
#
"
1
! 1 2
# & 3(4'45)/6/
376,
1 1
#
1
1 ## $ 250 ##- - 1 1
( 19
1990
#
- !
1 $
!
1## - 6 :
1
" # & 2
!
#
8 1 2--$ ''4(4')
; !
#
1 $
!
% 1
C5 6!
!
!
# '' # - "
4) 4) '+
" !
# # 3'5# ''
" "
"
!
3)5# '' -
!
%
6"
% ! "
"
4) 4) '+ " !
"
9
!
" !
!
!
# # 3'5 "
3)5# '' #- '
#
1 +!D'31
5; ;52 ;
# !
+
*9, $ 1
( 1 1 009075 0751
22
!
!
" ! "
4) 4) '+%
"
!
!
!
#
''3)5 -'
#
#
! - #
1 1&%+!
1$
1
# #
1
#
1#
+-+
*9,- $
1
## #- #
-#
$
# 4
)
! - #
# #
- $
# $ ##
-# '
#
1 +
1 1 $1
! - # -
## $ - + #
!
(76
7 %"
9 "
!
3'53)5# ''
!
!
"!! !
!
4) 4) '+
!
!! !
!
"
4) 4) '+% %
(:
4:
(44'
!
"
7
1 1
(
1
-
"
+-+
* ,1+
- $
+
1
&%+!
! 1 1 -
1
1 $
- #
! - # $ *-
;'/,
(
1$ $
# 1
4 $
#
$
- -# 1 # - #
(
- 1 # $ #
$
-
> #
$
9 *-
;'/,> 1
(1
5; ;52
F
! 1 5
1+
0
1
1 9 0
1
&
##
-
# $
# 1
- - 09
1 # !
1 #
1
1+"
/
$
- 9 0
# 1
E ##1 $
*
> $$
(
-
-
11
1 1 +- +
*,1 +
0/
+-5
*, -
&
-
11
4 $
1
1
#
1
-5
*,:
1 0 # $ #
#
+ "
/
##- 4 $-
1
- 11
# # >
1+-5
*, # -
(
1
- -
11
4 11
# $
11
1 $
# 1
'
56'
+ "
/
*;,, F 9 *;, 1 #
5
#
1 #
1$ #
$
1 7
1 11
>
:
-#
1 9 0
-
- 09
1 # *-,1+-+
*,1 +
(
1
11
#
(
1 >
1+-+
*, #
-# #
*;
,, *;,
## -
# ', ' 1 - 1 $ 1
- ## - # * , #
1
# -
1 3#!
, * ,
#
1
1+
0*,*, 1
09 0 1 ;
$# -
&
## +"
/
9 *"8&/'4++(4'/, +"
/
*"8&/ '4/):(4'',
5
1 > < # : 1
1
.(.=(..5%$.%(..5'$5.((.$$4 1
3"3 ) 3)
1 13 4 1
96
4 "3
" 6"3
! (- 5 ! (- 5 1 "
3
& "
3 3 1 4 )
!"#$
: 1 4 !"#$
& 1
3 1
.(.=(..5(
<-/
*)*+,-,(
(.$/ 1
$5.((.$$(
<-/
*)*+ ,-,% (.$/%$.%(..5(
<-/
)*+,-,2 (.$/;
(0%0* (66 * ->- 9 " $ 3 % " &
'& % ( ) '&