Bharam Pal And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others




   
  

!"# #$%&%'()*

+!,!-!.!'/"+#,& 0#"%"%'#,& 1#,&2& 3"!"# !,4!'!!'/"+#,& 0#&5'/#'"&
 ( 6 7 3
 13 8  9
 3
 :

7 3
  779 





 
 
 

 


 
 

 
 




!

 "

#
 
 
 

 



$ %
&

'

 
(
## 
 


!


 


 

 )* +,  


"#

 #

#

 
#


"#


 
-.

 13 8  9
 3
 7
%

, 



 
 






 "

!
/&+/.

# 

0 
- 

,  

1 
2

" 


/3%4

 
 

 
 






%%

, 
1 
2

%56&


37 %3 %66%






 


 

 


/3%4

3% 3% /3%&


"
 
 
 





"



"
 
! 

 


"
 8


 
9


 
 
 


"
 

 
 2
#


 


/&+/.



/3%4


 


#

 
%% 3% /3%5


"
 

 
 


/

, 
 


/&+/.



/3%4


 



#


 
 

"

"
 
-


:"
!
-

9

 
 


  

       



"
 
;
-


 
 
 
##





 

#
 

 
 2
#
 
"
 



"
 



#




/&+/.



/3%4
, 
#
 # 
4<4

 
=#



" 
>?

    !"

 # $#$" %    

 !"

"  !"

!  &'   ! "(

  )      !"

! &

 "  %  )  %   %% !! *"

(  " )     !  " '  "( 

 "  

 "

 # $#)$! "

! & "

! +

!  )  
& , % -.   "

  #$ ) %

"

  )-.-. ,   ! "/  "("

  #$ !  "

 !  & 0

" %   "

 !   !!    "

"  !   "

'   !     ) 0  "

 ) 
 %'"  ) 0'"

  )   

    '!"

 ) '   ) 0    

 , *  1 1      ! "

  #$ !  "

 !  &    "

     ! "

   "  , "/" ! 2   

      "

  #$  "      )    %   "

 3  !   (  

)!"# %$  ! !" !  "/ "

 ! "

! +



)    "

   """ %     !  "

 !  &
 "  ) (   "

 &  !  4 "/  "

 ! +

    ) ! !

'     "

 &  !   "

 " ) (  52   !

"

  # " $    

     !  "/  "(
 " ! 2   %   "



 3  !  ( ! !    ' "

   "

! & )   6 %6

 ! !" ! "/ "

 !  "

! +


7
 "    )

  "

   "

& # $! "

! +

'      "

  "/    "

  #$ 

 2    2  ! "

   "  , ) (     "

  )

(   "

& # $4%% !  ""

 "

   % (  !" ! ( "

 ' "  "

   "/ 

"(  "

 #$! "

! &
 ,   "

 #$! "

! &  )    !"

 #$  !"

 # $#)$
8 ,  ! 0(    "

 !

+

" 

 "

 #$)%(! /    9    :" %  )  

0( "

 ! "

! +

'         (  "

 #$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 

 "

 #$
+ ,   ! "

  #$  ( !      ! "(  

")   "      !     "

  0    "

 !!  )! "

! &"    !"'   "( !  "/  ( %  ""    

, !) "!      ) "    ) *"

   "

  !! 

 "

 #$! "

! & (   % " ! "

  /   (   ! ""



"( !  "/  "

   

  

"( (     ! !"   !  "

 !  &' '  


            2) "

        ""

 "(  

%

% /   (  ! ! 0( 

  "( !  !"

  

 !"    "/ .

, 
;


 
"
 
;
-
 
"
 @


 #
 


 

 

 
 
"
 -
 
+ .

9

 
 

 2



"
 
"






"



%%

 


%56&

 
 



 


/3%4
 3% 3% /3%&
 


 

#

 
 


 
 




 



"


 




/3%4

 
 







%%

 


%56&


"






 


/3%4
 

 


/3%4




" #

 


 
#





 
 





%56&



"
  +".

, 

>:


" 
 
" 
#


/&+/.

 


/3%4


"
 

-.


-.
 





 #

 2
#
" #

"
 #
 "




 


"



"
 
 





"

 
! 

 


"


"
 




"



 

"

 #
#!"  

&&#$! 3(  $
+.


 

 

 

 
 2


 :"
!
-

9


 # 
"



;
 

 
 
 


/&+/.


 


/3%4






 


A



2

"





 
 






"
; 

&


#

 

 



 

 

  "

 
  





"



#

 "# 




 
 








 
"
 @

 
 



#
 
 
A 
#


4%+%.
4%+/.
4&

 


%56&
 #
 
 

 



7%
53

 


/3%4
 :"
;
-


 



2

  

 





  





4&

 


%56&
B


:"
!-


 
 




 
 

 


"
8


4%+%.


2#
 
 
"
 @

  






 
 


 


"
   
,
 

 
 :"
!-


 
"





  



 


# 
 

 
 




 
  +.


 #
 



"
 


/&+/.

 

/3%4
 :"
!
-


 




 



 


"
 
"


 "

 
#


"





=

#


 


 

 

/3%4



"
 

 
  


 
 


 

 2


&

 


%56&

# #
 




"
 

  

 =#




 # 
 

 
 

 



"

 
1 
2
-


 
 


 
-



 =



#
 #
 "







 
 




 =

#
 # 
 


 
"



4&

 

%56&

"
 
2 +.


# 
 




#

 :"
!
-


 



 #

2
8
 

 



  



"


,
 # 

#





# 
"
 





 



"





%<

 


%56&
 


 
! 

 
 
"

#

 # +.


#
 
# 



 
" 
 
 






 


/3%4



"#


"
;

 



;#
 

 
 2
# 


'
 


 




/&+/.
 
"
  +#.

, :"
-


 
 




 2




 
"


#

 2

 

 
 
#


 
"




/&+/.

 


/3%4
 
"
 




 


"


  + .

9

447
 :"
-


 

 






/&+/.

 


/3%4

 

"
 
"
 " 

  







 

 


&

 


%56&

"2



C


  
 
 
 


/&+/.

 


/3%4 &



 
 


"
 

 

 



 
 #
%%
D  
%&

 


D


 &/88%<8/
+/ 4.
%7+' %'.
%7+/ '.
%5+7 %&.
%68%
%68%
+% 6.
//8/+% 5.
/4+5 3.
&68848/+% %'.
&8%+% '.
 
 
 

 

( #

 

=
, 
  "# 
*
0  "


, 
 

 
#

 

 
 
 
 

"
2
"
 ! 




 
 
3/ %656

3% %663



&


<

 
1 
2

%56&
 
"


 
37 %3 %66%

 
"

 
*
)@ 

  

 
!
&'
0  "


9

 








 



 


#
 2
#
"
#
-A
$
%66&

%66%


 


 

 

 


 
37 3/ %66%

 
 
 

 


 
/3%3
"
##


 

 

 
 

"
 

#

 



 " 
=

 

,  
 




 
%/
 
 
"


#


 
 

%5%
2 
 
 

 
&33
2 
!











#
 

 
/& 3< /3%'


 
 #
%/
  
 

2
#



 
 
9


"
 

"
 



 

 
34 /3%3



#
"
 
"
 :"
!
-

9
"
#
!1
" #
--
$
///3 ///%

/3%%




%& 3/ /3%% '

9


 
 



"









#



 

 








  

 

 

2 2
 
 2
#



"
 



"
 




/&+/.



/3%4


<

9


 
"
 
"
 


 
 
1
 
 
 

  #

! 


 








2 

"
 

 
 

9
*
 
+! .

 


 


 
9







2

 #

/&+/.



/3%4







"

'
 




 
 



/3%4
 


3% 3% /3%&
, 
;
-





#



'
 
 

#

 

 



"
;
1  

 
 


 




#
 2
#
"
#
-A

%66&

%66%



 


 

2
 
"
 
-


 
37 3/ %66%
, 
 
 
 

 

 
 

 



34 /3%3
9



;

#
'
 


/&+/.



/3%4
 

'
 


3% 3% /3%&




 

 
#



/&+/.



/3%4
 
"
 
"
 
 0 






 

 

#
"
 
-

-A
$
%66&

%66%
 
 #
%5% '3
2 

 
"
 


 


;#

 


 

 

!
&

 


%56&



 
 
"#
  
 
2
B

!
' 



%56&
<
 
 



$
&/88%5




 2
# , 






2
2


 
 
 
#




 
 


4'6

 
=#

9
*
 
+! .
!
/&+/.



/3%4
 
"




 


#


 
B
  
 


 
 
 



"
#



@ 


%4'
 
%4 %% /3%&




#

  


 #
 

2
 


 ! 



" 


# 
 
 




 

 




 


#
 
 
  

 
 
"  

 
 =

 


 



 
"
, 







 



 
 
 
9
 

  
"
 


 



 






 
 
2

 #

/&+/.



/3%4





#

 
 #

"
 
#
 
#
 





 





 



2 

"
 

 
 
"
 :"
!
-

9

 
 

9
*
 
+ .

  

 

 #
 #

2
#

 



 
 #
 

.
9



 



 





#


2
#
"
#
-A

%66&

%66%
, 



 
 


 

 

2


 
37 3/ %66%

 
 

 
 

"



 
34 /3%3

 


#

 
 



 

"


2

 
2


 
  
!

 

 #

37 3/ %66%

/3%3




 
'
 



3% 3% /3%&




;#






 
 #
" 

 
;
-

;#


#

 

"




 





 
'
 



3% 3% /3%&




 

 
 


/&+/.



/3%4 ".
9


  
 
;
-

9
*
 
+! .


 # 



!
/&+/.



/3%4
 
"







#


"
 
 
"


-



9
 
 



 





#
 2
#
"
#
-A

%66&

%66%
 
"
 
-


 
/3%3

 




 


 

 
 

 


2
#

 
;

"
 





 


9
 

  
=#
 

 
 
 #
%5% '3
2





<
 
  
 

!
' 
2


 

 







#
 

 
"
 
-
"
 :"
!
-

9 
!1





 
%& 3/ /3%%
9

 




/3%3



# 



 
 




 

 

 

 
"
 

 
, 




 


 
 

 2
#

 

 

 
"
 


 

#




/&+/.



/3%4 .
, # 




   "



 
 


 
2

 



3% 3% /3%&







 2
#


 
 




 




 
 





 
, 


 
 



 



"



"
#

 

%4'
 

%4 %% /3%&





  


 

 ! 

 
 


 
! 



" 

# 
 
 


 


# # 


:"
;


#
 
> :
#

! /&+/.

 

>:




!
/&
+/.

/3%4




 # 
"
 
 #



"
"
#




> :






 
 


"

 
"# 

 


A





 
E




F


"
; 


/34

 



8 
 
  "

  



"



#

 
"# 




 
  9

 

 

 



 






 
  

 
 
"  

 
 



 =

 

 
"
"
,  
 
 
#


 


 





 

"


 



 
 

 


 
 



 



"
 




 
2



 
2

 #
!
/&+/.



/3%4




;



 

 
 


2
#
2 2
 
;
 
 

 
 
"
 
-




 

 

 


/&+/.



/3%4


"

  

 


 




"



 #



 





 



 



! 
2
 

 
"

"
 



@ 

  

- 
!
&'
0  "


, 
"


 
"
 #8 #
 

 


 

 
 

 2

2
 
2



 

 
 
"





 #

%


 
 
'




%&
 
 #
%/



%

 
 #
 

43


#
"
#
#

6


%5


 

 


 
 
A



 
 

#
 
"
 






#
 
 

 


 
 

"




 #

 
 
#


 2

 


 
 
"




 
 8
 



 
"



"
@ 

 2



#
"


!  %3



2

 "






 @


4<4

9
*
 
+ .
 


#





 
 



2



 



2
#
 
 

 



 "# 

 

 
 


#

#



2



 

 
 
"




 






 
 
 
 
 





#

"# 
2
" 
#
#


/&
+/.

/3%4



"#

 



 



 



, 


#

 
%% 3% /3%5
 
"


 

"
 %%

#

 
 



#
 




 
 
 
, 




! 
2


 
   + (9
!

$DB
G .

















- 9B0
G)!,9-B

+ )$
119.






G)*B

03.02.2022 Manoj Bhutani
A  


#8 
H8$  
 "
H8$