High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3569/2016allowed

Murti Devi & ORS v. Union Of India

2019-02-11Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan11 pages

!"#"$%

&'(" )" $*+ (#

$"$ $*"

!"#$% &$ ''

("!"#$% &$ '$" ))))

!* + ''

*% -&$ - + #

" ".,""/0/121/0'

-3

, - ! " . % ! " . * &&"$ 5 - 6+ -34 % , ''

% $ & " "% $ /7 $&

43 , - %! 8 .%$,' $$&

9!11!111:;*

% + &$ " $& ! 4 $ 4

-" $& ''

:% ,$/; # !

-(%"-3 - $ .$ " ''

#$- $'$# "

." %% "4 $

43$4"

% " %$,'

" "% $/2<*%+*2+$&

%!/=9= $ &% %

3&$%$ " $$& " ,"

,''

% $! "-$#!4 & "-3

$291/21/>& " $&$ *

-"$&''

$/; # $/?/221/< ' ,''

% $! ,$ .$& 1?/221/<! "; .$ .$ 8&$"$ . $,4$8 "-$"" @ 4

43 $4 % " -$ 9<1 & '

. ($ 3 %8! -$"" -

$, $4&

"$4&$, . 8,$71:>;0-4

$ "@ 4

43 $"" " '$%%$" .$ ! "4 '

." "" " %% "

$-8 $4" % "- "

. %% "!

%8.$ '$"; & " 4 , "3 . "

. #, $& ,''

% $$ .$ " $

$4" % "%

." $& "; 4 , .$& '$# $ $&% $/2<*%+*2+"4 % $/2>;$&

%!$$8'

$ " "4 $'

. $& $1?/221/<! $ %8%$

"-&$ "&$, % % $& -$"3!"!

!%$- "$- "&$ $3%$,' $ ,$ 4 ,!

%.$ %

3 - " '.'

'$4

4 " % '$"; # .

$," 4 , 4&% ,3%$, '

. A 3$4#!", "

3!$,",4 ," 4

,-3 '$"; 43 $ 3

%$ " $ '

" .

$& ' ! $ &,"&$

$4 .

;

5*/+ ! "

# $ ! !#

$!(

! ! '

!% $" $

''$ % ! % B, " ''

%:% ,$/;, # !4 "$4$& " C;/

"'$ "

4 $%%$,'3 . ""!

!B%

"$-- $ $ $4 % "$$8'

$ 4

$4 "'

" %8$$ C;2!, 3!

&& "# "$ .

' #($- %$,'3"$ &&

"3! !$1?/221/<! 4

%$, .&$, 8$ 4

. $

.@$C

"&$, "4 .$ .&$,@ 4

43 $$&$$$

.@$! 4

% * %"% "+!4 $$ " ,

4 .$ . $ 8 -3'

. $&9<1 &$,@ 4

43 $&$'

. % &" ,"3! %,$ 8$4

% "&

"$4&$, 8,$71:>;0-4

43 $@ 4;

$ "

" "% " '$ "&$, % " "$

$&D! 8" " & " "" -$"3 $&

% ; $4#! '' &$,

;

B, $

%%'" 4 $#

.4 "$ &&

"3"!

! $3;4

$ % " ''

$-$ .

$%$" # "$% ,

" . '$ ,$,'$! $,,$!&"(,

! , $& ",!@3,$& 43! .

! ,

4!, ! .

, ! $$& '

-&$D :

, '$"; $ 3 "& "

-$"-3 - !%%$" .$

'$!$ %8%$

"- %$#" &$, "% " &" ,

-3 D

" 4 $#

. 3 %, " ,'%$& $, 4

. 43 $ E"

3 -

%$, $ %$%

$ ''

% ;

#$'

$%$"3"$% ,3# "%$$ # "%$

''$ &% "4 '

.$&

- , $" ,''

% $ '$? %84 % "4 $&$ " &"(,

& !&$, ,$& ",!@3,$&

43! '' -$"3$& "

-&$ "% " 3 .4$" &&'

% "

' 4 &$ " , ""

$& %8! 4 ! , . # -3

4", !4 #-''""4

'$!% , $" "%, ,'%$& $, "" "

! -

%$,$ %$%

$ "

- %84

$, ".$ ( ""

, 3" ""

"$4&$, 3 ! % - "$'$# $4" % " '$ ''

% ! 3 #$'$# " $%%$ $& ( 3

" %% " , -

. , $4" % " , $&% $/2<*%+*2+$&

"$-"$" ,''

% $4 (%"-3 - &$ "-%8.$ "$& ,! # " "

%$ &$ ''

'$"" #'

" %$"

''% $$& # %$ $! '' @3,$& 43!, 3! ", &$," $ ." .""-$"3

3 .$ 43%8"'$&4 $ " %8

$-$ =>0!4 $-# $

''$ ,$& " $%% "&9<1 '$ $& ,! "4 $-$" '

. %%$" .$ $4 " 4

'$ $ 4 # - 9<1&$, @ 4

43 $$ 8! ! '

%$4 "% "4

.$ .$'

% &" %

$& ''

% ,''

% $ " $ '% & % "

$ - %$ ""

. # - #'$ $& , @ 4

43 $ % "4 #

. $! 4 $A $$& 3$&

% $ # . ,-$" . $&

."$4 &$,- C;2

% "

&& "# !4

%$, .&$, 43 $& .

.&$, ".$ .$

.! ,

% 4 $ &$," , 4 .$ .$-$" 9<1!

$.$$ 8&$'

.% &" &$ "&%%$ '

"4 &% $" -3 9<1!$

4 # - &$,@ 4$

8!# & $" %# "%!

$-%$ ""! # 4$& " .% % , % # - ! 4 .$ .$ 8$ '

% &"& 4 .$ .$'

% &"- $-$"34

%%$,'3 . ,! 4 % - '

," 4 %8;

.&$ $ $ %8%$

"-&$ "&$, ' $$& "% "

&$ " $

-" 4 " 4"-3 $- 'B$ 4

% -" ".,"" $"$ $*"

-#"$ * )" ./0/")"10, F$ - ''% $! # '

.! ! '.'

$/?>'$"

%" ";

)*(+ & %& +",+ + -". / + ,+ "

+ &

" " + %& + + 0" +0 1

" .$& &$ "'

.! % 'B $

" ,' %$&""-$"3$ 43',

$-%$%

#$ " ( "$ "4 '

.$4#!,- %$& %84

( "$"% "4

$! , ,!4

$. # , 4 '

. &%$ ! - "4

-$ ,4 %- ."-3& .&& "# $& #&% - "4

&$ "

%-"% ""$ &%

$4$ " .

% % , % & $3;4

% % , 4

! !

C;2!4 $

" 4

% .$ .$-$" " , '

" %8"-$"" ! %$-(%"

3$ .$ " %84 $&$ "&$, ""-$"3$& "% "-%

- "4$

""&

& '$ 43$

2 $ $4 " "%

3G $4$

"-! & " "4

. 43 $ E"

3 %, " ,'%$&4 H&

%% " '' ! " #$& . " .

"$&

$ ,," 3 &$, $ $& 43 $ &$, .

%% "

% 4

, & % $//<$&

%!/=9= "$4 % , 4 # 3%% "4

, &$. #$

$%% ! $ $& $ $ '

%4 %% "$%%

!4 " 3! . # $ % $& %% " $

% .

$ ' "$&$ %!4 4 ( " % $ %% "$%% $4 A $4$

"-% "$

34 # .- &$,"-3 . #$ D "$& 4 #$ #"

3'$& %% "H 4

$- . #

. # $$ $ $4 3 A 3

-%$"

."H

! - %$& ! %$- "$ '

," %$" %# "% # - $&&

.$& "

&$, ! ,

#" "4

. 43 $#-3 .

%$- "$ -

$& '

,' $38 .

-& $

3'$& 4"'

,' $! $& %$-"

$"." %$"

3! &% A 34 "-3

!# .

'$";

%.$ %

" .'

$=$& 4

, # .

$," 4 ,& % # .

'$ &4# "%"&% 4$

"%$, ' A 3 '$!$,",%$

"--$ .

4 ,&%! 4 ,! $

% ,

- ," "% " " " 4

3%$

. 43%8I

$$ A $4$

- $4

3'$&'

,' $4$

"-# - H 4! # 4 $& &$ ""

$!4$

" #$- . #. '&$, -$#! '

'$! A 3 "-3 $ '

!! F ,$& , "''""$ '$- " '

$ ,; ",

-B, "

-3

$-& &$ "$&

" # .

$ $, . '

% $ " 4 ,-,""-3 '$"; $ 3" & ' $ 4$

" #-B, "! 4$

" # .

$ %$

;B, $

$$4#!

$''$ 34 #. #$ #&$, ,$& ",!4 "

''""4

'$! '' , , 3.

;4$8-%

"$ $8$4 %% " "8'

%-34

! ,3# 4! #$-- $"

. $

", 3$ -

$&.

;4$8!&$ " " "- 8 , $& '

% . .

, $ 3 4 ,8 . 3 ,", '

" .$- . .3 .$%$"-343$&3 '$ ## "% $ $4

" "$%% "4 ', $& - ! ,3%$ ""$' $!

.$ 43"43-3

,-$&

$,"$-

&$& '$"; $ 34

$A "$-"$ ,3# 4! ,

# - $%$""$

$4 " $& "%$

" #$%% " 3,!$

,4 #- "-3 ! !&

."$4&$,

343$&

- ."$-

&$& '$";

43 $ 3 '$ ,$,'$.$ $

$4 .4 #"

"'$& -$"34 &$ "$ %8!4 %$ '' &' $ &

&$, $4#!

,-$&.

$$"$ 3$- (%"&$ $ $B'

-B, "-3 $

- %$&4 ! ,3%$ ""# 4! %$-'

&' $&

&$, $%$" $! %$-".." $ 43%8-3 ,'%$&- $4 .4 "$ '"$& %$"

" - -$"3$& "

" #-% $ ' % " %"4 $ %

3$ .4 #"&$, -$"3- $ ( " %" $ ,$, '$,3

$- '$

- "

&$, &$B,'

" ( " -$8

" %

'% & %

$! 4$

"-#3" && %

$ $;

$&'

. %$%"! $ %84 &$ "&$, -$"3$& "-

3'$& %% "! 4$

" -'$

- 3 ,,3- &%

$ .$%$"$

$4 D $

43 $ 3 ,"B # % $ '$$&%% "$ -3 $& "$ - $. .

$& " - %$& ! %$ - '

,' $ "4 %8;

. &$! ,3%$ ""# 4! ''

$ - "&$.$& $3%$,' $,$ # ." " % "

43%% " "$4"% " *$,' $+

!/==1* &&"$ 5 "

6+ &&

"3 $& %% "! ! 1?/221/<! $3 ,$ # - $

> ,'

." "., ""

/0/121/0!$" 3! ,"" $3%$,' $%$-. #$ ,"&&% #&$, 3!21/? $4#!$- 'B$ " " "$ )"/#'3( 0 .

%$,' $4

-'3- ''

%- $ "$& %% " 4 ,3-%$ "" $- &$, ,$ ,$ , ' %% "% ,% - & ,$ $%

" $. 4

,$ ' % -" $ "$& 4"$& - ! ,4

- "$ .

$& 4$,$ ! !$4

" $ "'$# $ $$4 #-'$# "" ,"" '$# $ ," &&% # &$, 1/1/21/? % $ 4" 4

'$$ %"-3 - $& "

"- $%$%

- " "! ,3%$ ""# 4!

,' % '

$%$ " . "$&

"% $

#""%$ '' .&$-$ ' #."

& ,'

"J9K$=K&$, "$&%% "! ,$ ' ,""% "

$& "

"-, .

$!4$

" #$ $ " . ''

"- "&$ $3,$ A # $

9 !

-'$# ""-3 $ & % $'

"$22" %,-!

21/7 4 '% $ # % "

% " 4 5

- . 4$"

5 ' &$

6$5 ' .

! " ,$& ;''

"-$&

9 $.4 ,'

J=K' ,$-

" &$, "$& ' "% $

E $ $& %$,' $,$

! ,'

.""% $$& - ""

$4"4 &$ ", / -0 //1221/= (

4+ + (#3 5"$67( #$ *8 #7 4+ + (( 3( 91 8 #7