High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3572/2016disposed of

Sunder v. Ajmer & ORS

2019-07-02Mr. Justice Raj Mohan Singh15 pages

!"#$ #

#%&'#'())*+ ,-*.'/ 00'11%*& 2 34'/%*.&5'/ '0*.'*&

#5%/4 00'11%*& 2 34'/%*.&5'/ '0*.'*&

,-65%5 00'11%*& 2 34'/%*.&5'/ '0*.'*& '75% 00'11%*& 2 34'/%*.&5'/ '0*.'*&

%/&%0 00'11%*& 2 34'/%*.&5'/ '0*.'*&

-..) 00'11%*& 2 34'/%*.&5'/ '0*.'*&

+

! "

# $%&' ( ' )

# *%&' (

++++

,-.

/ # $*12 345- 2$23 3235 3$*3 $35* 24-6

07

8 46 -- 24-*

(

: :

' 0'

;

(' ,2.

< 4- 41 24-2 =

= (

= > = = #8 '

!' 8

=

#8

' '

' " =8

# -

'

='

' ' =

/&= 8 # - 0 ;

= #8

8

,$.

8

# - = # $ '

' # * ' %' 8

8 ,3.

< 8

8 '@

! "

#$ $% & '

% ( )

' ' *) + )% * % ) & % , % -

%

. /,, $ 0

) &

) ) % ) &). /,, 1

) )

) . /,

&

)

. /,

&

!

)

". /, ! 2 ,*.

0

' ' ' # - A' '

# - ' # - ' B ' # 2 8

'

A' &' # $ * 8

' ' ' ' 8 8

= # - 8

# - 8 ' ,6.

&

,1.

-$

/

( # -2644@(&& 24-6

8 > -$

,C.

8

88 ' =

'

'

A' > =

8 *2 " ' '

" 8

= *4444%@ = 5444%@

8

' 8

'

8

= 64444%@

-%$ ' 8

'

8 '

= 34444%@ '

-- 8

8

= 334444%@ = *4444%@ 8

'

= 24444%@ 8

= 2*444%@ 8 '

8

= *$*444%@ 8 8

# 2 $ 8

?

( A' # 3 * 8

,5.

D '

'

8

8 '' '' ' -4E

,-4.

= *444%@

8 & -4E ''

= *44%@

8

8'

'

= **44%@ >' ; -%$

8'

= $661%@

**44@-C$$

' = $614%@ 8

'

= 33434%@

$614 ;

-2

' ,--.

8 ' *2

8

!"##" "!"#" $%%& '$&( )*

'

--

8 '

= 3C3334%@

33434 ;

--

('

; = 14444%@

#" + ,"

#-

. /# $%'0 '$0%

14444%@

8

'

= **3334%@

3C3334 14444

,-2.

= -5334%@

**3334 *$*444

8'

1 *E '

I

,-$.

-5

/

( # -$5**@(&& 24-6

8 > -5

,-3.

@> ' A'

J; K@$% L@

J; @-3 J; @-5 & ' ?'%

8

; !& = /'

8 '

= 3123*%@ ,-*.

' ' 8 ' ; 8 = *4444%@

; = *444%@ = $444%@

= *444%@

= 24444%@ '

?'

,-6.

?' ' '

'

' '

' '

'

I ?' '

,-1.

& = 64444%@

; = *444%@

= -4444%@ = $4444%@ ' = *444%@

8

8'

'

= --4444%@ ,-C.

= 21444%@

--4444 C$444

8'

1 *E '

I

,-5.

@'

' A' " 8 @

;

D=

J; @*2 ?' 8

; !

" 8

?' 8 '

8

8

8 L@

J; @23 J; @2*

8

= C6$*%@ ,24.

' ' 8 ' ;

= 24444%@ 8

'

' ' '

= 24444%@ 8

8 ('

8 ?' ?' (

8 ' ,2-.

?' ' '

'

' '

' '

'

I ?' '

,22.

& = 34444%@

'' 8'

' ' ?' ?' = 24444%@

34444 24444

8'

1 *E '

I

,2$.

-1

/

( # -3*C4@(&& 24-6

8 > -1

,23.

?'@=

'

J; @*3 J; @*1

'

' = -*$64%@

= -1444%@

; = *444%@ = $444%@

= *444%@ = -4444%@ '

= 34444%@

8

' 8

8 ?'

' ' 8 ' ;

,2*.

?' ' '

'

' '

' '

'

I ?' '

,26.

& = 24444%@

; = *444%@

= -4444%@ = -*444%@ ' = *444%@ A' 8

8'

= **444%@ ,21.

= -*444%@

**444 34444

8'

1 *E '

I

,2C.

/

( # -35$2@(&& 24-6

8 >

,25.

@ A'

'

J; @$5 J; @3$

33434%@ ' ,$4.

' ' 8 ' ; 8 = 3*444%@

; = *444%@ = *444%@

= *444%@ = *4444%@ '

?'

,$-.

?' ' '

'

' '

' '

'

I ?' '

,$2.

& = *4444%@

; = C444%@

= -4444%@ = 64444%@ ' = *444%@ ?'

8

8'

'

= -$$444%@ ,$$.

= 2$444%@

-$$444 --4444

8'

1 *E '

I

,$3.

-1

/

( # -2*-5@(&& 24-6

8 > -1

,$*.

@!' ' A'

J; @$- J; @$6

= 356C4%@ ' ,$6.

' ' 8 ' ; = *4444%@

; = *444%@ = *444%@

= -4444%@ = *4444%@ ' 8

' '

,$1.

?' ' '

'

' '

'

'

I ?' '

,$C.

& = **444%@

; = -4444%@

= -*444%@ = 64444%@ ' = *444%@

8

8'

= -3*444%@ ,$5.

= 2*444%@

-3*444 -24444

8'

1 *E '

I

,34.

8'

K

;

)'

42 24-5 !, !

# K % M%# K

M%#