High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18758/2023dismissed

Ansal Township Infrastructure Ltd. And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-08-25Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari21 pages

!"#"$%&'&# (

)% *+),- --. *+),- .+

!"### "$%&"'# !!#""( ")$%&"" !"*+"#","$%&" -# !.*!")$)/$ "0""'# !"*"1#!"($/$ "0"" !,2"$%&" -# 3 /// .+ ( , 4 # #"% %*)0 '% " '1 - "-&") ))(")0$ "()( # "&5* &($ '#&# ' )"'-*))0 ,"&&"#")04678$"

9:&"1"&.# +*&")&&&-#*$#"' "

"1" ))"%, )'#" )#"--,$" --" %*-# $'#&#,",))--*) )"0$1$ ") %*)( # &"")* " *#)0 9* %")( 1*) &);"# ",-'"*0 )"( &&

< # & ")&"*1## 1(%# *%.#&*"),0$"#&)<<=-# *- "$1**"# & )-5*0$

&#))(") %)"'-*))0"&5* )"# &"*'*)%#"%"$#"&"&1*10 #*$"--,"$* # ",&&-# "$ ( %"&" ")) &"&#,$ - "0$ -, # "&5*)"#"- "0"" > #"' $-"&$%(-,# &*10#*$ 4?877<8<<$'#$#*(#" "'4?8><8<>$# "&&'"& --0#)"$'#&##"1"&5*- *1)& * " '#"'"#"%1&,-")"#"-$&*&"9& "&"#9-&"&#,*&#"&5*)"$#10# ("))"'10#*15*%$"*&#"&5*)" %#"&&10%*-#)%""'""#"*- #("))"'- " ? '%$*#)"&.""&")"

"&#-#"*# &&$#*$<887<8<>$#"*&"(&&# ' @* "A$* #)"$1"&")B$"$ $ -#'#&*"",---&"'-,")) "(&$ %)% "&5* - )" - *1)& * $ " #"-$ )"&&#")"&)"(#*1+& ,"$"9"&#"--,#"<887<8<>

!" # $ %

! &"'(

)

+ "

$ ! ! ./0

1! ! 213

4 :

**"#*((#)"'-&,"(& &&$&'%10# ",@A&&* "))# &"&# % # "&5* )" &&$ '#&# (( #

#*##*$#'#0'" (# -*-#))(") %#"&5*)"$"&%&))* '#--&")@A --&@A-# ",-'"*0 )"( &&$#*(#1"(#5*)&&@A-%) ,- &)0@A* #"&5*)"$'#&#%# "$ -"))" * + 1-2-

- = # #"%%.#'+*&-#* 0"(#5*"#(-#-&""#&)""$"* &%)0*&?"=-#"&5*&$436? @#"--"#C&-436?DA$"$")#&5* # '" 1"( ?6/ " <=8>4674 "$ #

#"%*(##5*"#(-#&"4:44<843" <483<8<>$ % &%)0 * # 3 " #

7 #-*#)-@A$"".-#"' $ )"#,".(-","",** # @A&& )" # )"$ ","*( <8: "&$ *" ))"( B"#"# *$#)"&/**(",$-,"&5*$%'- &484-# (# ", """ "&0 "&5*$ #"1)"" ),&$<84>@#"-

-"#C&-<84>DA$"'))"$# )&0"4?86<843$ )"E# )&0- *-*);"F - + 1-21-2 3 # ,"0(*$""("-5*"#(-#, *( "&5*-&"$&)""$"'""&@* "A$)" # 1( &, ) )"&. - .')( # '#) )"' &&# $"1*#"&5* &( @* "A$'##1#"&5*-&"#"'"&&$ "

*0-#"('"%"--#,!%$)0 # $%#(%,"*#&&$'# * )0 ("#5*)&&@A""

%")# $5*"#

)"$"")"))(1*"'"-#"&5* &( @* "A 6 #, *(&@* "A$"*4:44<843" <483<8<>$ &%)0* # 3"# $" "))(1#&*,"&5*"(# '##"&5*

&(@* "A!%$#, *(&@* "A""))( 1))("))0*$ #1(%")"&-"&1"( 43-<848# $ &-# )"$*#

%- "0""%) ," (*)"-1""&$ 467:$-#%) ,-"")&)0# 48

-""#)-)"()"-# )"-, "&5*&&$#",-** E*%"1)0F"E ")0F-# )"-#)%" *1)& * $"# ",,"0**);-# * -'#&##0'"&5*$ "$&5*)0'""1()"$" *)"&484

-#&-<84>$"'))"$# )&0"4?86<843 44 B-' &,".#5*)1"* # *"#"' "#* $ '* *)" -"+*&"#-$,")-"& #-"&*"),"9-# &" +) 4< # )"$")('#,#"&-)"$' 1*(#"&5*10# "$'#)%.(#*(&0 &)"*$-" *1)& * $",)0$-&*&-B"#"# *" -, 8 ?888))"(B"#"# *$#)/*("$& /*("#"&5*-# )"'"#*(#*"&- "-&"""&)""$1#"'848>4674$ &%)0 *&?"=-#&-436?$'#&#'*&&10# "*&,-""'"1"(?6/$<=8>4674 "( -#"'"@* "A$"&, )"&44-#&-436?$#

-#"&5* )"'""*,10#"&5*( "*#0&&$#*(##"'(-" "

"1"(>?3$ <=8>4674)- 4> !%$ # -"&*, 5*" & - # "'" &, "10#&)"'&&$#*(#&&") 10# $#'%$"1"()"&"#'0 *

) 10#)""&*)$'*)&1"#"1%-"&*, 4? ,)0$# #"% *&#"# )" #0"<883$"1*>70""-)"'-*),"-#)%" "&5* &($ " #"-$ #0 ,""( &* # 5*)&&@A-,# ",-'"*0 )"(

&&$ <848$ - # %) , - &)0@A # #)$# -*#)","+ "&)-# )" # 3$#*(#9&*-'--") 4384<847"4=8=<847 4:

'*)1(-&"&##"# 3$ '#"*15*%-# )"$#",""&"(& *1,$ # ' 0 $ 5*" # #"%( 1+& (%"&#"&5* &($", *(#"'

*"))0$-##"1"0))(")0(*)"0# "&5* &(@* "A$# 3$'##" *&#""

,"+ -# )"$,"*("

947:"&$*- ")<8:"&$,"0#"%1#-)"(1"#"' ")0$# 3#"9$""

"#"1%$"

E1+&F#"&5* &(@* "A -) -- - -+ - 4= #)"&*)-# #"%&-*)0 "(*#"$#"1&-* "-#)%"%*&$#

$"")-#%")),1-#(%,,"&#0 &&$'"))0*"'""1*#"&5* &(@* "A *1""#"(*,$##""'"-#*'" " -# ")5" "'" #)"&&$"*1,# &$'"*0 )"(&&$"#,-("-# 5*)&&@A$'#$'" #"# )" '# " -# B"* *&#" $# )&&@A %) &)0 # )"'" (" #

$10# ",&&$'#&#&5*)0,".#

1#1"- *&#"-# )" 47 # -*# "(*,$ " " 10 # )" &*)-# $")0 "-&"-#

)"$,-&484-#&-<84>$"'))"$#

)&0 " 4?86<843 #" "(* #" E*%"1)0F " E ")0F-# )"-#)%" *1)& * $"&&* -,"(0**);%"-:&"-1("&5*$ ,".#,","1)--&" -) -- - -+- - , 43 #)""&*) (# 4 7#"*1,#"# #"%,","")&&"),# ","#"%")," *)"#(")-"& & #"# * 1"- *&#"-# )"10# #"&&*,*&#1)")0"-)"'-*),"-#"&5*

&($ 1$ #" &&* " " +*&*$ '# # (") )"'&&'%-#(#$)"%# "&5* )" #"")&#"))(#"(*, 10# )"&*)-# $'#&#)"*"'"- # "#("))"'&&"1*#"&5*

&( @* "A$ 10 &( # -"&*, 5*" & - # "'" &, "",*10#("))"'$#10*)(# "&.')((#"&5* &(@* "A 46 #)""&*)#"")1*(##&- #*$#"# #"-)"%)*1"(:44-<846 1-#&*-(")+*&"/**(",$#10&#"))(( #,*"$"&-"%*-# (" ",&&$

#0"<843#*(#"))0# '*&&-*)(( "-"*5*10&&")(#,"")-"&$#'%$* # *-"&1( #&*&&$#-"*5*'" %"&"%"4383<8<>#%"&"-#"*5* , )) # *# # * " # ))(")

%#)"'-*))0"&5* )"$*#("1- &#"))(( # "&5* &( @* "A$ '#&# ' )"'-*))0 &&)*:&"1"&. -) -- - -+- , <8 #)"&*)"

"(-# 3#"$" #$*1,#"&# 3$'#'","+

-# )"$#"%"01+&(%"& "("#"&5* &(@* "A$", *(#"

$#-$&"*-"&*%%"")) <4

*#,$#)"&*)-# 3#" ")$)"(*'##)""&*)$"))(#&&"),- ,"")-"&"#"&-# &1"# )"- &&"),$##"*1,#"""*#; "%-#

@A, "0#"*1,"*".($"--"%$# --&")@A --&@A&&-# ",- ("""

*&$ 8644<846$ "(( # *1, ")) # 5* &*, - -,") "

%") " , )," - (* ")(,-#B"#"# *.")$-"0$ "(#*(## )"'10 @A, "0&=7#)%"9"&- #*".('10#"*#;"(-# @A, "0 ""*

! ,5

% $- 6

,89 :

% $- 6

89 :

5 6

, ,

% $- 6

,89 :

5 6

% $- 6

,89 :

4 +- - << #"%,""&, #%"&&")*%0-# &$" )"&1-*%"))&*0-#&#" 1*(#*"%"1)&&)*#"# ,$"#)),%- # 1#*-#' $"" & #))(") %#)"'-*))0"&5* )"$'#&#% # " /%, &&$ - ")) " * #

#"%"0)&*"&#"))(#"&5*

&(@* "A$'#&#')"'-*))0 ,""*:&" 1"&.$#*(#@A#"*&, -"%"))0"'"'"1"(

?6/$ <=8>4674G @A 1*, " & - # "'" &, " ",* 10 # (") )"' &&G " @A "*, - 10#"&5*("*#0&&$% "

" >?3 <> #9&*-"0")5*"#"&5* )"$ 10#("))"'&&$ #)"'-*),"-# "&5* &(@* "A$&5*")%"0(#$) "%#"&5* )"# $'#" ",)0 # *15* %$ " "&5*$ # (") )"'&&'#,)%%-#(#$)" %#"&5*)"#-$-"@* "A$#") $")* 10#)"&*)-# "1)##'# %# )"$ "# ("))"'', '9&*#", #)"'-*) ,"-"&5* &( <? # "1% & ) (" &1" -, " +*(, 10# D1)* ,*$&")

$ " !"#$ '#$#"1#)#""0")$ #*"&-"-&" *&?$%"1" &")"0"0&#"))(# "&5* &($#(#-*&#")$"#)-*&#

)--&%"%#)%"9"&-#+*(, @* "A *&#"- / :

20 %& '& %

(% %('%&%& )%%&%%'&)& %&* ( &

)

&+ %&, (

% ('

-*& -

( ''& .& %&

(/% .'

& &(% #0,/&% .%& '&.

'%, &.'

%,* (&& .% 1 .& *&

& %&(%2 # 5

! 213 ;

21 "

20 ! 213

! ./0

202

3& &('

% % % (/% '

& %&(%!%.&%%&* *& %,0 (1)& & $ %&%

(% (& $ ') , %

(% $ %%'& (

0& (/ & %&'

( ( &('

% (

0& .%%)'

%0&'&.

'$4%

&/% 0'&%.&%&'

(1%* ( & '

) %( * 0'&0& .'

)() * (& (/%

& %&(%2 #3&(%!

& %( &

, .% * ( & )& '& 0 % ( %

& % ' %&

& %&(%!5

&( &

& 0,%&* ( % & %&!(%

( * ( & .

%%&% %& 2 - $ 0 %$- ''%,$ *&

%&$

(

% ('

%& '

&('

% (& %%'& 0&&

( &

& * %('

% %%&'

0&.& 0 (1% !

- "

20 ! 213+

202

! 213

- ! ./0

#( = >

? '

20 ! 213 ;

4 <: #"1% *)"-)"'(-*#"10# D1)* ,*$&") 6&'6&&'* & %% %, 7 &,8'* 89% $

'**& '5!"!$'#$ #"1")0#)#""*15* *&#"#"(# "")"&5* &(#)%" ""("

#-#+*(, @* "A""* 02 @

- 09/.9

2 % . %

A % 1 %

2. % . %

2 % . %

$ ! 03 "

5 ?

= % *

? '

% *

" B

C ! # 5 D 22 *

,= % ?

4 <=

*#,$ #*(# " +*(, &" )

0 7&

& %5 36&'

%& $ 1"( '**& '5!;!$# D1)* ,*#") ", )*1""# & )@* "A10#)(#""*15*

*&#"#")&*")"0&#"))("&5* &( <7 #-$ # *&# - # #"1% &*

-)"'$'#"%#"#)#"#"'

"")),"""1)"#"&-# $ 1(*15*%-#("))"' <3 '$)*"%"#"(*,$","10#)" &*)-# $#""

"-,# "# ("))"'&&$-#%")),1-#(%, ,"&#0 && '" ") "))0 *"'" "1* # "&5*

&(@* "A$"# '("#5*)&&@A %) "")&)0%# )"10# ", && '%$ ' " *"1) "&& # "(*, - # #"-&" <6 #-"-,"#"#, *(-&" "&)""@* "A' *"1)0 *1)##--&")("; "-0# &-"&5*$" &1#&-436? &#%01+&- *1)&"-"-&"#--&")("; ","#(") *1)&$#-$")(") *, "5*".')( &--&""&)""@* "A1( (" 10 # (") *1)&$ &)*( # # )" - *"'"$""#10# $-"#1"&1+&-"

(";-&"1%"))$("&-)"'"9&*%'- #,"9, *

>8 # " - +&( # "1% "(*, ,"" -,#-"&*,$"1*(#&10#)""&*)$#"# % - # #" &% # &, " ",*$ " ,#"'"@* "A#-$'"-)"

-%:

&"$#""0%-# "#"#0 #%'#"%("0.')("1*#"&5*

&(@* "A >4 -""("&-#"&5* &(@* "A$ # "--#),1-#(%,,"&#0&&$ '#&#"#")-#"&5* )"# " #"-$"&&,,"# 1"#5*)&&@A -%) ("")&)0#$"

"1#"'))-*) ("&"("&*9"*&"#&""#" "%%9", )-*#)09*1'1*) &);"# ",-'"*0 )"(&&# )"$ '#&#%'#-# ",-#"/%,$

(" ",$'"&%)0)-"%*-# "%")&&'"("%) ")&)0#$'#&# ,"0#"%1 1)'#*9&-"0&))*#

" # --&")@A --&@A - # ", && #-$ # (" - )&& #

%" 1*) - %) ,-"")&)0%(%,)"$'""" * 1 >< '$-""#&)",-# )"( -&"-# )"-,"&5*&&$' -"0,#&)",# #"%$'#)%.(#

%-&484-#&-<84>"# )&0" 4?86<843$*(#-&"-# )"$# ,$#" # )","0**);-# *1)& * $-'#&# #0 ' 1*(# "&5*$ " #-$ #0 #"% 1&, E*%"1)F"E")F-#"/%, '%$& # " , '$ "# 1" 10 )"'$ " "0 &#"))(#"&5* &($1(*15* *&#"-#

)"$ #- # &)", - # ") (-&"& >> #)$%,$# )""*","1) -1()"-,"&5*#*&") 3&8 & < *',&&

= &

>*&

%&7 *? .(&%,9% % %& ?

%& 1"( @8> "#>!$ #" ," )"1")1"#1+&"& -&484 #&" @* "A$#*#"-,*)"#*&&(&484$ '#&#'"'("%##"-9"&," A<5B C

1,!

! 213

< 4

! ./0

A<5B C

1,!

! ./0 A<5B C

4 >?

#&"@* "A$#*#" &-&"))0#)#"# 1"&1+&1#-&484#&-<84> )"#E**);F"&5*)"$"#","1+& , '#"/%,-0)0*&#)"$'#&##"% 1&,E*%"1)F"E")F--"&)"("0 *1)& * # )%" ""("

# &"0( # "1% 1%" " 9"& #"- 38 5

1,!

4 ,

" *

* 39

! ./0 ! 213

D 6 >

4 >

< 4 ?

< 4

3. !

&E "

1,! ! 213

! ./0

4 3/ ?

4 ,

< 4

- , ,

4 >: !%$ # && - *1)& * #" ") 1 9 )"#&"@* "A$##"-9"&," 3 F

&E "

6 '

% .

= %9

(/% ''&(% $"

';$

), G93 (

(

4 32 5

% %&&

DE 1

8''

"!$ &E "

), 3 5

$ ! ! ./0

8 $ ! !

) ;

H 5

6 (

6 %

;

4 >=

-""# )&0"4?86<843$)"E# )&0-

*-*);"F&&$#)"%&"/")$ "0""#",""",1-#*$ 4?877<8<<$#" #'#"'(-#" )&0$'#&#10#& - &484-#&-<84>$*"&%&"-# /%,- "0"" >7 #-$""5*)##"1%&*,"")$ #&)",-# --&"- )"$"-* * & 484 " # )&0 " 4?86<843$ *'#0 - "&& "&""&&()0+&

+ >3 #1,)-*#"1%,"&*#"# "' "-%)*)0(,""'#

,"")&&"),--"&$'#&# ,10)),%@A$#'" # (-#"$- ")%*")#-$# "' ,'#&- 4$88$888 1-#'# # " *- / ! $#"("# >6 !

%$# &""0 $"#" - # &1($ 5*" # *#)0 " &)" 9* %")( 1*) &);"# ",-'"*0 )"( &&#-$'&#)"#-&"0$/%,- "0"" @A ,,")0 5* -, ")) 5*" &&$ &-#"&5*)"$"#"-$ * &-& & # ", - %* * "#)%"%*& ""),".*&# -,""%")"1)"))# (" *1 ("# "- "0""$#"#")-"&5*)","0 1(-** @A ,".

"5*0#&, ) "( ("-") &-"&5* )" " #* $ -9 # 1)0 - # )5* --&@A --&")@A @A ,".

-%) ,- ")&)0%(%,)"$"#* $-9 #)"1)0-#)5*--&@A --&")@A @%A -#5*0 @A&%$#"1%("$ &"#&,,-"0 ")--&$#* $

&)"*&#(-"

"&,") &("(" #)5*--&@A --&")@A ?8 &, )"& $#"1%("$1*1,# *'#',#-,#"-& -"& 0-# "&-& 0-#1-#'##--&-#)" #-&"0$/%,- "0""$#*(##--&-)" %&"/")$ "0""$-,,""&&, )"& 1--.2 1.+ &'&# (

7"$6 9

8#:

;"$'<8

#$ 6% #<

8 :8

=> % #<