← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6965/2017allowed

Md. Iqbal v. Central Govt. Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court Ii Chd And ORS

2019-07-24Mr. Justice B.S. Walia10 pages



       

  



  

 !" #$ %& $"'%($")$!("*(+*,!($($*- ./$..$ #01   

2

 3456(+$ #$ %& $"'%($")$!("*(+*,!($($*- ./$..$ #01  7 

 0+ "  #$ %& $"'%($")$!("*(+*,!($($*- ./$..$ #01   

7

 3!$ #$ %& $"'%($")$!("*(+*,!($($*- ./$..$ #01   

2

 0+ #$ %& $"'%($")$!("*(+*,!($($*- ./$..$ #01   

2

 %3/.  #$

%& $"'%($")$!("*(+*,!($($*- ./$..$ #01   

 8," #$ %& $"'%($")$!("*(+*,!($($*- ./$..$ #01  2 

7 

 3("6(+$ #$ %& $"'%($")$!("*(+*,!($($*- ./$..$ #01        !"#  $ %"  $ 

$9!.0.$-9% $.1$:; :"".<$1;

$("33-9% $$1 &= :"".<$1;

$04%3.$+-9% $$17&0, :"".<$1;

$<6(+$,/-9% $$1 &<5$ :"".<$1;

$9!.%6"-9% $$1 & &6,"3 :""<$1; *****  $ %"& ' ( &  ). $$ .""     -

2 -

-

7-

2-

2-



7 

++ ( "<  $%"%"".1><%$- $.1($1 /.<$ 1-$"%?" $%$$!5.1$

 

$ <$ 1  " . $"  /$ !5 . $" '% ($")$!("*(+*,!($($*-./$.:.$ $$ $$ .)$!(";.+).+($ * $    %    

")*$ +"# 

"

*    &



 !"

7 

-

&*

7&

 3!$



77 

-

&* 7

2&

 0+

77 

-

&*

7 &

 3("  7 

-

&*

2&

 %3/.

 

7 

-

&* 

&

 0+ "



77 

-

&* 

&

 8,"



 7 

-

&* 2

2 &

 3456(+$



7 

-

&*   @$ . 1($1      . !% + <$ 1- $!/? $+ 

 7 8$    . - "/  . "/   . 1$ <$ 1 $ . $1  & =" $1$ ,+- 1 :.$ $ $ $$   . A=B; // $1 7&0  ,+- 1 :.$ $ $ $$   A0B;  $$ $ (" + 0"<53/-10 $5 $+.5$ <$ 0$17//.$% <5$-C$$. $1 3(!$$:.$ $$ $$AB;). 1$<//(?"""!($.1 '/+!5

  <$? (("5  (. "" 7 

  ><%$- . $% .<$?+<$$$. 

<.(15+ $$.+ +1 $ 5  ). 1$ "  "+ +.%$+...!11.1 '/+ 

/+."5"$5  2&*.$%(("5

$+

7 

<.(5!$?.(.<$?+$ .

5. +.1$/ $$.+ 

-

$+<...<""<4(5-..$%.!

$+ <.( /%/ 5  $ $$.+ +1-  $ ($($3

*@ .($"1(9- :.$ $ $ $$   . A9B;- .  $ $+/ . $%- <$? < !/ ? $+ < <$?$ .$(/.  < $$- . $+   . $% < <.( 5 $- <.$ . .  $/.   $*+1"5+ ($3

*> .A9B@($.$..$+<$/ "+

-<..-.!/$.<$?+ <("!$+%!(1."+-.$%.!$+   01 "<$+:9D($& ;?/ (1...1$.$<$?+<$(/<.(1 .($ .$!5$17- %($7

  %<   D1$5   $+   $ $+ 7

-  



- "/ +1"   $  $+   //+

$+ 7

 < (  .  %$5 <$?+ ($ .$ ?<"/+ $D1$5 .$$-.<$?<"" & 6,"3&01 !5 &0,+&017 <"+.D1$5 .$-.5<$$515. !   11"!" ($ 3

*@   9- !( . <$?$ < +1"5+ ($ . < $$- . . <$?+ . "  +"$ .($ "$%"E(/:3$%;-1-.""//  

-..<$?+.<.$<.+("5/ .@9(-...!($%"".+$1  .<$?).$ $-. ( ( $%$?/ !?.<$?++1"5+$   ,?<- 0 " " $1"5 :9D($ & ; .  $ +1" <$?$$ %($ 7

:<$/"5<$



7;-.(""!($<$$$.(<$?( </%.+!5.5<$"1.$/$(5<... <$?$$ (-..$<<$? $ 5 $.$$$.+  $//+ </5-<1((1.

 !$-

$/+1"5+!5</5 &6,3$1  -!("5 ( 7 <$?+11$<$//-$ . <$?+.<5$<$?<..D//5-. "!"5<"+<.<1(".$1"5  01    & 6 ,"  3 " "  $1"5 :9D($ &;- / . 0 . <$ . $   < 



..11<$? +< 7

D1$5 .$$..1!$ .

$ $51$+

$.<$?+$1$ $<$? <. $1  $ < 11+ !( "5  <$?+ 4- <.$.$<<$?.$<$+-<..<1!"- ..(<.( .<$?+-"5 .!$*// $   . <$?+ <$ $."5 $$(   $-  +!"  =&10 $5  =?(1.! $.)$!(".../ <.."!($//!5.$$$17  . . <$?+ . ! // !5 $1 7     $$ 2 ). )$!("  . !   % " ! $  +  . "(.<1(.=./%$ $.(" + 0"<53/-10 $5 $+ <$0 .0//.$% 3(!$$-..$+ 11+ .<$?+.!1". "1$!!"5 $

.$.(.$+.!$(<$/-.<. +..("+$ <D  $7

</%!5$17$1 - ..!/%.%$5<$?+ 

:FD

* ;-  $+/ . .$ //+ <(" +    $+ 7

-.$ $+ $"<5$?<("+ 9$/"5-.$<<$?<.$1 -.$% .<$?+<$$+ $/%/.+ 

). "$)$!("?(...$!1"$1$% ..$<5$!<$1 .<$?+. . $%   . <$?+ <(" +    (+""5  . $+ .$!<$17-    )."$)$!("?(.".(/.$1  ./%.<$?+:FD * ; 

-. .$!1"$1$%..<$?+.!1$$.+ +1=.$$5-.!1"!5$1 . <$515.! 11"!"($3

*@ .9!( . <$?+ < +1"5+ ($ . < $$  ).(-  < +!5$1 .$$.++1<1 . <$?+  7

   <. . $% <$ $$.  ("5-.$+ .$% .<$?+<""/"     . !?/$(   . $ $ +   $"<5 $?!<=..$17 ..$ . .%/ +   - . "$ )$!(" ." . . <$?+ ("!$$!$:%$"5<$!%-".(/. (/.$$ $+ $"<5$?!< $17 +-.<$?+("!$$

!$$%1$("$"5($$1 <.<.+.. %$ <$?;- .$ $- . 1$*<$?+ < $$  ! 1 $$.+ +1   

-

&*  < ($.$ $$ . . <$?+ <("!" $%$  (+   

-

&* $+ $1     4"5  %$"5    $1   1 . +(-  <("!"!$5$%$.+ $+$17    ).+(!+ "$(" $.1$. %< "+

:9D($&;!<$1 7 .="0 $5$?$C($3 :7;$ <.32:7; .9$1 7 <$?$"(/.1$- /$/ . "" (. + . + $ $+ <. $17-$17<("($.<<$?+< 11  1" . 1$ <$?+ "" .  $$+&$/ .<$?+-.$ $-."+<!/ $17 1$32 .9- (""5-. <$?+<"$+    ,$(".1."+:9D($ &FD*& ;.%/!D.!1$%! $."$ )$!("- . "$ )$!(" "  ?  ( . $/.   . 1$  $+   . "+  . %$  (    .$ . "+ 9 1$("  ."+ :FD& ;  9D($ &  

 !< $1 7-   . =" 0 $5$?$C($3 :7;$<.32:7; . 9$%".""(.+-.+$ ($+ <.0-0<($.<<$?+<// .D/<$?+-"". $$+&$/ (.D/ <$?+

7  ,$(".<(+!(10. 1$1"$$($.($/.15 .$<.- ."+<.$<<$?+<//1" .D/<$?+D1<.$.5.$$$$/.. $(+-  <- 11$ . .    0 <  "( . "+:FD& ;1$%.1$:;*<$?+ .$ $/.$+ ."+-!5$$/ $.$$(+/%/ <11+<$?+!5//$.<$$ $1     ,$ ("  .  <(" .% !  

$ 1"/.$-..1$*<$?+!(<.(5 !$?!(<% $+. 0- &6," 3-.<$?!5$17 117

 $. 11+ < /$  . <$?+ ($ 01   <.( ?/(.$/.B .1$&<$?+.%(5 $%  1$ . "+ ,$ ("  . . 1$ $$%.$$/.?($3 .9 $!$. . "+!(1$ $+."!"5 $1"5 !$. "+-. 1$ $ "  11$1$ +    . 9<$ !5 $+ .1$*<$?+($$17%< . "+<. (""!?</(5 $%    ,$ (" $ $1 7  . .$ .  . .5 <$ $5  15 $$.+ +1  1$ 3

@ .9%$5/. D1$5 $  

$ . ! D % ! $ . " 

$ "- .<%$ . <$?+ .+"%  1/ +1  ++1"5+($.<$$&$1 <.<.+

.5 .  4 1   .%/ ! 1( (1 ""/ . " <$?+  4 ).$ $ .$ <  %"   . +$5 1$% .9$ ."+.1$ .$1   .%$.(!+ ."$(" $. 1$  1$( . $"% $$  +5 $ 1- . "+:9D($&;$5""$.1$$!(1$ 32 .9.$.$+.$$

1"5+1"($3 .9><%$-."$ )$!("?(."+:FD& ;01"5 " !5$1 * &6,"3"$ "1$/$1. . <. < 

$  . 1$ < $. :< 11+; <.$ "+ < $$%   

 !< . +/+  $17 .="0 $5$?$C($3 :8;$<.32:7; .9FD& :9D($&;-. ""(.+.+$ ($+<.0-0 <(" ($ .  < <$?+ < 11 1"  . D/ <$?+ "" .    $$+&$/  0"% D$   . "+$1$(($ * G)$+ .3"+ *  /$."".+.+$ (<. 0)F3,-0)F3,<""($.<<$?+1" . 1$<$?+11"". $$+&$/H 9$/"5-."/. .1!%-"$. $+ "+:FD& ;-<(+!

(1$17 ($.<<$?+<//1" .D/<$?+- "". $$+&$/ .1$*<$?+><%$- .!!%-.$% .1$*<$?

7

-<.(15/5$$.++1-<.$ $ <1((1.!$-""/"5!5$1 -

$/ <   $. 11+  3 $1     "/$  . 1($-.$1!"5 $($/.$."++"5. <<$?+<("!//1" D/<$?+-"" $$+&$/- $ D"(%"5  $1 7  .$  $1 7 ($ .$  . $+   "+ $  $1 +?15+ $$.++1-.+ $+ $% .1$*<$?+   .$(+-9<$ 2 

:9D($&;- + 017$($.$.$+ . "+

:FD& ;.9D($&  (.$ -.1$*<$?+.""!$.""! .$1!"5 $17($.<$?+/(5- $<.."+:FD& ;).1$*<$?+ $$!$<.(5 $% (""!?</-<." "%/  1  . 1$  ? ( 11$1$ 1$/ ($ 3 .9 $%"!5$17 ."+ :FD& ; .++1"<.$!% 2  $1, ). $+$+        ' $ %"( )-  ./0&/123 A04.B ..$1?/&$

I& ..$$1$!"

I&