Neeraj Kumar v. Davinder Pal Singh & ORS
!"# $#%&'&() ** ##+!,-./!+ 011#22!(" 3#+'.' !4&($#+!25&(67!($"7#+' 0#'1($#("' ) 89 5
5:9 +#'#(") ++!"##;!"7##<$4%!"# + +!,#'7 !.+<$4%!"# +"7#!11#22!(" +3&1.2<$4%!"# + +&"&( &""!2< $4%!"# ++#'1($#(" + 55!=7(#><$4%!"# ++#'1($#(" +57&4!/ +4#+<$4%!"# + ' !(,!++.-!.2<$4%!"# ++#'1($#(" ???
@A
2!&/ &' + #(7!(%#/#(" %/1#('!"&( !=!+$#$ B> "7# 2#!+(#$ "+%%&$#(" 2!&/'+&B.(!2</B!2!7#+#&(!
"#++# #++#$"!' C"7#+&B.(!2D"##+!,-./!+!11#22!("(!%%.(" &(,.+>'.'"!&(#$ B>7&/&(!(!%%&$#("(E +#'.2"&(6&(!/1."!"&( 7&'+&67"2#6 ( @A 9#!+(#$%.('#2 +"7#!11#22!("7!'%( &(#$7&'!+6./#("" '##;&(6#(7!(%#/#(" %/1#('!"&(("7#6+.($"7!""7#!11#22!("=!'
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
<GF1#+/("7!'1#++!"#' /&(&/./=!6#'1!>!B2# +"7#+#2#4!(" 1#+&$ &' 1#+ #%"2> ,.'"& &#$ !($ $#' (" %!22 + !(> &("#+ #+#(%# =7!"'#4#+ @A %%+$&(62>< &($&(6 ( /#+&" &( "7# !11#!2< "7# '!/# &' $&'/&''#$5&(%#<"7#!11#!27!'B##($&'/&''#$(/#+&"'<"7#+# +#<"7# !112&%!"&(''##;&(6%($(!"&( E$!>'8$#2!>&(2!"# &2&(6!($
$!>'8 $#2!> &( +# &2&(6 "7# !11#!2 !+# /#+#2> !%!$#/&% &/1+"!(%#
('#J.#("2><"7#'!/#!+#!2'$&'/&''#$ 5:!2&! .$6# ** !/&" :7#"7#+'1#!;&(6G+#!'(#$ ) #'G :7#"7#++#1+"!B2# ) #'G