Ashima Munjal v. Mahesh Chander Munjal And Others



 


   !"!#!

$!! !
!# !






































 










%&%


 




  
  




  
!"   
 !'

(") % *
+!

! *   

 
#$
%&'
%$(
)"* 
'
!

 
)+',
-'(
%
)"*
.'


+
/#(
)"*
 !"
0 1(
2

3

%.!4
/#(
)"*
 !"
0 
"
  +!

! *   ,  

4 5'
4
!! &

$'4

'
!
#"
!

,
'
' .44
$
"

 ,
" 

&*

'
 
 "!

!!4
4"
$,
!
"


4
1

 6
"
!!4
4"
"

(


#
$"

#



 5'
4
 !"
0 1(
2

3(
.'4
#!&&
' #$4,

'

4"
$ 
'
 

*4
7"&
7

*(
8"'
 '
$#
'
'
!!4
4"
$,
' &
!"
"


4
1
 6
"
"

 4
11
 
 
44
!"&

"!4
$ 
'
 
"

'


4"
4.
'
 4,
'
"
!!4
4"
"


4
1
"
11
 
 

$
"!"

$,
'
 
 "


 "
.'
4.
"
' 
!!4
4"
"


4
1


 6
"
"


 

$
" "

5'
4

'
!"
$#
'
'
.44
$
"
  ,
" 

&*

'
 

 4,
"!
 !!4
4"
"


4
1
"
11
 5'
4
!! &

$'4

'
!

'*&
 $9

,
'
" 

&*

'
 
$
 '

#"
!

,
'

!!4
4"
"


4
1
"
11 

 
"""
&
'
!"
'
'
 
'4"

$
+"

:!"
'
"!4

!!4
4"
"

 4
1


 6
"

 ;
*.

'
$*(
!


*4
*

!

' $,
"!"


.'
" 

'
 

 4,
"!

!!4 4"
$,
'
!"
"


4
1
"
11
 
.'

",

'
:
"
:"

'
*4
(

 "
.'
4.( 
' &
$'
'
! (
"

(
'
 "
!!4  
44."
'

 '



$
+
$,
'
 
$






"#4

'
!!4(
'
 
'4"
:!" '
"!4

!!4
4"
$,
'
!
"

 4
1


 6
"


!

 $4,
.'

! "
 :
1
#'

'
"!4

'
!!4
4"
"

 4
1
"
11
 5'
!
"
"!"


'
 "
 #(
.' :!

&
,
!

'
# 

'









 +!

! *  %&% 

# 

 -*.

./ Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No