High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4666/2015disposed of

Subhash And ORS v. Jaiveer Singh And ORS

2017-09-08Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh3 pages

!"#$!$%& ' (

)

*!+!%,& *-./0!*1% $2"1,!

*,0!133!441%,+ *12!!%*1,13/#%50 $2"1,!

**!+3%$!%,

0! "41#61%,+ 1*! #% 133!14 +!!7#%5 !%01%"!6!%,

"63!%+1,#%#%*!51*$,$!1,0 01%$!*7141#%16,*2!0#"841* 1""#$!%,,01,,7341"!% )

9 0!*#:8%14 :;*!4;#%583%,0!"*#,!*#13*2#$!$#% %$ /"0!$84!133!%$!$,/!",#% 9< ,0!,*-!0#"4!+", (''

01+1++!++!$1%%814$!3!%$!%";1,+'

=<:;,17#%5#%,"%+#$!*1,#%

=9*$#%"6! 08+:1%$ ,0!$!"!1+!$1%$ 8*,0!*$!$8",!$ =9*$>81 +,1%$1*$$!$8",#% ,!*1334;#%5684,#34#!* 4++ $!3!%$!%";

01+:!!%1++!++!$1,+

=<%1$$#,#% 1%168%, +

=< ,?1*$+ 8%!*141%$41+,*#,!+!@3!%+!+ +

=< *4++ "%+*,#86 1%$ +

=< * 4++ !+,1,! 01+ :!!% 1?1*$!$ 617#%5 ,,14 "63!%+1,#%,+

=< 8%+!4 * ,0! 133!441%,+ 01+ +8:6#,,!$ ,01, 1+ ,0! 1334#"1,#% *"63!%+1,#%?1+ #4!$8%$!*/!",#% ,0!,*

-!0#"4!+", ('' #%+0*,,0!A",A ,0!*#:8%1401+"66#,,!$1 5*++!***:;*!4;#%583% %$ /"0!$84!?0#"0#+6!1%, *144?#%5 "63!%+1,#%8%$!*/!",#% 9< ,0!",%,0!*+8:6#++#%61$!

:;"8%+!4#+,01,,0!$!"!1+!$4!

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

"1,!%1 B8$56!%,+%,0!#++8!1+,0?+!*2#"!+ 108+!?# !1*!, :!2148!$ *,0!38*3+! 1++!++#%5B8+,"63!%+1,#%8%$!*/!",#%

,0! ", %$!* ,0! "#*"86+,1%"!+ #%$#%5+ *!"*$!$ :; ,0!

*#:8%141++!++#%54++ $!3!%$!%";1*!,0!*!+84, %%<1334#"1,#%

6#%$ +,0!$!"!1+!$4!

,:!0#%$ 16#4; #2!6!6:!*+#%"48$#%5 ,0*!!$1850,!*+1%$16#%*+%"834!$?#,0+"#14+,1,8+ 16#4;

,0!$!"!1+!$ 2148! +!*2#"!+ ,0!$!"!1+!$#+1++!++!$1,+

=< 3!*6%,0$!$8",#% *3!*+%14!@3!%+!+#+3!*6#++#:4!#%,0!4#50, #2#+#%!%"0A+B8$56!%, ,0#+8*,#%"1+!

#2#4 '(%

2#!? ,0!1:2!

4++ $!3!%$!%";"6!+, +

=<C

C +(

=< %$!*"%2!%,#%140!1$+ ,0!"41#61%,++0144:!!%,#,4!$, ,0! 44?#%5"63!%+1,#%&< @3!%+!+% 8%!*141%$41+,*#,!+D+

=< E++ "%+*,#86,,0!08+:1%$D+ 41" E++ 42!1%$1

!",#%,,0!"0#4$*!%<+ 41"+ 63!%+1,#% +

=< *4++ !+,1,!1?1*$!$:;,0!

,*#:8%14 #+ *$!*!$ , :! +!, 1+#$! ,14 "63!%+1,#% "6!+ , +

=<1%$1$$#,#%14168%, +

=< +

31;1:4!?#,0#%,!*!+,F)G3!*1%%86 *6,0!$1,!

3!,#,#%,#44*!14#H1,#%#+,:!+01*!$:;"0#4$*!% ,0!$!"!1+!$#%,0!

*1,#

& *!+3!",#2!4;0!168%, "63!%+1,#%+0144:!

$!3+#,!$#%,0!*!+3!",#2!%16!+ "0#4$*!%#% #@!$$!3+#,*!"!#3, *1 3!*#$ ,0*!!;!1*+*,#44,0!6#%*"0#4$1,,1#%+,0!15! 61B*#,;

?0#"0!2!*#+41,!* 33!14#+31*,;144?!$#%,0!1 *!+1#$,!*6+

!"" # $ %&'

' (

) +$ I0!,0!*+3!17#%5=*!1+%!$ !+= I0!,0!*!3*,1:4!

!+=