Vikram Singh Chouhan v. State Of Haryana


   

   

 


 
  $'()*+(,-.-)/ 0 

 






 


5
 



  %& ( 
    




  
6

  
7(.

) 
 

6
3
7

/'
7((

'
7(.

)
1 '
  


88888 

! "

#$%& 

 

& 
& 
"

"
'(
 (
)
<;

  
 
 
 

 

"
(

= =  !
  

&95 )& 
"'
 

) )
"
# #$%
 :

((

,

-
 (
 
  )
&  "'

'
 (
) 
-"!

 +
7)
2;-

 ')
 * '


+)
* '


.

#$ $%

4
')


,

-
 ')
).(
)("'


 ''  )
 () /  (.('

'
'
0


 (
1 1('
/
 & 
)

)



)
"
 

"
%-,9 :- 
7)


    


/
'(
 (
&

 )&
 (
 &)   (
. )'

 '

-
'


 ( (
2


& 
& &

!
/ 
) .(
3 
))(
/
 "4 '
&&  ((
 (



()'

 
 
/
) ((

)) ( )
/ 
& )( 
+
  
) 9))(
0 


.'(


(

& )(


'


& 






₹

 
 


 
& 9  !


> (
)  '
 
& 

(
 





"
''
&')(

 
&  
)
 ''

"
()'

 
 
(
"
) 9)) )(
0



/

/ /
&&  ( ((
/
-
'


 (
2


) 
& 
&  !
> (
)  '

 
(
 

) .
 


)

)

 

 ) 
 '

"
)(
 
#  
 


 (& ( 
)  "

.
.( )
' 


 
'' (
  )
 (


( 
  (
 
 
#$%
3 '
"

&') 

 " (
()'


 

9))(

$

 
 (
"
'  (
)  '
 
 
'' (
)

.
)(
 
 9)) (
''
 ( 
 
)


9) ) )'
4 
 (
  
 "
 (
) ) :

+
7)
2;-

)(

 
& 
) 
$

" 
 
 (
 




'
"
 &(

  
) 
 (
 
"

)

2

+
7)
/





"
  
'

"'

 

)
&)

 .

'.  

 
) 

 )

> (
)  '
 




  (
 ))


/



;9 9

'(
 '
"(/ 

'
/

'(
.

'
&& 
 '(
) 
 (
( &
&)''

 


'
.( )
 

$

"
 
 (

 


(
 
) ( ('
  


 ) 
 
 "
) .( (
 
> (
)  '

 


  


.( 
& )

'/
 (
 (

)

&
 ''

/ 
 

$

@
" (
"
 
' (
)  '
 

(

?


 
 .
 (
 )

'
&& & 
'(
" 
.(
"
 ( 
" (
 
"
B
 
"
   (
" 
  

  
&

 (
 

<

 
' (

)  '

&& (
   
 )&


"'
 
"
   
'' 
 (
 




 

 

7)) (
' (
 
 '
 

).'
 .

'.

.(

 
'')
(

)

)

 (

 '

 
&  
)


 
 )  
# 


 
/
 
&&'

'

) 
& 
& !
 /
" 4 '
) .(
 
 &  9))(
0 


 ( (
1('

,

-
 ''

'

/ 
)&

)("'
 &))
 )
  
"
 
& ')

> (

)  '

 '


) .

''
/ 
9) )'
)



 )
 (
 ()


 
) )  
(


 .

'. 


/(
@ @

) )
)
). 

%

&
;

&'
((
2 2 :

-

6

  
+& &
&  ( 

 ')
A!
* '
' (

)  '
"
 
&') ) 


) '

))( '
"

"( (
)
'(
(.'

&(
(
 .
 (
 
are CDR (C Call Detail Re cord) available with the prosecut tion so as to show the culpability y of the petitio oner. Furthermore,  
" '
 

 
 
 
 '

&


 .
 (
"

'(
 &
/ /
.( )

 ' )

/ / 
 

/


 
"
)&"'

'

&

 ( 
1 1.
 .
 )
' 
&"

"')
 
 .

'.(

)" 
 )

(
) 


 0
'
 
 

) ()


'


 
&) ''
"( (
 
 
( 
( .
 ) 
 )& 
"'
 (
 

&(
 
 
& 
&

(.

"
((


-
$
.
(
 
' (
)  '
 
.'
&
 (

.


 


.'"'
) (
)
,
7
&
 
)
&
 
 
#$%

4 
 (""

"'
 
'

' 
.
"
'.''(
  
 
$
 
  
) ( (


,

-
 ') )
)
&))
 (
)( "'
 ''  ) )
&&  ((
/
 (.( '
'
0


 1('
9))(!
/

/
  (
  & 
) )
" )
 

)
" 
 
 
%-,9 :

:- 
3 
 )& 
. )'
'(
 
) .

-
'


 ( (
2


& 
& &

!

 " )

. (
 (
 
&  . 

) )
+ 
 )



&)
" )
7)
2;-
# '

''

/ 

 
()'


  

))(
/
) (( (

)) ( )
/
'/
 "

"'
9)) (
0



( 

  
&)) ''
()'

(
(
& )(

 '


& 
  

( 
₹

59
 
 
&  
& 
'



 
3 
 
 
 
"


&')



 
&  
)

7
 
 
 
''

(
 .

'. 


 ((
& & )&''

()'


  
(
"
 
) 9)) (
&'(
/ / 
@ )
''
+'

%) (
+%!
/ 

&

  )
 ()
)  ) )
 (

( 

 ) "/
 
 (
 9)) (
 "


 
&  "'
&') 

  )

:

$



(&



) .
)(
 
 ))(
   

-
'


 (
2


) 
& 
&  !

) )''
''
/ 
 
" 


9) )'
4  

( (
  (
 
+
7)
 /.

)') 
) . (


9) )'

'
) 
"
(


 ) 


.'


 .
 )

  '
 '


 
" (
) 

'')
) )
&&'

#  

"
&')(

" 

&))
()'


(
"
9)) (
0



/

(   
)

)''
 (
(
& )(

'


&


 
 





( 
$
(( 
()'


 
& )


'
(
 
@  )
''
+'
%) (
+ %!

) )) ( 
 .


 )
" 
)  )  (
 )
"/
 
 (
 9))(
 "
' ( ( 
 
)( )
 
'' 
 .

'. 


;



'' 
) &'(
/ 
& "'

"
&


' 
@
(

 
 '/'
( ) )
 " )

 
) )  
 
) 
"
" (
( 


)  
 
 . 
3 
&&  
@&(
"
& )


 

'( (

"'

") (

& &
  ' )
/ 
/


"
.'  "'

) )
'
&&


"


/


"

1.
 
  
 )
 
 
 "'

& 
/
.( )
") ?)
  (
 .)
&"')
  

( 
 ) ) )
( (
) 





./
 
 
(



 ) 
"'

 
? ) 


6 .

./

 
 1
'' 
 
) ('
   
 (&  "'
 (
))'
 
 


" (
) &)
 ( 


&  '
)) &') 
 

"
/ 
 
@)' .
/'(


&  
&  
6 .
  

 )&


"'

 
&
 
 
 '
&?()


 (
&  ''
'
 
&
/
.( )

 ' )

'
/ 
2
$

"
  
 
/ '
) (

&'

 

  )& 
"'





4'"
"/
 ( (  (.('

'



 (
& )
 ) '
 !
3




 )
/  
 (
 (

 )C
 
 '
"( (
 
)) (C
 
(
 

 (

 .

' 
(&
 /(
& &)

)
'' (
 4


 )
$

&.
 .
&

 
 )
)
@&)

 & 

 
 "

( ( D


 
   
7
 
 
 


'

) ( (


'(
 

)


( (

  
 
3 '
/ 
) 

) (
 (
& &' 
 . 
&& "
"' (

 "'
"
 
 )) 
3  


&& & &
  
 )& 
"'
 


/

'(
)'

'
)
&( 

) .
 . 

$

  
 



   



     
 
&



'(

 (



&;2
&
,!



 
 






 
  





 
 


 
  


 


 



 





 
  
" 

#$%



 


 

!
 
  





  
 



  
 

  

 
  
 


 

 
 






  
"  


  





 


  
 





 
   
 
  


 

 

 






  

 
) 

  










 


 

(
  
  
 
  




 







 



'  

 
  





  !
 !
 
   


  


  


 
 
(




 

 


  
 




   


 





 

 
 




   



  *

  






  

 
7)) ( '






) ((
&  
( 
(.
 ) 
 )& 
"'

 
) '
'

)

 (
6 . 
) ('
  

)
 

).
 .
D

 .'
 
  


 
(.

(


 ( (

"
((



(
 "

.


''
"
((

"

@& 

& 

&


)5 .



 
 (
&&') !

  
 ''
'
 (
(& (

0'
<

&'
  "



&  



-
 
& 5 ( F5  
& "'
F5