High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4688/2015allowed

Raj Rani And ORS v. Dharam Pal And ORS

2018-10-10Mr. Justice B.S. Walia9 pages

"%&#&'( )

$ *+% ", " " #%-&.( //00&11" %( 2&.(3( -"."+ "1" #%-&.( / &(0 #& %(

.&(& %) .*" #&&02&.+"4#5'"%&. .*36-#&&0 ".+".4#5'"%&.%-&"00&11" %( . 7-"3#-".84#5'"%&..&(0 #& % *&.5'&.&(0 #& % #(0& (&#9%-5#&.#&.#"%&#

$ . ".#&&08"14#5'"%&..&(0 #& % :::

.%-&.&"( ("(".&+& % &# %-&"001'"% 4%-&("+&( "119&#&1"8 $#"8( 1"%&1 ;%-&"00&"1(' # &#(3<,&'% %"11,3(%&='&0% ( ## !" >? @&". &# '3 (&1 . %-& "00&11" %( -"( 1&# 5&. +& % ".8" "1&%%&.<&". ; !$ ABA4#"%&#

((3&#<8%-&

$ % @"<3. ++(( &.4 ".8" " 3.% %#"8 -& ("+& ( %"6& .&'.#"(".6 > ? &".#1&". &#'3 (&1.%-&0".%&( >? -& (%" %"00&"1-"(<&& 1&#<8%-&9#94%-.&&#"3;-%&.( " # &( #&'&"(&# ",<.9-#&# "+%.5&-'31"."''#& %

% &&#( %' ;-&.&%-"%3%%-.&&#"3;-%&.(4 18 &( + .C<&(#&(4&5& %-&( 9"(+ ."( %-&#"%&"''#& %" # & %-&+",.#"3;-%&.(".&+"..&#-&#&'&"(&#9"(" ";.'31%3.(%-& 1&". &#%.''#& %(1"+(.<3 "14 " 0"%D-&.& "%&..&&..&#% "(E%-&.<3 "1FG<8%"6 ; %"''3 %%-& % "1 '+&%-&#&'&"(&# "(

!0&.+ %-C<8+"6 ;#&#3'% !%-%-& '+&%-& #&'&"(&# %9".#( -( 0&.( "1 &=0& (&(C <8 "0018 ; +31%01&. 4 9.6&#3%#&0& #& '8" #<8"9".# ;"(3+

! "''3 % 1((' (.%3+" #

! "''3 %3 &."1&=0& (&(4"9".#&# %%"1'+0& ("% 4B

!"1 ;9%- %&.&(%HA I0&." 3+ 9%-&&'%.+%-&#"%&'1"+0&%% %11#"%&.&"1J% >? @&". &# '3 (&1 . %-& "00&11" %( -"( ."(&# 3.1# (3<+(( (.& -" '&+& %'+0& ("% "9".#&#@&". &#'3 (&1 ' %& #(%-"%%-&+ +3+9";&(." 3 (611&#1"<3.&.#3. ;" 3".8

%-&*%"%&".8" ""(0&.%-&".&+& % &#1&%%&.".8" " 5&. +& %49"($AA0&.+ %-&$ 0&.#"8-&.&.&4%-& '+&%-&#&'&"(&#9"(1"<1&%<&%"6& %"''3 %"%$AA0&. + %- D.3 #&# $

! 0&. + %-G "( ";" (%

! 0&. + %- "((&((&#<8%-&1&". &#.<3 "1 *&' #184 1&". &# '3 (&1 ' %& #&# %-"% 3%3.& 0.(0&'%( 9&.&"9".#&#%-3;-#&'&"(&#<& ;8&".(";&4%-&"00&11" %(9&.&

$ % & %%1&# % "9".# 3%3.& 0.(0&'%( <8 %"6 ; % "''3 %

I %-& &(%"<1(-&# '+&%-&#&'&"(&#+ 3(%-&%"='+0 & %.%-&03.0(& 9.6 ;3%%-&3%3.&0.(0&'%(0"8"<1& "''.#" '&9%- ".";."0- D5G %-& #&'( F<1& %-& *30.&+& 3.% &'()&* )+,-&)./01&)2 (0('/34 5-&)&2/'6(&)3'6/-+ !7 (4(*!!8 @&". &#'3 (&1' %& #&#%-"% "''.#" '&9%-0".";."0- D5G%-&#&'( F<1&%-&*30.&+&3.% ." "8*&%-F( '"(& D*30."G4 %-& "00&11" %( 9&.& & %%1&# % 1(( &(%"%& "%

! 9-'-9"( %"9".#&#<8%-&.<3 "1" #%-&"+3 %

!"9".#&# "''3 %3 &."1&=0& (&(9"(1"<1&%<&& -" '&#%

!9-1& "''.#" '&9%-0".";."0-$A%-&#&'( F<1&%-&*30.&+& 3.% &90&:/)/-&*)+,-&)./ '3 4 &),&0*(&+6,6-, &0&)3'6/-+3/.(3/3)# !8 !#()(4(*11/&* 8"# !#4 &"'-%-&5&"00&11" %(9&.&& %%1&#%"9".#

! "''3 % 1((' (.%3+ @"(%184 1&". &# '3 (&1 ' %& #&# %-"% %-& ."%& %&.&(% "9".#&# 9"( %-& 19&. (#& " # + +3+ BI 3;-% % -"5& <&& "9".#&# "''.#" '& 9%- %-& #&'( ,;/ ()96 &)3 &)'6/- 4 62&0()96</&3&)3'6/-+ !# (4(* > ? @&". &#'3 (&1"00&". ;..&(0 #& %D&#.5&.G %-&%-&.-" #' %& #(%-"%'+0& ("% "9".#&#<8%-&1&". &#.<3 "1 (,3(%" #0.0&. >? @&". &# '3 (&1 "00&". ; <&-"1 .&(0 #& % (3." '&+0" 8-"( %#(03%&#%-&"'%3"1.1&;"10(% "( %&# "<5&

$% >A? -"5& ' (#&.&# %-& (3<+(( ( 1&". &# '3 (&1 . %-& "00&11" %("(9&11"(1&". &#'3 (&1..&(0 #& %D&#.5&.G" # .&(0 #& % 9- -"5& ".;3&# %-"% %-& '+0& ("% "9".#&# <8 %-& 1&". &#.<3 "1(,3(%" #"." ##&( %9".." % %&.&.& '& >$? -&"00&"1(%-&8&".

9-1&%-&"''#& %%601"'&

4 %-&.&.&4 "+ % '1 &# % "#,3. %-& +"%%&. "5 ; ' (#&.&# %-& ".;3+& %( 1&". &# '3 (&1 . %-& "00&11" % " # .&(0 #& %4%&+&.;&(%-"%"(0&.%-&("#".8" "5&. +& %F(1&%%&. ((3&# <8 %-& @"<3. ++(( &.4 ".8" "4 " 3".8

4 %-& + +3+ 9";&( . " 3 (611&# 1"<3.&. 9"( $AA 0&. + %- D.3 #&#$

!0&.+ %-G&$ 0&.#"8 >B? %-& (%" %"00&"14%-&#&'&"(&#9"(" ";.'31%3.(%49 &# (+&1" #C<&(#&(43(&#%%"6&(+&1" # 1&"(&" #'31%5"%&%-&("+& -&.<3 "19-1&-1# ;%-"% .&5& 3&.&'.#9"(0.#3'&#% #'"%& %-"% %-& #&'&"(&# 9 &# " 8 ";.'31%3.& 1" # . '31%5"%&# 1" # 1&"(&4 %6 %"''3 %%-"%&5& "#"189";&.9"("<1&%&". ".3 #

! 0&.+ %--3("1%-3;-4%-&+ +3+9";&(" 3 (611&#1"<3.&.( $AA 0&. + %- D.3 #&# $

! 0&. + %-G4 8&% &&1 %-"% %-& "((&((+& % % "1 '+&%-&#&'&"(&#"%

!0&.+ %-<8%-& .<3 "1 #&( % 9".." % " 8 %&.&.& '&4 ( '& % '" .&"( "<18 <& 0.&(3+&#%-"%%-&#&'&"(&#931# %-"5&;%9.6 "11#"8("+ %- > ? #+%%&#184 %-& #&'&"(&# 9"( (&1&+018&# " # 8&".( ";&"%%-&%+&-(#&"%-4%-&.&.&4 "''.#" '&9%- ".";."0- D5G %-& #&'( F<1&%-& *30.&+& 3.% ." "8 *&%-F('"(& D*30."G4" "##%

I%-&&(%"<1(-&# '+&%-&#&'&"(&#+ 3( %-& %"= '+0 & % ( % <& %"6& % "''3 % . 9.6 ; 3% 3%3.&

$"% 0.(0&'%( ".";."0- D5G %-& #&'( ." "8 *&%-F( '"(& D(30."G(.&0.#3'&#"(3 #&.) K

"# $%

" >? @6&9(&4 %&.+( ".";."0-D5G%-&#&'( F<1&%-&*30.&+&3.% ." "8*&%-F('"(&D*30."G4%-&"00&11" %( ".&& %%1&#%

! "''3 %1((&(%"%&4

!.3 &."1 &=0& (&( ".";."0- D5G %-& #&'( ." "8 *&%-F( '"(& D(30."G(.&0.#3'&#"(3 #&.) ' (

( "%

) ( "

)

( "%

)

"* &(#&(4"00&11" %(9-".&9&" #3.'-1#.& #&'&"(&#

",<.931#<&-&1#& %%1&#%"9".#'+0& ("%

!&"'- "''3 %1((' (.%3+ 5&9#&'( F<1&%-&*30.&+& 3.% &90&:/)/-&*)+,-&)./ + .&+/ ,1-& &1&5" %&=%."'% %-&#&'( ";+"& &."1 (3." '&F('"(&D*30."G(.&0.#3'&#"( 3 #&.)

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

".& %"1 ' (.%3+ ( ;." %&# % %-& '-1# 30 %-&0.&+"%3.&#&"%-"0".& %4.1((K0".& %"1"#4 0.%&'% 4 "&'% 4 ('&%84 #('01 &4 ;3#" '& " # %." ;L

1"1 ' (.%3+ ( %-& .;-% %-& 0".& %( % '+0& ("% %-& '"(& " "''#& %"1 #&"%- " '-1# "''#& %1&"# ;%%-&#&"%-"'-1#'"3(&( ;.&"%(-'6" #"; 8%%-&0".& %(" #"+18%-& #&'&"(&#-&;.&"%&(%"; 8."0".& %(%1(&%-&. '-1##3. ;%-&.1&%+&-1#.& ".&5"13&#.%-&. 15&4 "&'% 4 '+0" (-0 " # %-&. .1& %-& "+183 % (.%3+("(0&'"10.(+.&1&'% ;'-" ; ; .+("<3%%-&(%"%3(" #9.%-"'%3"1.&1"% (-0( #&. ,3.(#'% (9.1#5&.-"5&.&'; J&#%-"%%-& 5"13&"'-1#F(' (.%3+".&='&&#(%-&&' +' 5"13& %-& '+0& ("% "9".#&# %-& '"(& %-&

$7% #&"%- " '-1# (% ,3.(#'% ( %-&.&.& 0&.+% 0".& %( % <& "9".#&# '+0& ("% 3 #&. 1(( ' (.%3+ %-&#&"%-"'-1#-&"+3 %"9".#&# % %-& 0".& %( ( " '+0& ("% . 1(( %-& 15&4 "&'% 4'".&" #'+0" (-0%-&#&'&"(&#'-1# -&%.2&-'1&('%("<& &'"11&;(1"% "+&#"%0.5# ;.&1&%%-&5'%+(.%-&."+1&(4 '"(&(;& 3 &'1"+( '"(&9-&.&"0".& %-"( 1(%%-&.+ .'-1#4.3 +"..&#( .#"3;-%&.4%-& 0".& %( ".& & %%1&# % <& "9".#&# 1(( ' (.%3+ 3 #&.%-&-&"# 1"1 (.%3+

".& %"1 (.%3+ ( "9".#&# % '-1#.& 9- 1(& %-&. 0".& %( +%. 5&-'1& "''#& %( 3 #&. %-& '% &9;-3.%(-"5&"9".#&#'+0& ("% %-('3 %9&5&.4%-&.&9"( '1".%89%-.&(0&'%% %-&0. '01&( 9-'-'+0& ("% '31#<&"9".#&# 1(( 1"1 (.%3+ -& "+3 % '+0& ("% % <& "9".#&# "( ' (.%3+ 911 <& ;5&. &# <8 %-& 0. '01&( "9".# ; '+0& ("% 3 #&. E@(( (.%3+F "( 1"##9 ." "8*&%-D(30."G %-& 0.&(& % '"(&4 9& #&&+ % "00.0."%& % "9".#%-&"%-&." #%-&((%&.%-&#&'&"(&#4" "+3 % (

!&"'-.1(( 1"1 (.%3+L > ? @6&9(&4 "( ";" (% "9".# %&.&(% A I 0&. " 3+ 5&9%-&#&'( *3<&* ;-F('"(&D*30."G4%-&"00&11" %(".&-&1# & %%1&#%"9".# %&.&(%HBI0&." 3+ >? 5&9%-&0(% "( %&#"<5&4'+0& ("% 0"8"<1& 9.6(3%"(3 #&.)

$#% - /&3+ 0,)' &++/++/3 ;2 '6/-(;,)&* 0,)' &++/++/3 ;2 '6/,-' '+&

3%3.& .(0&'%( @

! %"1 '+& "((&((&#

! D

!G N

! 31%01&."001&#

&#3'% D%9".#( 0&.( "1 &=0& (&( #&'&"(&#G !%-

! !%-

!N !

! !G N B!D0&. + %-G B!= N

4 $! A +0& ("% 9".#&#

!G NA !D0&.+ %-G A != N

! &0& #& '8 D 3"1G

4 $!=N A4 $4AB ! $ @(( (.%3+

!=N 4A4

! D

!0"8"<1&% &"'-%-&"00&11" %(G B @(((%"%& @

3 &."1=0& (&(

! %&.&(% A I BI 4B

! 8 #78 = >? ''.# ;184"(";" (%'+0& ("% 4B

!"9".#&# <8%-&.<3 "14%-&"00&11" %(!'1"+" %(".&-&1#& %%1&#%'+0& ("% B4$4AB !"1 ;9%- %&.&(%HBI0&." 3+9%-&&'%.+%-& #"%&'1"+0&%% %11#"%&0"8+& %41&((0"8+& %4" 84+"#&&".1&.

$8% > ? &&#1&(( % +& % 4 0"8+& % "''3 % 3%3.&0.(0&'%( (-"11<&+"#&"%&.#&#3'% ;%-&%"=1"<1%8" 8 "''.#" '&9%-%-& #&'( ." "8*&%-F('"(&D(30."G >? ''.# ;184 "00&"1 ( "119&# <8 +#8 ; 9".# #"%&#

0"((&#<8%-&1&". &#.<3 "1%%-&&=%& %"( %&#"<5& D*M"1"G 3#;&

$ "+% M-&%-&.(0&"6 ;!.&"( &# ) &(!

M-&%-&..&0.%"<1& ) &(!