Mukul Dev v. A.K. Rathee

 









 

 






















 


!"























#$%
&
'%()*)+
,
 
!-.-/
%0









































1
22%//#+$


3 #$4%%















































































%*2+'%+$
 !
,

 5
!


 
 3

 5
!


 
 3
!

%*%+$


!.*4#6
4#+'#)7
'0(#$%7
&
$4%
#22%//#+$
!#-#84
-/)#7
'0(#$%7
&
$4%
%*2+'%+$





9
9
9
9
9
 3
7

#/"



4%
#22%//#+$
)+*$)$-$%'
#
*-)$
8%&%
$4%
)0)/
-':%
%+)
)0)*)+"
--:#;
&
*4$
<
$4%
()0)/
(-$"
)+
=4)(4
$4%
%*)'%+$
>%/&#%
**()#$)+
&
)*2#/
?)4#7
%($
 7
--:#;
&
*4$7
>"
=#*
$4%
'%&%+'#+$

4-:4
4)*
*-)$7
$4%
#22%//#+$
*-:4$
$4%
)**-#+(%
&
')%($)+*
$
$4%
>
$
#//=
$4%
#22%//#+$
$
-*%
$4%
&$2
&
4)*
2%+$4-*%
&/#$
)+
$%;*
&
$4%
/#-*%
@ #"
&
$4%
8.)+:
/%$$%
#+'
$
=)$4'#=
#//
+$)(%*A%;#)/*
*%+$
86
$4%
>
$
$4%
#22%//#+$
=)$4
%:#'
$
%*$#)+)+:
4);
&;
-*)+:
$4%
&$2
&
4)*
&/#$
#*
#/*
$
)+B-+($
$4%
>
&;
&()+:
$4%
#22%//#+$
$
%;0%
$4%
*/#
2#+%/*
)+*$#//%'
86
4);
+
$4%
&$2
&
4)*
&/#$

/+:=)$4
4)*
*-)$7
$4%
#22%//#+$
&)/%'
#+
#22/)(#$)+
-+'%
'%
 
*%%.)



#22%//#+$
.+(.%'
$4%
'*
&
$4)*
-$
)+0.)+:
)$*
(+$%;2$
B-)*')($)+

>4)/%
$4%*%
(+$%;2$
2(%%')+:*
=%%
2%+')+:7
#:#)+*$
$4%
'%
&
$4%
()0)/
(-$
'#$%'
 7
$4%
')*8%')%+(%
&
=4)(4
4#'
8%%+
(;2/#)+%'
&
)+
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
(+$%;2$
2%$)$)+7
$4%
>
&)/%'
#+
#22%#/
8%&%
$4%
'')$)+#/
)*$)($
-':%7
--:#;
&
*4$7
$4%
#22%//#$%
(-$"

4-:4
'%
'#$%'

D7
2#**%'
)+
>C*
#22%#/7
$4%
#22%//#$%
(-$
%;)$$%'
$4%
;#$$%
$
$4%
()0)/
(-$
=)$4
#
')%($)+
$
$#.%
#
&%*4
#+'
&)+#/
'%()*)+
+
$4%
#22/)(#$)+
&)/%'
86
$4%
#22%//#+$
-+'%
'%
 

+
$4%
;%#+=4)/%7
$4%
#22%//#$%
(-$
*$#6%'
$4%
2%#$)+
&
$4%
)+$%);
'%
&
$4%
()0)/
(-$
'#$%'
 

+
/)+%
=)$4
$4%
')%($)+*
)**-%'
86
$4%
#22%//#$%
(-$7
$4%
()0)/
(-$7
$4-:4
)$*
'%
'#$%'
@D7
&)+#//6
')*2*%'
&
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
#22/)(#$)+
&)/%'
-+'%
'%
 
86
')%($)+:
$4%
2#$)%*
$
;#)+$#)+


E-#
2**%**)+

4%%#&$%7
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
(+$%;2$
2%$)$)+7
#//%:)+:
$4%
')*8%')%+(%
&
$4%
()0)/
(-$
'%
'#$%'
 7
=#*
$#.

%+
-2
#+'
'%()'%'
86
#
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
&
$4)*
-$
+
FG

4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
=#*
&
$4%
0)%=
$4#$
$4%
()0)/
(-$
4#'
2#**%'
'%*
'#$%'
 
#+'
@D
=)$4-$
(+*)'%)+:
$4%
&#($
$4#$
$4%
*/#
2#+%/*
4#'
8%%+
)+*$#//%'
86
$4%
#22%//#+$
+
$4%
&
&
4)*
&/#$
=)$4-$
#+6
2)
2%;)**)+
&;
$4%
(;2%$%+$
#-$4)$6
#+'
$4#$
$4%
#22%//#+$
4#'
+
):4$
$
/(.
$4%
%+$6
$
$4%
&
&
4)*
&/#$
#*
$4)*
=-/'
')%($/6
)+$%&%%
=)$4
$4%
):4$*
&
$4%
&/#$
=+%*
=4
#((')+:
$
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
#/*
4#'
$4%
):4$
$
-*%
$4%
&$2
#*
$4%%
=%%
=#$%
$#+.




%#+%'
(-+*%/
&
$4%
#22%//#+$
%*$)($*
4)*
(4#//%+:%
$
$4%
8*%0#$)+*
;#'%
86
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
%&&%($)+:
$4%
;%)$*
&
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
2%+')+:
()0)/
*-)$
#*
#/*
$
$4%
#'0)*6
)**-%'
86
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
$
$4%
()0)/
(-$
#*
$
4=
$4%
()0)/
(-$
*4-/'
2(%%'
=)$4
$4%
*-)$
#*
#((')+:
$
$4%
/%#+%'
(-+*%/
86
4#0)+:
;#'%
$4%*%
8*%0#$)+*
#+'
)**-#+(%
&
$4%
#'0)*6
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
4#*
2%B-':%'
#+'
2%B-')(%'
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
*-)$

+
$4)*
%:#'7
#$$%+$)+
&
$4)*
-$
)*
'#=+
$
$4%
'%
'#$%'
@ 
2#**%'
86
$4%
#22%//#$%
(-$
)+
#+
#22%#/
2%&%%'
86
$4%
>
#:#)+*$
$4%
'%
&
$4%
()0)/
(-$
'#$%'
@D
=4%%)+
$4%
#22%//#$%
(-$
4#*
#//=%'
$4%
>C*
#22%#/
86
;%%/6
%&%)+:
$
#+'
E-$)+:
$4%
);2-:+%'
8*%0#$)+*
#+'
#'0)*6
86
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%

%#+%'
(-+*%/
&
$4%
2#$)%*
4#0%
8%%+
4%#'
#+'
=)$4
$4%)
#8/%
#**)*$#+(%
$4%
%('
&
$4%
(#*%
4#*
#/*
8%%+
2%-*%'
D
4%
#22%//#+$
4#'
)+0.

D7
2#**%'
)+
$4%
#22%#/
86
>
')%($%'
$4%
()0)/
(-$
$
$#.%
#
&%*4
#+'
&)+#/
'%()*)+
+
$4%
)+$%);
2#6%
;#'%
86
$4%
#22%//#+$

+
$4%
/):4$
&
$4%*%
')%($)+*
$4%
()0)/
(-$7
$4-:4
)$*
'%
'#$%'
@D7
&)+#//6
')*2*%'
&
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
#22/)(#$)+
-+'%
'%
 
86
')%($)+:
$4%
2#$)%*
$
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
*-)$
$
;#)+$#)+



%)$4%
2#$6
(;2/#)+%'
&
#+6
0)/#$)+
&
$4%


'%
&
$4%
()0)/
(-$
'#$%'
@D

+
$4%
/):4$
&



$4%*%
*-8*%E-%+$
'%0%/2;%+$*
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
(-/'
4#0%
*);2/6
')*2*%'
&
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
(+$%;2$
2%$)$)+
8-$
4%
')'
+$
'
*

#$4%7
4%
')*;)**%'
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
(+$%;2$
2%$)$)+
#&$%
%(')+:
$4%
&//=)+:
8*%0#$)+*,

 !
"#
$%
%
&!
%
"'

("$')
*"'&

#&#&
%
$*
"#''"#
*
'
+#'!
+"
+(""#
*
,-,,.,/0,-,,/  1!

"&
#&
(')
$2
%
+""#

%"
#
%
*"3&
%
'
+#'
"''
#
4" 

"4%

%
+""#
"%

'25
%
#)
*
*+


"
"#

(##!
%"2%
"
&"2')
**2"#4
%

$)
%
*'
#!
%
'
% 

"4%

4

%
*+

%


#5
#&
%
2((#
'2"2")
2##2"#

"#''&,
6%
"'

%
*"'&

++2"
%"
+2
*
%
2
%
%
+""#
%
&+&

# '
(%&
*
*"3"#4
'
+#'
#
%
*+




"
32'" ')
$)
%"(,

7"#&"#4
#
("
"#
%"
2#(+
+""#!

%
(
"
&"("&,

6%
"'

"
& "&

5+
"
"#
("#&
%
%"'
2#"&"#4
%
$'#2
*
2# #"#2
#&

+"(
*2"
2!
%
"#
*
%
*'
#
"#
%
(

%
%
+#%
*
%
+""#
"
"&
"
'

$
5#
2
#&
"*
#
+(""#

4#&
$)
"%
*
%
*"&
%
%""
",,
,-,,.,/0,-,,/  1!
(
*"3"#4
%
'
+#'

%"
#
$)
%
+""#!
#
+*#"'
"4%
2#
$
2'"(&
$)
%
+""#
4"#
%
%
*'
#
*
%
(
,8






%;24#*)*
*-22/)%'"
@
4-:4
$4%
#&%
E-$%'
8*%0#$)+*
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
4#*
4%/'
$4#$
$4%
#22%//#+$
4#'
)+*$#//%'
$4%
*/#
2#+%/*
+
$4%
&$2
&
4)*
&/#$
=)$4-$
2%;)**)+
&;
$4%
(;2%$%+$
#-$4)$6 )%*"
#+'
$4#$
$4%
#22%//#+$
4#'
+
):4$
$
/(.

$4%
%+$6
$
$4%
&$2
&
4)*
&/#$
$
2$%($
$4%
*#)'
*/#
2#+%/*

4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
=#*
&-$4%
&
$4%
0)%=
$4#$
$4%
$4%
&/#$
=+%*
4#'
#/*
$4%
):4$
$
-*%
$4%
&
0%
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
&/#$


G
4%
#22%//#+$
4#*
&)/%'
4)*
*-)$
*%%.)

2(%%')+:*
=%%
#0)'#8/%
#*
*-(4
8*%0#$)+*
86
#
*-2%)
(-$
=-/'
(%$#)+/6
2%B-')(%
$4%
#22%//#+$
'-)+:
$4%
(-*%
&
'%()*)+
&
4)*
*-)$
F
+
$4%
%H%()*%
&
4)*
(+$%;2$
B-)*')($)+
%0%+
$4%
#&%
E-$%'
#'0)*6
86
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
$
$4%
()0)/
(-$
$
'%()'%
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
)+$%);
#22/)(#$)+
)+
#
2#$)(-/#
;#++%
#+'
86
.%%2)+:
)+
;)+'
#
2#$)(-/#
&#($
=#*
#/*7
/%#*$
$
*#67
-+(#//%'
&
%*2%()#//6
=4%+
$4%%
=#*
+
(4#//%+:%
8%&%
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
$
%)$4%
&
$4%
'%*
&
$4%
()0)/
(-$
'#$%'
 

@D

%0%+
$
$4%
'%
&
$4%
#22%//#$%
(-$
'#$%'

D

+
$4%
%H%()*%
&
)$*
(+$%;2$
B-)*')($)+
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
*4-/'
4#0%
+$
'%/0%'
)+$
$4%
;%)$*
&
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
2%+')+:
*-)$
#+'
2)+%'
$4%%-2+

6
')+:
*7
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%
(/%#/6
$#+*:%**%'
$4%
*(2%
#+'
%H$%+$
&
4)*
(+$%;2$
B-)*')($)+


+
$4%
/):4$
&
$4%
#80%7
=%
&)+'
$4#$
$4%
/%#+%'
)+:/%
-':%7
=4)/%
'%()')+:
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
(+$%;2$
2%$)$)+7
$#0%//%'
=%//
8%6+'
4)*
B-)*')($)+
$
2)+%
+
$4%
;%)$*
&
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
*-)$
#*
#/*
$
%+'%
#'0)(%
$
$4%
()0)/
(-$
$
2(%%'
=)$4
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
*-)$
)+
#
2#$)(-/#
;#++%

4%%&%7
$4%
#&%
E-$%'
8*%0#$)+*
;#'%
+
$4%
;%)$*
&
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
*-)$
#+'
$4%
#'0)*6
)**-%'
$
$4%
$)#/
(-$
#%
-+*-*$#)+#8/%

((')+:/67
$4%6
#%
*%$
#*)'%

4%
()0)/
(-$
*4#//
2(%%'
$
'%()'%
$4%
#22%//#+$C*
*-)$
+
)$*
;%)$*
#+'
(;2/%$%/6
-+)+&/-%+(%'
86
$4%
8*%0#$)+*A&)+')+:*A#'0)*6
)+
$4%
);2-:+%'
B-':;%+$


//=%'
)+
$4%
#80%
$%;*









I 3
J



















 
 




































I 3
!J
%(%


















































 








>4%$4%
*2%#.)+:A%#*+%'

,

%*
A

>4%$4%
%2$#8/%

,

%*
A