← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO-M/293/2013allowed

Nisha Alias Renuka v. Rakesh Kumar

2018-04-05Mr. Justice Krishna Murari,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri14 pages



 

   

 

!

 " # $ %&& '

( )&*& '

+ #, #" -   . ## "- #/0   1 





  









  

 # 1

&" $2 ,3$(  44 ,,&

& &5&6 36&$( 7 

&+ 6 3$(   #4 & 888888   

 & 9 44 ,,7  60&+ #:" -# ,  #44 ,(,, 

 0      (    

&'&   4##           ,    ,;

# (< 36 #$  7 (4   ,  #4  #"- #/0 6 (  

  (3 ))       #=  # (( 4  0

 7  4 ##  ##,$ 4##  (  $( &

9 (# # 4 #4 #3#4  #4   6 (   (3 # 0  7  4 #7##, 0 > & ?

 

;7, #4 

  #(  0 #  #     $ ,, 5  9 # ,;7, 0, ( ,7# 7 ,(- & ?& #$   0 3 44 ,,7  (0 0 0 ,0 # 7#  ## #4,  $ # ##0  7  4 , 0 '& ?     #7 - ( ?& #$    0 3  #4 # #($   44 ,,7 

#4 ( ( # #  & &@ , ( $ ;

#  0

; 4 ## $ ,, ## &;&&7 ( ###(  7 6( >4  3 # 7#  0 ;&@ 6 A$

#& #$     , $ ( , & ?3 44 ,,7   (0   , 3 #, 4, ##3 0  - (  ( ,# #- (,, ## #30 # 0 (0   (& #,#$    &*& '3  #4 #44  44 ,,7    4 ,0 <0,439 # , # # (  # #  #

  7  4 #&9  #4 ### 4(#  44 ,,7  7##  00 , # #(-  4    # B4 ( , $ 7  # ,#    (00 #  & 9 44 ,,7    4, 4   6 (  (  # 7##  00 , # #,,  4   & 6   $  $  04 (00 #  &9 44 ,,7  - # (  $   #4 # #0  7#  0  ,77##    4  4 # ## 30 ,  3 3    



70 7#   0 0 0 , 0  &%&

*& 9   #4 #   ,    4, (        #  -     44 ,,7  37 ,       $ 0 #  0     4  & 9 4 #7  44 ,,7  ## #1

C       #4   #     # 

( #,D  0  ,00 , # 3#,, E 

C   4    #  ,  (  $( 

  #0 7  #4  ##,$    0 ,4# (,( ,E"

&C   4    #  ,  (  $(     #  E

$& C      4     #    ,(##     ,   # 4  E"

$& C   4   #(0    7 (,  # #  ,  , E"

$ & " , & )& 9  #4 # B0  C;&;0  < 3C ;&@  A$3C*6-;,3C)/ # 5,3C%; $ ;, 0# ,# 44  7  ##B#C&  9 44 ,,7   B0   "C;&

 #/3"C @,7 3"C6# ,/0  # ,# 44  7  ##B#"C*&

*

%& F4(#     $  ( ,  4 #3 ,  ,7      #  # ## #+& $  #4 # ,    44 ,,7   ##  00 , #  # (   #4 #0 ,4# (,( ,&## # +&*)7   (   #  #4 #(# G , 0 7#    ##,$ $   04   0  (  

&'& &

 $ 7  #0 3 44 ,,7  # ,  4 # 44 ,& ?& 9  ,    (# ,     44 ,,7   7 , ## ,    04    0  ( # 

 #0   ,  ,7  # 44 (    $  (   ( (4#4 ( $  (   #((,#  44 ,,7  7##  0 (, 0 ,   # 3  7  #        (#  7 (    B0     44 ,,7  3  #  3

$  # 4 (& '&   3 ,  (# ,  #4 #37 ,     0  (, $  ( ,  0#7 ,,# 44 ,,7  3 ##0   0  (, $  ( (, , #, # #0 , #   44 ,,7    # $  #(0 , #  # (,       #  ( (0#( #3    0  (          04    0  (  ##,$ 0  4 # $ 74$ # # 6 ( 

 (&

C $ (#    $,#0 ## # ##    # $ ,#4 #  ( (# &  & 9 (# 0 , # G # #7   44 ,,7   #

)

, ( 7 0 , # #(-  (  B4 (   #4 #( 7  & 9  #4 #37 ,   ##B3#   7  $ 0 #0   4    ( #7   #4 ( ( # #  & @ , ( $ ;

#   (; 4 ## $ ,, ## &;&&& #  && '3 # - 44 ,,7  < ;  ( 36 B2  ,

#4 ,3    ;7,     0 &      #     $    *&)& '37  44 ,,7  #  00 , # 3# 7#    0;&< 0*&)& ' &%& '#  

04$ & #     - ;& $  6   ,*&?& '& & 9  #4 # B0  C;&;0  < 37#   && '3  B0   44 ,,7  377#,-  ( B37#  , 7  #0 &9  #4 # B0  C

;&@ 6 A$3;

 (36 

##  #4 ,3  ,97

#3 7#  44 ,,7  7#0    ##4 , && ?

 # # 4 ## $  # 4#( (  #

 ## 7  # ,  ( #3#  0    #4 , ,, %&& ? 7# #( 4 , 04$ 0 &6  $ #  ,,,7 4 ;&   4# # 7# 0    #4 ,

'&& ' ,,&*& '& #  ( ( ,, ##( ,  , #   #     #   $  ( 3    44 ,,7   4  0   # , # 44  7  ##B3#, 0  (, $  ( #7 ,,  #4   # 0"C;&

 #/&0   0   

%

,  ,7  ?& 4##    ( 0  (, B0   44 ,,7  3 ((  #(  ; 40 32 63"- (##(   

  ,0 &9   ?&  ## 1 

!

"# $ % &

    !

'( '$ % &

  )   

     * & 

 %&&

+ , ,   

 '



   $    *  )     * &

 ,

,  ,     

  %&&

+ , - ,   

 $ 



-  +  & .,  ,  - 

# ,$ /0!$ ) 1     2%% $



  3 &   3*  %$  

 

  3 , - .,  3- - 

# ,$ /0!$ ) 4 1 & - 

# ,$ /0!$ )

 

  , - .,   * & & ) 5%,

 %+  3       *



 %&&

+ , - ,   





!6

#  ( , !+ #7$ !



8 9 & #  #  3 44 ,,7  7# B0   (, @(04 #  (# ; 40 #(  (32 "-&9 44 ,,7  7#- 40   2 63"- 7 - & &0

%&&  # $   (,@3 7 (4   44 ,,7  7#( ,#  0 0 , # &9  4 %&& IB&"CD@ ##,,7#1

?

H

       (-6 6:6:

# ;66 4

4   !%

$

 '# ! ,$ /0!$ ) !%3  

  &  

*6 ! ) 5%,  -

&

 -%



(/0!6'6 6<:      %32  3=    

*6 ! ) 5%,

,  , 

 -  - *  # (; 6  > (???

,    ;  %

 3 =  & ,  3  &  &* +  

 #   5%   # 



!

+  #  @  5%,  4 3 

 &        

*6 ) 5%,

  0AB<;

 %

-  %&&

+ , - ,     4 

 &

-%

& ,    -    !6 !6

!6 #  

# 



#  @  5%, $

&

&

!

  

# & -  -

# & -  - # & -  - /0!$ )

/0!$ )

/0!$ )9 *& 9 44 ,,7   B0  ;&

 #/3 ##3; 40  #(  (32 63"-3  0 0 #  (,@3 4$   #  4&9  # (7#(## B0   ,      #4 #&  9  (## B0        #-         (  # 4(  ,7    1

'

H( ,   ) 0  * %        *   - %

3 =    3    .,    0

 

  

  

  0

  0

 

  

  

  3 3%  % 3 



 & 4   

%3  *    &  - , $ , 3  C   -$

 %3  %-  ,  $ *   = "% 

 = &

  - +  , 0

 

  %

+   =   &    $     = %  -  %

+ ,  $     3 ++  = &



 0 ,- 

,-  3 +  0

 

 

    3 ) + ,  &

 +  ,$ 

  

   ,- 3  , 0

 

        

 ,+ -  )*      ) ,  %

+  

 & .,   !

   =   &   

  = 3

 +$  ,    + 

) &  ,  * % 1$ * %3,  %

    3  &   3 =  , # -  -   = -

 *

    ) ,  3&  

.,   4    ) , 

 

3 3- , - 

 0





  %++   %  

=  3-  3 

 * + 0

 

   , 0A

  3=   0A 3*  , 0





  %++   3 =  &  3       9

)& 4 #,  #  4IB&"CD@  (,@#7 ,,#  # 0    "C  ;& 

 #  /  #7#      44 ,,7  3 4#  ( # ##  ,7  37#0   2

 

"-37  #  0   # $  7 -  @ (#; 40 #(  (32 63"-74   + #  "      JK'%    ( ,    #   0    0 , # &("C;&

 #/(  (,,#     7 - & &0

%&& 37  44 ,,7   0   0  3  7#0 ,  D # & %& 9 ,  (# ,  #4 ##37 $ 3 04  ## ,  4  (,@  "C;&

 # /  #(## B0  #   ,0 7# , (,  ,4# &9 ,  (# ,  #4 # #,#     # 0 #C;&;0  < 37#    B0   44 ,,7   && '# 7#,-  ( B7#  ,   $ 7  #0 & ?&

7 $ 3C  # B0   (  # ,37 ,  #(   ,0 3 # #  0    # 0 7& && && '  &%& '      #   #7  04$ 0       0    7# 4  ## $ , ( &; (## B0  3 #  4  7#- 40 ,> #  $  0#7 (7#4   #44 & ,# #     4  - #0   #  ,,3 0  4 # #0 ( #   & '& 9 ,  (# ,  #4 ##,#    # 0 C ;&@ 6 A$37##  44 ,,7# # 0    ##4 , && ?7  # # 4 ## $  #  4#( (  ## 7#  7   4 ###

 

4#( ( 4  04$ 4 ,,7# #( 7 $ #  ,,74 ,, ;& # # # 7# 0   &?& ?7# #( &'& ?   # 7# 0   '&& ' ,,&*& '& #     4 (0 ,,74)&*& '&  #(    ,0 # 4, # 7  4 0 ,0 ( 4 ## & # # (   #( ( ,, ##3  ,4# # (( ( # $ (00& #37 $ 3# 

,, ## 4 ##  # , &  44 (   0  (, $  ( ,  4 # ( B   ## 4  4   $( 3  #44#    0   4$ # #6 ( 

 (37 ( #-      (   4(  ,71  # = 



- ,

+ , $ *

3&  

&

 ,,, &   $ ,-$        3-  

 %3 

 * &$ 3  = 3-    &  =    + %   

 -E ...

...

...

  3

% 3- & %% , $ 

 3 %&&

+  %%- 

 , - , ,   

& %  )    %  .     



3- 3 .   = *  



F. E0   %$E

  .   G,    , ,

$ 

 

, =, & , $ -   





- 

  



 3  - & ,  

%  C  H

3  .   G-    ,       



 3  - & , 

*





% + %3 , - &

 + * 

%

3 ,- ++  = 



%-

 3 %     &  

 -$  *







I%

 

 % 3  ,   ,H  J ...

....

.....9

C ,  B0   $  (  ( B  # 4$ # #37    74 $ (# B0    #4 #3$ #  44 ,,7    B0   0# 7#       $  0 ,   ,0 &  C  ;&  ;0    <     # # 0 ##   # # ,, ## 44 ,,7  # ,,7#1 H# &&    + 

 > &   %, - 

-  -

$ = &

 = - &    *   .

,  0&     -

   =   +

 

&& =   

%

   ,  * % - -,,&L

& ,,3C ;&@ 6 A$#,##  44 ,,7  7# # #(# 4#404#(# #  # 

#(#  4, # & 7 $ 3C##   4 - # 0   # ,,3 0  ,4# #0 ( # &@ # (#$ #     ,4# # (( ( #  ,, ##&

 

C;&;0  < #3 (3#4 (  (,,#   4  - #0   # ,,3 0  4 # # ,4# #0 ( #   &

 #   #  4#  ( #  3 44 ,,  7#- 40  7 - 2 63"-37   44 ,,    #4,#

0 ,   #     7 -&7##4 (  (,,4    (,@# 7# ( ,#  00 , # &"C;&

 #/3  (## B0  37 , #   4, #  # , (, 3 B4,    # #,,7#1 H0

 

  

  

  3 3%  % 3 



 & 4    

%3  *    &  - , $ , 3  C   -$

 %3  %-  ,  $ *   = "% 

 = &

  - +  ,9

9 #  #  # #( $ ( 4  "C;&

 #/30 0   (,@ 2 "-7 ( # 4  #    

  (,@7# (04 #       4 ###    #(  (  ; 40 3  7  $ (  (,,4   44 ,,7  7 - 4 # $   7 -2 63"-7# 0 #  00 , # &I$    #(( 4  44 ,,7  #  04# 404#(# # 4 ( $  ,4# #3  # $  0 4 (##( ,0 ( (,, 7 44  0  ( &9 $ (     7 -7 # 7#- 4 



# $  # $  (  ( 44 ,,7   #( (# 7  # ##0 4# #D(-##( ,0  #0   , &

*& F #(( (0#( #3 # # B4 ( 4$    #  0 # 44 ,,7   #  ( (0#( # 0#4  0  #- 4#, ,( ,##(4#(  ( ,0 #  

 

$ # , 3  ,  $ 0  7 ( 4  0 #&

)& 7 ,, 4,( 0   0  (#00 &  #,#0    #4 # 0  7  6 0,3/,, ,  0&9 4 #7  , ## 7  0, ( ,#7 ,,&7 ,,,# 4,( 0   #7  44     # %&& '37  #7  0  #0 (040 # &;     ( 7   7  3#   #4,#

0, &

%& ##(7  ,  0   # ,  ,7    ( 44 ,,7   ##  00 , #  B    #4 #( #,  B4 ( , $ 7  44 ,,7  &9   ##(($ (  $  (  (#7  44 ,,7      #4 #7 ( ,  #   07 #  , (# & # G ,3   # ,    ,7       ## #  +&      ( ##           $ # &

?& #(# G (   $ #,   # ## #+&3

04   0 (##  # $ # # #  &9 44 ,

*

0  #(( 4(  #  (( 4 &9  04   0  (    # #   4   6 (  ( ,  ### #0 ## &9 44 ,##(( 4 (( ,&

'&  # ,   7(##&; ( #  7(( ,&    







 !

""

  

    )&*& '

4- C  #4 - D #  A #D+ C   4, A #D+