← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaARB/403/2025allowed

M/S Roy Construction Jalandhar v. The General Manager (Engineer), Northern Railway, Baroda House, New Delhi And Others

2026-03-19Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri11 pages

       

 

 

  

!"

#$%$!&'

())* +,

 , - 

))))  $$!& .

/ .%0%  - 

1  -2 

 ,1 2

- 

,

)))))  %3!&4 &%  '

5- ) , , ,   

 

  

  

   

  , , 

)

-

 

! 

  "#$ !

  %%# "

  

& '$

( !

 "(($  *+, *+%  )

(

  !

 

 



 !-   * .   !(

  



/0 - )  1 / 2  !(

 1



!

 

#3





(

!

1



   1 /*



 

 ( 

    1 ₹+++++++5/

 "0  6

 6)$ 

 !







8 6 - ) !-  (  7  (  7 

 !



 #+ ) ( ) 

-

 (

!  7  2 !(

 

 



!

   ! 2  !(



!

   

 -

 ! 1 

  





  

#:

 

!  

 



 ;"$ < < **",$ :% 3:"*$ 3,"$"

$ ,, ,,/ ",$ ,; ,; #"$ #"*$

#*"$   7





 (

&1 '

2

 !(

 - 



  1  )

(



#:

 

#:

!) 





((



  (

 2  !(



 



!





  

    1 /,  



  

 / ( )

!

! (( -=

 

!   )  !

  :

.    !(



   ) !

!  -= )    

 

 (

 1 (

 -

 1

( ( ( !

  1  (   )

)  2  !(

  )   !  

 (( -=

 

=



!



  +; +, *+*,   1 /,





  !) )

=  



 

>?1 @ )

 !

!

  

! 

 



(

 ! 6  

  

    



  

 /A6B   (

 !(

! 

  -

  1  )



#*

   1  )





#:   !

 2  !(



  (

( -= 1 ( ( ( !

     (( -= 

( 



  

 

!



  1  )    ! ( , .    !(

/0 - ) (

    !

 ( )  (( -=

-

   =





        !



     ;

C   





4   

/ 



      

 



  

 

 





 



    





   

 

  



 

 

  

 

 



  





 

 !



"











#



 $







  # 



   % 



$





  &    

      

     '



 

  

  



   



(    



 #

  

)*+  

" (  '"

       ,      - 

  

 .  

/ "             

 

  01

&$2     )%/)) .  (

         - 

  

. 



/ " (     





  #

  



 '



     

#

 

 

3

45

4% 



" (                  



    

          

46 



"  (    

    '



 '

 7

  

  

 







    

    4, 



"&

 



  





 













   #





   

"







#- # / "(    



   )6 . (

8

8 $

"  &

  7- 

  

 .  

 

7



   599/ "  8            :    



    

.



   '



  - #   



#

&

 $

" ;< # 

 





 

#        



  

    

   



 

  

   #

 

    #    

 

     

 '



- #    

=,  7

&

 $

" ;<

<     # 

 

 '



 

  # 

 





   



  " =,  7

 



&

 $

" ;<

<     / '

  

 

 



  

  # 

  &

 $

" ;  <  < 

  <

       #

 #





   ,*+ 

  #

/ ""

""

""

""





 

 

     ! $ 

 

 #  









#

 # 



 #



  

# 



 





  





>

 >     #  )4*          



7  

 





   

 



 # 

   

#



     %3 ,/),/445 ?9 =?4 =5 55 55;

* $5 5% 5%$/6)) 6)4

64) 8

>



   

 

 

        "          8  



    

  7"  7 









 - # 







 





        7"    7     

 "

 # $ 

/ ""

""

""

""

"  #

!

" ! 



 #



   

 







  

  



    



 

 

 # 

- #

   

# )4* 



  "

@"  @



         6?/)     



 







 )4* # ),*   



 

   

 # 

 

 







/ "

!.





   #

  

3 

        ;#/A    

         #   

  

 #   

         - #

      

  



     

  

 / ""

""

""

""

"!#$$ 

 #

 $$ 



 

%#

 



6 #   & !

" ! #       



  

") ** ** ***:; -A 

 $ 

.



 



8 $ 

#  > BA #

 #0

$ 

>

>



/. 



   # 6* 

 # 

 





  >



/ ""

""

""

""C < 



 -  -

 

!

 1 !



 

 1  )

! -

 ! % 2-          ( 

) -

! 1 -= !

/ )  

-= ) ! -=

 = 

( 

 ! 

    2-    

  !

!



 

!   -=  ((   ( 

)

 ( 

   )

!

( -=

1 



#*



! 

 +

 -

-  2'!  (

>'()*  )   $

7 +

,-

'$  @."'/  '0%"

- 



( 

 

  6 

!-  

  )  / )  



 

 -





 

 )  !





)

) (  

   1  ) 

1

 =  ! )

 

 !





 



(    ) (   1

!

 - 2'!  (

'()*  )   $ +

 '$ 

  1

!

2-

   1  )   !( !

     -

 





    1  )  6 !

    1

!



!



  

 

   0) 2'!  (

6   #

&  &) ) 

  '

&  + 1.%'/  '.23  



!

 

 

 1 )  

(   

 



 

  (  

 / 6/.

 

  



# #" 

 #  8

)) 

( )996$   

 



  " 



 # 

/

 #    #        #  " 

3 

 8

))      





;





 # " 

/ %/8;

6$ 8

)) ##    $? 4*)6 #

4?/)*/4*)5  

 #





 ;

=

;

5

;

6 8  

!     

#



3   

   "

" 



 /   ,/$?? 4*)9 ;

6$

 

$ 





/

  



6$ 8

)) )996$     

/       9/.   3



 4*)5

  #    

;

6$

8

)) )996$  





  

$ 

   !  

8 

   "   



        #   6* /  

 #





   $ 

!  

 8   "

"    



 



  /C )*/.



  " 



 C    3



  4*)5   # 

  ;0   

  -   # $ 

$

  $ 





$ )996

 

8 $ ),995

#   

 4*9/.  "

   8 



!   

    

$ 

D"

"     



  

 

    E/ .  



   



        



#



   



3    







/C ))/-

   

  

-   

 ;3    

8  >

   

  /  F/  /  G   8

6C

  ))=/  H/                

 

   $ 

     "  







/(



#      

  D1 I

 /I

.



%



  D2.& / 8& F

F,

 3 





 #  

#  

  

C 

))"  #

  ";  

;



 

      

   

 -   

C/ 4 $ '$$  )4/$  

    ;

0     



 ;0  

   -   

#

 #  











  # 0    

'



/ #  

!  

 

   

 # 









 





 # 



   

  

 # 

/.

 

!      





;



   





 

# 

 

 

/ * B -

!  

-  

     2  *,,  

 6

(! E #;

(1  !

) 2



 ! E %<,:<#::* ?/(    F)

 (

( 

 !

  !-   ! (   )     * 

:

 



 !  !   (

  1

((    !

  G

   !

 

G

   ! 

( , . !

 4  ( 

 ( ( !

  *%/  4  

-

)    

   ())*

, , 



 

   =5  I5E *    ! I5E