Jhajjar Power Limited v. State Of Haryana & Others
!""#$%$&' () * ++ , -",.$/$!"01$22 3"4* &56,)$%!,$#!* ++ , "!$!$&", 1",%6% 7! !" ,( & !*",% "%5&0"&!%
!"# $%&'(# ('
")$%*+#
,"%"&!'
, 6&""! 2$)7"&$,08# !"-$!*
,,6&65! )08# !") ,!*"5"!$!$&",
,&0,"%*"2)002 ,( & ) ,!*"7! !" 99999
('
")$, *"5"!$!$&",:#/5 &($% 33,$"8"0!*"$/563&"0%*- # 6%"&!$#"0 !"0 &&";6," :<$%%6"0=(!*"*$"&%5"#!, #!,$"%) ,( & :,"%5&0"&! ,"2($&3 65& !*" "&>6$,(,"5,! 0 !"0 &&";6," :%6=/$!!"0=(!*""56!($,"#!,)&06%!,$ 2 7 "!( &0" 2!*) &$5 !)-*","=(!*"5"!$!$&",$% 22"3"0 !* 8"8$2 !"0!*"5,8$%$&%7"#!$&%: &0?!*" #!,$"%#!) @?A ,%*,!B@?A#!C &0 62"<<:!*" 6&+ = #!,( 62"%) @ ,%*,!B@ 62"%C
, 6&""! 2$)2" ,&"07"&$,6&%"2 %%$%!"0=( ,,6& 65! ) 08# !" ,"5,"%"&!$&3 !*" 5"!$!$&",:#/5 &( %6=/$!% !* ! !*" 5"!$!$&", &0!*". ,3"&0$ ,$8 !".$/$!"0 ,%*,!B. .C"&!","0
$&! / %!", 3,""/"&!&D@22-"0=( & %*% 2" 3,""/"&! 0 !"0,!*" #!$8$!(#22"#!$& &0!, &%5,! !$&2( %*) . .6!%6,#"0$!% #!$8$!( &0"&3 3"0!*"%",8$#"% !, &%5,!",: 7E(2$!".3$%!$#% ,$8 !".$/$!"0) $56, ,%*,!B7.
.C "6,!*",%6=/$!%!* !&@<) & %*=62E",=" ,$&3 ,"3$%!, !$& :<::<?0,$8"&=(0"#" %"0762E* &7$&3*- %%"&! =(!*"7.
.,!*"#22"#!$& &0!, &%5,! !$&2( %*,/!*" 0"2$8",( 5$&! *" % $0 %* =62E", "&!","0 !*" 2 0$&3 = ( !*" 5"!$!$&",F%5,"/$%"% ,6&0D
*$2"!$3*!"&$&3!*"2$0)!*"0"#" %"0 2%!*$%= 2 &#")"220-&&!*"3,6&0 &0,"#"$8"0%",$6%$&+6,$"%" - %! E"&!!*"$8$2%5$! 2)* ++ ,)-*","*"%6##6/="0!*$%$&+6,$"% *"$&!$/ !$&!*" ,"/"&!$&"0 #!- %3$8"&!!*"&%5"#!,
#!,$"%&!*"&";!22-$&30 ()$")D< -"8",)$&!*" "&>6$,(#&06#!"0=(!*""56!($,"#!,)!*"5"!$!$&",5,8$0"08 ,$6% 0#6/"&!%$Ą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
#!,$"%#!* %=""&$%%6"0# 22$&365&!*"5"!$!$&",-*(!*"2"3 2
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
B
%!*" #!%,"8" 2!* !!*" 22"3"006/5",= %$# 22(* 0=""& 6!%6,#"0=(!*". .,/7E(2$!".3$%!$#% ,$8 !".$/$!"0) $56,)$& /(8$"-) 22!*"0#6/"&!%-",",">6$,"0!="5&0","065&=(!*" "56!($,"#!,="," &(22-$&36,!*",#6,%" #!$&6&0",!*" @?A#!
"%62! &!2()!*"%*-# 6%"&!$#"0 !"0 &&";6,"
:<$%%"!: %$0" &0!*"/ !!",$%,"/$!!"0= #E!!*""56!($,"#!,) &06%!,$ 27 "!( &0" 2!*) &$5 !)!*20 ,"%*"&>6$,( =(! E$&3$&!#&%$0", !$& 22 !*"0#6/"&!% &0!*"0""&#"!*" 5"!$!$&",*"5"!$!$&",-620=" !2$=",!(!52 #"&,"#,0 00$!$& 2 0#6/"&!%$&# %"!*"(#*%"!0%."!!*$%";",#$%"="0&"-$!*$& ," %& =2"5",$0)5,"", =2(-$!*$& 5",$0!*,""/&!*%$& ##,0 &#" -$!*2 -
. ,$!5"!$!$&%! &0% 22-"0 ,/) ('
" ,0 $%*+# 2 2 13 ,4 56 ,1
2 2
,9