High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/47459/2021dismissed

Kewal Singh v. State Of Haryana

2023-01-30Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

!"#!$%&%"'()**) +!,-.%'/0 1! % %"'!2 3!2&4& . !"#25' 1*!&6"'7!'

"28( "'9:-!2*4& %$!*.*;-% 2!&!' ( 2*2&07!!6.%'/0.2<73"$ !#"2 0!6! % %"'!2* 2*. %&0.%'/-< <25'* === *.*;-%<*

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

7%' 0!5!2< 0!62!' &"# 0!7!$!&!7 &6!' 04/!8"4' "' 0!822%/!'7-&"/3!&4##%$%!' 7",25:4 0! 7!$!&!7,& 4' !7'702&&!7#"2:2%'/%'/%'&4##%$%!' 7",25'7,& -&":! !'46"'&!3!2-"$$&%"'&:5 0!6! % %"'!2&,!

8!8:!2& '7 "' :%2 0 "# 8-! $0%-7 %' 0! 5!2 >< 0! 6! % %"'!2 7!8'7!78" "2$5$-!,0%$07!8'7 0!#8%-58!8:!2&"# 0!7!$!&!7 ,!2! 4':-! " #4-#%-- #"2 ,0%$0 0! 6! % %"'!2 -"'/,% 0 0%& 62!' & $"' %'4"4&-502&&!7 0!7!$!&!7'7"'>*>* :"4 *)*< 7!$!&!7 $--!7 0!2 # 0!2 '7 %'#"28!7 0%8 0 0! 6! % %"'!2 07 :!!' :! %'/0!2#"2#%-42! "/! 0!8" "2$5$-!'7"' 0!&8!75 2"4'7> *< 0!6! % %"'!2 !-!60"'%$--5%'#"28!7 0!$"86-%'' 2!/27%'/ 0! --!/!7&4%$%7!"# 0!7!$!&!7* ?!2'!7 . ! $"4'&!- $"' !'7& 0 &%'$! 0!2! %& $ !/"2%$- & !8!' "# 0! $"86-%'' 0 0! $$4&!76! % %"'!2 07 :! !' 0! 7!$!&!7 %' 0! 8"2'%'/ "' 0! 7 ! "# "$$422!'$! '7 0! 07 :!!' !-!60"'%$--5%'#"28!7"# 0!:!

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

7'7'","'-5#"28-,% '!&&!&2!8%' " :!!B8%'!7< 0!. !,"4-7!'&42!62!&!'$!"#--62"&!$4 %"',% '!&&!& "' 0!2!&6!$ %3!7 !&#%B!7:5 0!-!2'!7 2%- "42 &"& "!':-! 0! -!2'!7 2%- "42 "$"'$-47! 0! 2%-!B6!

) ?!2'!7 . ! "4'&!- #42 0!2 & !& 0 7!&6% ! 0! 8 !2%- ,% '!&&!& %'$-47%'/ 0! $"86-%'' 03%'/ :!!' !B8%'!7< 0!2! %& '" !3%7!'$!6"%' %'/ " 0!%''"$!'$!"# 0!6! % %"'!2<2 0!2 0!$"86-%'' %' 0%& !3%7!'$! 0& 2!% !2 !7 0 0! $$4&!76! % %"'!202&&!7 0%& 74/0 !2'7"#03%'//%3!' 02&0%'/ "0!2"' 0!7 !"#%'$%7!' ,0%$0 ,&7%&$-"&!7:50%&74/0 !2 "0%8 !-!60"'%$--5"' 0!&8!75'7"# 0%& 74/0 !29& 75%'/ "' 0! &8! 75 %' 0! !3!'%'/ %' 8!2% "2%"4& $%2$48& '$!&* 03!$"'&%7!2!7 0!&4:8%&&%"'&"#-!2'!7$"4'&!-#"2 0! 62 %!&* 78% !7-5< 0!--!/ %"'&/%'& 0!6! % %"'!22!&!2%"4&%' ' 42!*"/2"4'70&:!!'&0",':5-!2'!7$"4'&!-#"2 0!6! % %"'!2&" & "!B !'7 0!$"'$!&&%"'"#:%- " 0!6! % %"'!2!B$!

6 A%'/ 0!6-! "#0%&:!%'/%'$4& "75&%'$! 0!6& )5!2&8"' 0&*",!3!2< A%'/ %' "$$"4' 0!/23% 5"# 0!--!/ %"'&/%'& 0!6! % %"'!2&,!--& 0! &&42'$! :5 -!2'!7 . ! "4'&!- 0 -- & !6& ,"4-7 :! A!' " !B6!7% %"4&-5$"'$-47! 0! 2%-<8"# 0!3%!, 0 !'7&"#D4& %$!,"4-7 :! 8! :5 2!E4!& %'/ 0! -!2'!7 2%- "42 " !B8%'! 0! 62"&!$4 %"' ,% '!&&!&!B6!7% %"4&-5'7$"'$-47! 0! 2%-&!B6!7% %"4&-5&6"&&%:-!* 0%& & /!< -!2'!7 . ! $"4'&!- & !& 0 0! '!B 7 ! :!#"2! 0! -!2'!7 2%- "42 %& **)* ",!3!2< %' 3%!, "# 0! 62"3%&%"'&"#.!$ %"') 2** *&-&" 0!#$ 0 0!$$4&!76! % %"'!2 0&:!!'%'$4& "75&%'$! 0!6& )5!2&8"' 0&<% %&7!!8!7662"62% ! "2!E4!& 0!-!2'!7 2%- "42 "!

B8%'! 0!2!8%'%'/62"&!

,% '!&&!& '7 $"'$-47! 0! 2%- & !B6!7% %"4&-5 & 6"&&%:-! 62!#!2:-5 ,% 0%'&%B8"' 0&#2"8 "75<%#'!!7:!<:562!6"'%'/ 0!7 !"#0!2%'/ %'$$"27'$!,% 0-,#2"8**) "'!2-%!27 !* ! % %"'7%&6"&!7"#%' 0!:"3! !28&*$"65"# 0%&"27!2:! &!' " 0! -!2'!7 2%- $"42 #"2 %'#"28 %"' '7 '!$!&&25 $ %"' %' $$"27'$!,% 0-,*

)**)