Dr Mohit Gupta v. Additional Chief Secretary Chandigarh And Others

 
  
  
 



 !"#$# %&'

'

(' )# *+

'''''' # %( ,$'

--# # % . 
)#!  /"(

(01   21   #.$1 
(#2#% .  %3$ #4

# %  5 -2#%#$ (

# %  !  *$ #"  + ( 2% 1   3(%2%  !   (0 % 1 
#3#.

/"(

(#

 (0 % 1/"

( 1
) %-#4 () %- )($ '''''''''$+ %-% $
& 67'/
7/ 
 





   
 

  



 







  







  ! 

 "#
$

  ! 

  

 

 

% &

 



 







'''''

7/ 1'879 (

     $   %!

 %&

  $

       %!

$ $       ) * +   ,% *- *.(/ 

$$)
    



   

   

 





     

     



 

   

      

  

 

   !

 

"# 



$"# 

     

  %     &"

'

""

()(**+(, #

""







"

 

 



#  

 $"



 "      

   

      "#  ! 



(-((*+(.



  

   

#      

   /  $"   &"   

   #   


 "0    # ""

   ""    $"  

     $"

 

   

    "    

 

      

#    %

 #  

  



  " " ' !

1

   

 

  

 

#

 

 #





  $"   3      

     

*.+(*+(4 

#

"

 

 

  &"

 #

    "

     #  "              " 



56 5  

 "

 #





 &"

# 



 &"

 

  % 

5  "

     &"

 



'

#

 #

""

# "

 

# " "

    " 

 3 



  "# 



 

#

"





  

7  8  #

 

 ""



5                 





 

 

"

 #





"

 ""

""

  $ 



  9

 

 #   

   

  "



  







 

 

 



 "



 "   ":;





"





#     

     <#





  "

# 
= 

 0 



 



#

"

# #

  "  ""

 

 !    "

  

     7   

  7 

                 

#  



#

   

 

""

  

 #   0 =    "       "

     

    #  

    

         6   

6&"

   





 



 





    

#

  



  

 " 

  

   











"



 "

#  $ 

-+(+*+(4 =   "



/   $ 

#""



1

 

0

+ 

1 

,% 0. *.(/ 

$$ 2 $!

   

0. (. *.(/

$



 

 $$!



$    *- (. *.(/3)  67;

7 

  

%6  '   %""

"'  #    





 "   &"

  



"

    

   

%

'

   7 

 "

  =    7         

 "



 

  

 

 



    &"

  #    



 

 

 



 

%   =  7  '

"      6   

6&"

3

  



  $  7   *-(+*+(4

      -+(+*+(4  

  6   

 6&"





>  ?

*4(+*+(4 @  /      7 

 

   $"    

*4(+*+(4 = "  

: 

#

     

 -+(+*+(4%#   

 

1 " 

'                

    "    A

    "



  

7 

# 

    

"" 



# " /  



"

6   #  

 



 

  2       

  %

 

'

  "

 

"   



"

 

" >  "?

#  

       $   $   2  3 $$!

4  &



  5

!

"

67;

"



"  

 "  

  



 

   "



"

  

1   



 

" 

   

    

    B-)+, *+(4    

=   

 #  
  ""

0#  

  C&"

6;"%; $'



 

 #

 "

"

  &"

%= '

 

:  



#

  "  

       

 "



   "      

  

   

 

% 

 





  



 

'

  



         "               



#







  "   "

 "





  "               "



7  #

  

%     #  # "  

   

"      "           "#   #

"'

  

 

 ""



 

     #     

       "  



 

 "



     "         

6&"

% '

1

#

"     "@ 

$"





"







3  

6&"

 ""    

#0  

 "   *+(4%#

 



 

 "  & *+(4      "      

'

       

 

#

  

"

$" 7

"

           7   &

  

6

% ""7 "*+(4'

!

   &" 

 -++-*+(4  "

#    "



 

&





#

"

 

    " "



#



1    #



   

 

 "



"  



  # 

""

  

   " " 

 ""

@ /   

 $"

   



20 



#  

  

#

 

 !

     !            

 "



  

 

 "



 

&

 



#







$"

"



 

 # ""

# "  



"

 

3 





      #

     

 

 6&"  

1     

 ""



        

 

 "  "

  

"

  #    # "

# " " D  "  

       

  

 "



  6  E  

&

  /  "









 $"



 



"     

  "





 "



 # 

 2  

 "

 

   

    =

 



!

#  "  

""# ""  &"  

" 

 

  

 





"   "

 "

 

 "



  

;  "   #   3 # ""

     

 

       

6&"

 "



 

&

   

!       " "  "

      

""

    



 

 



   #     

  

 

   &"

6

 7$ 

+)((*+(4   

" 7    

 "



 " 

     0 - +!     

0. (. *.(/ !

   

 $  

  7

&  

  $

  .8 (( *.(/

  

 

   

 $ 

)
 !

    -+(+*+(4   =

?"

=  

B-)+, *+(4"


6  A  7

"             E  0 #    

  

    



#





 $"

  

"  



      

   

!



 

 ""   

#

"


   $"

  "     = 0          3

3

 *-(+*+(4% 

"

'@  

      

 



    #

 "

   C ((..G   *-(+*+(4   

6&"

 





#

%

"

'!

" 

 

6 &"

  "

 C 4+-+ *B(+*+(4 " 





"

   #

   #  

1  

  #""        #    

 

"

7 

    6    

"

 ;

 =

 7 &"   

     

 7   6   



 

"

 H 

7  

 $"





     

   

      "

  3   

#  



 

3

""

 " 7   "

 

6 &"

  ""  



    $"

   "

 ""

""=

"



              

 

    $    

"

1 



    ;!

%  "

 C 4+-+ *B(+*+(4  

6&"

 





"

' !  # "  "            



      =

?"

 =   



           6  E  

&

 $"  



 3  

  $"

-((+*+(4

 "

#      

  :



&"

"

 





#



     

 $

 

  

 

6&"@

/  "



#

 

6&"



    

 7     

   

  



 

 

 

7 !  $" #

# !





 #     @    

 $"  "  

 



"  

!

/  

#

 *-(+*+(4 #  

3 3

3 





 " 

#  

  "   $"= "     "

             #  



 $"

 # ""



""  3  

$

6E  

 &



*,**+(43  



" 

 #

$"

# "" " 

#

   

6&"

 

  

 





#     

 

  #  

        

6&"



  
 @



             -+(+*+(4   =

?"

=   ! 

 $"

B((*+(4     

!"  

 

%  "

"

'



   

      

  

1   

  

"" !



"

 

#= "   

/ #6   # "



=   

" A

 ""

!   3A 

  

  ""

    $"

 #  

 

"

 $"  ! 

  # 



 $" 

    

# "

  

   # 

"

"   $"C  



#

 
 


 

    

,  % 



 $

  ! 

$

 !

  %!

!





 $



    7 $

& %$

)   

  & 

!



 %   $ $

  

23 9      %&

   





  $  2 %$!3   %

$

 %     2:% 





3

$

 $

 !

; 

  !

  %  %  





 $$   !

 $ & +

  $    %

$$

# $  $$  

$ 

 $ !

<*-1= <  $$    +

$   $ % %$ 

 ,
 ,
3

   %    %!

 

  !



   $       $

# $  

   

$   $$!

$$   

  

 # $

+



 

      $!

%    %

 

$  

  7

&  %

  $$!

  # $ 

 $

  ! 9  %

  
$  <C52& 3  %     %!

$$

# $  $ 

$ 



2%3 9

 

$$!

  

   $  

 $!

%

  $$!

# $

  <  <   

$!

  :9      ! %$   # $  

 &

 !

  ! $    $  

23 9  $ %   $  

  7 $ 

7  $  

& # $ $!

%   !

$ %&    

 

$ 







23 "1

 %   $> 

  $ # $ $$!

2 & !3

   23   

$   !

  7 $

  

   

<$$  <









23 "1

  

 ! 2*.(/3  

  *8 .? *.(=  

   



      

# $

! *.(/   

7!

*.(/ 4.0 

 

@$ %     

& 7 $ 5 + @$     $   

"1

 

  7 $  

 
  9 $$

! 2
9 3

 $%$

  7 $

&

 $ !

      $& 

 $!

%  



 %   %!

    " ,%# 

 2",3

  $      $ 

 %!

 $

$  !  .8 .- *.(/ 2 !



 % 1

1

)(

 3 9

 

 > $  



 

  $

$  !   $

  !     







$$!

$$  

 $!

%
$     %#

9

 $ !

$   

$ $$    

# $ %!

%$  &       

   $  % $ %

23 +



  1     $       %!

!



  $ :

 $     $ 

    *.(=   $ &) .?

 % (0 .0 *.(/  0( (. *.(/

 

    %$

<%!

 <

A  

 $ ,



# $  .* (( *.(/

$ 



 

 



  

 



 !

 $ %$   4$ 

$ 5

!

$ &)  %!

: 0( (. *.(/  

 $



  7 $ 

 $ % 1

1

)* 

)0  $!



+ !

% $!



  $ $



$

  7

& 



 

  7 $

& 2

 !3  

 %$ 1     $ 5   %

$  $   

$$!

 !  !

  

!

  1   !

 &    

  !

  

$!  $

   $

  7         

$  

 & !

%

  



 !

%$

# $ +  $     $$!

  



 $   %  

   $

  7

&     &     $ $

    $!

 

        

 = +  $  & !

    1       % $!

%

$  !

     2  



 

  7

& $

:



 

  7 $3  

%$$!

       $



1   !

 & %!

 # $ 



   !

?

   $

  $ 

   %   

$ $

   $ 

 2

   $ &       $  &   %    



 3  % $!

$$!

$$

     2 $

          % &

<6 5

 !

$   % %         

$ 

:$

$

!3

/        % 

!

 $& 

  

  $$ $    %

$            !

 &       $

  7 $          $$  $$

 $ ! 

   $  $   $ 

     

 



0. (. *.(/  %

   

!

     

      





!

$

 

  % $

    $$

        @       !

!



   

@$!  $ !

   

 $    %

 

$ %!

!

 <$$ ! C< 

   

 8....>)

       %!

!

 D$

 

 !  

 

 !

 $ %

   !

  !

%@ $ 

$

 @ 



  $$    !

     

 $$   $

<  $$

 $ !<      $

  7 $$!      $%$ %!

!

!

 >$     !

   

 E 

 $$ !

 $ >

 %!

  $ $ $$!

    %!

  !

 32<(1

87/ 9 >    ; & > F

;

%$ F