High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7272/2017dismissed

Rupinderpal Singh And ORS v. Financial Commissioner And ORS

2024-04-30Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj7 pages

!""

#

$%

&'( & #)(%**&$'( + & ), #-

'.&'( & /0 1 !"#$% %!&'(!")

$

2

" 1

,$ /3'

4 56& 7

,$ /3'

4 86 11

,$ / . &8&977

,$ /3'

4 6( .

" (,

:

,

/:

& ")

( *

; ,

$ (

),; ( '

. < , ,$

/0 1

"

% #

'. ; &

= &

;

, / '

! < + ,

$0- /.

"$

.

(

),; ( '

&5583

&> '

?6 . $ 152

& / " - .

.

& / " ( 77 - . . $

,$ / <

. (,$ / ".

,

$ /0 1 . "

- & / 8&.

& ,

"

. /0 . ,

"

- &

(

.& /

( - (,$ "& / , / ! "#&.

$

" (

11 - (,$ "& / (

, /&.

( 7 "

, $ $,

-

(,$ "&

@/55 0

7 , /

!""

& .(& / $

"(

1

"

;

/

.

$ "

& "

,

$ .- "

"

&

.

,$ / , *

-

( $& / , /

& " .

"

, $ <

"

"

. $

(

. & " ,

,

$ .& (,

&

/0 9 1

" $

",$

-

.

, /091 "

% #- " ;

.$ "<

/9 ;

+(

; . ( " " " $ , '

! < +- $

" - /"

, '

! < + 78 , ,$*

-

)

. " ,$ / 9 & .

$

$ (

,$*

," -

.

" .

( 77&

,$ $ <

. & ( &

,$ $ <

. 8 . ,)

& & ". ( ($ "$&

8 $& .

,$ $ & '

! < +

-

$& & /9

8,$

, /& .

.

11

.

, /,$.$ (

&.

( 7& & &@/55 0 . , /<

,$"

!""

& $ 80 -.(&.

/091,

!& $. ( 1& @

,$

1-

"

" % &70& $ $, "0 ' &0 $"$ ( .

"

., < ) % 00 & & . , (,$ %

., < )

0

% 00 ,$. ( $,) -

$

&.

$

A& (

( -

.$ ( $

$

,)

$ & & . $.

(

$

- & ,

$.

$" ( ,

!

.

,

<

"

.

, /091;

.

"

.

(

;

'

"

&" ( 77

. 98& ($

&

0 '

,$

/091& /&9( , '

! < +

&.

.

B" %"

:#*

&: '.; &= ' < ( " $

")

*

, ,$*

:'!< " "%)

%.:+(

: #*

&:=

%(

1

/ "

: #*

: D"

& : =

%.:=(

:#*

&: = "

=( =

&%.

% &:= '

")

*

C , " ,$ *

F (

,$*

@*," G :'!< 1 " ",$ &

. " ( "

., *

H

,$

&

" .

-.(& .

."

& "

, , & ".

"

" .

"

.

$ 8 '

,$

/091&

( " 71 % &.

$ * (

< )% (

.

00 &

"

(

(

2

(

-.(& "*

$

$

( " *

<

( "

(

8

, %

70

(

(

5 /

$ .$ ( $

<

$

, ! &.

$

,

"

,@

,$ ( ( . &

!

$

" ,

( $"

,$

*

+ ,

"

*

: I :/ , I :/